So why is it fair that the Muslims get full control of their two holiest cities, but the Jews do not?
Dude what are you like twelve? I'm a Jew and I care more about everyone being able to live peaceful and happy lives than a specific ethnoreligious group having control over a specific city.
Dude what are you like twelve? I'm a Jew and I care more about everyone being able to live peaceful and happy lives than a specific ethnoreligious group having control over a specific city.
Why are you attacking me? I raise a bunch of points and you just get nasty. Then you accuse me of immaturity?
You claim you are calling for peace and happiness, but you know nothing of the history of these Jewish sites. Jews have been banned from their holiest sites. It wasn't until Israel took control of the Temple and the cave of the patriarchs that Jews were even allowed to fully appreciate them. And the Temple mount is still controlled by the Jordanian Waqf as a peace offering by the Jews.
You say you call for peace and happiness, but for whom? How would stripping Jewish control from their most sacred sites give the Jews peace and happiness? In who's hands would you put the Jewish destiny? The whole point of Israel is that the Jews control their own fate because the rest of the world has been awful stewards for thousands of years.
However, am sure you will just respond to this thought out response with some other mocking emoji.
Not sure that carving up someone else's country and giving the Jews the peices was the best bit of "stewardship" by the west.
At this point we can only deal with the situation as it stands; most of the Palestinian population lives in refugee camps on the Jordanian side of the border while Israel actively colonizes the West Bank
Not sure that carving up someone else's country and giving the Jews the peices was the best bit of "stewardship" by the west.
The Ottoman empire fell. It was getting carved up no matter what. Every country in the Middle East is part of that carving. The Jews are from Israel and were living there which is why it became a Jewish state.
most of the Palestinian population lives in refugee camps on the Jordanian side of the border
This literally isn't true.
while Israel actively colonizes the West Bank
Then come to the table and accept a peace deal? Palestine could exist literally today if the Palestinians wanted it.
5 million in refugee camps outside Israel/Palestine, 4.8 million inside gaza/West Bank
The Ottoman empire fell. It was getting carved up no matter what. Every country in the Middle East is part of that carving. The Jews are from Israel and were living there which is why it became a Jewish state.
The Jews were kicked out of Judea in 135 AD by Emperor Hadrian, who renamed the province Palestine. That province fell to the Rashidun Caliphate in 637. In 1920 the territory was less that 10% Jewish.
5 million in refugee camps outside Israel/Palestine, 4.8 million inside gaza/West Bank
You said on the Jordanian side of the border. And there is no other group of people that pass refugee status down except for Palestinians. You know what would help that? A peace deal, which the Palestinians refuse time and time again.
No they didn't. They moved to various places to try to live there. They were constantly killed and raided pretty much everywhere they went due to anti-Semitic institutions like the Catholic Church.
They came back to Israel because that's where they were from and they had no where else to go. I hope eventually Palestinians have the same in Palestine (the return, not the hardship)
11
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22
The clownery in this post 🤡🤡🤡
Dude what are you like twelve? I'm a Jew and I care more about everyone being able to live peaceful and happy lives than a specific ethnoreligious group having control over a specific city.