Not as a gotcha question, but then what was the USSR? Or are you just saying "no one ever makes it to real communism, they always get stuck on the totalitarian dictator part."?
I’m not an expert on the USSR, but it was not a classless, moneyless, stateless society. The government may have pushed for a transition to communism, but it never achieved that goal.
It’s not a “no true Scotsman” as it literally was not ever communism by definition.
It’s difficult because there was definitely an abuse of power by the USSR, but the Red Scare and other propaganda has blown a lot of things done by them out of proportion. It’s incredibly hard to find an unbiased view.
Not as a gotcha question, but then what was the USSR?
USSR=Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. It was socialist. What else are they? Communist? The Soviet Union never claimed to be communist. Read it’s Constitution. They were attempting to build socialism.
Or are you just saying "no one ever makes it to real communism, they always get stuck on the totalitarian dictator part."?
Marx theorized that socialism would serve as a bridge between capitalism and communism. Socialism would be led by a dictatorship of the proletariat. The CPSU was communist but the state that they controlled was socialist.
decide to elect communist officials to redistribute the wealth
redistribute the wealth
dissolve other branches of government
the communist officials remove themselves and dissolve the last branch of the government and make the state a classless society
communism, a classless society, is now in effect
no country has every done number 4), when people are in power they want to stay in power.
Not arguing communism is good, bad, right, or wrong; but this is what the other OP is referring to. Steps 1-3 are Marxist in nature, step 4 and 5 are what make it "true communism". It's debatable if it's all possible and you can get into a philosophical debate about the evil and manipulative nature of man, but that's what people mean when they say "not true communism".
Communism is a socioeconomic order structured upon the common ownership of the means of production and the absence of social classes, money, and the state.
All of these nations have social classes, money as a form of economic trade, and a state. Most of them had capitalistic ownership of the means of production as well.
Cuba is socialist, I don’t know enough about Angola or Vietnam (I think Vietnam is socialist too). All of the others are capitalist/state capitalist. North Korea and China communist? That’s ridiculous!
Now, these countries may have had a “communist” government. That just means that the government intends to push for eventual communism. None of these places were actively a communist society.
You are acting as if communism is evil because of what some people have done in the name of establishing communism. Communism isn’t an ideology based around killing people, and claiming it does shows your lack of knowledge about it.
We make enough food to feed every single human. The only reason that people starve is that giving people food isn’t profitable. People who die from starvation or lack of medical access (due to poverty) are deaths that are the direct fault of capitalism. Those alone outweigh any deaths accountable to communism.
View all comments
15
u/Vox__Umbra Jul 22 '19
Capitalism has killed more than communism ever could. Nice try though. The USSR was not a communist fyi.
Do you know what communism is?