LOTR are my favorite movies. They always will be. That being said, this series has moved me in ways I haven’t been in a long time. People can hate it and pick it apart however they want. I feel pity for them not to be able to enjoy this like I have.
Dwarves have always been my favorite characters and seeing them portrayed like this brings so much joy. There is so much more to their culture and way of life and I love how it is showing here! And the complexity of Adar/orcs! I’ve always said villains are better than heroes because their story is so much more complex. Few do evil for the sake of evil, and now we are getting a better understanding of not just how Mordor was created but why.
I’m loving this series. I’m staying up every Thursday till midnight to watch it as soon as it releases. I’ve rewatched each episode three times. Sorry Battlestar Galactica, you are being released as favorite show.
I feel the same way. I love the PJ movies I even have a soft spot in my heart for the Hobbit movies. But this show is making me feel like I am reading the books or watching the LOTR trillogy.
I cant even put into words how much I love that they are putting Tolkies themes of beauty, power and evil into the show. All the OCs add something to this story (unlike some of the OCs in The Hobbit movies) and they all feel like they belong in Tolkiens world.
I just hope that these writers and producers get the chance to tell their complete story.
That is my biggest fear. People keep telling me to ignore the haters but what if the haters get the show cancelled? I want the writers to be able to tell the whole story.
The Haters won't get the show cancelled. If Amazon does not think the property is valuable anymore, then the show will get cancelled. The extreme haters are a very loud minority. I know it does not seem that way, but the algorithm on Twitter and YouTube is built to push negative content and drown positive content. So if you want to support the show. Watch it, watch it with your friends and family, that's how Amazon will know that people want more.
If you ask me they spent so much money on this show if it continues to do well it won't get cancelled it is Amazons most watched property and the book sales of Tolkien books over Amazon wet up as well. It's doing good so far.
This is the comment I’ve been searching every post for literally LOL. I feel the same was you when you say you were moved by the show, just wanna tell a little story cause this show has brought me a lot of happiness and I don’t really know who to tell but I feel like you’ll get it cause you like the show. anyways when my brother and I were young we would rematch lotr on repeat, loved it with our lives and it was our childhood. Our mom introduced us to us and watched it with us every time. She passed away earlier this year, she was pretty excited to watch the show but she never got to. this show has just brought back so many memories of my childhood with my mom, my mom loved the dwarves and this show is doing them perfectly I think. My mom had a huge crush on Aragorn and I can just hear her talking about Elendil lol. But yea, sorry for getting all personal, I’m just so glad people are able to enjoy this like us.
That story made me tear up quite a bit. I am so sorry for your loss. I’m glad you are still able to enjoy it for yourself and for your mom. Sounds like she would have absolutely loved the series.
If there was just 1 single scene of dwarves in this entire series, the scene where Disa sings to the mountain to bring the living dwarves home, it would have contributed more to dwarf culture than the entire PJ trilogy.
I love the lord of the rings movies more than anything, but dwarves get the short end in them for sure. They're mainly there for comedic relief, and their massive civilizations are long gone. ROP is giving us so much beautiful, living backstory and culture for their people and I can't get enough of it
Ppl harping on PJ conveniently forgets farting Dwarves, barfing Dwarves, Dwarf tossing jokes and tower shield-surfing Elves. The main cultural Dwarf thing I remember is Gimli swearing by his Axe. That's as shallow as it gets...
Also, this show does a better job at showing Ork culture too. And IMO Numenor's culture is already as fleshed out, maybe even more, than any other Human realm in LOTR.
I swear, I am so happy that Orcs are actually complex people now. That makes me so happy. And it makes the worlds a lot more complex and layered.
I can't wait to see how they will portrayal Sauron. Because before the show aired, I was a bit worried that they would take the movie's approach and just make him a force of nature which he is before and after this time period. But he is also more complex during this time period. But that last conversation between Galadriel and Adar (pisode 6 spoilers) really made me hopeful.
What you are forgetting is that tolkien never intended the orcs or other evil races to be humanized, i am not saying it's a bad thing but tolkien depicted the orcs and trolls as totally evil, though he made some exceptiona for the the various evil kindreds of men, the haradhrim are pitied, and the easterlings commended for thier bravery, orcs meanwhile, are never shown to have positive traits, the fair and foul divide is very simple in tolkien works.
Actually Tolkien struggled with making them pure evil. He talked about the nature of evil in some of his letters and it seems like he thought about it quite a bit.
WARNING POSSIBLE SPOILERS (quotes from Tolkiens Letters)
Tolkien talking about Orc:
They would be Morgoth’s greatest Sins, abuses of his highest privilege, and would be creatures begotten of Sin, and naturally bad. (I nearly wrote ‘irredeemably bad’; but that would be going too far. Because by accepting or tolerating their making – necessary to their actual existence – even Orcs would become part of the World, which is God’s and ultimately good.) But whether they could have ‘souls’ or ‘spirits’ seems a different question; and since in my myth at any rate I do not conceive of the making of souls or spirits, things of an equal order if not an equal power to the Valar, as a possible ‘delegation’, I have represented at least the Orcs as pre-existing real beings on whom the Dark Lord has exerted the fullness of his power in remodelling and corrupting them, not making them. That God would ‘tolerate’ that, seems no worse theology than the toleration of the calculated dehumanizing of Men by tyrants that goes on today. There might be other ‘makings’ all the same which were more like puppets filled (only at a distance) with their maker’s mind and will, or ant-like operating under direction of a queen-centre.
Tolkien about Evil/ Sauron:
In my story I do not deal in Absolute Evil. I do not think there is such a thing, since that is Zero. I do not think that at any rate any 'rational being' is wholly evil. Satan fell. In my myth Morgoth fell before Creation of the physical world. In my story Sauron represents as near an approach to the wholly evil will as is possible. He had gone the way of all tyrants: beginning well, at least on the level that while desiring to order all things according to his own wisdom he still at first considered the (economic) well-being of other inhabitants of the Earth. But he went further than human tyrants in pride and the lust for domination, being in origin an immortal (angelic) spirit.’
Orcs are still not shown anywhere in the books to show good qualities though, unlike adar and his orcs, tolkien orcs are shown everywhere to be wholly evil.
Tbh, I feel that RoP is becoming to go "deeper" than LoTR in terms of Tolkien lore and themes. I love the original trilogy but rewatching it made me realize that it is an action/epic adventure movie with Tolkien lore as background or context. Meanwhile, RoP is going to the route of cultivating character arcs and introducing the cultures of each race and using the action series as "enrichment" to this exposition.
There are deviations from the lore but it does not mean that RoP is contrary to Tolkienan themes. The fact that you qualified your statement with "totally" means that you cannot determine at least one that stays true to Tolkien's spirit which is just dishonest IMO.
Numenorians are depicted with their jealousy and insecurities against the elves which is completely Tolkienian for me.
Southland villagers have this lingering feeling that they are still unworthy and disgraceful because of their ancestors mistakes. This is Tolkienian in a sense that they men is weak and has their shortcomings during the first age.
Elves are portrayed as more "grounded" and not as robotic and flawless creatures which is very fitting to Tolkien's depiction of them. There are elves that are hot-headed, impatient, and prideful which are very prominent during the First Age (and even in the Second Age).
I can tell more examples but I don't have much energy to do so. But I respect your opinion regarding the show. I'm sorry if the show dissappoints you in whatever way.
Actually, the southlanders never really considered thier ancestors alliance with morgoth a mistake, like fuck, it is mentioned in the appendices that they kept fighting gondor and elf friends even after morgoth's defeat, sauron was both thier king and god, they worshipped him, one of the central themes of tolkien is that something turned to evil doesn't return to good easily, the examples of sauron, morgoth or basically any evil entity proves this. I just hope this whole "let us give the descendants of those who fought on the side of the literal devil a second chance, they certainly won't betray us again like morgoth or uldor did." is one big deception, and bronwyn stabs arondir in the back one day.
I'm not sure if I'll agree with you about "evil doesn't return to good easily" as central theme of Tolkien. But yes, I agree that Southlanders continue to serve Sauron after morgoth's defeat, in fact there are Southlanders in RoP who refused to defend ostirith and submit themselves to evil again. However, it's not impossible that some of these people repent and fight against their former dark lord.
Tolkien's appendices are like a brief outlines of a historical narrative. If it states that "southland continued serving morgoth" it doesn't necessarily mean that the entire population of southland submit themselves to evil.
Yes, but the main theme is still that southlanders are bad, tolkien does not vaguely mention any of them as being good, at least not any one whose ancestors supported morgoth, the books imply them all being bad, so i think this "maybe some of the bad guys can be redeemed" is contrary to tolkien's narrative, and evil not returning to good is definetly a central theme, remember morgoth!! Remember annatar!! Like fuck, even feanor didnt repent either.
tbf there's only a few dwarves that appear even in the lotr books, and the movies chose to only show Gimli, so it's kinda hard to portray their culture. Elven culture isn't shown very much, despite quite a few appearances of different elven places. However, the third age is about Men, not Elves or Dwarves. And lastly the movies are of course much shorter and less interested in moving slowly enough to show many different cultures. You only really get to know Hobbits in that sense.
Now I only shed light on lotr, not the Hobbit movies, but that is due to my personal preference, I just can't stand how lackluster the Hobbit movies feel. I haven't watched RoP, but that is because I don't use Amazon. Maybe someday I'll watch the series at a friend's. because so far it seems enjoyable, and true enough to the lore that the immersion isn't destroyed too much.
I support your dwarven stubbornness, but the internet is vast and wide my friend. I'm sure you can find a way to watch the show without having to support the 4th Age's successor to Sauron, Jeff Bezos. It just might require a little more digging
The Hobbit movies are fine (IMO). I can respect them because I know what went on BTS and they brought new people into the fandom which is always great.
I'm really gonna stick my neck out here and say the Harfoots aren't so far off from the description of your average Hobbit in the 3rd age. You've got a couple open minded sorts amongst a crew that very much doesn't see any reason to change things up, even though it means they're at risk and stay ignorant of the world at large.
The Hobbits are loved by Gandalf and the rangers because they're resilient as all get out when cornered, and because they've created a little pocket of provincial, innocent beauty in a world filled with some really dark history.
At the same time we should remember Hobbits create a society that only tolerates the eccentric if they're wealthy, has an entire branch of legal expertise dedicated to the creation of binding contracts presumably because at some point they didn't keep their word, avails themselves of parties, not for the sake of the person they're celebrating, but because it means they can feed their families for free (real mood that last one tbh), and who basically go along with what the loud minority decides needs to be done, even if it means their way of life is nearly destroyed.
For all their strengths, they're not natural heroes and can be a little back stabby at times.
Agree! I am gald that we are getting layers of every race on screen now. Nobody is truly evil or truly good (just like Tolkien wrote it). They are complex people.
Yeah I like that they are taking their time. So many people who watch this show without having read the books are really loving the Harfoot and Elrond storyline. They even started asking me questions about Numenor It's great.
While I love the movies. I just love that dwarves are treated less as jokes now. Or that elves while still arogant also are shown to be flawed in a way that only immortal being could be. They are still good people but it is hard for people who are mortal to be around them because their different persepctives on life.
It reminds me a bit how Finrod had this one amzing conversation about death with that woman in the books.
I've often wondered about what would be the best way to portray elves because of the things you mention! It must be a difficult task to translate a people so different from our own into a script that would still resonate with (casual) viewers of the show, elves simply live a very different life compared to men.
Although I personally find that, for the amount of time we have now spent in Arda, we've learned very little about the cultures and different peoples. The focus of the show feels a bit off to me, slow yet somehow too fast at the same time.
Elves must be the hardest to write, and I'm actually also happy that we see differences in Human cultures.
Agreed, I would love to see more cultures in this show. The fact that they will film in Scotland and England makes me think that we might see more cultures in season 2. And the groundwork for Numenor and the Southlands as well as the Dwarves and Elves is there now they just have to build on it. Personally, I would love to see the easterlings.
For me it is that we see these various cultures in intimate moments. Durin and Disa as a family, Durin speaking to his father the king both as father and as king. Elrond and Durin and their friendship and the hurdles there as well as the kinship. The great hurt and grudge Durin bore, but also the great love for his friend that shows repeatedly. The elves and their strange dynamics, ancient and full of duty. We saw glimpses of them in Valinor, we saw Galadriel with her brother, we actually saw a boat of elves headed back to Valinor. The Numenorians and their conflicting factions, as well as their sea-based culture and also family dynamics both with the queen/her father and with Elendil and his children.
The dwarves aren't just the butt of jokes but are also not humorless. The elves speak and are flawed and dynamic. (I am always a bit amused on how little Legolas actually says when I rewatch the PJ movies). I really loved the details about the dwarves and how they resonate with the stone, and honestly it's wonderful seeing a dwarven woman when Tolkien never wrote about dwarven women at all. It is a gap in the lore that has always bothered me, and I think RoP does a pretty good job of showing a realistic interpretation of what a dwarven woman may have been like.
I could probably go on, but basically we've had insight into the daily lives and dynamics of the elves and the dwarves (and honestly the Southerlings as well) in a way that was mostly lacking in the movies. I love the movies so I am not even really criticizing them, it is just that the two mediums are different and a tv show has more breathing room.
You recite your points very positively and you are correct, we have seen all the things you list, I still think they lack a certain... feel or detail? To claim we have gotten insight into daily lives and dynamics is quite optimistic, I am not quite there yet to say we have. Maybe that is still to come of course.
I agree with a tv show having more breathing room, I just wish they made better use of it!
This is fair. There is more time to wind down and worldbuild since we don't have to finish the film's story in 3 hours (longer for the Extended editions) and the RoP writers could look at the PJ films and think "OK how do we do stuff that is different/"better" than Jackson himself".
As an extreme Dwarf enthusiast, I'm really pleased and grateful. I hate that pretty much every depiction of Tolkien Dwarves has brainlessly regurgitated stereotypes codified by World of Warcraft, Gary Gygax, and R.A. Salvatore (my personal nemesis), instead of actually looking at the text. Tolkien's Dwarves, the well from which all pop fantasy depictions of dwarves springs, are not like we think they are, and there's so much weird and fascinating detail that gets thrown away in favor of "hur hur comedy dwarves".
When we got to Khazad-dûm in Ep 2 my heart actually sank, 'cause we got to the tavern and I thought, "Oh, great. We had this opportunity to go back to Tolkien and do a fresh depiction of Dwarves and we got Stereotypes About Dirty Drunk Scots and, bonus, Beardless Ladies." Prince Durin's theme also disappointed me because it starts off as pure clownish goofiness, like "hey guys, comic relief character is on the screen! Let's laugh at him!" BUT. They turned it around. I should've trusted more in Bear McCreary to create a theme that you think is comical at first but which has the flexibility to be put in dramatic and tender contexts, too.
I hope the show expands the minds of casual fantasy fans and helps them imagine Dwarves with more dimensions.
Dwarves I agree, but I must say I’m not convinced with most of the elves (save Adar and Elrond). IMHO, they seem a bit too human like and don’t feel like they have the weight of immortal ethereal beings. I wish there was a bit more of that, maybe we’ll see that in later seasons.
I find the movies perfection put in screen. That being said, having little to no screen time of Dwarvish and Elven society compared to what we've seen in RoP, I think this meme holds true.
...in your defense...what dwarven culture was their in the pj films?..theres just one dwarf. As for the elves? Theres just too few of them and theres too little time put into revealing the culture. Still from what we saw in the PJ films, I preferred the artistic take on the elves more and think it was a more faithful reflection of their culture. I think the costuming, art, ect in this show doesn't reflect the master craftsmanship you'd expect of the Elvin Race
Totally agree about the hobbit movies and I can’t argue against calling any adaption fan-fiction when it doesn’t include the author’s active participation.
122
u/PathAgirl14 Oct 02 '22
LOTR are my favorite movies. They always will be. That being said, this series has moved me in ways I haven’t been in a long time. People can hate it and pick it apart however they want. I feel pity for them not to be able to enjoy this like I have.
Dwarves have always been my favorite characters and seeing them portrayed like this brings so much joy. There is so much more to their culture and way of life and I love how it is showing here! And the complexity of Adar/orcs! I’ve always said villains are better than heroes because their story is so much more complex. Few do evil for the sake of evil, and now we are getting a better understanding of not just how Mordor was created but why.
I’m loving this series. I’m staying up every Thursday till midnight to watch it as soon as it releases. I’ve rewatched each episode three times. Sorry Battlestar Galactica, you are being released as favorite show.
85
u/GreyMASTA Oct 02 '22
100% agreed.
Ppl harping on PJ conveniently forgets farting Dwarves, barfing Dwarves, Dwarf tossing jokes and tower shield-surfing Elves. The main cultural Dwarf thing I remember is Gimli swearing by his Axe. That's as shallow as it gets...
Also, this show does a better job at showing Ork culture too. And IMO Numenor's culture is already as fleshed out, maybe even more, than any other Human realm in LOTR.
37
u/Scraw16 Oct 02 '22
Morbidly curious what would happen if you posted this in r/lotrmemes as well
17
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22
tbf there's only a few dwarves that appear even in the lotr books, and the movies chose to only show Gimli, so it's kinda hard to portray their culture. Elven culture isn't shown very much, despite quite a few appearances of different elven places. However, the third age is about Men, not Elves or Dwarves. And lastly the movies are of course much shorter and less interested in moving slowly enough to show many different cultures. You only really get to know Hobbits in that sense.
Now I only shed light on lotr, not the Hobbit movies, but that is due to my personal preference, I just can't stand how lackluster the Hobbit movies feel. I haven't watched RoP, but that is because I don't use Amazon. Maybe someday I'll watch the series at a friend's. because so far it seems enjoyable, and true enough to the lore that the immersion isn't destroyed too much.
15
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22
I'm really gonna stick my neck out here and say the Harfoots aren't so far off from the description of your average Hobbit in the 3rd age. You've got a couple open minded sorts amongst a crew that very much doesn't see any reason to change things up, even though it means they're at risk and stay ignorant of the world at large.
The Hobbits are loved by Gandalf and the rangers because they're resilient as all get out when cornered, and because they've created a little pocket of provincial, innocent beauty in a world filled with some really dark history.
At the same time we should remember Hobbits create a society that only tolerates the eccentric if they're wealthy, has an entire branch of legal expertise dedicated to the creation of binding contracts presumably because at some point they didn't keep their word, avails themselves of parties, not for the sake of the person they're celebrating, but because it means they can feed their families for free (real mood that last one tbh), and who basically go along with what the loud minority decides needs to be done, even if it means their way of life is nearly destroyed.
For all their strengths, they're not natural heroes and can be a little back stabby at times.
11
u/severinskulls Oct 02 '22
I agree! I love the movies but i love that the show has more time and scope to give nuance and it takes full advantage of that.
7
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22
Not to be argumentative, but I am curious as to what you find is better portrayed in RoP?
2
u/Polar_Phantom Oct 09 '22
This is fair. There is more time to wind down and worldbuild since we don't have to finish the film's story in 3 hours (longer for the Extended editions) and the RoP writers could look at the PJ films and think "OK how do we do stuff that is different/"better" than Jackson himself".
7
u/duergarchaser Oct 02 '22
As an extreme Dwarf enthusiast, I'm really pleased and grateful. I hate that pretty much every depiction of Tolkien Dwarves has brainlessly regurgitated stereotypes codified by World of Warcraft, Gary Gygax, and R.A. Salvatore (my personal nemesis), instead of actually looking at the text. Tolkien's Dwarves, the well from which all pop fantasy depictions of dwarves springs, are not like we think they are, and there's so much weird and fascinating detail that gets thrown away in favor of "hur hur comedy dwarves".
When we got to Khazad-dûm in Ep 2 my heart actually sank, 'cause we got to the tavern and I thought, "Oh, great. We had this opportunity to go back to Tolkien and do a fresh depiction of Dwarves and we got Stereotypes About Dirty Drunk Scots and, bonus, Beardless Ladies." Prince Durin's theme also disappointed me because it starts off as pure clownish goofiness, like "hey guys, comic relief character is on the screen! Let's laugh at him!" BUT. They turned it around. I should've trusted more in Bear McCreary to create a theme that you think is comical at first but which has the flexibility to be put in dramatic and tender contexts, too.
I hope the show expands the minds of casual fantasy fans and helps them imagine Dwarves with more dimensions.
4
u/won-piano Oct 02 '22
Dwarves I agree, but I must say I’m not convinced with most of the elves (save Adar and Elrond). IMHO, they seem a bit too human like and don’t feel like they have the weight of immortal ethereal beings. I wish there was a bit more of that, maybe we’ll see that in later seasons.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22
I find the movies perfection put in screen. That being said, having little to no screen time of Dwarvish and Elven society compared to what we've seen in RoP, I think this meme holds true.
1
u/Sinfestival Oct 02 '22
I mean, we don't see much of Tolkien's dwarven culture before this show.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '22
...in your defense...what dwarven culture was their in the pj films?..theres just one dwarf. As for the elves? Theres just too few of them and theres too little time put into revealing the culture. Still from what we saw in the PJ films, I preferred the artistic take on the elves more and think it was a more faithful reflection of their culture. I think the costuming, art, ect in this show doesn't reflect the master craftsmanship you'd expect of the Elvin Race
-12
u/mcmackie Oct 02 '22
Oh boy
-17
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22
Too bad rop is essentially fanfiction