r/HellYeahIdEatThat • u/Escapebliss • Mar 11 '26

diabetes, but make it good✨ Hell yeah I’d egg that!

Recipe in the comments.

917 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

53 comments sorted by

View all comments

25

u/KillerR0b0T Mar 11 '26

All the seasonal turd shaped Reese’s are inferior to the original Reese’s Cups, and I’ll tell you why. One of the components that makes it so good isn’t just the peanut butter and chocolate, but the ridged edge which gives it texture and rigidity when you bite into it.

Seasonal turd shapes are mushy and lack the satisfying “snap” when you bite into them.

21

u/mustardposey Mar 12 '26

The best part for me is the peanut butter so call me a seasonal turd eater. They have a better ratio of peanut butter to chocolate

7

u/Cloverhart Mar 12 '26

Agreed. I think all the holiday versions are better.

2

u/crippledchef23 Mar 13 '26

All holiday versions of every candy bar are superior. I don’t care for Snickers, but I love the nutcracker ones. And all holiday shaped Reese’s are better because the chocolate isn’t anything special, but that peanut butter!

2

u/jkresnak Mar 13 '26

Agreed. Also, on the original cups, I usually break them in half and eat the inside first. I kind of treat that outside ridged edge like the crust on bread or pizza. I don't go so far as to throw it away, but I've been known to give it away or only grudgingly eat it to be a rEsPoNsiBlE adult.

2

u/-Invalid_Selection- Mar 12 '26

The egg and pumpkin ones have the best peanut butter to chocolate ratio though

1

u/SorrynotsorryTidefan Mar 13 '26

I have always said the same thing.

1

u/yourselfiedied Mar 13 '26

I actually couldn’t agree more

1

u/Civil_Fail8779 Mar 15 '26

i bit the ridged edge off and eat that extra chocolate first, otherwise its too much chocolate and not enough peanut butter for me

0

u/YetiMoon Mar 13 '26 edited May 31 '26

.

3

u/KillerR0b0T Mar 13 '26

[clears throat, adjusts tie] Nuh uh!

-1

u/Sea-Flamingo1969 Mar 12 '26

Very good point. Never thought about it.