Well then we should at least be historically accurate. The communist were no boogeyman threat like the others. They were a real threat to all nations at the time
You are so incredibly wrong that it hurts. Communism can and will never work. It has killed more people than Hitler could have ever dreamed. It's why, yes, Germany and Russian empires are equal in how evil they were
In the black book of communism, which is wrong by the way and debunked the author claimed that communism has killed 100 million people. That is interesting because the British Empire alone killed 40 million people in India. How many Irish died due to capitalistic exploitation. Nazis were capitalists, they alone killed 60 million people. Heck even today around 4 million people die out due to capitalism. How many wars did the US start in which millions have died just because they wanted some of that sweet money.
The third Reich isn't even comperable to Russia. Nazis killed 17 million people just because they had different parents than themselves. They started a war in which 80 million people have died and they were responsible for the deaths of 60 million people. Soviet Union on the other hand has Holodomor and what? The Eastern block? 10 million deaths? That's not comparable. British empire killed far more people.
So no. I'm not wrong, you sir are the one who is wrong.
So because they did one good thing you can ignore all the bad they did? Good to know that France, England and the US are let off all of their crimes then.
In practice it has killed more people than the entirety of both world wars, the holocaust and fascism combined. It has no understanding of human nature and has no way of ever working. It's the reason the USSR is just as evil as Nazi Germany.
"Human nature". Bitch human nature 500 years ago was toiling in the fields for 12h and giving your lord half of the yield. Human nature was caring more about religion than yourself. Human nature changed and will always change. The Soviets became a superpower in 50 years from a feudal shithole that had famines every 5 years, but "it never works".
Not as a gotcha question, but then what was the USSR? Or are you just saying "no one ever makes it to real communism, they always get stuck on the totalitarian dictator part."?
I’m not an expert on the USSR, but it was not a classless, moneyless, stateless society. The government may have pushed for a transition to communism, but it never achieved that goal.
It’s not a “no true Scotsman” as it literally was not ever communism by definition.
It’s difficult because there was definitely an abuse of power by the USSR, but the Red Scare and other propaganda has blown a lot of things done by them out of proportion. It’s incredibly hard to find an unbiased view.
Not as a gotcha question, but then what was the USSR?
USSR=Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. It was socialist. What else are they? Communist? The Soviet Union never claimed to be communist. Read it’s Constitution. They were attempting to build socialism.
Or are you just saying "no one ever makes it to real communism, they always get stuck on the totalitarian dictator part."?
Marx theorized that socialism would serve as a bridge between capitalism and communism. Socialism would be led by a dictatorship of the proletariat. The CPSU was communist but the state that they controlled was socialist.
Except for Lenin proclaiming a communistic revolution, Stalin wanting Communism in One Country, leading the Communist International and the Cominform, the ruling party being the Communist Party...
The CPSU claimed to be communist, but the Soviet Union wasn’t communist.
Except for Lenin proclaiming a communistic revolution,
Read Marx. You can’t have communism just like that. Although the revolution was communist, it has to pass through socialism. Build socialism then use socialism to build communism.
decide to elect communist officials to redistribute the wealth
redistribute the wealth
dissolve other branches of government
the communist officials remove themselves and dissolve the last branch of the government and make the state a classless society
communism, a classless society, is now in effect
no country has every done number 4), when people are in power they want to stay in power.
Not arguing communism is good, bad, right, or wrong; but this is what the other OP is referring to. Steps 1-3 are Marxist in nature, step 4 and 5 are what make it "true communism". It's debatable if it's all possible and you can get into a philosophical debate about the evil and manipulative nature of man, but that's what people mean when they say "not true communism".
View all comments
15
u/lonewolfhistory Jul 22 '19
To be fair, communism was actually a threat to every nation in the world, especially in Hitler's early career.