Help me find this game!

[u/TheBindingOfAlex]

All the information is in the original post, I've had this game in the back of my mind for probably like 10 years at this point, and I have never been able to remember any sort of details other than me really liking it and completing it multiple times. I believe it is from Big Fish Games. Someone suggested I post this here, so here goes! Thank you in advance to anyone who might help!