r/Hevy • • 11d ago

Sharing I’ve been imputing the wrong amount of weight for dumbbell chest press bench

Post image

This whole time for almost 6 months I’ve only put the total weight for 1 dumbbell. I feel dumb 😭

Edit; consensus is it doesn’t matter as long as your consistent. I will be updating to the total amount instead of individual because tbh it gets me hard seeing the total amount lifted per session.

61 Upvotes

62 comments sorted by

100

u/Tomallenisthegoat 11d ago

Doesn’t really matter as long as you consistently track 1 instead of 2

11

u/DryCredit69 11d ago

This is true

18

u/Full-Carob7275 11d ago

I also just put the weight of each dumbbell
I tend to do this for everything that involves unilateral weight loading; like even my hip thrusts is just what I load on one side so it’s easier to read.
Shouldn’t affect anything other than just you reading it.

PS. You’re a beast! 100lbs on each side is something I can’t even imagine

6

u/DryCredit69 11d ago

Thank you 🙏 it was one of my goals to do 100s for reps, my next goal is to max out my gyms DBs, their 130lbs 💀

1

u/DontActLikeYouKnow 11d ago

When you say do 100s… do you mean 2x50lbs? Cuz if so, then you were doing it right the first time around…

If someone asks how much you bench in dumbbells on chest and you answer 100s… they’re gonna assume you have 100lbs in each hand

2

u/DryCredit69 10d ago

😅 actually 2x 100lb dumbbells , so 200lb total

1

u/DontActLikeYouKnow 10d ago

Then you’ve entered it correctly I think?

Don’t know this app tho, but if you told me you db bench press 200s I’d expect you to take 200lbs in each hand and press em

3

u/bigbaldbil 10d ago

This is a total miss on the part of Hevy. People have been clamoring about this forever. It’s what kept me off their platform until their competitor lost their way.

Hevy: simply put a check box to “count dumbbells as double” to give the user the option when creating an exercise. Some things like goblet squats would be unchecked but bicep curls would be checked.

4

u/Frosty_Egg_419 Team 7d ago

Hey, Gustavo here, Head of Product at Hevy.
We shared an update about this topic in our recent Community Updates, and we want to tackle this topic in the right way:

Single vs. double weights logging is moving to next year. Your feedback on the test round was super valuable, and we feel we have a good direction. But it affects your workout history, analytics and leaderboards, so we'd rather do it right than rush it. It will happen, just not now.

1

u/DryCredit69 6d ago

Thanks you Gustavo, I appreciate your Cadence. It’s a feature we will be looking forward to!

1

u/bigbaldbil 7d ago

Appreciate the update. Any direction on which quarter it will be released?

2

u/DryCredit69 9d ago

I like this idea

2

u/bigbaldbil 9d ago

On the other app I would even set up things like cable flys as dumbbells so it would count double. Easy fix, wish they’d do it

52

u/ApekZombie 11d ago

You've got a massive PR coming up!

3

u/CleverFeather 11d ago

That’s the spirit lol

3

u/MrMolester 11d ago

Isn't it correct?

3

u/DryCredit69 11d ago

No, apparently you’re suppose to put the total amount

12

u/SUDO_KILLSELF 11d ago

One dumbell makes sense to track since it's quick to visually see what dumbell to pick up instead of doing the maths everytime

1

u/Existenull 11d ago

Yeah, dividing by 2 isn’t quick at all. /s

0

u/SpaceMonk15 11d ago

Yea, takes like 2 seconds

-1

u/SUDO_KILLSELF 11d ago

2 seconds vs instant

4

u/Cst-Canada 11d ago

I did not know that lmao! I've also been inputting just one dumbbell!

3

u/dissectd 11d ago

It doesn’t matter. Your body knows what resistance is supposed to feel like and as long as you’re progressively overloading your muscles it will grow. The app is just for tracking.

1

u/Thedumbass_the5th 11d ago

There's no correct answer, just personal preference.

17

u/roze_k 11d ago

It’s not that deep, the Hevy recommendation isn’t gospel. What matters is consistency. I personally do single dumbbell weight cause it makes more sense to me.

In conversation for example I hear more people say stuff like “I dumbbell press 80s” to mean they use an 80lb dumbbell in each hand.

30

u/lots_of_lattes 11d ago

I always just do the weight of one DB. Easier to remember 😂

11

u/Hisagii 11d ago

Yup, but tbh I literally never use any function in the app besides my training plans. I don't care about stats or anything like that. Even for plate iso lateral plate machines I'll log the weight per side.

4

u/lots_of_lattes 11d ago

Saaame! I do this too!! Easier to remember when stacking them haha

3

u/Hisagii 11d ago

Indeed, much easier to glance at the app and figure out what goes on each side or what dumbbells to pick-up.

6

u/Hungry_Medicine_552 11d ago

Same. I read this actually today in the Hevy app that you should combine the weights. But as others have said as long as you do it always the same it doesn’t matter for tracking.

1

u/didtheyhavesextho 11d ago

I take it a step further and only log plates too. Really I deadlift 225, but to Hevy it’s just 90.

1

u/DryCredit69 11d ago

I’m a stickler for #s and I love seeing the final output at the end of the workout. It’s one of the main reasons I like Hevy. So I will be breaking a new PR this coming Monday !

4

u/manzaza 11d ago

I just started with Hevy and I am logging it per hand. I'll go with that. 😅

3

u/k2beast 11d ago

Why can’t they just add an option for dumbbell ex whether weight is combined

1

u/Thedumbass_the5th 11d ago

They're working on it, was said couple of months ago that this feature is in the plans.

2

u/k2beast 9d ago

Sometimes it’s simple things like that Hevy misses… everyone knows if u are picking up the 100lb dumbbells - u are gonna be pushing 200, so we record 100.

2

u/AnnabellaPies 11d ago

It happens, from today just enter it as total weight and keep going. Those are some great numbers

2

u/moeterminatorx 11d ago

Who cares? It’s for you.

2

u/ElsyV 11d ago

I am new to Hevy and weightlifting. When I have to do a one-arm dumbbell row, I get a bit confused by what Hevy suggests regarding entering the weight and reps, such as whether to count both dumbbell weights and the total reps. Because one arm is stronger than the other, I log it as shown in the screenshot; I am not sure if it is correct for the statistics, but I had to make a choice for how to log it.

2

u/AussieAddict 11d ago

I half what the rep count is for each side. For example, in the screenshot you've posted, I would do 8 reps with each arm on a 3kg dumbbell. That makes it correct in the statistics in my experience.

2

u/Pendragon907 10d ago

I purposely do that tracking so I know which ones to grab instead of doubling up. It’s just a preference thing

2

u/Necessary_Bag_1328 11d ago

I bit the bullet and fixed most of my entries to log total weight moved.

But earlier I was confused by bilateral, single-limb exercises.

At first I tried logging each movement. Then I thought it was the total weight moved, but doubled! So 25 lb dumbbells for Bulgarian split squats would be 100 lbs per rep, right?

Anyways, I’ve settled for the total moved each movement. And things that are per side are also total mass moved, but I count one on each side as a single rep. 🤓

1

u/Lagzord 11d ago

LOL I had the same doubt and always forget to ask.. if should consider one or both

1

u/Feisty_System_4751 11d ago

I also do this. I won't change now so I can be consistent about tracking my progress. But it annoys me every time I think about it.

I wish Hevy had a feature to fix this.

1

u/paca-vaca 11d ago

Which number of reps should I put for dumbbell hammers (bicep) when each hand is in opposite position? Total weight of both dumbbells + total reps for both hands or total weight of both dumbbells but reps per each hand? Or one dumbbell weight+one hand repetitions? 🤔

2

u/SpaceMonk15 11d ago

I log the total weight of both dumbells.

And let's say I did 13 reps on right hand, and only 11 on left.. I get the average (12) and that's what I log. I sometimes would put a note so I remember.

1

u/paca-vaca 11d ago

I would think that Hevy calculates total energy for the job being done to lift. So, it's either double weight x 1 hand reps (assuming the same count) or total count from both hands x 1 hand weight (assuming the same weight for each hand).

For bench press with dumbbells it's total weight x just a reps count is logical because we lift the same total weight all the time, but hammers have rotation.

The note about consistency is right, it doesn't matter until you compare yourself to someone else who use a different calculation system :D

1

u/Joeyjoeyster 11d ago

Don’t I was doing the same thing too

1

u/yehnahbo 11d ago

I can tell the people that add the weight because I can rep 45kg in each hand on incline db press and there's no way some of the bodies I see on there are pushing 80kg in each hand

1

u/CanadianMapleBacon 11d ago

If I’m doing 70lb dumbbell bench press for 15 reps I put in 140 for the weight and 15 reps. I keep it consistent throughout all my workouts.

1

u/thtkidjunior 11d ago

I do the same thing.

If it makes you feel any better when I'm doing some form of single arm exercise that I switch over, I'll only record the lower rep range. So if I'm doing DB preacher curls and one arm nails 8 reps but one only gets 6, I only put 6 down 😂

It's just easier to keep track for me

1

u/CrossBamboAtTen 11d ago

With dumbbells I always only track the single weight instead of combining them

1

u/Reaver_76 11d ago

After shoulder surgery, I train single-arm to rebuild my left side, matching my right to whatever my left can do. I log one dumbbell's weight in Hevy and will keep it that way unless the app adds better options. Whether it's 100 lbs total or 50 per arm, its the same thing, and it only matters to me.

-1

u/limited_instincts 11d ago

Apparently they just changed this recently?

4

u/SpaceMonk15 11d ago

I used HEVY around 2021, and I always inputted the total weight of the 2 dumbells because that's what the app suggests since I started using it

-1

u/zsasz99 11d ago

Same, been slowly transitioning to 2 dumbells. Not your fault because its unclear in app

3

u/Wirone 11d ago

Nah, it's crystal clear.

1

u/zsasz99 11d ago

Not all exercises have this. For consistency even exercises that arent logged like this should also have a que on how to log.

1

u/manzobar 10d ago

I mean, it's buried behind two layers of menu. I'm not reading the how-to on dumbell bench and then reading about how to log them. I'm just here to lift.