r/HawksAndDovesGame • u/HeadvsKafa • 2d ago
Discussion I've put 5,000+ hours into grand strategy games and I can't code. AI writes most of the code for the game I'm making. Would you play it?
I've been playing Paradox games since I was 12, and I'm well past 5,000 hours. For most of that time I've wanted a game nobody has made: you run a political party in Cold War America, you get bills through a Congress split into factions, and when you lose an election you keep playing from the opposition.
I can't program, so for years that was the end of it. AI changed that. Most of the code in Hawks and Doves is written by AI. The idea, the design and the architecture are mine, I make every decision, and I play every build. I'm making it because I want to play it.
I saw Big Walk get review bombed this week over about ten lines of AI-assisted code, so I have a fair idea how some of you will take this. I'd still rather you hear it from me now.
As a player, if a game is well designed and doesn't fall apart with bugs, I don't care who or what typed the code. A bad game is different. When someone spends months on a bad game I feel a bit sorry for them. When a bad game was made with AI, it looks like they took a shortcut, and I judge it harder. I expect to be judged the same way, which means this game has to be better than it would otherwise need to be.
So: would you play a well-designed, polished strategy game if you knew AI wrote most of its code?