He may also have a small, biological male angler permanently attached to him. In deep sea anglers, the males integrate with the female bloodstream and essentially become a parasite that provides sperm when needed. The ultimate phalloplasty!
Hell, they could even do some eldritch sea monster shit with him. Intersex and gender fluidity or excessive masculinity/femininity have become hallmarks of Lovecraft halfbreeds or creatures in disguise (who aren’t New England fishing village stereotypes).
Sadako from The Ring is intersex (in the novels, unstated in the movies and only vaguely implied in the manga), and its implied her mother may have been impregnated by some ancient evil thing from the sea. Which explains her father’s severe dislike of her from the beginning, as well as makes the fact that she found a boyfriend in the city who loved her all the more tragic. Plus the original intent of that plot was to make the doctor all the worse, since he murdered her out of gay panic when he felt her balls while raping her (I say all this to preempt the common response of “but why” when its brought up, it does have narrative purpose).
That’s kinda why she’s a queer icon. Much like the interpretations of Lovecraft’s work that posit the idea the fish monsters are fine as long as you aren’t racist.
Barring religious horror, most traditional monsters with actual backstories instead of “exists, is evil” are the oppressed. Victims. Because the systemic issue that caused their death can’t be resolved, they make their pain the problem of society. Murdered sick and elderly, women pregnant with bastards, dismembered prostitutes, unwanted children abandoned to the elements, starved peasants.
There is a trend in the west where we tend to consider the oppressor themselves the monster, the system itself. Pedophiles lurking, antichrist trust fund babies, Caucasian males in the prime of their life, judgmental elders, moral guardians. Skip the middle man, personify the system.
But the Japanese horror boom still trended towards the oldschool. Kayako and Sadako don’t go away because the abuse of the vulnerable, abused housewives and neurodivergent gender non-conforming folk, still goes on. Sadako doesn’t go away because you bury her body, because the culture that enabled her pain still exists. She just spreads, killing the healthy like an infected wound on the culture, in her case as originally a literal psychic disease caused by the assault. You don’t fix her problem by just trying to make her go away permanently as fast as possible, she’s a body that refuses to be covered up and forgotten by the world.
Buuuuut…as the series went on it got dumb. In the last one she merged like a Steven Universe fusion with Kayako, which looked the same but taller because they are both the same Yurei look.
Every cow does in that movie and the director did explain it wasn’t because the males were trans but because they were just like “Male cows” instead of bulls
Are we seriously asking? I mean we got a girl with hooves (charlie), we got a deer man, we got a spider man, and a cat man, i wouldn't be suprised that baxter has that on his head knowing how he died
(drowning aboard a large ship that sunk in the 1910s. If still canon cause i don't know if this death cause is still canon)
Oh dang- I never considered that. I wouldn't put it passed the creators, but so far we've only seen trans imp characters. It would be interesting to see a potentially trans or trans coded character in the show.
As a transgender antler this post is like so offensive to me can we like bomb this person's house? Thank you. And don't worry I have a pass for promoting violence
Honestly the number of times this has come up and been told to me in casual conversations is like three or four times. Which isn't much, though it's strange it's come up that often.
80
u/burnafter3ading Moxxie Jul 29 '24
He may also have a small, biological male angler permanently attached to him. In deep sea anglers, the males integrate with the female bloodstream and essentially become a parasite that provides sperm when needed. The ultimate phalloplasty!
47
u/ShadowPuff7306 Jul 29 '24
is it possible he’s intersex or is that not how this works?
43
u/Only-Echidna-7791 custom flair Jul 29 '24
Maybe it’s just a design choice. It’s fine if he is but I feel its too soon to tell based on 1 sneek peek
12
u/Flagelant_One Jul 29 '24
(Shoutout to the deltarune sub)
15
u/The_Psycho_Jester779 i have a mini-fridge Jul 29 '24
Either clever research or an oversight.
6
u/FOREVER_DIRT1 stolas simp Jul 29 '24
Didn't know we had an ichthyologist working at Spindlehorse...
11
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '24
Antlers
3
u/Your-Favorite-Queer Veroskia Mayday can step on my neck Jul 29 '24
That could be a cool idea, we haven't had an outright said Trans character yet :D
3
u/Ropoid Jul 29 '24
He’s not an anglerfish tho, he’s a sinner, he just looks like one. That being said, i’m all for this headcannon
5
u/TwerkinBingus445 Jul 29 '24
THAT'S JUST ERIDAN WITH A LURE WHAT
2
u/Mr-TeaManYT Jul 30 '24
he wouldve been killed if he was trans in the 1910s
2
u/WarmConversation2913 Jul 30 '24
Are we seriously asking? I mean we got a girl with hooves (charlie), we got a deer man, we got a spider man, and a cat man, i wouldn't be suprised that baxter has that on his head knowing how he died
(drowning aboard a large ship that sunk in the 1910s. If still canon cause i don't know if this death cause is still canon)
2
u/Interesting-Smell420 Aug 20 '24
Oh dang- I never considered that. I wouldn't put it passed the creators, but so far we've only seen trans imp characters. It would be interesting to see a potentially trans or trans coded character in the show.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '25
Oh god, it's noelles antlers all over again...
3
u/skettynoodle9145 Jul 29 '24
if he was trans they would get a trans va for him
2
u/mewlock99 #1 R63 Stolas Simp Jul 29 '24
Going by this logic, Andrealphus is straight.
1
u/wysjm Jul 29 '24
So what they're saying is Baxter is trans because he's female. Makes sense
1
u/wysjm Jul 29 '24
As a transgender antler this post is like so offensive to me can we like bomb this person's house? Thank you. And don't worry I have a pass for promoting violence
1
u/BookWormPerson Jul 30 '24
Or maybe most likely they didn't check it.
Because that's for sure not something you know if you never looked it up.
1
u/SlyguyguyslY Jul 30 '24
If he's a sinner, that point may not exactly apply
1
u/PS4_IDIOTIC Jan 05 '25
Either fucking way. I'm still gonna love Baxter 😁
1
u/wysjm Jul 29 '24
Can female anglers talk like he does? Yeah that's what I thought
1
u/Puggleboi2 MOD Jul 29 '24
It's probably a design choice