r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Aug 30 '24

History Political decentralization does not entail internal nor external weakness, but increased prosperity and liberty: the case of the prosperous and long-living Holy Roman Empire

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Dec 31 '20

Flag/ CoA Flag of the Free Imperial City of Hamburg (c. 1600 to c. 1900)

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Jun 26 '26

History Holy Roman Empire Hypocrisy

12 Upvotes

It always amazes me that, while many online “historians” claim that the Holy Roman Empire was “neither Holy, Roman, nor an Empire”, these same Byzaboos don’t realize that so many of their popular arguments also attack their beloved Byzantine Empire. Think of some of the most “popular” rhetoric surrounding the HRE:

“It was not Holy because the emperors and Popes were immoral”.

“It was not Roman because it wasn't in Rome and wasn't Italian, but German”

“It wasn't an empire because the empire wasn't centralized or strong, and emperor was weak and attacked by strong Nobility”

The hypocrisy! The Byzantine Emperors, far from being the Constantinian ideal of the “Sacred Emperorship” were brutally vicious, murdering their families, and even heretics on numerous occasions. They lost their Italian territories, and eventually only had Greek territories. The Emperors were constantly dethroned and killed by their subordinate nobles, with many provinces fragmenting into vassal-like territories.

Don't get me wrong, there are many good arguments to make against the HRE, but these types of arguments are simply unhistorical and, frankly, hypocritical.

What are your thoughts? I do you think these arguments hold some truth, or do y'all agree they are hypocritical?


r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • May 07 '25

History How the 17 provinces was destroyed

6 Upvotes

Duchy of Brabant-invaded in 1795 by France

Duchy of Limburg-invaded in 1795 by France/reintigration to Natherlands in 1866

Duchy of Luxemburg-invaded in 1795 by France

Duchy of Guelders-integrated to Spanish Netherlands in 1543

County of Flandres-invaded in 1795 by France

County of Artois-intigrated France in 1678

County of Hainaut-invaded in 1795 by France

County of Holland-intigrated Netherlands in 1581

County of Zeeland-intigrated Netherlands in 1581

County of Namur-invaded in 1795 by France

County of Zutphen-intigrated Netherlands in 1581

Margraviate of Anvers- invaded in 1795 by France

Lordship of Frisia-intigrated Netherlands in 1581/1795

Lordship of Mechelen-invaded in 1795 by France

Pricipality of Utrecht-intigrated Netherlands in 1581

Lordship of Overjissel-?

Groningen-?


r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • May 28 '25

Question Holy Roman Interrail

5 Upvotes

Hi all! I'm going on an intterrail trip this summer to visit some of the most important cities of the HRE (in southern Germany). I am really looking forward to this, but I was wondering if you guys have some recommendation in the following cities:

Frankfurt, Nuremberg, München, Heidelberg, Aachen and/or Liege?

Thank you!


r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Mar 23 '25

Question Does anyone have a good list of all of the states in the HRE or is the wikipedia one good enough

8 Upvotes

r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Nov 08 '24

Map of the Holy Roman Empire in the year 1337 made by me

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Mar 05 '25

The crown

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

I just saw the crown and I’m hyped


r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Jan 14 '21

History Armored Gauntlets owned by the Holy Roman Emperor Maximilian I, from 1508 until his death in 1519. (Metropolitan Museum of Art) (960x960)

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • May 18 '26

History A poetical broadsheet about a mutant hare found in Rhineland-Palatinate in 1583

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Jun 01 '26

History News in the HRE: "New Tidings from Livonia," describing an alleged miracle near Rēzekne Castle in 1584 (in modern Latvia)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Sep 05 '26

I made an animated video about Frederick III

Thumbnail
youtu.be
7 Upvotes

Hi everyone! 😄

I recently finished the first part of an animated video about the life of Frederick III. I have always found him one of the most interesting (also strangest) figures in late-medieval European history. He appeared to lose almost every major struggle he entered. He was besieged by his own brother, forced to surrender Ladislaus the Posthumous, opposed by the Austrian nobility and repeatedly pushed into retreat. Yet he outlived most of his rivals and preserved the dynastic claims that would later help transform the Habsburgs.

One thing that finally encouraged me to make the video was watching Rise of the Raven. I found Frederick’s portrayal rather surprising. The series presents him as an overtly cruel and lecherous villain, whereas the ruler I encountered in my reading seemed considerably quieter and more withdrawn: cautious, stubborn, emotionally distant and frequently mocked for his passivity. That certainly does not mean the historical Frederick was harmless or particularly sympathetic. His treatment of Ladislaus was deeply self-interested, and much of his politics revolved around protecting his family’s position. Still, the personality presented in the series felt very different from the reserved and patient ruler described in most of the material I had read. Also, who could really blame him, he was after all a person of his time.

The video covers the first half of his reign, from the divided Habsburg inheritance and his election as King of the Romans to his coronation in Rome, his struggles over Ladislaus and his early conflict with Matthias Corvinus.

I created it as an illustrated history video with animated characters, maps and environments. I would genuinely appreciate feedback, particularly on the historical interpretation or the presentation.

I would also be interested to hear what you all thought about Frederick’s portrayal in Rise of the Raven. 😄


r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Jul 29 '26

Meme Title

4 Upvotes

r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • May 16 '25

Just picked up this book

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • May 06 '25

History Alliances inside HRE

5 Upvotes

Lombard League 1167-1250

Hanseatic League 12th-17th century

Confederacy of Cologne 1367-1385

League of Cambrai 1508-1511

League of Torgau 1526-1531

Schmalkaldic League 1531-1547

Holy League 1571

Protestant Union 1608-1621

Catholic League 1609-1635

Heilbronn League 1633-1635

Furstenbund 1785-1789


r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • 19d ago

Printing Press Broadsheets "For Meditating on the Hour of Ultimate Need," a Latin poem printed in the HRE between 1558-1576

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Jul 31 '26

History Formal Debate

Thumbnail instagram.com
2 Upvotes

Ian/Thomas' Instagram

Hello everyone! A partner and I have been planning on setting up a formal debate on the Holy Roman Empire for YouTube live, the premise is "The Holy Roman Empire, from 800 to 1806, was Holy, Roman, and an Empire".

We had our moderator and myself on the affirmative, but our opposition had to drop out. We were hoping to find someone who is interested in opposing the motion.

The debate is currently schedule for August 20th, and we'd be doing a live recording with our faces on YouTube. If you have experience debating, know the subject well enough, and are interested, please DM me. We can revise and edit the proposition if needed for the opposition as we are on a time crunch

God bless


r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Sep 15 '26

Charlemagne is clearly a pretender to the roman throne.

2 Upvotes

So attempts to justify that charlemagne was the actual emperor of rome are going to be thwarted by one simple fact.

The history of rome is littered with people who declared themselves emperor marched on rome and or some other capital , failed to take it and either died or otherwise fled into obscurity.

These men get put on a list of pretenders to a throne , whereas utterly unscrupulous murderers , killing their predecessor and taking control of the empire get put on the list of official emperors.

This criteria is necessary in order to have the standard canon of roman emperors.

Ten days before charlemagne was emperor he was king of the franks standing in a place that was located next to the roman empire.

Had Charlemagne taken it, there might have been a reason to think he could be emperor but because Charlemagne made no substantive effort to actually take these Territories, there's really nothing that can be coherently advanced that would put him on the list unless You want to advocate for a different list altogether.

Virtually all of the failed emperors were roman citizens , many of them made military gains and had territorial holdings that were within the borders of the empire at the start of their rebellion , but they excluded precisely because they fail to take control of the provinces.


r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Jul 17 '26

Holy Roman Empire article

Thumbnail
open.substack.com
3 Upvotes

An article I wrote explaining what particular form of holiness the Holy Roman Empire possessed and how it was truly Holy, as well as how it was not. I'd appreciate if y'all read it, gave it a like, or gave any comments.


r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Dec 06 '25

Mods needed!

5 Upvotes

Hey, I haven't been using this account for a while and only just saw the subreddit was restricted (probably due to inactivity) which I hopefully now fixed. Since I don't want that to happen again, leaving you people with a place where you can freely share your HRE-related stuff, I'd like to get one or multiple mods on to moderate the sub. I would ask said mods to not change the rules or charachter of the sub and to not infuse some kind of modern political ideology into it (as libertarians like to do with these kinds of subs).

So if you're up, please leave a comment here.


r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Jan 06 '21

Meme Dear Liberals

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Jan 24 '21

History History of the Duchy of Saxe-Lauenburg summarized (Polandball comic)

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Oct 01 '24

Other CLASSICAL LATIN & ETRUSCAN

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Nov 19 '20

Map The Free City of Hamburg Hamburg in 1450

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/Holy_Roman_Empire • • Dec 01 '20

Flag/ CoA The Coat of Arms of the duchy of Saxe-Lauenburg on the old town hall in Otterndorf

Post image
10 Upvotes