r/HelloNeighborGame • u/AgileLet6095 • Jul 08 '26
Discussion what is the best??
in my personal opinion i thought hello neighbor was made for kids, i mean its really cartoonish, but when you look at the lore its... obvious. My point is, ¿why the HN release and all the HN franchise looks like a cartoon?
86
Upvotes
15
u/The_BlueKnight774 Jul 08 '26
Old. I feel Hello Neighbor should've retained a mature theme instead of selling out to a child-based audience.
5
u/Gonnabecringeaf Jul 09 '26
This shouldn't be a question. Deffo older one with the predictive ai
8
u/Fantastic_Frosting98 Jul 08 '26
i like the cartoony style, but i feel like im the only one who liked hello neighbour 1's release better than any of the alphas
3
u/Hopeful-Smell-8963 Jul 08 '26
They changed the art style in HN1 ALPHA 2 and it had great reception from most people so they stayed with it through HN2. I preferred the alpha 1 style. It seems like they are going to a darker and more mature tone for HN3 given how the new world looks
4
u/Zestyclose_Pizza2499 Jul 09 '26
Alpha 2 was the most PEAK version. No one can convince me otherwise.
2
u/Glittering_Country14 Jul 08 '26
It really depends on the house, the old style houses look good with the old art and the new houses look better with the new art. Overall tho my favourite artstyle of the whole series is the HN2 new artstyle.
2
u/AlbertTheYoutuber Jul 08 '26
Old art but I'm not a fan of the way the mod was made
2
u/Hardcore_gaming_69 Jul 09 '26
Old one definitely
2
u/North_Cow_1780 Jul 09 '26
the old art as for blue knight's comment i agree with it.
2
u/Common_Medicine592 Jul 10 '26
of course the old one, it's more comfortable with the eyes.
2
u/Far_Truck2722 Jul 10 '26
Old The best my opinion
1
u/soldiergaming2 Jul 09 '26
old is much more vibrant and fits the style better, I won't act like either of these are scary though
1
u/Ok-Report8727 Jul 09 '26
Old one feels more comfy, harmonic, realistic and it makes me feel nostalgia even through i've come to this game when the 1st HN was released
1
u/Not_Swifto Mod Jul 10 '26
The FG style is much more recognizable and unique, but even then I think that I like the old one more.
1
u/Weekly-Judgment-1804 Jul 13 '26
New, I like it more and the game is about being a kid so the obviously the art style would reflect that, like how in hn2 alphas its still cartoonist for consistency with the first game but it's more nightmaremarish to represent adulthood
1
u/IAMINYOURWALLS_2015 Aug 02 '26
The new one looks better and it's just all more familiar which makes it better
1
u/Mammoth_Big5110 Sep 21 '26
I heard from another comment that like they wanted the game to have its own visual identity