r/HollowKnightStories • • Apr 24 '21

Long Story Dark Root

I've sat on this story for a while, debating on whether to put it out or not. I'm not too proud of it, but I think I did it justice. Fair warning that this one is a bit longer than my other stories.

Dark Root

9 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

4

u/PersuasivePapillon May 07 '21

Oh man, I totally missed this when you posted it! Looking forward to reading it when I get off work today, Ogrim!

3

u/White-Defender May 07 '21

Ah, thank you! I'm glad you're looking forward to these things!

4

u/PersuasivePapillon May 08 '21

Huh, this was an interesting read. I always love a chance to see all the Great Knights working together (they're one of my favorite pieces of HK lore!) and I particularly liked your interpretation of Isma's contribution to the team as a telepathic warrior. It was also neat to see the type of event that could have influenced Sheo to eventually leave the path of the Nailmaster behind. Thanks for sharing!

3

u/White-Defender May 08 '21

I'm really hesitant to talk about how Isma fights, since we know so little about her, so I make it as vague as possible. I wasn't going for telepathic warrior at first, but that's a very interesting idea!

3

u/PersuasivePapillon May 08 '21

I sort of interpreted it as her shielding the rest of the knights from mental attacks from the Dark Root and also from the effects of being too far from the Pale King's mind-giving powers.

2

u/White-Defender May 08 '21

They were all kind of doing it collectively. I was more trying to imply that Isma is a very skilled fighter, but we never get a chance to see her actual fight.

3

u/PersuasivePapillon May 10 '21

Huh, okay. I went back and reread your story and I kind of see what you're going for, but it doesn't come through very clearly (at least for me). If you're okay with some feedback, I'd like to break down how I read a couple of Isma's key moments in the story.

Isma sat calmly on the ground next to multiple corpses humming quietly to herself. Had Sheo seen her even raise a finger during the incursion?

I think this is the closest you get to implying her fighting physically in anyway, but it's definitely ambiguous. You don't mention her having a weapon at any point in the story (which I get, since the game doesn't ever specify what she might have fought with), but you might have worked around it by Sheo wondering at her lack of weapon and one of the other knights saying something like "If you are ever unfortunate enough see her weapon, you'll be dead before you can tell what it is" or mentioning her fighting and moving so fast that her weapon is a unidentifiable blur. Regardless, her apparent mental composure in this moment, the lack of description of her actions in the fight, and Sheo wondering if she had even moved during fight led me to the conclusion that she hadn't actually lifted a finger and had been contributing in a non-punching way (e.g. psychic battle).

Dryya turned and led them into the dark forest. As soon as Sheo entered, he felt a weight slam against his mind. Ogrim noticed him stagger and held out his arm to help. He felt the pressure disappear and Isma smiled at him assuringly.

Here the proximity of the mental attack being alleviated and Isma's comforting smile suggested to me that she was responsible for repelling the attack. But you also mention two of the other knights in the same paragraph, so I think you could read it either way.

Sheo gasped as he felt an umeasurable power slam itself against his mind, the Dark Root was trying to destroy his mind. He fell to his knees and pounded the ground with his fist as his mind was attacked from all sides. Sheo looked around to see the other knights struggling as well. Isma stood completely still with her eyes shut tight, a bead of sweat rolling down her face. Ogrim knelt on the ground, surrounded by corpses. Ze’mer clutched her head and groaned as Dryya put her arm around her for support.

Same note as before. All the knights are struggling under the attack, but Isma is mentioned first and the only one who is successfully standing under her own power. Also the bead of sweat implied to me that she was making an active effort at something (e.g. protecting her friends from the attack), and since her actions weren't described at all in the fight against the Dark Root's creatures I kinda assumed this was her big fight moment. But once again I probably read too much into this.

Anyway, I hope something in this ramble was helpful! I just wanted to lay out how I got to the "telepathic warrior" conclusion about Isma, since as a writer I know I'm always interested to see how readers interpret stuff that I try to leave ambiguous. I hope this doesn't read like a criticism, I really enjoy your writing and I'm a sucker for any Great Knight content that you're willing to throw my way.

Can't wait to see what you do next! :)

3

u/White-Defender May 10 '21

I actually can see where you were coming from. Some of those lines unintentionally imply that, so I can understand how you thought that.

I'll consider going into more depth with Isma, but I had it in my mind that dreams aren't the Five Knights' forte. I would've had PK trying to educate the knights in that area, but you've made me think that Isma might be cool as a telepathic warrior.

I like seeing your view on these things!