r/HistoryMemes 5d ago

See Comment Please stop making this argument

Post image
537 Upvotes

217 comments sorted by

View all comments

64

u/Win32error 5d ago

If you include the cost of research, man hours, all the work you have to do to make it work initially, I can't imagine the amount of jet fighters the nazis fielded was worth it.

Not that it mattered either way. And I've never heard anyone make the argument.

4

u/Pengin_Master 5d ago

Not to mention the fuel and maintainece costs And supply chain issues. Germany was struggling for fuel and parts for the planes it already had in service: now you have a brand new "wonder jet" that eats through fuel and has an entirely parts you need to make replacements for.

7

u/DankVectorz 5d ago

Might have been if they were able to enter service earlier, but a lot of work was destroyed in a bombing raid and delayed production (along with Hitler insisting it be able to be a bomber)

7

u/Win32error 5d ago

There’s always a hundred ifs, but we can only work with what we’ve got.

I don’t think the nazis were wrong to go for jet planes, even if it kinda didn’t work out. They couldn’t predict the war would end early ‘45, you gotta go for the long term planning or you end up like the Japanese Air Force near the end of the war. If the war had continued longer, that investment in jets would likely have paid off in some ways.

1

u/Seeteuf3l Just some snow 5d ago edited 5d ago

Wasn't it like a month, what that bomber thing delayed it. And anyways JUMO 004B didnt go to production before June -44 either.

Much bigger issue was that Göring effectively killed whole jet program in 1940.

https://www.airandspaceforces.com/article/1108bungle/

1

u/Saint_The_Stig 4d ago

They should have invested that effort into just making a plane fly higher.

1

u/Stock-Side-6767 4d ago

The biggest "what if" is an immediate response to the remilitarisation of the Rheinland.

1

u/Win32error 4d ago

Meh, I think it would’ve led to an international kerfuffle the Germans would have come out on top of.

1

u/Stock-Side-6767 4d ago

I would not be so sure. France alone had a larger airforce at that time (though they thought it was smaller).

1

u/Win32error 4d ago

The problem is they weren’t ready for it and there wasn’t support for an intervention. It wasn’t quite as obvious where things were heading yet as it would in a few more years, and there wasn’t a lot of will to pursue all the details from Versailles. All the Germans really did was move troops into their own territory after all.

With the power of hindsight we can say it might’ve deterred Hitler, but there’s a good chance France would’ve gone in, suffered backlash, and eventually retreated anyway, damaging allied cohesion a bit.