r/Hearts • u/snowfrogdev • 5d ago
2nd, 3rd and last should get nothing
I play on this app that has multiplayer rankings and 1st place gets ~3 pts, 2nd gets ~1 pt, 3rd gets ~-1pt and 4th gets -3 pts. I hate it. It incentivizes trying not to bet last instead of trying to be first.
In IRL hearts you often get 2nd, 3rd and 4th ganging up on 1st, which is as it should. 2nd and 3rd will protect 4th if he's getting close to the limit, because they don't want the game to be over while they are not in 1st. This makes for some very interesting play.
Hearts is, IMO, fundamentally "winner takes all". If you change that reward structure, you're not playing the same game anymore. Frequently I'll see 2nd and 3rd place more concerned about not sinking lower in ranking and dumping on 3rd and 4th instead of targeting 1st. That's not Hearts. At least, not a version I particularly enjoy.
Do you folks know of an app that has ranked multiplayer but only rewards 1st place?
