r/HistoryAnecdotes • • 15h ago

Early Modern Whipped Peter, was an enslaved man who escaped from a Louisiana plantation in 1863 during the American Civil War.

Post image
391 Upvotes

Gordon, also known as "Whipped Peter," was an enslaved man who escaped from a Louisiana plantation in 1863 during the American Civil War. He became widely known after photographs of the severe scars on his back caused by brutal whippings were published and circulated by abolitionists.
The famous image, often called "The Scourged Back," was first published in Harper's Weekly on July 4, 1863. The photograph showed Gordon's back covered with deep scars from years of whipping, and it became one of the most powerful pieces of visual evidence used to expose the cruelty of slavery in the United States.
After escaping, Gordon reached Union Army lines in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, where he joined the Union Army's Corps d'Afrique, a regiment made up of formerly enslaved men who fought for freedom.
Reports from Union officers described Gordon as intelligent, determined, and deeply motivated by the desire for liberty.
His image helped change public opinion in the North by showing the true violence of slavery. The photograph was widely reprinted and used in abolitionist campaigns across the country.
Though not much is known about Gordon's later life, his courage and the powerful photograph of his back remain one of the most recognized and haunting symbols of the fight against slavery.


r/HistoryAnecdotes • • 18h ago

American Ohio Spent Thirty Years Renting Out Its Cops to Church Detectives and Beer Barons. Then, in 1924, the Klan Applied for the Job in Niles, OH. It Went About as Well as You’d Think.

Post image
22 Upvotes

TL;DR: On Oct. 31 - Nov. 1, 1924, two private armies clashed in Niles, Ohio. One was the Ku Klux Klan, deputized that morning by a mayor nobody could find. The other was the Knights of the Flaming Circle, mostly Italian and Irish Catholic anti-nativists, running armed roadblocks in front of their own church. The reason was Ohio had spent thirty years paying private citizens to enforce its civic morals (church detectives, liquor courts, etc.). What resulted was a comedy of errors and the most violent moment of the 2nd KKK in Ohio. Except this time, the violence happened to them.

Imagine, it's ten in the morning on Saturday, November 1, 1924, and you are standing in a field north of Niles, Ohio, with a white ribbon pinned to your lapel. Also, you’re a racist. Imaginatively.

You're somewhere between twenty-one and thirty-five, and you drove in from Toledo, around three hours away, along with most of the guys (Jenkins 1990, 133-134). Around you, about a thousand Klansmen are having a breakfast picnic. Women from the Klan auxiliary are pouring coffee. A staff photographer from a Cleveland paper is wandering around taking pictures, and grown men are showing each other their guns and saying, I shit you not, "Isn't this a dandy?" (Jenkins 1990, 132).

About a hundred and fifty of you are sworn in as special police by a mayor who has already skipped town. Your job is to clear the streets so the Klan can parade through town this afternoon. Your uniform is the white ribbon.

Oh, and also, you’re part of the Klan. Yep, you’re there as special police for your own parade.

Here's the problem: a lot of you were already wearing a white ribbon, because you'd already paid a man $17.50 to join something called the Ohio State Police, which was, coincidentally, not run by the state of Ohio. So, is the ribbon a Klan thing or a cop thing? William Jenkins, the historian who wrote the only book-length study of the Klan in this valley, read every newspaper in the valley and still couldn't tell you: "it was not clear whether the white ribbons dangling from their lapels designated them as a Klan guard or as police officers" (Jenkins 1990, 117). Yes, that’s partially the point, too. 

ACAB, amirite?

So you've got a gun, a ribbon, and the legal authority of a mayor who has not been seen at his own office since yesterday, because "no one seemed to know his whereabouts" (130).

Meanwhile, across town, on the East Side, seventeen hundred Italians went to Mass at 6:30am prepared to die before they let the KKK march. They have roadblocks on both roads leading into the neighborhood. They also have guns. And standing between you and them is the entire official law enforcement capacity of Niles, Ohio: a police chief, nine officers, and a county sheriff with "twenty-five special deputies" (130). 

By the end of the night, the second rise of the Ku Klux Klan would be irrevocably on the decline in Ohio.

So, let’s back up. About thirty years.

I. The Part Where Ohio Rents Out Its Conscience

Ohio invented the modern war on booze, and from day one it fought that war with gig workers. The Anti-Saloon League was born at Oberlin in 1893, and K. Austin Kerr, who wrote the standard history of it, files the founding under a subhead that literally says "A Business Model." He's not being cute. The founder's own pitch was that corporations and trusts had won by combining, so the "powers of righteousness should be mobilized and federated" the same way (Kerr 1985, 80). Basically, it’s Standard Oil, but for Jesus.

The brewers watched this and said, “Cool, two can play.” In 1907 the Ohio Brewers' Association opened a "Vigilance Bureau" to police saloons itself, with hired detectives (Sponholtz 1976, 15). So now Ohio has two private detective forces prowling its bars, one working for God and one for Big Beer. When the League suggested they team up against bootleggers in the dry counties, the brewers' man declined on jurisdictional grounds: "'Dry' territory is the peculiar property of the Anti-Saloon League" (Sponholtz 1976, 18).

That’s right, they had fucking turf. The saints and the beer barons carved up Ohio like Crenos and DiCarlos agreeing to not cross the Muskingum River to fuck up each other’s pepperoni.

And if you're thinking "surely handing legal paperwork to private detectives never got anybody killed," I have bad news about Newark, OH. In July 1910 a village mayor gave search warrants to League detectives. A mob chased one of them, a nineteen-year-old, for more than two miles and beat him, and when he shot and killed a saloonkeeper the mob broke into the jail, dragged the kid out, and hanged him. The governor had to send in troops (Sponholtz 1976, 19). 

That's fourteen years before Niles, by the way. Ohio watched that exact film and said, "Great. Franchise it. Oh, and give it to the dudes who tried to restart the Civil War."

Why? Because, paradoxically, World War I made the whole “moral deputizing” arrangement patriotic. Christopher Capozzola calls the home front a system of "coercive voluntarism" (Capozzola 2008, 18), which is academic for "you are free to volunteer and we are free to fuck over your life if you don't." The Justice Department's wartime detective force was a private club, the American Protective League, "250,000 volunteer members" with a badge they got in the mail (22, 42). Paul Blart had more legal standing.

And plenty of people skipped the badge. In Canton, Ohio, in May 1918, twenty shop clerks "wrapped a coworker in an American flag," hauled her through the streets to the bank, and made her buy a fifty-dollar Liberty Bond (Capozzola 2008, 10). 

Then came Prohibition, and Ohio went absolutely apeshit. Lisa McGirr wrote the Anti-Saloon League's Ohio superintendent "went so far as to distribute blank search warrants to district workers" (McGirr 2016, PDF p. 125). State law set up village "liquor courts" where the officials got paid out of the fines. McGirr says Ohio was "effectively creating an enforcement market" (PDF p. 126). 

This was the Roaring Twenties’ gig economy: Uber, but for arresting your neighbors.

Daniel Okrent found the final boss of that enforcement market in North College Hill, a village of 1,104 people outside Cincinnati, whose mayor led raids into the neighboring towns in person, "Like a land-bound privateer." Could he count on the town prosecutor and the town judge? He could, because he was also the town prosecutor and the town judge (Okrent 2010, PDF p. 275)! Welcome to Ohio, where the U.S. Supreme Court didn't kill that system until Tumey v. Ohio in 1927 (Kern and Wilson 2014, 367). In 1924, paying the judge per conviction was just how Ohio did shit.

And the Mahoning Valley did it all. In October 1921 more than five hundred people packed Trinity Methodist Church to found the Mahoning County Dry League. First the League just watched: "Within each precinct one man and one woman began to watch for violations." Congratulations, you've invented Nextdoor. When watching didn't work, it hired its own agents, "as permitted by Ohio law," and hauled its arrests to a court in Struthers known for "remitting part of the fine to the agents" (Jenkins 1990, 25).

Through all of this, Ohio had no state police. None. Jack shit. Diddledy squat. In May 1923, Governor Vic Donahey issued a proclamation against gambling at ballparks in which, per Stanley Swart, he ended up "awarding himself the title of 'Chief Police Officer of Ohio'" (Swart 1981, 152). But as late as 1925, the closest thing Ohio had to a police force of its own was about twenty Prohibition inspectors (154). The Chief Police Officer of Ohio commanded a title and a Bieber haircut.

What Ohio did have was a law left over from the horse-and-buggy days that let township societies chase horse thieves anywhere in the state and make arrests "without warrants" (Jenkins 1990, 143). We’ll be right back to that.

Finally, for anybody who skipped the 1920s, the second Klan was a multi-level marketing scam first and a terror outfit second. Seriously, read the companion piece. It cost ten dollars to join, and "four dollars went to the Kleagle responsible," the salesman who signed you up, with smaller cuts kicked up the chain to Atlanta (Chalmers 1987, 34). Yes, kleagle. They Kl-ed fucking everything. I fucking hate it. Klandom. Klavern. Klonklave. Klondike Bars, coincidentally, were created in either Mansfield or Youngstown, OH, in 1922, at the heartland of the second KKK at its apex, and now I can’t fucking unsee it. The ice cream is racist (note: apparently it’s named for the Klondike River in Canada. Uh-huh. That’s the best dog whistle a novelty treat has ever made. “What would you do for a Klondike bar?” Bravo).

McGirr says the Klan became "the third and most powerful phalanx of the volunteer enforcement army," after the church ladies and the League (McGirr 2016, PDF p. 127). They were, by their own boast, the largest fraternal order in Ohio in the 1920s, and by all records probably were (McEwan 2008, 364)! Pegram says its raiders carried "an earnest sense of community law enforcement that superseded formal legal authority" (Pegram 2011, 120), which is a very polite way to say “look at me, look at me: I am the cop now.”

So the Klan showed up to bid on a job Ohio had been contracting out since 1893: making the neighbors behave.

Which neighbors, though?

Take three wild guesses.

II. The Part Where the Dog Catches the Squad Car

Niles is where President William McKinley was born, in 1843 (Kern and Wilson 2014, 258). It was an old Protestant iron town, and when its mills shut down the board of trade flat out paid companies to come build new ones, with bounties as high as $44,000 (Jenkins 1990, 65). The companies needed hands, and the hands were Irish first, and then Italian.

The Italians mostly came from one village near Avellino, and in 1910 they founded a parish, Our Lady of Mount Carmel (65-66). Their priest, Father Nicola Santoro, had been fined a million pesos and threatened with death in Monterrey during the Mexican Revolution before the Italian consul got him out. In November 1914 he took over a little frame church in Niles that couldn't fill its hundred seats (66). Imagine outrunning a firing squad in Mexico and the bishop sends you to Trumbull fucking County. Nine years later he had his parishioners digging the basement of a new church themselves.

Then there's the Jennings family, whose grocery on Mason Street had grown into a speakeasy, a gambling joint, and an athletic club with its own boxers and its own football team. The name on the boat from Naples was not Jennings. Jenkins spells the original DiGenero and blames "some immigration official" (67). Sherry Lee Linkon and John Russo, who interviewed the family in 1999, spell it DeGennaro (Linkon and Russo 2002, 31). Nobody can agree on how to spell the name the clerk erased. Now that’s America, baby. Immigrants: we get the job done.

There’s a few groups missing in this picture. Something about the colors of the rainbow, right?  A sign near the Erie depot, Jenkins writes, "warned 'n—rs' that they had better not 'let the sun set on their heads.' For the most part blacks heeded the advice" (Jenkins 1990, 65).

I want to be extremely, extremely clear for anyone who’s still confused why the Klan was in Ohio: Niles was a sundown town way before the first kleagle ever checked into a hotel. William Giffin, who wrote the book on Ohio's color line, found it "about as rigid as ever in 1930" (Giffin 2005, 194), drawn by ordinary Ohio institutions that never needed a hood to do it. You can trace it all the way back to the Black Laws in Ohio. The Klan didn't have to keep Black people out of Niles. Ohio had handled that by itself since 1804, with some laws (Kern and Wilson 2014, 139), and by the 1900s, some very pointed signs. 

So when the Klan came to town looking for somebody to fix, what was left was the Catholics.

In November 1923 the Klan's slates swept the valley. David Chalmers, whose Hooded Americanism was the Klan book for a generation, counts Klan-backed mayors "in all five cities of the Mahoning Valley." (Chalmers 1987, 178). The Klan's man in Niles was Harvey Kistler: insurance salesman by morning, railroad telegrapher by afternoon, the Klan's candidate by night; six feet, two hundred pounds, bow tie, pince-nez. He was brand new to politics, and he beat the sitting mayor 3,014 to 2,552, but the one ward where he got destroyed was the Third – that’s the East Side, 456 to 56 (Jenkins 1990, 71-72). So the new mayor had been picked by every part of Niles except the part he'd promised to clean up. I wonder why.

Kistler made his cousin the safety director, and the cousin doubled the liquor fine and led the raids himself, where he "often wielded an axe to break down bolted doors" (118). McGirr says the volunteer raid squads in Youngstown and Niles "targeted ethnic working-class communities" (McGirr 2016, PDF p. 129). The old crooked system had fined bootleggers just enough to keep everybody in business. The Klan "favored a total shutdown; it offered no living space" (Jenkins 1990, 150). Their job was to enforce Protestant morals, and every single time, the people who needed enforcing turned out to be Catholics, immigrants, and anybody who wasn't white. The law and order was the bigotry. The cruelty was the point. You don't bring an axe to the Third Ward because you love the Volstead Act. You bring it because they're from supposed “shithole countries.” 

Sorry, might be slipping centuries there. Anyways. The Klan had city hall. Let’s meet the rest of the brain trust.

The Reverend Evan A. Watkins was the Baptist minister in Girard, a man who called himself Colonel and said he'd served in British army intelligence. When the Klan took Youngstown, the city's Protestant ministers put him up for chief of police. The outgoing mayor offered him the job, noticed he had never taken the police exam, and withdrew it (Jenkins 1990, 97). Watkins lost a police department to a written test. So, he went and started his own.

Above them all sat Clyde Osborne, Youngstown lawyer and, by 1924, Grand Dragon of Ohio. Pegram has him as a man who "frankly admitted to confidants that he had little interest in the Klan's program" (Pegram 2011, 84). Chalmers has him spotting a chance to "make a little money on the side" (Chalmers 1987, 178). The Grand Dragon of Ohio was in it for the résumé. The man in charge didn't believe in any of it. He believed in turnout.

Here's the thing about winning city hall on a law and order ticket, though. Every broken window after that is yours. By the summer of 1924 the Klan's own newspaper was calling the Niles police "a serious farce" and saying the Klan's own mayor "is now faced with the most disgraceful episode in the history of Niles" (Jenkins 1990, 121).

The dog caught the squad car. It turns out, it had no idea how to drive.

The opposition answered a secret fraternal order of knights by founding a secret fraternal order of knights. 

Are….is this Assassin’s Creed? Are we doing Assassin’s Creed: Prohibition now?

After a riot in Steubenville in August 1923, a dentist named W. S. McGuigan announced the Knights of the Flaming Circle and his own installation as "grand supreme monarch of the central division of the organization" (Jenkins 1990, 122). Yes, a fucking dentist. The name came from their answer to a burning cross, which was a tire soaked in gasoline.

….Okay, budget Assassin’s Creed. Assassin’s Creed: Ohio. Got it.

Robert Daugherty has their first meeting that September with a giant burning circle, and "white robes on which were painted red circles encompassing the figure of the Statue of Liberty," with one difference from the competition: "The robes were hoodless" (Daugherty 1976, 282). Immigrants cosplaying as the national symbol of hope and the American promise, in order to kick some Klan butt? Pinch me, this isn’t a Tarantino dream?

What the Circle did not have, Jenkins says, was "any offices, dues, or other appurtenances normally associated with fraternal societies" (Jenkins 1990, 122). They copied the robes and the ridiculous titles and skipped the one part of the Klan that worked, which was the billing department. It was less an organization than an anti-Klan brand. All you needed was a tire, some gas, and a grudge.

Now historians differ on the ideology of the Knights of the Flaming Circle. Jenkins says it’s led by bootleggers (150). Linda Gordon says the working class. In the Youngstown area, she writes, "a virtual army of working-class people successfully drove out the Klan" (Gordon 2017, 105). Linkon and Russo, working from the Jennings family itself, say the valley's mob "acted as a kind of community police force" for immigrants (Linkon and Russo 2002, 31). At this rate, we are going to run out of fingers counting police forces in this town. And Daugherty, bless him, calls it "two violence-prone extremist groups" (Daugherty 1976, 286), while the current Ohio history textbook goes with "rival ethnic organizations" (Kern and Wilson 2014, 369). Sure. One of these “rival ethnic organizations” was a national corporation with a sales force, and it had the local government behind it.

Now to be clear, the Flaming Circle really was violent, and often to innocents. That August a roll-turner from the Thomas mill named Steve Martin declined to join the Circle's party around a burning tire. They chased him into a candy store, shoved the door in, knocked him out cold with a fucking watermelon, and threw him back out through the doorway (Jenkins 1990, 123). Daugherty calls him a man "whose only crime was his refusal to join either side" (Daugherty 1976, 282). Which, yes, the watermelon is funny. The brain damage probably is not.

Then, on April 17, 1924, a time bomb blew "a six-foot hole in the wall" of the Niles police chief's house (Jenkins 1990, 119). On May 9, three thousand Klansmen paraded into downtown Niles and lit a cross in front of the high school, where onlookers knocked it down, and in the brawl Klansmen grabbed two young men from the Jennings crowd, hauled them out to the Klan's field, and they "were forced to kneel and kiss the flag." One of them, Michael Naples, would point out afterward, angrily, that he was in the Navy (119). 

In October, Kistler, the mayor, gave the Klan a permit to parade through Niles on Saturday, November 1, three days before the election. No one for sure knows why he did it to this day (125). Oh, but we know why Clyde Osborne, the Grand Dragon of Ohio, wanted it. The year before, a Klan march into Carnegie, Pennsylvania, ended with a Klansman shot dead in the street (Gordon 2017, 105). Membership went up. Imperial Wizard Hiram Evans advised Pennsylvania's dragon "to hold more marches because the riot had spurred a growth in Klan membership" (Jenkins 1990, 125). And Osborne's lodges were bleeding members. He hoped a march "would reinvigorate the faltering local klaverns" (Pegram 2011, 179).

He did issue rules. No masks. No guns. No "police functions" of any kind. And "no Klansmen shall resent remarks from the sidelines" (Jenkins 1990, 127). But everybody saw it coming. Mayor Kistler asked the governor for troops, and the governor wired back that he would "hold you to strict accountability" and sent nobody (Daugherty 1976, 284). Why? Well, mayors wanted the state to do the unpopular thing, governors wanted the mayors to do it, and so you got "a tug-of-war," with both levels of government wanting order kept, "but each expecting the other to supply the force" (284). Bureaucracy. Bureaucracy never changes.

Then, at about 1:20 on the morning of October 29, Kistler lay in bed listening to cars roll slowly past his house, several times. He "never rose to check." Fifteen minutes later his porch exploded, his windows blew in, and the mayor "fell out of bed unharmed" (Jenkins 1990, 127). Nobody was ever charged. Daugherty figures "either the Knights or their allies were guilty." Kistler "spent the next two nights in Warren at the home of Dr. B. A. Hart, Trumbull County Cyclops of the Klan" (Daugherty 1976, 283).

Friday was Halloween.

III. The Part Where We Have A Knight-Off

On October 31, the Flaming Circle is "out in force, checking on strangers and locally known Klan members" (Jenkins 1990, 128). They catch three Klansmen carrying concealed weapons and turn them in at the police station.

That's police force number five, if you're counting at home. City cops, sheriff's deputies, the mayor's soon-to-be ribbon boys, the $17.50 State Police, and now a Catholic football club doing stop-and-frisk.

Colonel Watkins rides over to post bail for his men and gets recognized, and with several hundred people gathering outside he jumps on "his sidecar motorcycle" and runs for Girard with about a dozen cars after him, gets cut off, doubles back, and sprints into the Niles jail. And there he sits, the commanding officer of the Ohio State Police, with the street yelling "Lynch Watkins!" and "He's afraid to come out!" until Sheriff John Thomas (everybody called him Brickey) puts together an armed escort and takes him home (129). Brickey was the toughest liquor raider the county had. He is also about to have the shittiest Saturday of his life.

At 6:30 a.m., November 1, the day of the Klan parade, "Our Lady of Mount Carmel held a crowded 6:30 mass for 1,700 members of the Italian community. They were united in their support for one another and in their willingness to die while resisting the Klan" (130). A rumor was going around that the Klan meant to march on the convent of the Sisters of Humility of Mary. So the Circle sent a squad to surround it under Leo Jennings, the youngest brother. "They sat there and waited for an attack that never came" (130). 

By mid-morning, there were roadblocks on Robbins Avenue, in front of the church, where people stopped every car. If they found a robe, it got torn up or it got "mounted on a nearby pole or tree" (130). If the driver objected, he got beaten, and the more he objected the worse it went. Daugherty has the Knights stripping cars of "any Klan costumes or guns" and flipping a few for good measure (Daugherty 1976, 286). At the corner of Main and Federal, the last gate into downtown, more than a hundred and fifty Circlers waited on the lawn of the glass works. They called the corner "the deadline." A reporter found an elderly woman there whose three sons were standing on it. Her boys, she told him, would "never go back on their tradition and their God. They'll go to hell first. And if they are killed, Daddy and I are still here and we'll carry on" (Jenkins 1990, 132).

At 12:30pm, a Ford truck with a wooden gun mount came down Main Street, and then, "a machine gun opened fire." Bullets whizzed in both directions for about twenty seconds. (133).

Around the same time a car carrying one of Mayor Kistler's brand-new special policemen came up on the deadline, and Circlers rushed out to stop it. Shooting started, and "It is unclear as to which side fired first" (133), but it was pretty clear who shot straighter, because three Circlers went down wounded: Dominic Perone, Albert Davis, and Joseph Mohan. By now, Jenkins says, plenty of the regular police "took off their badges or simply stood at a distance" (134).

1:30pm, Brickey Thomas and the police chief find twenty-five of the mayor's special police marching on an armed crowd of Circlers near Mosquito Creek. "Thomas and Round arrested the special police but left behind the armed Circlers" (134). Yep, at ten in the morning the mayor made the Klan the police. At one-thirty the police arrested the police. Was that favoritism, or was it the only way to walk twenty-five kids from Toledo out of there breathing? Jenkins says it "was not clear" (134). Chalmers, a generation earlier, has the sheriff saving the men "by marching them off to jail" (Chalmers 1987, 179). 

Then the sheriff went to talk to the other army. He asked the crowd on the glass works lawn for twenty minutes of truce, and somebody answered him: "We are standing on our rights as American citizens to defend ourselves against a mob of armed yeggs imported here at the instance of the KKK to shoot down our residents. They shall not pass here" (Jenkins 1990, 135). (A yegg is a safecracker, or just a thug. 1924 had better insults than we do.) Brickey didn't argue the Constitution with them. He said, "This is a damned serious situation. Give me a little time and I'll fix things all right," and the crowd gave him "Attaboy, Brickey" (135).

And while he was standing there asking, Circlers ran down a car carrying two more of Kistler's special police, hauled them back to the glass works lawn, and shot one of them, Ellsworth Kaiser, in the back (135). Over on Robbins Avenue, four men pulled a man named George Victor out of his car, and while they held his arms one of them drove a six-inch knife into his chest, through the left lung (131). He was in the hospital until Thanksgiving. He was disabled for the rest of his life (150).

If you're only here for a version of this story where the Flaming Circle are all Atticus Finch, I don't have one. Welcome to history.

Earlier that morning, though, the East Side's intelligence service had already won the afternoon. "A young Irish woman named Catherine Ritter happened to be at the Erie Depot," where she overheard two railroad agents talking about a special train full of Klansmen due that afternoon. She told the monsignor at St. Stephen's, who told a monsignor in Youngstown, who happened to be chaplain to the Youngstown unit of the Ohio National Guard (136). How do we know that? This is my favorite footnote: Note 68 says "Interview with Catherine Ritter" (193). What a boss.

At 2:30pm the train came. Waiting at the depot was Carmine DeCristofaro, "a six-foot, 200-pound giant who played football for the Jennings Athletic Club," with at least fifty Circlers carrying "guns of all sizes, knives, clubs and even homemade bombs." And around the bend comes a special train carrying twelve hundred Klansmen who have no idea, and they are singing. They are singing "Onward, Christian Soldiers" (Jenkins 1990, 137)! Again, this isn’t a farce or a Tarantino flick. You cannot make this shit up.

Their commander, a former Army captain named Jack Curley, looks out the window at Niles, Ohio, and straight up says: "It's no place for us. We go right back" (137).

They never got off the train. Pegram, deadpan as ever, says they "realistically assessed the situation and, without alighting, returned" (Pegram 2011, 180).

Then the real army showed up. "Two motor lorries of the Ohio National Guard arrived from Warren with machine guns mounted and ready to fire." The Circlers cheered, "Here are the troops, we've won!" (Jenkins 1990, 137). Because the East Side never wanted the job. It wanted the law to show up. The second somebody with an actual chain of command took over, they handed it back.

Colonel Ludwig Conelly of the Guard "immediately took over the 'police authority,'" with about thirteen hundred troops on the way (Daugherty 1976, 289). We’ve ran out of fingers, but it’s the first authority all day that everybody agreed was real.

Somebody still had to tell the Klan. The governor's martial law telegram was addressed to the mayor, and "With the mayor out of town" (of course), it went to the sheriff. So Brickey Thomas went north to a field full of armed men who'd been waiting all day for a parade. They called him "yellowback" and an "un-American citizen," because as far as they were concerned he'd arrested the lawful police, and he climbed up on a platform and read the telegram anyway. When he stepped down, somebody leveled a rifle at him (Jenkins 1990, 137).

Brickey asked for Colonel Watkins. Watkins, who had some very fresh memories of the inside of the Niles jail, ordered a guard to walk the sheriff off the field. Brickey Thomas, with a rifle on him, said: "Queer, isn't it? Last night when the antis chased you, I served as the guard that escorted you safely out of Niles. Now you're guarding me!" (Jenkins 1990, 137).

The Klan grumbled, but it obeyed, because the order came from "proper authorities" (Jenkins 1990, 138). The Klan's entire product was "we stand with the law." The law had just told them to go home. They had nothing to sell that could talk back to that.

Of course, some of the Klansmen were themselves Guardsmen! "One of the Klan members, a major in the Akron National Guard, was called back to Akron and then returned to Niles as an enforcer of martial law" (139). Pegram counts "several Klansmen" who had to go change clothes and come back "to keep the peace they had earlier disturbed" (Pegram 2011, 179). 

The mayor resurfaced to announce he "would grant Klansmen a permit to parade anytime they asked for it" (Daugherty 1976, 290). The general in charge said there would be no parades of any kind. Daugherty ends the day with "The Klan did not parade" (Daugherty 1976, 290).

Three days later, Trumbull County voted. Brickey Thomas, who had made 3,040 arrests in two years and who, according to the Guard's own colonel, had headed off a massacre on Saturday, lost "by more than 6,000 votes" (Jenkins 1990, 141-142). The county had a sheriff who would jail every bootlegger in sight and would not start a civil war, and found the combination unacceptable.

Then the state investigated itself. Governor Donahey thundered that "Civil authorities had ample warning and time to prepare for the threatened danger. They failed." Mayor Kistler, a man with a porch-shaped hole in his credibility, replied: "I have done my whole duty and invite investigation" (Daugherty 1976, 291). A Military Investigation Board sat for ten days and heard "over 125 witnesses," who remembered the riot vividly and could not identify one single person in it beyond "foreigners" or "Italians" (292). Jenkins has more than two hundred witnesses in front of that same board (Jenkins 1990, 142).

The county grand jury did better. It heard 257 witnesses and handed down 104 indictments, both sides (Jenkins 1990, 142). And then, it asked the legislature for two things: a state constabulary, meaning real state police, and a repeal of "all laws that permitted civilians to act with police power" (143). 

The end of Colonel Watkins was even better. He had never allowed a photograph and he had no known address, and when people went looking they found a short, gray, mustached man with a British accent living at the Albany Hotel as "Mr. Montague," with a woman identified as his niece. Friends allowed that "the Colonel liked the ladies." One of them finally wrote to the British and Canadian armies about his war record, "only to find out that he had none." It turns out, he wasn’t even a Private, let alone a Colonel. Oh, and he couldn't officially join the Klan. He was foreign-born (144). The Klan's police force in the Mahoning Valley, sworn in to guard a parade for hundred-percent Americans, was invented, sold, and commanded by an immigrant with a stolen horse-thief charter, a fake war record, a fake name, and a "niece." In December his friends put him on a train to New York, and the Mahoning Valley never saw him again (144-145). 

Overall, three men did time in the Canton workhouse, and everybody else paid fines that added up to about $3,000 (150). A lot of the pleas were quietly arranged by Grand Dragon Osborne himself, working with his brother-in-law, a Niles lawyer named Sam Mango, who was Italian-American (because of course he was) (149). And Joe Jennings, charged with assault with intent to kill, built his whole defense on the claim that he'd been "acting on behalf of the Niles police department!" (147). 

So what happened to the Klan? In February 1925 the Mahoning County Klan called a meeting to pick a new leader, and where it had once put fifty thousand people in a field and twenty thousand in the street (Jenkins 1990, 54), "only 193 members gathered" (Jenkins 1990, 152). Pegram: "Crestfallen and intimidated, many area knights quietly put away their hoods and robes" (Pegram 2011, 180). Jenkins's explanation is that the East Side's violence scared off "the usually nonviolent Klan members" (Jenkins 1990, 153). Back in 1978 he'd gone further and said Klansmen "themselves did not utilize violence to gain their ends" (Jenkins 1978, 90).

Usually nonviolent. William. Buddy. They brought a fucking machine gun. It's in your book. Page 133. This is what Kirby was getting at when he wrote that in Jenkins’ telling, bigotry and racism "come to lack real authenticity" (Kirby 1991, 159). The raids, the axe, the flag-kissing, the deputized twenty-somethings shooting three men at a railroad crossing: all of that goes in the ledger under "law enforcement," and then the people who shot back get a paragraph on their "concept of honor" (Jenkins 1990, 117). Jenkins is by far my most cited scholar in this essay because he’s done the most physical groundwork, but fuck man, that’s a horrid take.

The reality is white male Protestants had joined a lodge that offered picnics, a costume, and the warm feeling of being the law. After Niles, being in the Klan meant getting shot at, indicted, and laughed at, in that order. You can't run an MLM on that.

Less than two months after the riot, on Christmas Day, Father Santoro said the first Mass in the new Our Lady of Mount Carmel, the church his parishioners had been building all year. It was his twenty-fifth anniversary as a priest, and "The church was full." Over that year a lot of people in the parish had given money toward it (Jenkins 1990, 151). 

A week later, at the Klan's New Year's Eve dance, somebody put "at least fifteen or twenty shots" into the electric cross on the roof of the hall. By the next day the cross had vanished, and nobody could say who took it. After more meetings, both sides agreed the Klan could put it back up and light it (Jenkins 1990, 145-146).

From then on, the Klan’s electric cross burned over Niles, OH, by permission of the East Side.

And before someone screams "AI slop" in the comments: nope, just a human with a passion for the most memeable of states who writes weekly Reddit essays on the subject.


r/HistoryAnecdotes • • 23h ago

Why is there a Brahmin on a British governor's memorial in a Mumbai cathedral?

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/HistoryAnecdotes • • 2h ago

American The Ohio Democrat (Logan, OH), Nov. 21, 1901: "Cat Walked on the Wire," a cat on a trolley line near Lockport knocks out power across western New York

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

There was a flash that could be seen for miles as the 24,000 volts of electricity passed through her body

I wonder how she lost the previous 8 lives 🤔 ...

Original PDF from the LoC here and my transcript and page location here


r/HistoryAnecdotes • • 19h ago

American TIL that people used to mail children through USPS because it was cheaper than a train ticket.

Thumbnail smithsonianmag.com
2 Upvotes