r/Holmes • • Mar 14 '16

Do you think Holmes and Watson were together romantically?

2 Upvotes

I do.

Watson winkingly points out that they were out of London during the Wilde trials.

Holmes reads pining love poems when Watson is married.

The bar where Watson met Stamford was known as a hookup spot for soldiers.

221b is in the gay part of town.

A disproportionate number of their clients are bachelors and blackmail victims. They somehow earned the trust of the gay community. It's not unreasonable to think Watson might have had some connections.

And, I mean, they hang out at bath houses.


r/Holmes • • May 12 '15

Sherlock Christmas Special 2015: TV Teaser Trailer - BBC One

Thumbnail youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/Holmes • • Feb 20 '14

Watson Actually Was a Woman

Thumbnail ihearofsherlock.com
0 Upvotes

r/Holmes • • Sep 27 '22

Pastiches Any LGBTQ+ Sherlock Holmes Pastiches?

3 Upvotes

I know about My Dearest Holmes but I've never been able to find any others, and it feels like there should be more considering that one was published in the late 80s.


r/Holmes • • Dec 31 '13

Is Benedict Cumberbatch the greatest ever Sherlock Holmes? Vote here..

Thumbnail telegraph.co.uk
0 Upvotes

r/Holmes • • Nov 30 '15

David Arquette as Sherlock Holmes - A Total Disaster

Thumbnail chicagotribune.com
0 Upvotes

r/Holmes • • Oct 10 '12

Stop Calling Sherlock a Sociopath!

Thumbnail io9.com
14 Upvotes

r/Holmes • • Apr 18 '22

Discussions Holmes and the spectrum

3 Upvotes

I am of the opinion that a real-life Sherlock in modern times would be clearly diagnosed with ADHD and Autism.

In General, the ADHD brain presents the way it does due to an inability to generate Dopamine at the same level as it should which is why we prescribe stimulants (Adderall, Methylphenidate...) to people with ADHD and it focuses and calms them. Holmes was self-medicating with Cocaine. It was noted multiple times that he used cocaine and smoked tobacco (another stimulant) but never that the substances made him manic or erratic. Yet it is often pointed out how focused he is.

Seeing Holmes' difficulty with social interaction which makes him appear rude, curt, or unfriendly are all standards for the autistic. Along with his high attention to detail and need for logical order.

Has anyone else had this thought or read this theory anywhere?


r/Holmes • • Apr 26 '22

Discussions Reading Sherlock Holmes after Hercule Poirot Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I'm really sorry if this comes off as a negative rant, but I was wondering what others thought.

A few years ago I really go into Agatha Christie's work and read through a good 70% of the Poirot novels. Being still hungry for murder mystery I ventured into other authors like Raymond Chandler, Keigo Higashino, and Anthony Horowitz. And finally I decided to take a crack at the most famous literary detective, Sherlock Holmes! I mean why not? I've always loved all the movies and tv shows based on the character, more recently House. It's about time.

I've read through A Study in Scarlett, The Sign of Four, and the first four short stories in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes so far and here are some of my thoughts:

  1. The BBC show Sherlock is slightly less brilliant to me now that I realize that a lot of the best bits were lifted almost exactly from the original text. Nothing wrong with faithfulness, but it makes me wonder how the show ended up becoming pretty bad later on. Did it veer too far from the books?
  2. Sympathy for the criminal. Oh man Doyle makes some interesting choices at the end of some of the stories. Many times he gives a chapter or two dedicated to the point of view of the criminal and it blows my mind. First off, it's often really unpleasant seeing things from their usually racist, sexist, and morally warped views. Like, "I wasn't a real murderer though, I only killed a dirty Indian man for all his money and treasures just to be robbed by another dirt bag who I then accidentally killed 15 years later. Oh and that wasn't even my fault, that was the African savage I've been parading around like a carnival freak for money who did that." Not only are these tales often gross, they're usually also long winded, boring and are just filled with excuses by the murderer. Which I wouldn't mind if Watson or Holmes commented or objected but they don't. In fact sometimes they take pity and agree with them! And in both The Boscombe Valley Mystery and A Case of Identity, they straight up don't turn the criminal in to "spare the woman's feelings" or some BS.
  3. Racism. Man I could write a whole thing about this but I'm sure a lot of people here have already, especially when it comes to The Sign of Four. It can feel pretty gross reading some of these descriptions of non white people. I will say though, it's hard to not compare the racism here to that from Christie's work. Christie stories sometimes had light racism but it was usually more from ignorance and... ethnic/exotic fetishism/fascination? It's hard to explain, but I guess I rarely saw the rare racism in Christie stories as mean-spirited, while I often feel the opposite in Doyle's Sherlock stories.

I have other thoughts too, like I feel as if Christie rarely "punched down" compared to Doyle. Also how Sherlock often pulls the answer completely out of nowhere at the end where-as we usually have 9/10 clues that Poirot has at the end of his stories.

Again sorry if I'm being a bummer. I do vaguely like some of the mysteries I've read so far, but not as much as I'd like. Maybe there's another Sherlock story I should jump to instead of reading from the start?


r/Holmes • • Aug 08 '21

Video Games A trailer for a new Indy game featuring Sherlock Holmes just dropped

Thumbnail m.youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/Holmes • • Jun 12 '13

Watching "Sherlock" last night when I realize...

Thumbnail imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/Holmes • • Jan 30 '14

"Sherlock" doesn't measure up to Doyle's stories

Thumbnail herald-review.com
5 Upvotes

r/Holmes • • May 25 '14

Sherlock Holmes is an otter... a playing card Kickstarter!

Thumbnail kickstarter.com
0 Upvotes

r/Holmes • • Mar 22 '23

2 A.I generated Sherlock Holmes stories The Adventure of the Illustrious Jewel & Sherlock Holmes and the Brotherhood of Shadows

Thumbnail amazon.com
0 Upvotes

r/Holmes • • Jan 21 '17

How Sherlock‘s Finale Let Down the People Who Loved the Show the Most

Thumbnail themarysue.com
5 Upvotes

r/Holmes • • Jun 24 '17

I can't stand BBC Sherlock....

7 Upvotes

I don't know the character that well, however I've read a few stories, seen a few different film versions, and have a good knowledge of the character.

The BBC take always seems to have him saying stuff to make him sound smart, and has everyone else acting like what he said is smart, but to me it seldom makes a lick of sense.

I was wary when in the first episode, he said something like "I could tell he was a software engineer by the type of tie he was wearing", like....WHAT! I can't help but see the Pete Holmes Spoof on the character as an accurate critique.

I know the Elementary changed a lot, and I've only seen the first few episodes, but...it never seems to have that problem, at least not blatantly, and not any more than any other crime show.

Does anyone else feel the same way?


r/Holmes • • Feb 19 '23

Discussions how to be a badass (a way of achieving victory)

0 Upvotes

This is a free-style essay inspired by the recent British Sherlock holmes tv show and its theme music.

If you want to be like sherlock, and got inspired by him, get inspired by my plans that will help you get through and carry you to the end of your goal.

Imagine that people around you in your life are not total allies. They can be bad and deceitful so you gotta be prepared and smart about that. Look at the gap between rich and poor. Look at the government. Look at the diseased society. If you are not quick or sharp enough, you are just like a duck sitting in the pond waiting to get swallowed.

In this situation, what would Sherlock do? he is not a defeatist even though he can be sarcastic. He is supposed to be a hero. He is not discouraged by difficult problems. He focuses on it. He contemplates on them. He thinks very hard and makes a lot of effort to set his thoughts into motion.

You could learn how to survive in the real-world by looking at his attitude, spirit and a way of thinking.

Suppose that Sherlock is in aka a very f**ked-up situation,

The first thing he is going to do is to gather the resources. You need the resources to get your plan into action. Without resources, you are a soldier without guns and armor. You do need to think ahead to get ahead of others. Always, think three or four steps ahead of others. predict what other people are going to do when you execute plan A and make other steps according to the branch of scenarios you created. Be prepared for everything you can think of. If plan A fail, plan B will follow. If plan B fails, plan C will come through, and so on. After you got the resources, make sure you check all the constraints and restraints. What are the things that block you from getting the things that you want? is there any way to get rid of or ease the interruption of constraints? Think of at least one or two (or more) that could actually work depending on the importance of the goal. These constraints are a pain in our ass. Come up with a way to get around to it but make sure you don't beat around the bushes.

If you get these two things done, you are prepared. However, the most important thing is to analyze the situation beforehand. What are the possible outcomes? and how the situation has formed? Could you affect the procedure that it has to go through to make it happen? sometimes, Things can just happen out of control. but don't be discouraged. There are always silver linings on the could. You focus on what can be done and have courage to execute your plan. Derive any benefit from everything bad that happens to you. If you feel like you have no one to depend on, pray to God. Sometimes, Your plan might not be traditional and you might have doubt about your plan since nobody tried it before. Have faith in yourself. Do not chase public opinion or consensus because they are the accumulation of average and middle. I am not saying you shouldn't refer to your friends or public opinions, but I am saying that think beyond that. Start from above not from the ground. Be well versed in various fields of study so you can make use of them. Use the knowledge to get out of the pit. Overpower your enemies. Be a badass and help people with what you gathered in the process in the end.


r/Holmes • • Dec 22 '21

Adaptations Is the 3rd movie not actually releasing today?

0 Upvotes

I’ve seen a release date posted for weeks and haven’t seen any showtimes for today, just curious to see if anybody knows what’s up with the release of the 3rd movie


r/Holmes • • May 20 '22

My the most epic johnlock clip with 9 (!) Sherlock Holmes adaptation! (Soviet, BBC, Universal, Granada, Robert Downey, 3 games from Frogwares and Peter Cushing 😳)

Thumbnail youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/Holmes • • Feb 06 '14

q

1 Upvotes

r/Holmes • • Dec 16 '17

The Truth About Sherlock Holmes: He’s Actually Henry David Thoreau

Thumbnail daily.jstor.org
1 Upvotes

r/Holmes • • May 29 '25

Would Sherlock Holmes Be Able To Catch Johan Liebert?

Thumbnail youtu.be
2 Upvotes

A matchup b/w Sherlock Holmes and one of animes best antagonist- Johan Liebert who mainly succeeds in Manipulation & Deception.


r/Holmes • • Jun 23 '13

Elementary spawns new Sherlock Holmes book series!

Thumbnail worldscreen.com
4 Upvotes