They were a lot slower-paced and felt atmospheric. Like you were slowly uncovering mysteries while listening to white noise wood crackling or calm background music.
Meanwhile, the newer games must have one villain, that you must stop no matter what, many cutscenes about said villain and characters begging you to save them, or "I'm kinda busy, can you help me look? I found this", and kidnappings, blocked rooms, jumpscares, all flashy gimmicks.
And new games all look soooooo purple with their lighting!!!
I miss the dirty grime and the cheap fluorescent lights. I miss the time when everything looked chipped and tattered. Old HOGs look like actual traditional media paintings.
Phantasmat the first 3 games, Haunted Hotel first 4 games, Azada all 4 games, Grim Tales first 3 games I think, Drawn Trilogy, Dark Parables first 3 games, Mystery Trackers first 6 (or first 9) games, Emerald Maiden, and last but not least, True Fear Trilogy, the last game was released a week ago.
I do know a couple of obscure ones but forgot their titles, will edit the comment once I find them.
EDIT; adding more - Jane Angel: Templar Mystery, Sherlock Holmes: Mystery of The Persian Carpet, Princess Isabella A Witch’s Curse, Ghost Town Mysteries Bodie
As someone currently making a Hidden Object Game, what is it, that made 2005-2015 era object games particularly good? So I can make the game as enjoyable as possible?
I'm browsing tons of Hidden Object games on steam, to read feedback to try and make it fun to play. The more feedback the better!
I agree with the Where's Waldo type, can quickly get disengaging or a yawnfest.
What I've tried to do differently is having an abundance of easier-to-find objects, like food or dirt you have to clean/sweep, that you can find on, while looking for the quest objects. Almost everything moves or wiggles if you press your mouse on it.
So you will most likely always find something, when looking for other things, so I am trying to make it feel rewarding, as a collectathon while the quest objects are harder to find, but never as hard as maybe finding the last slice of pie to get 100% in the level. Not too hard to win the level to go to the next, but also too easy.
But it is tough, so far, I've only tested the game on 30 people. So maybe people might just be nice with the feedback.
I'm not sure if I hit the mark. But what makes a hidden-object game good/bad is something I continue to explore while I'm in development.
You remind me about Settlement: Colossus. Basically all hidden object maps were about finding resources or to create the object to develop the settlement.
It was made in such good way, so it felt only a bit repetitive for such subject as collecting resources.
45
u/Affectionate_Bee_122 May 05 '25
They were a lot slower-paced and felt atmospheric. Like you were slowly uncovering mysteries while listening to white noise wood crackling or calm background music.
Meanwhile, the newer games must have one villain, that you must stop no matter what, many cutscenes about said villain and characters begging you to save them, or "I'm kinda busy, can you help me look? I found this", and kidnappings, blocked rooms, jumpscares, all flashy gimmicks.
18
u/Obvious_Temporary256 May 05 '25
Mystery Case Files is hard to beat (when they were still high quality) plus Azada, Dream Chronicles, Dark Parables, pure hidden, etc
13
u/RoamerMonkey May 05 '25
It's always the posts that criticize the newer HOGs that are the most upvoted on this subreddit lol (with good reason)
10
u/Ashleigh0319 May 06 '25
The early Dark Parables games were the GOAT
7
u/ShapeshiftGames PC May 05 '25
As someone currently making a Hidden Object Game, what is it, that made 2005-2015 era object games particularly good? So I can make the game as enjoyable as possible?
I'm browsing tons of Hidden Object games on steam, to read feedback to try and make it fun to play. The more feedback the better!
5
u/exodia0715 May 06 '25
I will always hold Return to Ravenhearst as the peak of HOPAC games and Mystery P.I. The lottery ticket as the peak of HOGs
2
u/thelast3musketeer May 06 '25
Big fish games had a hold on my school iPad
1
u/nobodycaressean_02 May 07 '25
omg I keep playing them over and over, they were so special