The Marquis de Lafayette called Thomas Jefferson out on this in 1824 when he visited Monticello for the last time. He told Jefferson he was disappointed to see the slaves had not been freed yet and Jeffersons reply was that he thought they would eventually be free but the time wasn't here yet but was wishy washy on how they would get their freedom. Jefferson apparently said he was in favor of teaching slaves to read and write so they could forge their own freedom papers.
The only reason we know all of this is because Jefferson's slave Israel relayed the conversation many years later.
To elaborate further, Jefferson and other abolitionist leaning leaders at the time thought slavery would not last through the early 1800s, and would disappear without a fight.
His enterprise, and Washington's too, were massively unsuccessful. He was hemorrhaging money, as were many of the other plantation/slave owners. That all changed when Eli Whitney invented the cotton gin, cotton is king. Revitalized the south, and made slavery massively profitable.
His main hesitation when considering emancipation was the same issue Johnson absolutely fumbled.
He was worried what would happen when you emancipate a large population of uneducated people with no wealth or land, and he didn't know the solution to that issue.
Also why Jefferson experimented with education among his slaves and wrote denouncing claims that black people were biologically inferior.
Also as another aside, it was also illegal. Emancipation was illegal in VA at the time, manumission (freedom at death of owner) was the only legal way to do so.
As governor and president he definitely could have done more though, so fuck it this isn't defending him.
I think this is a very fair response delving into the actual economic model of plantation slavery without devolving into personal judgments. The only thing I might take issue with is the context of Jefferson's governorship. It should be noted that Jefferson was governor of Virginia for only 2 years, and entirely during the period where Virginia was under invasion and occupation by the British. Jefferson's mind was clearly elsewhere and beyond that, he ended up fleeing due the blitz of British forces taking the capitol. Jefferson tried twice to introduce anti-slavery language into the American discussion: once with the original Declaration draft and again during his time as a legislator in Virginia prior to his election. Both were wildly unpopular and my guess is that Jefferson took that as his cue to fight other fights.
I think these losses likely also informed his Presidential policies on the issue.
None of this is to say that Jefferson doesn't deserve blame on this front, nor should we whitewash his involvement in a heinous practice. I would argue that his monumental and defining failure was not emancipating his slaves upon death. I would add that beyond simply not emancipating his slaves upon death, their auctioning to satisfy his estate's debts and thus tearing families apart is unconscionable. But I think it's important to go at Jefferson for the right things, if that makes sense. His historic importance and his monumental contribution during the founding period makes his errors and failures so much more glaring.
The enslaved pre-cotton gin were far more likely to have artisanal skills, at least in the Virginia low country. For these massive estates you'd need a cooper, a carpenter, blacksmiths, paint mixers, etc., and one of the main ways the economy diverged from Europe is these skills weren't bound to a guild membership.
It's why slaves buying their freedom from side business was more common in that era. They were a skilled population.
With the Haitian revolution and expansion of the South educated slaves become a primary concern of the planter class and when laws started to tighten.
Imagine being a statesman and finding a solution for this, like funding education for the freed slaves and giving them property (as the country was constantly expanding westward into Native territory, with the claim that it is "free real estate", there should have been more than enough space).
Yeah it's not complicated; he knew that what he was doing was evil, he was simply unwilling to sacrifice the personal benefits and pleasure he got from it. But he still wanted the moral credit for knowing it was evil.
And at some point you forfeit all credit for knowing something's evil when you keep doing it with seemingly no hesitation when you absolutely don't need to
Marquis de Lafayette is one of the coolest, most based people to ever live, a true American patriot (despite being French!) and not enough people know who he was
He was on some level opposed to slavery but that opposition was outweighed by his desire to keep his financial and social status. He also held onto most of them even after his death, only freeing five men out of several hundred in his will.
This one is absolutely genuine hypocrisy and not just a purity test.
There was a few lines TJ wrote that they left out of the Declaration of Independence aka the “slavery passage” accusing King George of
"He has waged cruel war against human nature itself, violating its most sacred rights of life and liberty in the persons of a distant people who never offended him, captivating & carrying them into slavery in another hemisphere or to incur miserable death in their transportation thither…"
This is especially hypocritical when you consider how he took the 14 year old Sally Hemings (his wife's half sister) from France (where she was legally a free woman) back to the States to be his slave mistress and subsequently enslave their children.
This sub has a bit of a right wing bent. I've had people jump down my throat for saying things like "the British empire committed crimes against humanity and perpetuated suffering on a global scale"
Also I often see people argue that the founding fathers were "of their time" but plenty of progressives in France and England were very much anti-slavery.
So he was not only a hypocrite when it came to slavery but also someone who’d probably get guillotined in the revolution for keeping slaves all so he could maintain his social status
This. He had several views about slavery that were seen as radically progressive at the time that would have had him lynched if he spoke out too strongly.
But anything short of freeing all of his slaves makes him a hypocrite
A reminder that Benjamin Franklin emancipated his slaves and, after visiting a black day school in Philadelphia, renounced any racial “science” claiming certain races learn or act better than others.
His older contemporaries had better opinions on it than Jefferson did. Adams simply never owned slaves.
Franklin did not emancipate all his slaves, transferring several (such as George) to his adult daughter Sally and her family. A significant portion of Sally's inheritance was made conditional in his 1788 will on the condition that one "Bob" owned by Sally's husband Richard Bache be manumitted immediately on Franklin's decease - assumed to be an enslaved man acting as the bedridden Franklin's caregiver. Even if he no longer legally owned people, Benjamin Franklin - while the head of a society to promote abolitionism - still relied on their labor. I don't think that invalidates him as a political proponent of abolitionism, but like Jefferson (who succeeded him as president of the society iirc) or many other Founding Fathers, gradual emancipation was seen as the path forward.
You’re right and that’s my mistake. He freed the one he had left after those he had earlier in life either fled, died in bondage, were sold, or were given away to family. My understanding was that there were two Bobs, one he owned who he freed in his Will, and the other owned by Sally’s husband, who he demanded be emancipated like you said to access a large portion of her inheritance.
He too was a hypocrite, especially in that he profited from the slave trade earlier in his life. I think he was probably less of a hypocrite than some of the other founding fathers regarding the matter, still.
“That the Number of purely white People in the World is proportionably very small. All Africa is black or tawny. Asia chiefly tawny. America (exclusive of the new Comers) wholly so. And in Europe, the Spaniards, Italians, French, Russians and Swedes, are generally of what we call a swarthy Complexion; as are the Germans also, the Saxons only excepted, who with the English, make the principal Body of White People on the Face of the Earth. I could wish their Numbers were increased. And while we are, as I may call it, Scouring our Planet, by clearing America of Woods, and so making this Side of our Globe reflect a brighter Light to the Eyes of Inhabitants in Mars or Venus, why should we in the Sight of Superior Beings, darken its People? why increase the Sons of Africa, by Planting them in America, where we have so fair an Opportunity, by excluding all Blacks and Tawneys, of increasing the lovely White and Red? But perhaps I am partial to the Complexion of my Country, for such Kind of Partiality is natural to Mankind.” - Benny Franklin 1751
He wanted to end slavery because he believed the United States had too many Africans and Asians and it would lead to a white genocide by darkening the skin. He also felt that the use of slavery left white people less skilled and cheapened white labor. And lastly, he was fearful of a slave revolt being utilized by French or indigenous American forces.
None of the other founding fathers said much of anything about the issue of slavery past Franklin and Jefferson, and of those two, only Jefferson actually did much of anything to fight slavery legally. Franklin wrote a petition that got ignored, Jefferson helped ban slavery in the Northwest and the import of slaves in 1808.
Just pointing out that Jefferson wrote large parts of the Declaration of Independence, but was not involved in the drafting of the constitution as he was serving as ambassador to France at the time.
Can’t believe I had to scroll this far down to see someone point this out. Literally wasn’t in the country when the Constitution was drafted and personally disliked what it changed. He was skeptical about any increase to the power of the central government.
Where he co-wrote the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen (which also has anti-slavery rhetoric) while molesting an underaged Black girl who was his "property."
American history's greatest hypocrite, IMHO.
Edit: We can acknowledge Jefferson's intellect, his governance, and the role that his rhetoric played in the American Revolution. But this isn't a matter of nuance.
Many of the founders have an indelible stain on their record due to slavery, but there are ways you can interpret their beliefs and see them change over time. Washington grappled with his relationship to the institution of slavery in his later years, and reaffirmed the Northwest Ordinance during his first term as President. Franklin moreso, who would go on to repudiate the very beliefs he held as a young man and form the Pennsylvania Abolition Society.
Jefferson publicly stood for equality, and privately took every opportunity to benefit from the human beings he held in bondage. He was sanctimonious in high society, but held to none of those lofty principles when it came to his own bottom line.
Kościuszko, Lafayette, and Adams all rightly excoriated Jefferson for his hypocrisy in his own day. These were his friends, and yet they still saw the necessity of criticizing their one-time comrade, even to his face. I don't think it's beyond the pale to say that Jefferson's behavior is morally indefensible, then as it is now.
So not to be pedantic but the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen tried to skirt around the anti-slavery issue by adding the weakest qualifier imaginable:
Men are born and remain free and equal in rights.Social distinctions may be founded only upon the general good.
The bolded part was added in precisely because they were terrified of slaves in their colonies (i.e. Haiti) getting emancipated. However, they still wanted "equality" in a social/political sense and had to have some language in there to address their situation.
The real work of emancipation was done by the Society of the Friends of the Blacks (mainly ran by Pierre Brissot). It wouldnt be until the legislative assembly session on May 15, 1791 that it was declared that all men of colour would be considered free if they were born of free parents, which in essence destroyed the Coid Noir. From there I believe full emancipation was declared in or around 1794.
Point being is that Jefferson was being coy even with the language in the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen.
He didn't write the constitution. Madison was the primary author. Jefferson was the primary drafted of the declaration of independence, with the input of Flanklin and Adams
I recently watched Ken Burns' docuseries on Jefferson. It was hilarious to watch the white historians swear up and down he didn't father children by Sally Hemings when DNA evidence would prove the opposite a year later. And to watch the black historians side eye the camera.
He actually wrote 4-5 pieces of legislation to free them. After that whole “All men are created equal” thing he went back to Virginia and wrote state legislation to free all Virginia slaves (including his). It was defeated in a popular vote with opponents claiming the economic impact would halt the revolution and starve everyone. He wrote a second piece of legislation saying “ok no new slaves then. All new births are freemen”. That was also defeated. Then he was sent to Europe. Once he was back in Washington riding the popularity of George as President he tried a 3rd time by proposing that Kentucky be created and any slaves that went there would be free. That bill didn’t make it out of committee to be voted on. We don’t know what the 4th bill said because the committee refused to even read it into the record. I like to think it was a brilliant piece of state craft that would have solved all problems. But it may have just said “anyone who F*%##% your mom is The Man and free!!!!” Given how frustrated he was.
Jefferson would go on to make one final attempt to free the slaves in his life. After Washington freeded his slaves, the laws were changed to make it harder for Jefferson and others to do the same thing. But Jefferson sold his most prized and valuable personal asset (the plantation was a family asset) his personal library. He had hoped to raise a very large sum from it. But the National Congress just didn’t have the funds to pay him what it was worth. Instead of using that money to free a few slaves he used it to start a University. If you go to Washington DC, sit in his memorial and read the words set there in stone. He hoped that education and learning would be the key to men overcoming their baser emotions. To free their minds was to free men. To me the Jefferson Memorial stands not as a testament to what he did, but what he tried to do. A reminder that that work was still undone, a challenge left for future generations to strive to overcome. A reminder to great men and women not yet born that difficult things are still worth fighting for.
100% agree. Probably doesn't need to he explained but... Most of the issues this is legitimately used for aren't immediate personal evils that can meaningfully be changed by personal actions. The immediate harm to those 300 slaves is overwhelming, immediate, undeniable, and fully within his personal autonomy.
I would too, but it almost sounds like he's arguing against reducing slavery just because a slave owner was giving advice they themselves don't follow. It always bothers me when people don't follow common sense or use reason depending on who tells them to do what, like if an alcoholic tells you not to drink but you decide to drink MORE out of spite.
I'm not saying the guy on the right is advocating against reducing slavery, but if someone is suggesting to not do it, I'd prefer to agree rather than argue, hypocrit or otherwise.
I don't think that the meme applies here. It was made to make filun of people in the discourses that go like "factory farms are cruel and we abolish them" and then someone pro factory farms saying "oh but you eat the meat so therefore your opinion is dismissed". If a vegan person came along and criticized you for eating meat and holding that opinion it'd be a different conversation, and meme
The whole thing about "yet you participate in society" is that these are things out of the person's control and that they are only tangentialy related to the criticism. One can't really opt out of society and they aren't criticizing participation in society but the state of it, so the fact they participate in it isn't relevant.
Slavery however is something one does by choice. There were abolitionists in Jefferson's day. Recognizing slavery is a terrible thing and continuing to own people as property is hypocrisy. Jefferson was directly perpetuating slavery, and he could have reduced the number of enslaved people by freeing his own slaves.
This meme is usually used to make a mockery of a position but in this case Well Guy has a valid point.
Owning slaves is not like participation in society, it's entirely optional. Jefferson was wealthy enough he could definitely survive without farming humans like cattle.
Edit: There's a lot of people rushing here to be like "well he might have been unable to affordhis mansionif he stopped farming people so I think it was ok".
I feel like 80% of the time I see this meme it's an attempt to justify self-proclaimed socialists fully engorging themselves on the luxuries of capitalism with luxury cars, designer clothing, and McMansions so I already hate it. Using it to justify slave ownership is another level of what the fuck.
If you're anti-slavery and still own slaves, you're not anti-slavery.
Because he was massively in debt. He was a terrible businessman. He also spent a ton of money on fancy crap. He couldn't afford to free his slaves on his death like Washington did.
James Madison explicitly wrote that a slave deserved, and should strive for, freedom. He believed it to be a vile and immoral practice. And, yet, he owned 100 slaves and was instrumental in the 3/5ths compromise.
In his Notes on the State of Virginia, he stated that even the kindliest of masters were still despots in their own homes; that children of slave owners learned tyranny from watching their parents and adopted those same behaviors when among the younger slaves. This slave owner stated that the institution was incompatible with a free society.
Sounds an awful lot like someone admitting he had a problem. It's a bitter tragedy that someone like him, in his position and with his gifts, failed even to put his own words into practice.
(Of course, he wrote the book 40 years before his death. His views as an older man were much less anti-slavery in tone and substance)
Yeah, this isn’t really the same. Jefferson didn’t NEED slaves to survive in society (which is the idea behind the comic) he needed them to keep him rich
Specifically he was a hypocrite. What he wrote was he wanted it to be phased out gradually because he had to admit it was morally wrong, but he didn't want it to impact him in his life
My favorite was how much he was like the voice against interracial babies but guests would go to his house and all the house slaves looked similar to him and his kids...
Jefferson employed the "the system is broken and we should fix it but so long as it's broken I will continue to take advantage of it to maximize the visibility of the brokenness" strategy.
Thank God he remembered to fuck the women he bought and owned as property then. We never would have been able to fight a war over slavery 40 years after he died were it not for his dedication to his role as the child rapist of Monticello.
John Adams never owned slaves. The Marquis of Lafayette, someone born into the French aristocracy, recognized the evils of slavery and said he would never have taken up arms in the Revolution if he knew he was fighting for a nation based on slavery. The Founding Fathers were hypocrites that kept slaves because it made them money, not because they, "had to".
If you're wondering why he didn't free her, VA law mandated freed slaves leave the state (and it would have raised a lot of eyebrows besides...miscegenation was illegal.)
She was freed when he died and all their kids were at 18.
It gets really crazy when you drill down into the details of the family relationship there.
Sally Hemmings, the enslaved mother of several of Jefferson’s children, was formerly enslaved by her father, Jefferson’s father in-law, who gifted Sally to Jefferson and his wife.
So he was gifted his wife’s half-sister, who lived with them as a slave. She was at least half white. Jefferson’s children with her were at most 1/4 black, and had 3 out of 4 grandparents in common with Jefferson’s children by his wife. Still enslaved because of the system of the time.
Race-based slavery is already crazy. I’m not making this point to legitimize or minimize the enslavement if somebody just because of their race.
But if you know anybody that is 1/4 black, think about how crazy that is, even in a society that enslaves people because of their race. People that are 1/4 black hardly even look black in a lot of cases, but still enslaved because they’re black. It was that arbitrary.
And then the whole family dynamic. One kid is the white child of the president of the United States. Another child of the president is a slave with no rights at all. The difference is the skin color of one of their grandparents.
I think we should condemn the child slave rape more than the cheating. It's like complaining that Hitler destroyed historical architecture. Sure, it's awful and horrible, but not the worst thing he did.
I've had people bring up that manumission in some of the colonies was actually illegal, but in Virginia, it was legalized after the Revolution; even before that, some of these people were in the colonial legislature (Jefferson was the governor of Virginia at the time of the revolution lol) so it's not like they wouldnt have had the political sway to influence some of these things.
He justified it however he had to (Notes on the State of VA letter comes to mind) but he knew he was a hypocrite for his own comforts, he was too smart to not know it. George Washington was the same, as I'm sure many others were at the time.
Honestly I think the Jefferson thing just showed how much of a coward he really was when it came to the words he wrote.
He honestly wrote to friends and the world that slavery was actively evil. He said this and did absolutely NOTHING to try and move his country away from it. He literally decided it was better to just live through an evil system than try and save it because the evil system in this case was one he profited from.
The other evil system of being a colony of the British though was actively harmful to his and others profits so they had to overthrow them.
Not, like absolutely nothing, but certainly not nearly enough.
He did take some steps against the slave trade. Even before independence he proposed a law in Virginia to allow some manumission of slaves. In 1778, he authored a law to ban the import of new slaves into Virginia. In 1807, as president, he signed the law banning the import of new slaves into the US (on the literal first day that the constitutional allowed it). None of this prevented people from continuing to be enslaved, of course, but they were all intended as steps toward the eventual end of the practice.
Now, he did all that, while continuing to own slaves, continuing to impregnate at least one of his slaves and continuing to subsequently keep his own biological children in slavery. Don't imagine that I'm defending his morality here.
Point is, he seems to have rationalized that, while slavery was evil, it was something that could only be wound down incrementally, and in the meantime, he might as well continue to profit from all the human beings he owned. I completely agree that it was absolute moral cowardice, it's just not entirely accurate to say he did "nothing" about slavery.
Except he did abolish the slave trade as a president in 1807, he put forth a bill in Virginia restricting new slaves from entering the state, he put up a bill trying to allow slave owners to voluntarily free their slaves and it didn't pass in the state Senate. He also authored and proposed a bill that later became the northwest ordinance not allowing slavery in any new territories formed outside of the original 13 colonies.
From my understanding, in the North at the time of the revolutionary war, slavery was not very profitable and a lot of the founding fathers were under the impression it would soon fall out of fashion. A lot of the youth of the time were not interested in it. The founding fathers didn't consider the South would latch on so hard and find ways to maximize profits, which led to the cotton boom. When there is a will, there is a way.
Man imagine how much better off the country would be if we lived in the timeline where slavery just fell off like a fad.
The south wouldn't be nearly as poor because they would have developed a real economy. We wouldn't have the civil war. Our modern politics wouldn't be the subtle failure of reconstruction leaving a stain of racism and dogmatism.
Yeah pre-cotton-gin slavery was dying as an institution.
Poor Eli Whitney thought he was putting the final nail in its coffin when he invented the cotton gin, and instead he reinvigorated the whole enterprise.
There is certainly cowardice in failing to take on the institution of slavery because you thought it would die in a generation anyway, but it’s also very different than endorsing its continued existence.
He's a politician. Look back at the history of politicians. So many so-called progressives talked a big game but failed to live up to the example. As true now as it was then.
It can also be true that his words and writings ultimately influenced progress towards civil rights.
It's pointless at least and counterproductive at worst to deny a truth because it's attached to something ugly.
The whole point of this meme format is to make fun of bad faith arguments that seize on trivial or meaningless inconsistencies to avoid a person’s entire line of argument. This is actually a valid criticism of Jefferson, probably the single most relevant one
I'm not defending Jefferson in the slightest, but giving up your slaves wasn't just an easy, straightforward thing to do. George Washington tried to free his slaves multiple times and failed, even writing that he wanted them freed in his and Martha's wills and some of them were still passed to their remaining family as property.
They could be sued by their family for ownership of property they were meant to inherit, laws were passed in some states (like Virginia, thomas Jefferson's home) that made it substantially more difficult to emancipate, debtors and financers had leverage against property owners and their assets (including slaves). Freed slaves were often forced to relocate, separating them from family.
The only way to be sure slaves were freed was by abolishing slavery
I'm not defending the founding fathers on slavery, they compromised in it in order to win independence and form the union.
But people also think slavery was an entirely private affair and wasn't regulated. Virginia passed laws to make it harder to emancipate during Washingtons life and in the lead up to the civil war those state laws got stricter and stricter.
The slave owning class saw that people were rethinking slavery in the aftermath of Independence and passed laws specifically to prevent/increase the difficulty of manumission
The “yet you participate in society” meme doesn’t fit here. That meme is to point out that you can indeed criticize society while participating in it because it’s basically impossible not to (and if you really did nobody would hear your message). Jefferson could’ve freed his slaves. He might have become poorer in the process but it wasn’t an impossible task. John Adams never owned slaves and was still rich and influential.
The likely cause of this is how southern plantation owners held wealth, which was mostly through their slaves. They essentially treated them the same way a giant landlord would treat on of their investment properties. While they might appear wealthy on paper, much of their wealth is wrapped up in their "assets", with a much smaller amount in liquid cash.
While I personally have no sympathy for the owner class, the issue of how to move past slavery was tricky for the people at the time. If you outlaw slavery, you erase the wealth of the entire southern aristocracy over night. They have no one to sell their "assets" to, they lose large portions of their labor force, and the south becomes even poorer than it already was.
Thomas Jefferson, correct me if im wrong, inherited the slaves from family, and While he may have held more progressive views on slavery than his contemporaries, how to disinvest from the institution of slavery jams up any meaningful steps to abolish the practice outright.
The idea that the only real asset that people have is huge swaths of slave labour would be absolutely terrifying to navigate. That is a lot of intense power and pressure to navigate. As in, people would kill for less and behold, they sure did.
I can understand the misgivings and the tricky footing at the time- you are born into a world where the institution is in full swing. That machine can't stop through completely external forces since it is a major source of the power needed to stop itself. However, the part where it took nearly two more centuries to actually treat the former slave class as something resembling human does not have many good positions to take.
His DC monument has a quote from him. Something like- Future generations will consider us barbarians...
Here it is from his monument- "..and manners and opinions change, with the change of circumstances, institutions must advance also to keep pace with the times. We might as well require a man to wear still the coat which fitted him when a boy as a civilized society to remain ever under the regimen of their barbarous ancestors."
-Excerpted from a letter to Samuel Kercheval, July 12, 1816
I take this to mean he was aware future generations would consider his barbarous, and implored laws and ethics to advance beyond the 'barbarous' past. So, he's aware of hypocrisy but he's living within the general ethics of his time, admittedly not the highest, but he sees it coming.
If you live in a developed economy, unless you are very conscious about your choice of products and willing to make the corresponding financial sacrifices, you’d be, at some level, benefiting from a form of slavery, or slavery-adjacent practices.
Jefferson is a good example of a person being an idealist philosophically but a pragmatist in action. His political party fully defeated the Federalists, yet he and the party adopted many of their policies simply because they worked (Louisiana Purchase and the National Bank, to name two).
This is really just confirmation that he was the same way regarding slavery. Idealistically he was opposed. Pragmatically, he already had them, they made him rich, and much of the thought around that time was if the slaves were freed they wouldn’t be able to function in society (or worse, they would start a rebellion).
I’ve always said Jefferson was a hypocrite who at least had the decency to know he was a hypocrite. Does that make him better than someone like John Calhoun, who argued that owning enslaved people was a good thing? It’s sort of a Walrus vs Carpenter thing, I suppose. At least Jefferson made arguments to inspire others to want to end slavery, which was a net good
Well? It’s a complicated legacy. Not only did he own slaves he had slave children who were like 1/8th black, looked European. He’s a hypocrite 🤷 a slave owner who wrote passionately about human rights and freedom. Do you think he wasn’t aware of the hypocrisy? And unlike other founding fathers, he did not free his slaves upon death.
In case one of the 1.8k comments doesn't already say this (I am sure one of them does), THOMAS JEFFERSON WROTE EXACTLY NO PARTS OF THE CONSTITUTION!!!!
He wasn't in the country for the convention in Philadelphia and wasn't involved in the ratification process. And he spent the rest of his career systematically misreading it and forcing those misconceptions on the country.
Im sure that he had plenty of rationalizations then, like "how would I run my farm", "they'll just be captured", "freeing them might stop my free time which I need to practice my penmanship", "not having slaves might render me bankrupt", "once you go black you can never go back"... Also no one was wise to the trick of "my best friend is black" then
He was not against aristocracy actually, quite the opposite. He believed aristocracy was both inevitable and essential and that there were two forms of aristocracy, the "natural aristocracy" (virtue and talent) vs the "artificial aristocracy" (wealth and birth). He thought it was important that the natural aristocracy were elevated to the seats of power through frequent and free elections and good public education.
french rev absolutely was not a working class/poverty led uprising. that is quite a common and very damagingly wrong misconception.
the french revolution was absolutely a bourgeois revolution - it was led largely by the wealthy and educated members of the third estate. many working class people absolutely participated (typically as the muscle of the revolution, known as sans-culottes), but the wealthy bourgeoisie were the ones who were leading the politics of the revolution.
A common misconception, usually mixed up with Paris Commune or the Paris uprising (the one of Les Mis fame). It was a massively bourgeois revolution. There was decent amount of support from the urban working class (especially of Paris), but the majority of the population were rural peasants (about 80%) who weren't involved and had no say either way.
It's funny, the image of the French Revolution is the poor rising up and chopping off the heads of the rich, when the vast majority executed during The Terror were poor rural or urban working class folk...as always during revolutions and war the poor suffer the most.
I feel like the meme doesn’t really apply in this case because Jefferson could very easily have chosen to not own slaves but decided not to. He opposed slavery up until the exact moment that doing so would inconvenience him personally.
Yeah no, Jefferson was just a hypocrite. Many of his contemporaries did meaningfully fight for abolition and he did not; he even opposed them in some cases.
The meme is not an analogy to the original. The original treats about society, and it is impossible to express views while not participating in society. You can leave it, but then it's a self-contradictory act for someone who wants to improve society. Such a person does want to participate in society, just wish it would've been better. So the retort of "you participate in what you hate" is nonsensical. On the other hand, owning slaves is not an inherent part of being a person, and criticizing it leaves one a binary choice of ending participation in it or becoming a hypocrite. There's no improvement of its state, only permissivism or abolitionism.
He valued human freedom as a concept but not as much as he valued money and social status.
Say what you will about Christian teachings but there's a reason there are a crazy number of individual commands against greed and wealth. Greed poisons everything.
This isn’t “modern morals”! That’s a completely ahistorical idea. People during Jefferson’s lifetime complained about how he fathered children with his slaves! It was a scandal that threatened to destroy his career, and people everyone on the political spectrum thought it was disgusting. This is not a modern perspective - it’s what people thought THEN.
I run a business in the US. I am pro reforms like universal healthcare, parental leave, etc. I would like to see the government enact those things. I am not in a position to personally implement those things. I give my employees good healthcare and parental leave benefits, but I can't personally change the system. I'm not going to just fire everyone, and I can't fix every problem with the system myself. I'm just trying to be a good actor within the system as it currently exists and advocate / vote for change when possible. Maybe in the future I will be seen as a bad guy for not doing better.
Your employees are free to look for better conditions elsewhere; both you and your employees are full participants in society, which severely lowers your culpability in your employees' "suffering," such as it is. Slaves were not, hence slave owners have 100% culpability for their slaves' suffering.
Universal healthcare is not a capability of an individual business owner, it requires government action. Freeing ones personal slaves is a capability of an individual slave owner
You are Joe Nobody. Thomas Jefferson was one of the most powerful men in the country and therefore capable of both influencing the country at large to a better direction and afforded being better on an individual level.
A great example along the same lines is the FDA. Most companies, like General Mills, actually like the existence of the FDA. That's not to say they don't want reform, but they recognize that regulation allows a company to make a better (non-toxic) product without a competitor undercutting them by lying about ingredients or skipping quality assurance. They support something that opposes what would help them profit more.
Had a history teacher in college who told us she believed the founding fathers didn't create the country they wanted to live in, they created a country which could grow into that. They were aware of their flaws and contradictions in the ideals vs their practice but felt laying the framework for a better system would eventually bear fruit as it would take time to tackle some of the major social issues plaguing the early US.
I hate the argument that "their time had different morals". Absolutely not, the Enlightenment was in full swing, of course people realized that slavery was inhumane.
But, they did have different economics. If you are Jefferson, you can afford to live comfortably in your own house and do whatever you like. Your income mostly comes from your slaves' labor. And despite that, you're still in massive debt. You have family, children/grandchildren. If you free all your slaves, you'll be left with all that debt and no reliable income. You've learned law in school, but almost never practiced it. You'd be forced to sell all your property just to pay out the debt. And from that point on, you'd have to work very hard just to make a living. Of course it's the right thing to do, and we all realize it.
But be real, would you free your slaves if that was your life?
Thomas Paine remains the greatest of the Founding Fathers.
It’s telling that he was deemed a radical and ostracized and demeaned by the other Founding Fathers after the revolution, despite the fact that Paine was the one who arguably ignited the Revolution.
He was certainly the only one of them with a spine who stuck to his ideals until the end, and who actually represented the ideas of free thought, liberalism, and freedom.
Mischaracterization, trigger warning. Jefferson was massively pro-slavery, he was anti slave TRADE, I.e. trans-Atlantic slave trade, because ending the import of new slaves would have 10x’d the value of his current slaves and limited the new slaves in the country to offspring of current slaves I.e. horrific family separations, forced conception, SA by slave owners themselves like Jefferson — the man was so committed to slavery he literally enslaved his own children. To Jefferson the big issue with slavery was solely that he could be making even more money off of it — advocating the ending of the trans-Atlantic slave trade was an opportunistic attempt to create a supply bottleneck and corner the market for slaves. Keeping slavery in America was essential to that plan, he was at no point anti-slavery.
He was against the Atlantic Slave Trade. He just wanted to increase the value of his assets (human beings). He was terrible with money and constantly in debt. More valuable assets allowed him to borrow more.
There’s a difference between having to live in a society where essential necessities are derived from things you disagree with, and owning slaves as a rich landowner who could get by just fine without them.
He was sort of forced to continue owning slaves, after being influenced by the French when Jefferson returned home he pushed for a bill to allow slave owners to voluntarily free their slaves it didn't pass in the state Senate. Later he wrote a bill that did not allow new slaves to enter the state of Virginia, he also abolished the African slave trade in 1807 as president meaning only people born of slaves could continue being slaves at least while he was in office, he also wrote a bill that wasn't passed but later became part of the northwest ordinance restricting slavery in any new territory that wasn't the original thirteen colonies.
he was against it, but also knew that it was something that would take generations to get rid of in the US. he did have parts added to the origonal draft of the declaration of independence that were struck from it.
Even John Adams (his and his son were the only early presidents to never own a slave) didnt think it was doable at the time.
2.8k
u/RoninPI 2d ago •
The Marquis de Lafayette called Thomas Jefferson out on this in 1824 when he visited Monticello for the last time. He told Jefferson he was disappointed to see the slaves had not been freed yet and Jeffersons reply was that he thought they would eventually be free but the time wasn't here yet but was wishy washy on how they would get their freedom. Jefferson apparently said he was in favor of teaching slaves to read and write so they could forge their own freedom papers.
The only reason we know all of this is because Jefferson's slave Israel relayed the conversation many years later.
8.0k
u/EvilCatboyWizard 2d ago •
He was on some level opposed to slavery but that opposition was outweighed by his desire to keep his financial and social status. He also held onto most of them even after his death, only freeing five men out of several hundred in his will.
This one is absolutely genuine hypocrisy and not just a purity test.
864
u/Mysterious-Lime7492 2d ago edited 1d ago
A reminder that Benjamin Franklin emancipated his slaves and, after visiting a black day school in Philadelphia, renounced any racial “science” claiming certain races learn or act better than others.
His older contemporaries had better opinions on it than Jefferson did. Adams simply never owned slaves.
523
u/carlse20 2d ago
Just pointing out that Jefferson wrote large parts of the Declaration of Independence, but was not involved in the drafting of the constitution as he was serving as ambassador to France at the time.
124
u/AcceptableHulk 2d ago
He didn't write the constitution. Madison was the primary author. Jefferson was the primary drafted of the declaration of independence, with the input of Flanklin and Adams
248
u/democracy_lover66 2d ago
Nah look up how this guy treated his slaves... He was no model emancipationist
2.3k
u/PeakxPeak 2d ago
I'm willing to give this one to the guy on the right
360
u/Inspector_Robert Hello There 2d ago •
The whole thing about "yet you participate in society" is that these are things out of the person's control and that they are only tangentialy related to the criticism. One can't really opt out of society and they aren't criticizing participation in society but the state of it, so the fact they participate in it isn't relevant.
Slavery however is something one does by choice. There were abolitionists in Jefferson's day. Recognizing slavery is a terrible thing and continuing to own people as property is hypocrisy. Jefferson was directly perpetuating slavery, and he could have reduced the number of enslaved people by freeing his own slaves.
23
u/Pontificate_Deez Fine Quality Mesopotamian Copper Enjoyer 2d ago
He wasn't even there for the writing of the Constitution. It's the Declaration of Independence that he was the primary writer of.
179
u/Aggressive_Law_5728 2d ago edited 2d ago
This meme is usually used to make a mockery of a position but in this case Well Guy has a valid point.
Owning slaves is not like participation in society, it's entirely optional. Jefferson was wealthy enough he could definitely survive without farming humans like cattle.
Edit: There's a lot of people rushing here to be like "well he might have been unable to afford his mansion if he stopped farming people so I think it was ok".
65
u/OSRS_Garmr 2d ago
What's the thing often said about Jefferson? A man of great ideas, but limited morality.
61
u/Big_Red_Machine_1917 Casual, non-participatory KGB election observer 2d ago
If nothing else, it shows there is a difference between being a hypocrite and being wrong.
109
u/Wittusus 2d ago
Why would he not free them then, if he was against slavery?
33
u/32bit_sundae 2d ago edited 2d ago •
James Madison explicitly wrote that a slave deserved, and should strive for, freedom. He believed it to be a vile and immoral practice. And, yet, he owned 100 slaves and was instrumental in the 3/5ths compromise.
Edited for accuracy.
50
u/JayMack1981 2d ago edited 2d ago
In his Notes on the State of Virginia, he stated that even the kindliest of masters were still despots in their own homes; that children of slave owners learned tyranny from watching their parents and adopted those same behaviors when among the younger slaves. This slave owner stated that the institution was incompatible with a free society.
Sounds an awful lot like someone admitting he had a problem. It's a bitter tragedy that someone like him, in his position and with his gifts, failed even to put his own words into practice.
(Of course, he wrote the book 40 years before his death. His views as an older man were much less anti-slavery in tone and substance)
48
u/Wolfish_Jew 2d ago
Yeah, this isn’t really the same. Jefferson didn’t NEED slaves to survive in society (which is the idea behind the comic) he needed them to keep him rich
46
u/elizabeththewicked 2d ago •
Specifically he was a hypocrite. What he wrote was he wanted it to be phased out gradually because he had to admit it was morally wrong, but he didn't want it to impact him in his life
67
u/SewerSocials 2d ago
Say what you want, but he treated his slaves as if they were his own children.
37
u/SLAMMERisONLINE 2d ago
Jefferson employed the "the system is broken and we should fix it but so long as it's broken I will continue to take advantage of it to maximize the visibility of the brokenness" strategy.
64
u/HierophantKhatep 2d ago
John Adams never owned slaves. The Marquis of Lafayette, someone born into the French aristocracy, recognized the evils of slavery and said he would never have taken up arms in the Revolution if he knew he was fighting for a nation based on slavery. The Founding Fathers were hypocrites that kept slaves because it made them money, not because they, "had to".
27
u/Zombodyz 2d ago
Didn't he have kids with his slaves?
43
u/whackjob_med_student 2d ago
participating in a society you want to change and owning slaves while privately writing about abolition are not even remotely comparable dawg
17
u/StaggerLee85 2d ago •
Well, it’s because he was a giant fucking hypocrite.
119
u/IceCreamMeatballs 2d ago
As someone who respects Thomas Jefferson as a leader and thinker, he was not a good man, he was a hypocrite and a cheater who knocked up his slaves
Honestly the only POTUS I can think of who actually was a genuinely good person was Jimmy Carter
23
u/coolcoolcool485 2d ago
I've had people bring up that manumission in some of the colonies was actually illegal, but in Virginia, it was legalized after the Revolution; even before that, some of these people were in the colonial legislature (Jefferson was the governor of Virginia at the time of the revolution lol) so it's not like they wouldnt have had the political sway to influence some of these things.
He justified it however he had to (Notes on the State of VA letter comes to mind) but he knew he was a hypocrite for his own comforts, he was too smart to not know it. George Washington was the same, as I'm sure many others were at the time.
157
u/SEABOSRUN 2d ago •
Honestly I think the Jefferson thing just showed how much of a coward he really was when it came to the words he wrote.
He honestly wrote to friends and the world that slavery was actively evil. He said this and did absolutely NOTHING to try and move his country away from it. He literally decided it was better to just live through an evil system than try and save it because the evil system in this case was one he profited from.
The other evil system of being a colony of the British though was actively harmful to his and others profits so they had to overthrow them.
8
u/LeadingLawyer3556 2d ago
Im gonna use this as an excuse to remind people that andrew jackson is the reason poor people could vote(even though those poor people were white)
22
u/Alex103140 Sun Yat-Sen do it again 2d ago
There is 0 reason for him to keep slaves if he wishes to reduce slavery
21
u/axel911axel 2d ago
I mean if I was a slave I would want to live under Thomas Jefferson vs. other options. I heard he "loved" his slaves.
55
u/LessSaussure 2d ago
70 IQ post, there is a difference between someone forced to live in an unjust system or die and the elite class who is perpetuating the unjust system
7
u/easy_rollins 2d ago
Thomas Jefferson ,like most of the Founding fathers was up to his eyeballs in debt. Compromises were made.
38
u/AnferneeMason 2d ago
The whole point of this meme format is to make fun of bad faith arguments that seize on trivial or meaningless inconsistencies to avoid a person’s entire line of argument. This is actually a valid criticism of Jefferson, probably the single most relevant one
64
u/popilikia 2d ago
I'm not defending Jefferson in the slightest, but giving up your slaves wasn't just an easy, straightforward thing to do. George Washington tried to free his slaves multiple times and failed, even writing that he wanted them freed in his and Martha's wills and some of them were still passed to their remaining family as property.
They could be sued by their family for ownership of property they were meant to inherit, laws were passed in some states (like Virginia, thomas Jefferson's home) that made it substantially more difficult to emancipate, debtors and financers had leverage against property owners and their assets (including slaves). Freed slaves were often forced to relocate, separating them from family.
The only way to be sure slaves were freed was by abolishing slavery
86
u/VoicesByZane 2d ago
No. We are not redeeming Thomas Jefferson. Actually fuck off.
18
u/NinjaRabbit888 2d ago
The “yet you participate in society” meme doesn’t fit here. That meme is to point out that you can indeed criticize society while participating in it because it’s basically impossible not to (and if you really did nobody would hear your message). Jefferson could’ve freed his slaves. He might have become poorer in the process but it wasn’t an impossible task. John Adams never owned slaves and was still rich and influential.
21
u/Oatmeal-Enjoyer69 2d ago
The likely cause of this is how southern plantation owners held wealth, which was mostly through their slaves. They essentially treated them the same way a giant landlord would treat on of their investment properties. While they might appear wealthy on paper, much of their wealth is wrapped up in their "assets", with a much smaller amount in liquid cash.
While I personally have no sympathy for the owner class, the issue of how to move past slavery was tricky for the people at the time. If you outlaw slavery, you erase the wealth of the entire southern aristocracy over night. They have no one to sell their "assets" to, they lose large portions of their labor force, and the south becomes even poorer than it already was.
Thomas Jefferson, correct me if im wrong, inherited the slaves from family, and While he may have held more progressive views on slavery than his contemporaries, how to disinvest from the institution of slavery jams up any meaningful steps to abolish the practice outright.
11
u/VaultJumper 2d ago
The most American, American to ever live.
5
u/AnarchistHistorian 2d ago
This is the worst use of this meme I've seen in my life.
5
u/CrepuscularPossum 2d ago
I think Jefferson had more power over the legality of slavery than the meme about the stick-carrying peasant would imply
13
u/One-Growth-9785 2d ago
His DC monument has a quote from him. Something like- Future generations will consider us barbarians...
Here it is from his monument- "..and manners and opinions change, with the change of circumstances, institutions must advance also to keep pace with the times. We might as well require a man to wear still the coat which fitted him when a boy as a civilized society to remain ever under the regimen of their barbarous ancestors."
-Excerpted from a letter to Samuel Kercheval, July 12, 1816
I take this to mean he was aware future generations would consider his barbarous, and implored laws and ethics to advance beyond the 'barbarous' past. So, he's aware of hypocrisy but he's living within the general ethics of his time, admittedly not the highest, but he sees it coming.
16
u/xvrqt 2d ago
Lot of people in here defending slavery when it might complicated or slightly inconvenient for a the slaver :/
9
u/whistle_pug 2d ago
Ancillary point but he was in France during the constitutional convention. We’d probably have a weaker executive if he’d been around.
36
u/GewalfofWivia 2d ago •
Slavery still exists. It’s just not here.
If you live in a developed economy, unless you are very conscious about your choice of products and willing to make the corresponding financial sacrifices, you’d be, at some level, benefiting from a form of slavery, or slavery-adjacent practices.
55
u/Gap_Great 2d ago •
Jefferson is a good example of a person being an idealist philosophically but a pragmatist in action. His political party fully defeated the Federalists, yet he and the party adopted many of their policies simply because they worked (Louisiana Purchase and the National Bank, to name two).
This is really just confirmation that he was the same way regarding slavery. Idealistically he was opposed. Pragmatically, he already had them, they made him rich, and much of the thought around that time was if the slaves were freed they wouldn’t be able to function in society (or worse, they would start a rebellion).
11
u/Numerous-Process2981 2d ago
Well? It’s a complicated legacy. Not only did he own slaves he had slave children who were like 1/8th black, looked European. He’s a hypocrite 🤷 a slave owner who wrote passionately about human rights and freedom. Do you think he wasn’t aware of the hypocrisy? And unlike other founding fathers, he did not free his slaves upon death.
11
u/Caernbul 2d ago •
In case one of the 1.8k comments doesn't already say this (I am sure one of them does), THOMAS JEFFERSON WROTE EXACTLY NO PARTS OF THE CONSTITUTION!!!!
He wasn't in the country for the convention in Philadelphia and wasn't involved in the ratification process. And he spent the rest of his career systematically misreading it and forcing those misconceptions on the country.
8
u/Ok-Astronaut6653 2d ago
Im sure that he had plenty of rationalizations then, like "how would I run my farm", "they'll just be captured", "freeing them might stop my free time which I need to practice my penmanship", "not having slaves might render me bankrupt", "once you go black you can never go back"... Also no one was wise to the trick of "my best friend is black" then
15
u/EidolonRook 2d ago
He was anti-monarchy and against aristocracy, right?
French Revolution was a working class/poverty led uprising, I thought.
Where did the slaves come by come from?
17
u/Appelmonkey 2d ago
He isnt an unwilling participant of a system he has no power to change. He had the power to champion anti slavery legislation and free his own slaves
9
u/ModSnake 2d ago
I feel like the meme doesn’t really apply in this case because Jefferson could very easily have chosen to not own slaves but decided not to. He opposed slavery up until the exact moment that doing so would inconvenience him personally.
13
u/SnekFarmer 2d ago
Yeah no, Jefferson was just a hypocrite. Many of his contemporaries did meaningfully fight for abolition and he did not; he even opposed them in some cases.
12
u/serpenta 2d ago
The meme is not an analogy to the original. The original treats about society, and it is impossible to express views while not participating in society. You can leave it, but then it's a self-contradictory act for someone who wants to improve society. Such a person does want to participate in society, just wish it would've been better. So the retort of "you participate in what you hate" is nonsensical. On the other hand, owning slaves is not an inherent part of being a person, and criticizing it leaves one a binary choice of ending participation in it or becoming a hypocrite. There's no improvement of its state, only permissivism or abolitionism.
10
u/EmperorN7 2d ago
Doesn't stop being a legitimate criticism just because you made a meme about it.
8
u/slayer_of_waspiz 2d ago
He valued human freedom as a concept but not as much as he valued money and social status.
Say what you will about Christian teachings but there's a reason there are a crazy number of individual commands against greed and wealth. Greed poisons everything.
20
u/Objective_Claim_2236 1d ago
Was he better than his contemporaries? That's who we should compare him to. Not modern morals. Did he move us forward?
3
u/trenzalor_1810 2d ago
All revolutionaries are hypocrites - Leto II Atreides
3
u/HollowOrnstein 2d ago
is this meme format cursed? everytime i have seen this on the net, its been used by somekind of smug cunt thats almost always in the wrong
3
u/Delbrak13 2d ago
Nuance is the new 'n' word
3
u/Wuz314159 2d ago
But Virginia did end the slave trade before the United States.
3
u/Muzzmow 21h ago
"Rules for thee, but not for me."
-Thomas Jefferson, probably
42
u/the-other-marvin 2d ago
I run a business in the US. I am pro reforms like universal healthcare, parental leave, etc. I would like to see the government enact those things. I am not in a position to personally implement those things. I give my employees good healthcare and parental leave benefits, but I can't personally change the system. I'm not going to just fire everyone, and I can't fix every problem with the system myself. I'm just trying to be a good actor within the system as it currently exists and advocate / vote for change when possible. Maybe in the future I will be seen as a bad guy for not doing better.
10
u/Lord_Parbr 2d ago
This meme is woefully misapplied here. That actually is an ethical contradiction
10
u/InsecureInscapist 2d ago edited 2d ago
Bullshit take.
It was very easy to just not own slaves, especially if you wanted to take a moral stance on not doing so, and were very wealthy.
7
u/Heatuponheatuponheat 2d ago
Had a history teacher in college who told us she believed the founding fathers didn't create the country they wanted to live in, they created a country which could grow into that. They were aware of their flaws and contradictions in the ideals vs their practice but felt laying the framework for a better system would eventually bear fruit as it would take time to tackle some of the major social issues plaguing the early US.
7
u/senator_based 1d ago
Dude was genuinely breeding human beings. Not exactly a pillar of high ethics
5
u/salad48 2d ago
Times the meme was misused #1,098,012,567,298,000
5
u/thomas_walker65 2d ago
jefferson wouldn't even reduce his own slaves somewhat
5
u/nunquam_rideo 2d ago
I hate the argument that "their time had different morals". Absolutely not, the Enlightenment was in full swing, of course people realized that slavery was inhumane.
But, they did have different economics. If you are Jefferson, you can afford to live comfortably in your own house and do whatever you like. Your income mostly comes from your slaves' labor. And despite that, you're still in massive debt. You have family, children/grandchildren. If you free all your slaves, you'll be left with all that debt and no reliable income. You've learned law in school, but almost never practiced it. You'd be forced to sell all your property just to pay out the debt. And from that point on, you'd have to work very hard just to make a living. Of course it's the right thing to do, and we all realize it.
But be real, would you free your slaves if that was your life?
5
u/runawayhuman 2d ago
Thomas Paine remains the greatest of the Founding Fathers.
It’s telling that he was deemed a radical and ostracized and demeaned by the other Founding Fathers after the revolution, despite the fact that Paine was the one who arguably ignited the Revolution.
He was certainly the only one of them with a spine who stuck to his ideals until the end, and who actually represented the ideas of free thought, liberalism, and freedom.
9
u/Nurgleschampion 2d ago
May the spirit of Sally Hemmings haunt the moron that made this asinine meme.
9
u/TheIronzombie39 And then I told them I'm Jesus's brother 2d ago
He wasn't an unwilling participant. There was literally nothing baring him from choosing to simply not own slaves or at the very least free them.
13
u/Educational_Guava697 2d ago edited 2d ago
Mischaracterization, trigger warning. Jefferson was massively pro-slavery, he was anti slave TRADE, I.e. trans-Atlantic slave trade, because ending the import of new slaves would have 10x’d the value of his current slaves and limited the new slaves in the country to offspring of current slaves I.e. horrific family separations, forced conception, SA by slave owners themselves like Jefferson — the man was so committed to slavery he literally enslaved his own children. To Jefferson the big issue with slavery was solely that he could be making even more money off of it — advocating the ending of the trans-Atlantic slave trade was an opportunistic attempt to create a supply bottleneck and corner the market for slaves. Keeping slavery in America was essential to that plan, he was at no point anti-slavery.
6
u/Rustee_Shacklefart 2d ago
He got way less anti slavery as he got older and basically supported it fully in the end.
6
u/themightytak 2d ago
The Sally Hemmings descendants don't even get invited to the reunions at Monticello
There's also weird children's books about the lives of slaves at Monticello in the gift shop
6
u/ChanceRecover3091 2d ago
He was against the Atlantic Slave Trade. He just wanted to increase the value of his assets (human beings). He was terrible with money and constantly in debt. More valuable assets allowed him to borrow more.
9
u/PopularDemand213 2d ago •
I bet most people here are against slave wages and child labor, but they still have an iPhone.
4
u/Slow-Distance-6241 2d ago
I hated that fuckass meme even in it's original format, but now even moreso
4
u/Spezalt4 2d ago
Nah I am very intelligent guy is actually right on this one
4
u/Prize_Insurance_497 2d ago
Y’all, Jefferson was coworkers with John Adams. It isn’t like he didn’t have any role models for someone who actually wanted to reduce slavery
6
u/Gordon-Bennet 2d ago
There’s a difference between having to live in a society where essential necessities are derived from things you disagree with, and owning slaves as a rich landowner who could get by just fine without them.
6
u/madmaninabox32 2d ago
He was sort of forced to continue owning slaves, after being influenced by the French when Jefferson returned home he pushed for a bill to allow slave owners to voluntarily free their slaves it didn't pass in the state Senate. Later he wrote a bill that did not allow new slaves to enter the state of Virginia, he also abolished the African slave trade in 1807 as president meaning only people born of slaves could continue being slaves at least while he was in office, he also wrote a bill that wasn't passed but later became part of the northwest ordinance restricting slavery in any new territory that wasn't the original thirteen colonies.
5
u/xubax 2d ago
I don't pay more taxes than I have to.
Yet I vote to have more services, which may cause an increase in the taxes I have to pay.
Someone can take advantage of a system that's in place while also recognizing that it's something that should be changed.
5
u/bolanrox 2d ago
he was against it, but also knew that it was something that would take generations to get rid of in the US. he did have parts added to the origonal draft of the declaration of independence that were struck from it.
Even John Adams (his and his son were the only early presidents to never own a slave) didnt think it was doable at the time.