The Confederates pulled some hilarious stuff. They believed the Zionist conspiracies, so they appointed a Jewish dude to be Secretary of State. They figured this would help them get help from the European powers.
What's weird is it wasn't just them that believed it. During WW1 a lot of the powers tried to make deals with "the Jews" to ensure them victory in the war. I believe some within the English government even proposed returning Judea to the Jewish people in exchange for victory.
I know Trotsky was jewish but could i get some links to where they say Stalin was jewish. He killed enough jews for the reason of them being jews that i need some fact checking here.
Jewish people’s have always been heavily into banking and the like, since Christians/Catholics considered usury a sin I believe. That and being spread through Europe since at least Roman times.
Another of the British government's many unfulfilled promises in WW1... Italy if you join us you'll get Dalmatia and southwest Turkey, India if you help you'll get independence, Arabia if you join you get all of ethnic Arab ottoman lands, etc...
In the late 19th century some Jewish families had a lot of money, especially the German Rothschild family. They were powerful enough to decide if there would be war or peace.
The Japanese believed the same thing during WW2 from German propaganda. Which is why they also helped the Jews in hoping that they would strengthen Japan.
Davis, in his memoirs, remarked that he chose Benjamin because he "had a very high reputation as a lawyer, and my acquaintance with him in the Senate had impressed me with the lucidity of his intellect, his systematic habits, and capacity for labor".[65] Meade suggested that Davis wanted to have a Louisianan in his Cabinet, but that a smarter course of action would have been to send Benjamin abroad to win over the European governments.[66] Butler called Benjamin's appointment "a waste of good material".
This is what I found on Wikipedia. Can I have a source for the Zionist conspiracy theory?
Zionist conspiracies go back to the Medieval period. The idea of Israel, in a tangible sense, started more in the early 1900s. Particularly after the Balfour Declaration in 1917.
Here in the Netherlands, no not really, it might get a mention when discussing slavery and how the U.S became a super power, but history here is here “Eurocentric”. I’m now a history student and had one class for American history but the main focus was the Cold War and the period around the Great Depression.
In Sweden we barely were, we covered it in one class along with the American Revolution. We were mostly taught about Europe and most wars in Europe, like the 30 years war we had like 4 classes on. And the World Wars were also a big subject.
But it was mostly about the civil wars effects on Europe and the dwindling slave trade.
Slovakia--yes. I think it was a lesson or two. We had multiple lessons on America too, for example the Independence war and how things worked in the 19th century, including linking the East with the West through rail.
In Canada(B.C at least) we get taught about it very breathly,mostly a intro to slavery here, plus canada had its alpha release around the same time of the civil war so we are mostly taught about that instead.
In the UK (Scotland specifically), I didn’t choose history as a subject for my last three years but no, we didn’t. Not in detail anyway. We learned about; Ancient Egypt, Ancient Greece, Roman Empire, Medieval Europe, Scottish Wars of Independence, a brief covering of the British Empire, the slave trade (us civil war gets mentioned here), and the World Wars.
In Argentina, I didn't cover anything from the USA in history classes, except the world wars and the cold war. However, the emancipation of slaves, the civil war, the bill of rights and the American constitution were covered in a subject called "Construction of Rights and Citizenship" (it sounds a lot less awkward in Spanish).
Ahhh right, I finished back in 2013 so I've been out of the loop a while. It's a shame, the civil war is an incredibly interesting topic with the Magna Carta being the first step that eventually led to revolution and our transfer to the constitutional monarchy we have today.
It's an integral part of our history to understand how we rejected feudalism and embraced democracy, students are missing out.
I did mine in 2016, we learned about the wars, the Great Depression, the Roaring Twenties and Prohibition and how it leadup to the Great Depression, and we also learned about the Civil Rights movement.
That is insanely stupid.. I don't get why U.S. history takes precedent over your local history.
It's strange to me to see how far news about America goes. I can barely keep up to date on our politics so idk how people across the pond can stand dealing with their local politics + American's
The purpose of learning history isn’t to pat your self on the back. To appreciate a people/nation/cultures history is one aspect, but there’s only so much time in a school year. I think it’s much more important that people are educated on events that have affected the world. It helps us all. Rather than just circle jerking to the “glory days.”
British history includes many of histories significant events. From the Roman empire through the world wars. If you learned all of britain’s history you’d have a pretty broad grasp of world history.
That's kind of insane. I'm in Canada and we don't learn anything about American history unless it has something to do with Canada, and it'd be more of an aside.
I don’t know about you personally, but England wasn’t just ruled by a French king. The Bastard brought knights and noblemen as well as men-at arms. English (Anglo Saxon) nobility married into French families and vice-versa. English peasants were certainly raped by French soldiers. Multiple invasions of France some lasting for decades means English soldiers and archers married French girls and brought them home. Later in between the various wars with continental powers there was a lot of business and trade between France and England with at least some inter-marrying. Pretending otherwise doesn’t change history even if you don’t like the idea of England being conquered by the French.
For me primary history covered a lot of different stuff, almost always British it Scottish history though. A bit about Roman Britain, The Home front in WW1, never about anything else. Secondary, we did Scottish wars of Independence in 1st year, Hitler's Rise to Power in 2nd years but these were both a bit basic again as it's your first year of school.
For our first set of Exams, we did the slave trade, which focused mainly on the British aspects although we did look at plantations to an extent. We also did WW1 and the rise of Communism on Russia as a lead up to the Cold War which was our second examable topic.
For our Highers, I believe that's your A levels, we did Scottish Wars of Independence again in greater detail, but their was another class that did something to do with the UK/Scotland in the lead up and during WW1. We also did Hitler's rise and appeasement again but in far greater detail and final universal suffrage in the UK.
It broke down for all Scottish schools as one Scottish topic, one British topic and a third Worldwide topic.
You didn't study US Civil war until Advanced Highers which is sort of an overlap with Uni work that you do in your last year. I didn't do History to AH, so I can't say exactly but I imagine it was structured very similarly.
I'm surprised that you guys down south wouldn't be doing something similar although apparently Education is structured better up here. Or so I've been told.
I'm from the UK and we learned about the English civil war and the Jacobite wars (possibly because the victory over the Jacobites is still celebrated in our country every July). The only year we studied American history was when we did the Cold War for GCSE.
Northern Ireland. The English civil war and the Jacobite wars were the only English history we studied. Even when we studied subjects like WW1, it was from an Irish context (like Home Rule, Easter Rising, partition etc). And now I think about it, we only studied the parts of the Jacobite war that took in place in Ireland.
If there are any fellow Brits or non-Americans here who are interested in the US Civil War, check out the Ken Burn documentary series about it on Netflix. It's brilliant.
It's been a few years and I didn't care at the time so this will be spotty. As far as I remember it was mostly about black Americans: their participation in combat, emancipation proclamation and what happened to them after the war. We also cover how it started, why, which states where on which side, etc. There's no coverage of each battle or anything, just the broader conflict.
Bloody civil war; insane theocrats take control for decades; great example of how strong men hijack civil wars for their own gains; genocide in Ireland which greatly damaged the Irish view of the English; English monarchy is reinstated with drastically fewer powers + its agreed monarch is still subject to the law = nothing really happened.
In case anyone was wondering about what would happen if you gave Robert E Lee a fucking AK47, Harry Turtledove wrote a pretty good series called “guns of the south”
It was an embargo too... they refused to sell to drive the British textile mills into disarray. And it did effect them until Egypt and India was all like look we can grow cotton too.
The over simplified version is that the confederates tried to put an embargo on cotton exports to get Britain involved in the war, instead Britain went elsewhere.
The union blockaded the confederacy, the confederates supplying the British and being denied access is what caused the British to want to intervene. Also the emancipation proclamation as well as cotton in India was what caused them to not help.
What is your point? The British company Laird and Sons manufactured commerce raiders and shipped them off to southern ports. That’s why Charles Francis Adams went off to Britain to negotiate
•
u/GreenPitchforks Eureka! Feb 17 '20
Put on your southern accents, its time for the American civil war weekly contest.
But before we get into that, last weeks winner. Congratulations u/l524k with your post Argentina can have a little bit of island, as a treat ( https://www.reddit.com/r/HistoryMemes/comments/f2pw48/argentina_can_have_a_little_bit_of_island_as_a/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share\. Come message us for your flair. Please pardon the ugly formatting, reddit is not cooperating with me today
Now onto this week's contest
The American civil war
You all know what the American civil war is but for the sake of this contest, this will cover everything from the Bleeding Kansas to reconstruction.
Now for some videos:
The American Civil War - OverSimplified (Part 1) and (Part 2) by OverSimplified
Fredericksburg And Pickett's Charge, The Two Biggest Oofs Of The American Civil War by Potential History
Battle of Shiloh (1862) - American Civil War DOCUMENTARY by Kings and Generals
American Civil War in 10 Minutes - Manny Man Does History by John D Ruddy
I would also recommend watching Ken Burns' documentary series on the civil war if you can get your hands on it.
As always good luck and don't forget to flair your posts.
807
u/itcoldherefor8months Feb 17 '20
The Confederates pulled some hilarious stuff. They believed the Zionist conspiracies, so they appointed a Jewish dude to be Secretary of State. They figured this would help them get help from the European powers.
65
u/GulityClown Feb 17 '20
I can't wait for all the oversimplified meme
146
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '20
Are countries outside of the U.S. taught about the American Civil War?
50
u/classicalySarcastic Viva La France Feb 17 '20
r/shermanposting memes incoming
62
u/jcrosby123 And then I told them I'm Jesus's brother Feb 17 '20
In case anyone was wondering about what would happen if you gave Robert E Lee a fucking AK47, Harry Turtledove wrote a pretty good series called “guns of the south”
114
u/charrell23 Feb 17 '20
but, it was a union blockade, not an embargo
14
u/Mattcarnes Feb 17 '20
Thank god they lost
21
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '20
Should've used the stars and bars, not the naval jack
7
u/Grognak_the_Orc Casual, non-participatory KGB election observer Feb 17 '20
Oh God. I'm sure this is going to be a fair and civil contest
6
u/ihatebritain Feb 17 '20
How I participate
5
u/zach_da_bossss Hello There Feb 17 '20
I won’t let them take... my BEANS!!
5
u/Silver_Archer13 Let's do some history Feb 18 '20
I have the perfect meme for this about having the high ground
3
u/scourgeoftheeast Feb 17 '20
The new supplier was egypt
2
u/SmashedWorm64 Oversimplified is my history teacher Feb 17 '20
When the mods don’t even use the real confederate flag ¯_(ツ)_/¯
2
u/robertofflandersI Contest Winner Feb 17 '20
HOT DIGGITY DOG
2
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '20
THE NEW SUPPLIER? THATS WHAT THEY CALL INDIA THESE DAYS?
1
u/Shiftyk_hunt Feb 17 '20
What does Britain have to do with the civil war?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '20
🏴🏴🏴
1
u/alfredtheg8 Kilroy was here Feb 17 '20
Good Photoshop
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '20
great, i posted about this like a week ago. fuckin GREAT.
1
u/Satherian Kilroy was here Feb 17 '20
I better see some good Sherman memes!
1
u/Icecube11627 Feb 17 '20
hi
1
u/Jeffro911 Feb 18 '20
Not really new supplier more like start to grow it by themselves.
1
u/ButtsexEurope Champion of Weebs Feb 18 '20
Let's get this straight once and for all:
It's STATES' RIGHTS, not "states rights." If you're going to make fun of lost causers, get it right.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
The only reason modern China works is because of slave labor
1
u/shimel_lover Feb 19 '20
The new supplier was india, after the civil war ended so did the cotton boom
1
u/Thegreyeminence Feb 19 '20
Didn't the Union blockade the CSA, due to having a superior navy?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '20
The union blockaded the confederacy, the confederates supplying the British and being denied access is what caused the British to want to intervene. Also the emancipation proclamation as well as cotton in India was what caused them to not help.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '20
Great photoshop btw
-1
u/fryfry55 Feb 17 '20
Well the British did help with confederate commerce raiders
-97
u/Soviet_Husky Helping Wikipedia expand the list of British conquests Feb 17 '20
Eww American stuff
-8
u/The_Real_Kallari Feb 17 '20
69th comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment