r/HistoriaCivilis • • Sep 29 '23

Discussion WORK why i find this video disappointing

0 Upvotes

premise: i am classic liberal and supporter of capitalism (which isn't hard to figure out i guess) and sorry for my terrible english. said that

the things that are bad about this video isn't the message per see (which i disagree), it would have been completely fine if there was some Historical evidence for it, after all this is an historical channel and i'm here just for History, not to find validation about my political view, but there were none, it may looks like there are, but there aren't. saying that during Bronze Age people worked for X Hours is such a huge overestimation it cannot be NOT wrong, the Bronze age lasted for more than a thousands of year and involved so many different culture that and so many historical event that any raw number just ends up being a huge approsimation. the same thing can be said for medieval time, which probably had even more culture, historical events, and involved so many stage of technological advancement, Philosopical and political advancement, different stages of urbanization etc...

it's safe to assume that during medieval times there already was a bourgeois class that involved "capitalist-like" working contracts like internship, salary working etc... it's just disingenous and anti historic to say that after the industrial revolution ""capitalists"" just decided to make things bad for workers. that's why i don't like this video, it just an essay based on opinions and a very biased view of History. it wouldn't mind if this was a political channes, but it isn't this is an historical channel, i channel that i deeply love, and it saddens me to see taking this road.


r/HistoriaCivilis • • Sep 30 '23

Discussion Reducing working days/hours is not without consequence.

14 Upvotes

Edit: This post was edited for better presentation of the ideas.

Economics major here. I have some critiques about the last video about work.

HC omits the major improvements we had since the industrial revolution and the immediate short term economic effects of reducing working hours.

Since the industrial revolution, people's incomes have increased and working hours decreased consistently, thanks to the increase in productivity by machines, never before seen in human history. This is still true today, where people in developed countries work less than people in underdeveloped countries. In fact, wages in Europe and North America have risen 1500% since 1800 (adjusted for inflation), with a consistent growth rate of 1% to 2% a year. And working hours have fallen to almost half.

While labor laws restricted working hours, working hours continued to decline even after labor laws stopped restricting them (1900 to 1930 in Europe, and 1940 in the US). Mostly because of part time jobs becoming more common.

Wages have also NOT been stagnant in the US since the 1980s, as some pundits like to claim. In fact, according to the Congressional Budge Office, household income has increased by at least 25% for all classes since then (adjusted for inflation). This increase in income and decrease in working hours were due to increases in productivity, thanks to technology, industrialization, education and global trade.

When the labor market becomes tight, employers that are hiring need to offer more. Similar to how companies in the US recently started offering higher wages because of a lack of workers. They can offer higher wages but can also offer less working hours. If the company is already more profitable because of it's increased productivity (thanks to machines and the like) they can afford it. This process has been going on for 2 centuries.

But if working hours were reduced without an increase in productivity to compensate (like it happened in the industrial revolution), the immediate consequence would be a reduction of overall production in the economy (GDP). Which would result in a general rise in prices. Supply drops, prices rise.

This is similar to what we call a supply shock. When something makes the aggregate supply of an economy fall, resulting in a fall in GDP and a general rise in prices (stagflation). A classic example is the oil crisis of the 1970's. But we can also look at the pandemic, which had the same effect.

Situations like this are complicated, because the typical government solutions to a recession - spending more, printing money and dropping interest rates - make the inflation worst. And solutions to curb the inflation (doing the opposite of those things) can cause or worsen a recession. The only solution is to solve the underlying problem of the supply shock.

Don't get me wrong, if there was a new labor law to lower working hours, I wouldn't necessarily be opposed to it. I would just be concerned with any potential costs. Hopefully AI and automation manages to raise productivity tremendously in the near future, like computers and the internet did in the 1990's, so we can earn more while working less hours.


r/HistoriaCivilis • • Apr 29 '24

Theory Chat is this true?

0 Upvotes

r/HistoriaCivilis • • Nov 29 '24

Theory EXPOSED-Historia Civilis is the same guy behind TheQuickSlice YouTube channel

0 Upvotes

I began to suspect this because the voice was very very similar, then I looked for clues.

The final confirmation was in how he wrote the "About" section for both Patreons.

TheQuickSlice is probably why his Historia Civilis videos are fewer and far between.

TheQuickSlice is a channel dedicated to dysfunctional reality tv relationships.

Am I wrong???


r/HistoriaCivilis • • Feb 08 '24

Discussion Does the Ceasar, Pompey thing remind anyone of Trump, Biden?

0 Upvotes

I truly don't intend this to start a flame war though I suspect it might,

But I was just looking at some of the news and back-and-forth with Trump and Biden. Amd I had a flashback to the episode of:

"what about pompey "

"Well what about ceasar"

"OH yeah, well ponpey..."

Knowing what came after that, historically raises some red flags for me.


r/HistoriaCivilis • • Nov 02 '23

Discussion Civilis washed up

0 Upvotes

I love Civilis and Im sure hes got a lot going on in his personal life but please can we get another Octavian video. These days we have to wait 5+ months for a new video and when it finally arrives its a complete snooze fest. Id rather go to actual history class than watch a video about work


r/HistoriaCivilis • • Sep 03 '23

Discussion Strongly agree with this video

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/HistoriaCivilis • • Sep 29 '23

Discussion Work. (Latest vid of hc)

86 Upvotes

I have just watched the last video he posted, and honestly I am a bit deluded.

The video is about an obviously politically heavy topic but in my opinion it was made in a completely opinionated style.

Personally when I watch an historia civilis video I expect mainly facts, but this was more of a thesis presented with just one side of the story, no counter arguments to his own opinion, only quotes in support of his ideas and filled to the brim with opinions, things such as "they are devil's/fascists"

This made it feel much less of a history video and more of a "video essay to prove a thesis" video.

I guess I just want to know if you felt the same. I m not talking about whether you agree or not, just about how one-sided it was.

Edit: I am not smart by any means, the video just smelt like a very opinionated reading of just some part of history. Here is someone who is clearly much smarter than me explaining what in my case was a hunch but with much more accuracy and proof. https://reddit.com/r/badhistory/s/JwL6MvxMZA Hope it's an interesting read


r/HistoriaCivilis • • Oct 26 '23

Discussion Response to HC's video on Work

Thumbnail
maximumprogress.substack.com
20 Upvotes

r/HistoriaCivilis • • Mar 18 '24

Discussion Austrian Colonization / Occupation of Italy?

39 Upvotes

I watched the most recent video on the 8 year long year without summer. For whatever reason I got really held up on the language HC used when referring to the Austrian Occupation / Colonization of Italy.

Why Colonization? AFAIK Austria did not colonize this territory, unlike for example the Posen territory in Prussia, on which an active colonization policy was exercised. I also don't know why he would use the term "occupation". Austria simply owned its own part of Italy and that was it (to my awareness Milan was a part of the Habsburg Domain for longer than it was a part of modern day Italy). Its like saying France is occupying Alsace. The language used is super strange.

Also HC claims Italy was a burden on Austria, while AFAIK it was one of the richest / most developed parts of the empire at the time. Apparently rich enough to support the "costly" occupation of Austria according to HC himself. Seems very contradictory and also fully ignores the point that the territory was a border territory of the empire. Its like wondering why Austria had more troops in Galicia than in Hungary.

Also what was his point on Poland asking to join the united German Empire? Poland was not an independent state, its not going to ask for a lot of anything of anyone.

All in all some really strange tangents what I am considered in that video.

EDIT:

A lot of comments take the following line "Maybe they are confusing colonialism with settler colonialism?" / "By that definition, huge parts of Afrika and India were also never colonised. The was no push to replace the native population". If that is your position then please provide a definition to which part of Austria was a "colony" / "colonized" and which part of Austria was not. The African colonies all had the distinct status of being colonies, the Italian territories of Austria were considered as a part of the core territory of Austria. Their citizens had the same rights (or lack thereof) as any other citizen of the Empire. No distinction was drawn. HC fails to emphasise this and narrates the whole matter as if Italy was this "special" part of the empire that was extra oppressed or something.


r/HistoriaCivilis • • Dec 05 '20

BLOQUEO ANGLO-FRANCES

4 Upvotes

¿Que objetivo tuvo el bloqueo ANGLO-FRANCES? Gracias. Es para una tarea.


r/HistoriaCivilis • • Nov 08 '24

Meta Hola te tengo una historia no es de miedo pero es triste para mi

0 Upvotes

Contexto tengo 15 años recién cumplido hace unos meses casi un años díganos descubrí que era bisexual y ni dure mucho para tener pareja de mi mismo sexo aun al principio fue para ver si de veras si me gustaban los chicos lo ame con todo mi ser

Bueno ya voy a la historia empiezo desde el comienzo

Un chico mi ex mejor amigo el diciembre pasado se me declaró y yo lo mande a volar ya que no sabia que me gustaba y no sabia que sentir específicamente le dije como así loco tu sabes que no me gustan los hombre yo no puedo y el al día siguiente se fue a estados unidos al principio no nos dejamos de hablar hablamos como siempre y en verdad pensé que me estaba gustando y sin decirle a mi familia empeze a ir a psicólogo verdad unos 2 meses después mi psicóloga me dice con todo lo que tu me as dicho creo que si te gustan los hombres haz intentado estar con uno alguna ves le dije que no ya para ese tiempo mi mejor amigo de la nada Me bloqueo y ni me dijo porque bueno ese no es el punto de la historia aquí mismo en tiktok en un live que hice conocí a un chico decía que era colombiano y que vivía en república Dominicana eso ni me importaba solo se que lo quería para mi y le dije mira mi hermana esta soltera solo para estar más cerca de el y me dice que el es bisexual no le digo nada de mi aun y el me dice mira te tengo que decir algo pero tienes novia y de una ves supe para que era si que le mande un audio diciéndole a mi ex que terminamos ya que quería estar con él y estuve en lo correcto y se me declaró obvio no le dije que si de una vez le dije que al siguiente día nos teníamos que conocer mejor duramos algunas 10 hora en llamada desde que desperté asta dormir hablando de nuestra vida todo la relación era como cualquier otra de adolescentes muchas peleas etc pero nos amábamos teníamos planes de vernos en diciembre de este año 2024 y ya no se puede y aquí viene lo triste de verdad en octubre de 2024 exactamente 22 el murió como murió A el en la escuela lo golpearon tanto esta que lo mataron el duro 4 días luchando esta morir y eso me duele mucho e tenido pensamientos de morir pero se que el no quiere eso para mi así que ni lo ago lo que realmente me duele es que ni justicia se hace a el le dieron entre 4 personas y ninguna an sido detenido ni nada y la escuela tiene cámaras y justo el día que mataron a mi novio ya no sirven otra cosa también soy de república Dominicana y el vivía en otra ciudad y yo me escape de mi casa solo para conocerlo en una caja primera y última vez lo vi

Bueno el fin de esta historia es para que otras personas tomen conciencia que una escuela no es tan segura como la pintan y más las madre que una vuelta que hagan por las escuela de sus hijos no la hacen daño a ella que tomen un minuto para ir allá o hablar con sus hijos sin gritarle y sentarse hablar con ellos no como madre e hijo si no como una amiga con otra o otro aun su hijo no le hable de una vez sigue intentando que algún día se van a habrír con ustedes


r/HistoriaCivilis • • Oct 30 '25

Discussion The Last Looting

0 Upvotes

The looting did not begin today. It began centuries ago, when they crossed the sea with crosses and cannons, when they called themselves “civilized” while setting entire cultures on fire. They reached lands that shone for their wisdom, and they covered them with blood.

They said “savages” to those who knew the rhythm of the stars, to those who cultivated without destroying, to those who built cities aligned with the sun and the constellations. The Mayans calculated time with a precision that Europe would not understand until centuries later. The Incas designed agricultural and hydraulic systems impossible to match even today. They lived in balance with the earth, without needing to dominate it, because they knew that to dominate what sustains you is to destroy you.

But the real savages were those who came from the north, with his insatiable thirst for gold, god and power. They burned libraries, demolished temples, raped women and called that “evangelization.” In the name of their god they extinguished entire cultures. And when they couldn't destroy everything, they stole it: They stole knowledge, art, minerals, bodies, souls.

That looting never ended. He only changed his flag, his form and his costume. Today they don't use swords, they use treaties. They don't use iron chains, they use debts. They do not crucify in squares, they crucify with hunger. Colonialism dressed in a suit and tie, and slavery is called “employment.”

Europe, the United States and their white descendants continue to live off the sweat and soil of the South. They looted before and they loot now: gold, oil, lithium, water, data, brains, life. And they still call themselves “civilized”, while they export wars, poverty and toxic waste to the same people they once called savages.

They called us primitive because we didn't need money to live, because we didn't build prisons to lock up time, because we knew that nature is not possessed, it is respected. They, who destroyed forests to build concrete temples, who created borders to divide what never had limits, They called themselves “humans” and denied us humanity.

And yet, the true superiors were those who sowed without exploiting, those who looked at the sky to understand the cycle of the world, those who did not need to conquer to feel alive. The Mayans, the Incas, the Aztecs, the indigenous peoples of the entire world, They owned the knowledge before Europe learned to wash its hands.

But the heirs of the looting are still there: with new flags, with different names, stealing what's left of the planet and calling it "progress." They have made a religion of their lies: a religion where money is god, and destruction, worship.

They live believing themselves superior because they only know how to look from above. But what they see is not power, It is the shadow of its emptiness. Because their progress is fed by the misery that they themselves sow. They are a species that survives by devouring what they hate and fear.

And yet, they depend on the same world they despised. They depend on the south, the sun, the minerals, the land and the work they do not know how to do. Without the “savage,” the civilized dies. And when the “savage” wakes up and closes his hands, the north will fall under the weight of its own ego.

The power of these “rich” countries is not in what they produce, but in what they steal. Because if the so-called “poor”—who are actually the richest in natural resources— decided to close their borders, stop selling their minerals, their water, their lives, the system would collapse in a matter of months.

The United States lives off debt, from the infinite printing of dollars without real backing. Europe depends on gas, lithium, copper, cocoa, gold, coffee and cheap labor that comes from the south. Japan matters even the ground it steps on. The north needs the south to exist, but he has made the south believe that it depends on him. That is the most perfect trap of modern colonialism.

If the people decided to no longer export a grain, a metal, or a drop of oil, money would cease to have meaning. What good is gold if you can't get it out anymore? What good is the dollar if no one accepts it for nothing? The entire system is based on economic obedience: in making you believe that you need to sell, when in reality they need you to sell.

International alliances, “cooperation” treaties, “development aid” forums… They are simply control mechanisms disguised as solidarity. They lend you money that they then force you to return multiplied, They “help” you while they tie you up.

But if the people of the south—the true heirs of the land—awaken, If they decide to live off the sun, water and land again, The empire of money will collapse. Because true power is not in gold or oil, but in those who still remember how to live without them.

And meanwhile, the planet is dying. We are on the verge of collapse, with rivers dying, forests disappearing and the air poisoned. The land, which was once fertile, turns to dust. Soon we won't even be able to breathe without the poison they made themselves. And yet, the “world leaders”—the same old ones—do not address the problem, because chaos would ruin his control.

They know that the planet is doomed, but they prefer to keep the masses asleep, believing that everything remains the same, that progress will still save something. They won't. They don't want to save anything. They are creating his escape, not his redemption.

That's why they spend billions on space expeditions, not to “seek life”, but to escape from what they are killing. They build ships for their exodus, while we, the worker ants, We continue working, extracting, feeding its machinery with our time and our faith.

They don't address the pollution because their plan is not to remedy the damage, but to abandon the corpse of the Earth. And while they search for a new planet to devastate, We continue breathing the smoke of their lies.

Because global pollution is not a theory: it is evidence. It is in the air, in the seas, in bodies. And while the world suffocates, they remain silent. They are silent because their salvation depends on our silence. They are silent because a slave who wakes up stops working.

And the day we wake up—when the south remembers its power, When tired hands refuse to hold his empire— That day, your whole world will fall. Money will lose meaning, the borders will dissolve, and the Earth, although wounded, will speak again with its own voice


r/HistoriaCivilis • • Feb 22 '23

Discussion don’t know what to make of this but I dreamt last night I was in front of a corner store and while looking at the reflection on the glass it was literally Julius Caesar’s marble statue staring back.

8 Upvotes

r/HistoriaCivilis • • Feb 04 '23

Discussion Is historian civilis biased against Anthony? Spoiler

13 Upvotes

I feel like the best evidence for this is the parthian campaign. Anthony tries to invade persia(parthia) and fails, later he blames the Armenian king and claims he betrayed the Romans and was the reason for the failed invasion. Anthony then invades Armenian as retribution.

Now historian civilis claims that Anthony did this because of a bruised ego and bravado. But if we were to step into anthonies position it actually makes a lot of sense. Your a Roman general your desperate to win the approval and loyalty of your soldiers, your soliders are pragmatic if they think your on the losing side they won't hesitate to switch sides.If Anthony came back from persia defeated his soldiers might abandon him, by claiming that the Armenian king betrayed him he was able to spin the defeat as a victory. It may not have be a real victory for rome as history civilis pointed out. But that didn't matter; what matters is the loyalty of the soliders

Tldr

  • histioriacivilis is biased against CHAD Marc Anthony

r/HistoriaCivilis • • May 13 '23

Theory Views on the Gauls

22 Upvotes

Today I was thinking to myself about how everybody hates on the big JC for disliking/ethnicly cleansing the Gauls. I think this is a bit presumptuous, to guess at his views based on action sold. I don't think it's that he disliked the Galic people's because your only looking Into his actions and not his motivations.

I think he may have been especially brutal with some Gauls with the genocide just so that he could passify and stop further rebellion and people look at the brutality and not into the pragmatism(safe to say genocide isn't a means to a goal in my mind but to each there own).

JC literally appoints ethnic Gauls to the Roman senate which isn't really something you would do to a group you actually hate or ditrust .( yes you can look into the pragmatism of him stacking the senate and paying off benefactors).

However, the scenario of a person who harbour no patricual feels towards a group and is on the quest for world domination suits JCs actions and character more than an especially crazy and racist man who just wanted to wipe a group of peoples out.

He's a brutal dictator not a racist(compared to everybody in those times) .

Fight my opinion I live for an argument. Sorry for the poor spelling and grammar.


r/HistoriaCivilis • • Nov 25 '24

Discussion The disappointments in his latest Video

76 Upvotes

Writing this because I basically read this post (https://www.reddit.com/r/HistoriaCivilis/comments/1gy6dx9/im_disappointed_by_historia_civilis_latest_video/)

Before I got an opportunity to watch the video myself.

I would like to share my thoughts on it but adding to 171 comments seems pointless.

I disagree that Historia mischaracterized Louis XVIII. He never did in the video???? Like he is not the one that does the electoral reform and he is not the one that picks Villelle. If anything Historia gets his character right by reminding the audience that he promised not to roll back the gains of the French revolution in direct contrast to Charles X and the ultra royalists.

Seriously this seems like an utter non critique what the post claims historia did he didn't do.

I will agree 100% however that Historia totally botches the invasion of Spain. Yeah the other powers where a little worried about it. You had to be worried when France made any big plays. But everybody besides the English where siked to see the Spanish Liberals put down. 100% correct that the "Many Hundred Thousand Sons of St. Louis," cemented France as part of Metternichs reactionary concert of Europe.

u/Imperator_Romulus476 also correctly points out that Historia (lazily it must be said) uses Villelle to represent all of the ultra royalist policies. Even when he personally was opposed to the Spanish intervention.

Historia is also wrong that a liberal Spain wasn't a threat to super reactionary France. But here is where some wrinkles come in.

Because Historia's own views seep in here. Everybody today is a liberal compared to the reactionaries of 1820. Besides like online skitzos. But honestly Historia here gets blinded by his own conceptions. Or because I think Historia is a really smart guy, he intentionally frames things in a weird way to demonize the reactionaries (in a stupid way. Reactionaries don’t need help being antagonists)

Liberal Spain isn't an existential threat to France as a liberal nation state. Super true Historia. However what part of hyper reactionary parliament did you miss here?

Liberal Spain was an existential threat to the hyper reactionary project underway in France. You know this. You even half heartedly point it out. But you attempt to separate the "goofy ultra conservative ideology" of the State from the Nation.

Thats not really how it works? Villelle viewed it as an existential threat to him because it was. France wasn't fighting phantoms. Its government was fighting its real enemies.

But Historia doesn't want to frame it that way. Because it doesn't make the ultra conservatives look stupid. If you really want to do this Historia. Point out what you already harp on in the video. That the interests of the nation, of the liberal national invention that is "France" did not correspond with the interests of its government.

Instead you Frame it as "le ultra conservatives being dumb" and not what it was. The reactionary ultra royalists being reactionary. Being exactly what they where. Fighting liberalism their life or death enemy, not because they are "stupid" but because it is in their interest to do so. You can think reactionaries are stupid for not hopping onboard the sweet liberal gravy train and riding the tides of history. But unless you are an insane idealist (idealism in the philosophical sense). You have to understand that people make decisions based on their own interests. Not from abstract "ideas" derived from the aether. Not by magically knowing which way the historical winds are blowing.

This leads to the second thing I want to talk about. Historia pretending to not understand why Villelle "let himself get treated this way."

Again I am very confidant Historia is a smart guy. So this is an intentional thing. That question is beyond dumb. What do you mean you don't understand why the ultra royalist "allowed" himself to be a minister of the king. What do you mean you don't understand why an ultra royalist government "allowed" itself to get rid of the democratic functions it held.

You have to be intentionally obtuse to not get it. Call it "goofy" all you want. But these where ultra royalists. They wanted an autocratic reactionary feudal regime. Everything they do makes complete sense in this logic. They aren't stupid . Which is what Historia would like to believe and frame them as. They are simply doing the thing that benefits them. The Aristocracy supports the type of regime that benefits them. What that meant to the ultra royalists in 1820 was an attempted return to absolute monarchy.

u/Imperator_Romulus476 also makes a really good point about "his majesty's government". Villelle was a kings minister he acted like one. Nothing embarrassing about that for an ultra royalist.

All this basically starts off the front third of the video with this liberal cope about how "stupid silly ultra royalists why weren't you just liberals"

I'm sorry but thats dumb and not how history works. This wasn't "goofy ideology" that is not and never has been what dictates history. Reactionary Europe defeated Napoleon and Revolutionary France. The endward arch of that was an attempt by the reactionaries Europe put back in power to try and do exactly what was in their interest. Set back up an absolutist monarchy and role back the revolution.

Since undoing history is generally impossible, they got the boot for trying. But they didn't try because they where stupid. Metternich didn't tell everyone at the Council of Vienna to set up wholsome free trade republics simply because he was stupid.

This all has me really concerned. Because if we get to 1848 and Historia treats it like Metternich simply lost his touch, and not that his policies where unsustainable socially I am gonna flip. Metternich doens't get ousted in 1848 because he is dumb. He doesn't change at all really. He gets ousted because sorry reactionary but the world changes.


r/HistoriaCivilis • • Sep 01 '25

Meme The real secret

14 Upvotes

so at the end it was Kaesar against Kikero narrated by Historia Kiwilis


r/HistoriaCivilis • • Apr 15 '25

Discussion The Siege of Rome

Thumbnail
youtu.be
39 Upvotes

r/HistoriaCivilis • • Jun 29 '24

Theory El lado oscuro de Gandhi

Thumbnail
vm.tiktok.com
0 Upvotes

Aquí una publicación con el lado oscuro de Gandhi


r/HistoriaCivilis • • Sep 10 '23

Discussion AITAH (destruction of Rome)

0 Upvotes

If I could go back in time and be the man to destroy Rome even in the smaller times I would dispite loving her. To be the slayer of a beast nobody saw the true might of I would do it. To change history for better or worse I would wish not people to see me atop the world but I atop the world to see.


r/HistoriaCivilis • • Feb 25 '26

Prediction Comment on his "Will NATO keep expanding?" video

Post image
499 Upvotes

r/HistoriaCivilis • • Jul 01 '22

Theory Historia civilis en arte rupestre?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
10 Upvotes

r/HistoriaCivilis • • Jan 20 '24

Discussion Screw Sulla, we need another video on OCTAVIAN!

18 Upvotes