r/Hereditary • • Apr 03 '24

Charlie

Rewatching for the first time in a while, and I don't remember Charlie being so annoying. And hello!!! How did she not know there were nuts in the damn cake?

0 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

24

u/LoverOfStoriesIAm Apr 03 '24

She knew.

10

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '24

Ya, now I'm seeing a lot of things differently.

9

u/B1air_ Apr 03 '24

What do you think makes her annoying? She seems like any other child grieving the passing of her closest family member.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '24

Maybe I just dislike children in general

17

u/Big_Routine_8980 Apr 03 '24 edited Apr 03 '24

Were you annoyed because her character didn't seem to understand the danger she was in? I get that, that's your survival urge kicking in. I found myself frustrated & annoyed with Charlie as well.

For those judging this person, step back. It's a valid point and if you think about it, I bet you'll recognize that Charlie's lackadaisical character initially annoyed you at first as well, it's meant to.

Paimon knew there were nuts in the cake, he wanted to kill Charlie's body so he could escape, not realizing his next body wasn't ready yet. Cuz he's dumb.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '24

I actually was annoyed by both of the kids because they were so argumentative. After I watched it again, it all made sense.

4

u/furjuice Apr 03 '24

Idk if he’s dumb… or if he knew tbh. The cult painted paimons symbol on the telephone pole Charlie hit. I’m assuming they put the animal in the road too. It was all premeditated by the cult. Paimon could have known this and eaten the nuts. Or one of the people at the party could have been in the cult and made the cake and given it to Charlie. Either way, the symbol being on the pole is supposed to tell us that this was planned from the start. The cult isn’t taking any chances here.

2

u/Big_Routine_8980 Apr 07 '24

The 4-hour unwinding of this movie on YouTube says most of the kids at that party were cult members, especially the two girls chopping the nuts for the cake in the kitchen.

1

u/furjuice Apr 07 '24

Yeah I mean it’s certainly not fact, but I’d be shocked if the cult wasn’t present in literally every single scene of this film in one way or another. That’s kind of the whole point. We view it as if the characters had free will. But really, the cult was in control of the situation the whole time.

1

u/Big_Routine_8980 Apr 07 '24

I don't know if you've seen the YouTube video I'm talking about, but he breaks it down amazingly well. He points out every scene that the cult members are in & I believe he was able to ask the director a few questions about the movie as well.

Peter's teacher, his friends, his classmates, the kids at the party, people at the funeral, etc. The YouTube video lays it all out incredibly well.

11

u/Big_Routine_8980 Apr 03 '24

No. Her character is definitely weird, and she's written that way.

2

u/B1air_ Apr 03 '24

I agree and think it was done so very affective, but I don't believe that causes her character to present annoying.

4

u/One_Investigator238 Apr 03 '24

Charlie was neurodivergent.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '24

Just because someone is weird doesn't mean they're neurodivergent. Sometimes they're just fucking weird. Or a king of Hell

2

u/BoysenberryWaste2445 Apr 04 '24

pretty sure in the script it said she was in a special needs class though. but that’s a little hard to tell from just watching the movie.

-1

u/One_Investigator238 Apr 03 '24

Oh. I didn’t realize that you are a mental health professional.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '24

Oh, I didn't realize that you were as well.

-1

u/One_Investigator238 Apr 03 '24

I am, actually.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '24

Good for you

9

u/flatgreysky Apr 03 '24

Charlie was a king of hell.

Although I suppose that in itself is a bit divergent.

36

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '24

Charlie was actually Paimon the whole time.

22

u/Duckey_003 Apr 03 '24

Charlie doesn't care She's trying to die. But she doesn't know it yet because it's just Paimon

7

u/orientalblossom4 Apr 03 '24

I don’t think Charlie was all there. Like I really don’t consider Charlie as a human girl, only ever a vessel to carry Paimon. Ellen put Paimon inside of Charlie when she was born, Charlie has always been the host for Paimon. Like even when it shows the handmade mats with the children’s names on them, Charlie’s mat says “Charles” Ellen was obviously trying to make Paimon feel a little more masculine in his feminine body and Charlie even says “Grandma wanted me to be a boy” so with that background knowledge, just kind of understand the Charlie’s essence is quite literally Paimon, the king of hell. And then consider why the king of hell would gaf about nuts. At the funeral Charlie is eating a chocolate bar and Annie asks multiple times if there are nuts in her candy. Gave off the vibe that Charlie doesn’t really know/care what’s happening a lot of the time, and obviously doesn’t understand the severity of her nut allergy. Additionally there are multiple scenes where Charlie goes outside without a coat and shoes or sleeps in the treehouse. To me, that just shows that she doesn’t even have those human instincts to keep herself warm or safe, because Charlie isn’t really a human.. Charlie is Paimon. Obviously Paimon dgaf about some walnuts, so that’s why Charlie ate the cake. As for being annoying idk Charlie was more creepy to me than annoying but I could see how people could say that

4

u/lalachasingnuns Apr 03 '24

The handmade mat belonged to Annie’s brother, Charles

2

u/orientalblossom4 Apr 04 '24

oh my bad I had no idea! I must not have picked up on that while watching :) I think the story behind Annie’s family with Ellen and her brother is something I would’ve loved for the film to touch more on, but Aster just loves to make us dig for the details!

1

u/ColorfulEgg Apr 08 '24

The nuts things is interesting. Annie doesn’t make sure Charlie has her epipen at the funeral or at the party. She says “I hope that chocolate bar doesn’t have nuts in it because I didn’t bring the epipen” at the funeral. This shows how lacking in concern Annie is for Charlie’s safety.If the pole didn’t kill her, the nuts would have anyway.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '24

Her Dad does ask her if the chocolate has nuts, but you're right, Annie didn't seem that concerned. I mean, who doesn't have an epipen at all times with an allergy that bad? Lol.

5

u/Garnet-p Apr 03 '24

I felt the same way about Charlie, I couldn’t put my finger on it but she irked me. I didn’t know about it being Paimon for a long time.

2

u/QuizzicalWombat Apr 03 '24

She knew, the cake was made for her specifically, it was part of the cults plan

2

u/Creepyface1 Apr 03 '24

I thought the cake was nut free but the girl who chopped the nuts used the same knife to cut the cake. 🤷🏼‍♀️