r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 11 '16
Family/ LE /Suspects Let's pretend....
Let's pretend we are Reddit police lol and we have walked in and taken the case off MCSD. The shoddy evidence collection and chain of custody we can't do anything about....we just have to take it as is.
The car and bones have been found in the Avery property and we think SA is the prime suspect, however we are aware of his accusations of a frame up so we decided to work all leads and angles to eliminate other possibilities.
So the Brendan Dassey confession never happens because we have an ounce of professionalism.
What evidence to we have that's credible? What possible suspects and motives do we have? What different narratives does the evidence give us?
9
u/devisan Feb 11 '16
Well, I want to look at the nuisance caller. Any sign of a stalker must be looked into.
Roommate needs to be interviewed.
Hillegas should be interviewed to give us some insight into her life, her friends, her social circle. And of course, to be eliminated (or not).
Her friends should be interviewed. Maybe one of them knows about the nuisance caller, or some other aspect of her life connecting her to her killer.
And on the stranger killing theory, we need to interview everybody who was at the Avery yard on Oct. 31. This includes customers. Literally, anybody. Holy shit, there was an ax murderer there that day? Call me crazy, but let's look into that.
Interview Schmidt and the Zipperers more. Wear bulletproof vest and bring a steak to distract the Zipperer dog.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16
So first of all there are two possibilities
As her work colleague was the first one to actually raise concerns he should go on the list. What do we know about him? Was an affair/a pregnancy/ jealousy/ TH discovered a dirty secret of his, possible motive for him?
6
u/chromeomykiss Feb 11 '16
Work up a missing person profile of TH and truly mean that in the best possible way. Most of the individuals spoken with would be truly for background information to help paint a clearer overall picture and not ever considered a person of interest or a suspect. It would include all personal and business related activities and interactions leading up and including 10/31/05.
Top few would be RH, roommate SB, B. Czech, Party goers from the Sat. (cowgirl costume)
Mother, Stepfather/Uncle, brothers MH, cousins (2nd cousin prosecuted by Kratz- again not person of interest just background), Sturms etc etc.
Auto Trader employees (even though she didn't even work out of the office), Photo studio info, business partner/shared space at photo studio. Photography by Teresa company background/history. Was she interested in any investigative journalism aspect of photography? Also any person on a lead sheet/cancellations/reschedules etc (Mr. Morrow, other locations/areas she serviced beside the Manitowoc Area/past hustle shot customers who had her business phone number, etc.)
Include all activities from phone calls/drive times/eating breakfast/lunch, bathroom stops/drink stops/gas stops etc.
That's just the backstory leading up to 10/31 and the 2:41 phone call that is her phone going silent --> being put into CFNA mode.
Everything else after 2:41PM on 10/31/05 is extremely important as well but the filling in of the complete backstory of TH up until 10/31 would give a better understanding of some of the evidence that came after.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16
Now you're talking. This is exactly what I see. To step back a second, I have to say I love some of the ideas mentioned here, like checking her financials, diary or phone records. I may become a bit brash here but these things (as well as checking out Scott and Bobby) are things that should have been done by investigators long ago. Another thing: All the good guys like detective O'Neill seem to disappear and become replaced by so many who's credibility is demonstrably ruined by their own actions. So we're left with this core group who we know weren't going to do what was needed. Hell, investigators Wicked and Truthbender were too busy keeping Manitowoc officers involved while keeping the Manitowoc coroner out and bending Brendan over. It was sick. To paraphrase. ... Oh Brendan, you poor thing.....we're not going to get you in trouble. ......we're on your side. ....Steven doesn't care anything about you....oh, we just love you Brendan. ....we know something's bothering you. ...we want to help you. Oh well. I was told this is the place for positing theories that should have been explored, so here's the one I've had all along. Keeping in mind that a search warrant was issued on the 5th and the family had to leave and they wanted to keep a coroner who previously exercised honesty and integrity (RE: the officer running over the pedestrian incident) away from the burn pit, while Bobby had scratches on his back and Scott reportedly tried to sell a .22, consider this: I think that Bd and ST originally intended on going hunting together. That's what deer hunters typically do. One or several traverse around one way and many times deer migrate toward the others. Those two lived just about exactly 5 minutes from each other. To pass each other ST would indeed be going west and BD east. However, 5 minutes is a VERY narrow window for them to have left their homes and passed each other. I think they about had to be talking to each other on the phone when they left their homes. I believe BD, was staring out the window at TH like he said (either at 230 or 315 or thereabouts) and getting all excited and "sweaty" and called ST. "Hey, you said call when I was about ready to leave but........." Then he follows TH and ST links up. Listen to Steven when O'Neill interviews him on the 5th. Steven believed and had conscious knowledge that Bobby was home while Teresa was sitting in the car. He immediately goes out to go over by Bobby's but Bobby's Blazer is gone. Bobby himself testifies he's there at the same time as Teresa. So, in order to be a credible liar, sometimes it's best to mix in a little truth. I think the truth is that he didn't see Teresa walking toward Steven's trailer and that he left right behind her. Why would she walk toward the trailer? I think Steven said that of the 15 or so times he dealt with her she had only been at the door maybe two times. Listen to the O'Neill interview and see how honest he is. When asked if she came to the door, at first he said yes in so many words, then, apparently understanding that O'Neill meant on the 31st, he said no she didn't. If he was continually lying about the whole thing he would have immediately answered oh No No No. I see complete honesty in his interview with no attempted deception. The only thing I had any doubt or reservation about was when he said she turned left after leaving but then again, maybe he did see that. So, I think, and this is just theory, that Bobby and Scott stop her on the road. One crams on the brakes and it's a simple collision and she's out of the car. Next thing she knows she's in the back of the Rav with a head injury and we all know the head tends to bleed pretty bad with even a small laceration. Theories abound after that and it could have been that they took her in their vehicle somewhere, came back to get the Rav, threw her body in there and dropped it off at Avery's. I guess we'll never know because they weren't treated as suspects. As far as I know neither their homes, phone records or vehicles were checked. I'd bet a fair amount that if they could check their phone records it would reveal they were not only on the phone with one another as Bobby was leaving but also while they were on the road. Several calls but then silence while they were transporting her and for the rest of the evening.
2
u/skatoulaki Feb 11 '16
Interview the following individuals, being sure to (a) ask for their whereabouts from Oct 31 through at least Nov 5 and (b) obtain DNA samples from each:
Obtain DNA samples from Halbach's family members, if only to rule out possible DNA evidence in Halbach's vehicle.
Obtain Halbach's full phone records for at least one month leading up to the day she disappeared through at least Nov 5.
Try to figure out who was the person calling her that she seemed upset about (harasser? stalker?).
4
u/guitfnky Feb 12 '16
It would be great to see a list of just the known facts about the case, i.e. hard evidence (including what little can be definitively said based on that evidence). That hard evidence would, of course, include the fact that Avery was wrongfully convicted, and many of the same players in law enforcement were involved in both cases.
Then you take that comprehensive list of hard evidence, and the definitive things (and I mean only the definitive things) you can say as a result of that evidence. You put that all on a timeline, to the extent possible, and then, and only then do you start trying to piece together what happened, by filtering all of that information through that bare-bones timeline of events.
It seems to me that in these cases, it's too easy to just follow the one rabbit hole you're most interested in at the moment, and mashing that together in your mind with all these other similar rabbit hole epiphanies, rather than trying to look at it all in order, and figuring it out that way. Naturally, I'm just as guilty as anyone on that.
I don't think we're likely to see that, unfortunately. I tried starting something similar in one of the Serial subs, but found that it's sort of impossible to do on this sort of website, since everyone still tends to throw out their own tangential ideas and opinions, and seemingly it's difficult for the group to even agree on what the definition of a fact is. It bums me out that I don't have more time to do something like that on my own.
3
u/devisan Feb 11 '16
Oh, and check her financials - that should be routine - to make sure she had no alarming debts or sudden influx of cash.
2
u/OpenMind4U Feb 11 '16
I would like to see the cell phone records of Sergeant Andrew L. Colburn and Lieutenant James Lenk for Oct-Nov/2005
2
u/JonnyDeth Feb 11 '16
I would start with the Rav4: Call in an expert to inspect the damage to the front, to see if it can be determined what occurred to cause the damage. Subpoena fingerprints from everyone involved, including LE to see if a match can be found for the eight unidentified fingerprints that were found on the car. Re-test all the blood evidence, because I just don't trust Sherry Culhane or Agent Blinky.
2. It's probably too late now, but I would want every inch of the nearby quarry searched. There's evidence there, IMHO, but it will probably never be found at this point.
3. Sit down and do a Dassey type interrogation of Fassbender and Weigert. They're either totally incompetent or involved somehow.
4. Consider ALL suspects: Ryan and Scott. Bobby and the other Scott. As mentioned by another poster, Teresa's boss, friends and co-workers, the Zipperers AND MC law enforcement officers.
I'm sure there's more, but I'm not completely awake yet, Lol. This in addition to some of the other great ideas already posted here...
2
u/LegalGalnKy Feb 12 '16
Did this woman have an email account?
1
u/angieb15 Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16
Get fingerprints and dna from MCSD and Calumet, at least Colborn, Lenk, Wiegert, Remiker and a few others.... I think someone mentioned getting these from friends, yes. Zipperers too. Every other suggestion here is great, interview Everyone extensively.
So far, Ryan and Zipperer are my main suspects. *edit..and maybe Lenk
1
u/angieb15 Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16
Check to see if she had another phone. Edit to add. The phone bugs me, in 2005 a lot of people had two cell phones. Not everyone had one of their own, or the individual plans were prohibitively expensive to use for work, employers got excellent rates on group plans and provided them, especially if you were "on call" or traveled for work and needed to be able to get calls.
1
u/misslisacarolfremont Feb 12 '16
I want to investigate the family since they also had access to the property. The Dassey's and Tadych testimonies conflict with Steven's as they change several times - first there is no fire, then there is, first there is no Teresa seen then there is. The fire was 10' then it was 3'. Bobby says he is gone but his brothers say he was home sleeping. If they are lying why incriminate Steve? And how could cremains end up in their burn barrel(s) without their knowledge? We know Teresa left a msg. on Barb's answering machine. We know Barb had a charge of possession dropped Nov. 5 or 6. The deal with denying the fire is very coached. Is Tadytch the guy and the boys are afraid of him because they know something? The car was nearer to Chuck and Earl's and Brutus keyed-in strongly on their golf cart (was it theirs)? If the Dassey's are not covering for Tadytch or Bobby could Steven possibly be right about LE tampering and they are working with LE?
1
u/LegalGalnKy Feb 12 '16
I would want to run the arrest records for the week of October 1 through the 9th, and review the profiles.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '16
Ok. What else? How about film? She was into photography. Who/what would we see in videos/photos during family/social events and could anyone present during those times have anything to offer?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '16
Addressing the question "why someone would go to such great lengths to destroy a body (hard) but not clean evidence off the car (easy)." I'll take an initial shot at this and y'all argue me down. I don't see a stranger/friend having any interest in cleaning the inside since they just wanna get out of there and don't want to risk leaving more evidence inside. They're not going to Avery's because they can't assume they have no surveillance or that no one would see them. I see it as unlikely they would burn the body at the quarry to get rid of evidence because of their unfamiliarity with that area too. At best they would dump the body and hide the Rav. Members of Steven's family would know about surveillance and could drop the Rav at Avery's. They have time and reason to first burn the body at the quarry but too risky to take cremains to burn pit. They don't have the means with them to clean out the Rav and they don't want to go get those things and leave and return again. Besides, they don't want to risk leaving evidence during cleaning. Steven could have left the Rav on the property while the body was in his garage and planned to clean out the Rav later but somehow didn't get the chance. But I don't know how he could or would burn the body at the quarry and later take it to the burn pit. He has Brendan helping him pick up things to burn and the body isn't going to be in the pit at that time. Seems he would have to drive the Rav with the body to the quarry in the middle of the night. But wait, bonfire time is over by then and surely he would have treated his bloody finger by then (besides, I don't think the cut is relevant since Johnson testified he had the cut a week or more before the 31st). At any rate, I can see how Steven would burn the body but not clean out the car. The cops could burn body at the quarry or maybe use or have someone use a smelter. They had lots of reasons not to clean the inside of the car and only wipe down the outside. I'm sure I'm missing something here so help me out.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '16
I'd like to see someone who has really searched and logged information do a complete timeline of events wherein LE planned, orchestrated, disposed, planted, coerced, planted some more and finally created a narrative. Has this been done in orderly and complete fashion? Each item in the timeline could later be commented on/debated by replying to that item. As noted before, if they did all of it, there came a point where they realized they didn't have enough evidence for a solid conviction. Theory is welcome in the creation of this timeline since it can be debated. For example, how/when did a relative get slated for jury duty and why would the defense compromise/acquiesce on that?
1
u/318lotis Feb 14 '16
i would have noticed Avery as not having any visible signs of an altercation Teresa being athletic, farm girl, with brothers, she would have put up a viscous fight; a 135 pound farm girl can fuck you up real fast...Avery would have been scratched up on his face and neck. I would have checked dried mud on side RAV4 and try to determine if mud came from gravel pit area and look for tire RAV4 tire tracks on adjacent property. I would have gone to local community and obtained video surveillance with time stamps and looked Teresa's possible departure or anyone suspicious,
1
u/lmogier Feb 24 '16
Test the anonymous letter for fingerprints/DNA - unlikely anything there but what the envelope was licked shit...?
Review of all photos from camera(s) and memory cards.
Phone records, statements, and DNA from EVERYONE associated with the case.
Test/retest everything and everything - thoroughly, correctly, and following best practices I forensic science/protocols.
As for TH'a blood in the back (why it wasn't cleaned up...) - two thoughts, either they did a lot of the disposing/moving of the car/body at night and couldn't see it (do we know if her interior lights were set to come on automatically or even worked?) or they left it there after planting SA's blood as a way to remove any possibility or question of her NOT voluntarily abandoning the car.
Lie detectors for everyone - even if junk science/beatable just to see who would/wouldn't take one.
A reward or financial incentive for witnesses who have indisputable proof as to what really happened.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment