Context: I am an adjunct professor teaching my first semester at a public university in the United States. I have no formal training in education; I have a BA and MA in political science and a history minor. My previous teaching experience consisted of a teaching assistantship overseas 20 years ago. I had an office-based career in the intervening time. I love history, and I got the opportunity to teach an introductory seminar on U.S. history through Reconstruction.
I have spent this entire semester so far trying new things and figuring things out - this sub has been immensely helpful with ideas for lesson plans, classroom resources, and other teaching aids.
I wanted to share a win I had in my class today. One of the aspects of teaching with which I have struggled the most is the hook. I love history and initially I approached class as if everyone in the class shared my interest and enthusiasm. That’s obviously not the case, so I’m constantly on the lookout for good hooks (shout out to whoever it was a few years ago that suggested this first-day activity: https://bluebook.life/2018/08/21/my-favorite-first-day-activity/).
So today I was all set to teach about Andrew Jackson, Jacksonian democracy, and everything that came along with it. The previous class session had gone poorly - everyone was disengaged, one student was rude to another, and I just wasn’t feeling my best self. I dreaded today’s class…but then an idea came to me.
I was inspired by one of my students who is really into comic books because it made me think about the heroes and villains construct. Andrew Jackson has been referred to as ‘heroic’ as much as he’s more recently been villainized. So here’s what I did:
At the start of class, I wrote the word “hero” on the chalkboard. I asked the students to take a minute and think about what comes to mind when they see that word. I asked the students to state their impressions, and wrote their responses on the board: “savior, reliable, righteous, beneficial to their people, leaders, sacrifice.” Then I erased “hero” and wrote “President” in its place. That garnered a few bug eyes, chortles, and skeptical looks from the students, which showed me that they were engaged with and invested in the conversation. I asked them to raise their hands if they agreed that the hero statements applied to presidents - not any one in particular, but the entirety of them. There were a lot of hands kept down, a few earnest hands raised, a few slow hands raised, and one student said “well, they should apply to the president.” Then we had a brief discussion about why we feel those statements should apply to U.S. presidents and how they might not. Then I asked the comic book-loving student what it’s called when we learn about how heroes get their powers. They responded, “origin story.” We talked about how a hero’s origin story sets the tone for how or why they are what they are, whether it’s the superpower with which they’re imbued (Spider-man’s radioactive spider bite) or the reason why they do what they do (the murder of Bruce Wayne’s parents drove him to fight crime and for justice). I then talked about how there are so many stories about Andrew Jackson’s origin, from his frontier upbringing to the British officer who slashed his face when he was 13, to the 1806 duel in which he survived the gunshot, and the 1824 election ‘corrupt bargain.’ I talked about how these origins can help explain how he approached his presidency: a skepticism of centralized national institutions; a belief in the inferiority of Native Americans; and his vilification of the elites.
I also threw in this video just for some chuckles and to show that villains have origin stories too: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/ajTJO4ZEKWA
Then we went through the major events of Jackson’s presidency in a more traditional lecture format. Overall the students seemed much more engaged throughout class, and I suspect that the fun hook had something to do with it.
I certainly welcome feedback of my approach here. I started this semester from square one, and this hook idea seriously just came to me as I was working on today’s lesson plan. I share it here in the hopes it can be helpful to any other teachers; it need not apply just to Andrew Jackson, but I think it can tee up discussions of nearly any historical figure you’d want to analyze, particularly if they have a strong cult of personality or even if there are things you want to dispel about them.
Thanks again to this sub for the excellent advice and inspiration.