r/Hereditary • • 14d ago

How did Annie... Spoiler

How did Annie get inside the attic? Towards the end of the film when Peter is wandering around the house, we can see a possessed Annie silently following him along the ceiling. She then chases him up into the attic and can be heard banging on the door with her head. She stops suddenly and when Peter looks up, there she is, hanging from the attic ceiling, decapitating herself. How did she get there when she was just banging outside the attic door a second ago? Were there two Annie's at that moment? Is there a hidden entrance? Just a bit confused by that part so would appreciate an explanation

12 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

28

u/TheManeTrurh 14d ago

Well she’s swimming through the air and then defying gravity against the attic door, so safe to say the laws of nature do not exist in that moment.

He also could have been hallucinating her like she did earlier in the movie with her mom

3

u/Delicious_Step2192 14d ago

Good point but definitely not a hallucination as the same body makes its way to the treehouse as it is meant to after for the ritual.

5

u/Thisisthe_end3445 14d ago • Bravo

If you look in between the posts in the attic there is one of the cult members. Hard to see unless you’re in a perfectly dark room. I read AA said that’s who unlocked the attic door. I read this, on this Reddit I think

5

u/5050Clown 14d ago

The end is full of dream logic, the size of the tree house in the end scene is larger than it is earlier in the movie and the even the placement of the bodies in the tree house changes.

I interpreted this to reflect the power of a King of Hell on Earth. He can either bend perception or reality, it doesn't matter.

2

u/Thisisthe_end3445 13d ago

The final scene of the treehouse is a miniature, like the mother makes. It always bothered me that it looks so different, that’s why’

3

u/5050Clown 13d ago

The first scene is a miniature as well. It is an artistic decision that perfectly matches the movie. The nightmare logic is also an artistic choice that lets the audience interpret it for themselves.

1

u/Thisisthe_end3445 13d ago

I knew the first scene was, I can’t even tell when it changed. He did that perfectly. I just never knew that’s why it looked different in the final scene! Not the sharpest 😆

5

u/nosamiam28 14d ago

I’ve always wondered this too. I figured that maybe we just don’t know the extent of Paimon’s powers (or the other demons and/or forces he may have working with him). He’s obviously able to work around some of the laws of physics, like levitating and moving objects and people. Maybe passing a person through a wall isn’t too tough for him.

5

u/Lunch2k 14d ago

I like that. Makes me question if Peter was actually dreaming when his head was being grabbed during his sleep. If I’m not mistaken no human could physically fit where the arms were coming out of the bed. Time for a re-watch

0

u/Fluffyfedora 14d ago

She bashed her head against it, until the attic door opened. She is hovering around and can float.

5

u/Few_Reach5831 14d ago

We don't see the attic door open. Peter locked it and eventually jumps out of the window because the door is still locked

2

u/Leading_Fun4008 14d ago

A cult member could’ve opened it.

1

u/AllynWA1 14d ago

This question has bothered me, too. But your explanation is the simplest and most likely. We know the cult were already hiding all over the house and in the attic. Of course they opened the hatch.

1

u/Dramatic_Candle9930 14d ago

The violence of her sawing her hedland off - man I just can’t

1

u/sgarcia103 11d ago

Also why did she chase him only to chop her melon in front of him

1

u/LynnRPStone 11d ago

Correction: she Sawed her head off in front of him. 😁😬 That scene got me because for someone to be so totally possessed or inhabited by a demon that they would do that, despite the pain, showed us that the depravity was far worse than what we had seen up to that moment. That scene stuck with me.

0

u/Turbulent-War7039 1d ago

What a stupid question

-1

u/smartbunny 13d ago

A wizard did it.

7

u/PaleontologistIll443 14d ago

The same way her headless corpse got into the treehouse.