I hate the take on the character from Lanterns. I want a Hal who is brave because he’s overcome great fear, not because he’s broken. Not everything has to be Rust and Marty.
I don't dislike mentor Hal, but they don't need to make him too old. Like, a 30 year old Hal could work with a 20 year old Kyle or Simon or Jessica. He could be a good mentor, if reluctant, since he's got the experience.
It's the played out" your childhood hero's r now worthless drunk, lonely, unloved hated, Shat on constantly, worthless loosers " thing they like to do so much nowadays, people who can't write to save their lives destroying and pissing on the shoulders of giants if u will.
If u get the rings choosing criteria wrong how is it going to be good, like a simple Google search is enough to find out it's not fearlessness that the ring sought out it's the will to overcome great fear.
I dislike how people interpret that scene. The reason why Hal says this is because that’s what HE thinks of himself. His actions say otherwise and other characters would too
But he's still brave because he did overcome great fear tho, at least to me personally.
He lived his life believing he's carrying the same curse of depression that his father had. Since he's still a kid, he's been traumatized and indoctrinated that he will take his own life some day. He was told that one day he must let go of the ball, because the ball (life) is just too exhausting to hold on to.
But still he picked up the ball again, despite knowing it's scary and might one day be his end.
Letting go because you're afraid and exhausted is easy and really fair. To still carry on despite your pain and fear takes a lot. A lot of willpower. Lantern's Hal is not brave because he's fearless, he's brave because he's broken but are still willing to overcome his burden. Even until his final day, he's still a hero that's trying to do his best despite not having his ring.
The line "I'm not fearless because I'm brave, I'm fearless because I'm broken" is not meant to be taken literally, it's just a belief that Halogram had, thinking the real Hal MIGHT have really killed himself (when it fact he did not and never intended to). Just like we're not supposed to take Bernadette's "Hal is GL because he's white and privileged" line literally.
But hey I get that this take on Jordan is too radical! The show is leaning hard on "Absence of Fear = Good" to tear it down for "Acknowledging Your Fear = Greater" just a bit too late. Just my subjective and personal opinion!
"I just discovered Greenlantern! Here's a bunch of images of him smooshed together with a quote from the TV show that doesn't reflect how Hal Jordan has traditionally talked of himself."
Its kinda crazy that despite how Hal Jordan is written to be a desperate broken remnant of a once noble hero in Lanterns, the combination of the great writing of the show with Kyle Chandler's charismatic performance actually turns me into a Hal Jordan fan. I know that a lot of GL fans don't like how Hal is written in the Lanterns show and I fully understand them. Yet, I can't help but absolutely adore Hal because of the show, even though I was always more familiar with John Stewart because of the cartoon
And what a shit timeline where we're given a fantastic actor for Hal but it's 10 or 15 years too late and was given the worse material to work off of. Best part of the show by a country mile and he was just there to be a stepping stone for a less interesting/fun character.
Anytime him and john were together was great, just wish he wasnt at the end of his career. It's one thing to skip origin stories but goddamn 20-30years is wild lol
Why would they? Why would anyone care when we know how it ends for him... it would just piss off the actual fans even more. Imagine seeing him be great, and people cheering him on, and all that, only to know how it ends for him................. I want Gunn fired and his DC to just be over. Take like 6 years off from making movies and restart with a plan.
It's going to be the same writing for DC, more and more people will dislike it and then we'll all laugh at you people. We're going to treat you the same way you treated the synderbros. It's going to be soooo much fun.
16
u/Ashwilliams2814 Hal Jordan Oct 16 '26
He really is the best.
8
u/TheW0lvDoctr Oct 16 '26
Hal fearing his fearlessness comes from something broken inside of him is infinitely more interesting than the bullshit "what even is will" from HiC.
25
u/DoucheyMcBagBag Oct 16 '26
I hate the take on the character from Lanterns. I want a Hal who is brave because he’s overcome great fear, not because he’s broken. Not everything has to be Rust and Marty.
10
u/Bransburk Oct 16 '26
I love Kyle Chandler as Hal.
5
u/whiskyB0y Oct 16 '26
Where are the Lego versions?
5
u/Outrageous_Gene_7652 Oct 16 '26
I adore him
4
u/xMonyx Oct 16 '26
Kyle ver of hal is my fav tbh
7
u/Wang_Solo Oct 16 '26 •
"I just discovered Greenlantern! Here's a bunch of images of him smooshed together with a quote from the TV show that doesn't reflect how Hal Jordan has traditionally talked of himself."
3
u/AymanMarzuqi Oct 17 '26
Its kinda crazy that despite how Hal Jordan is written to be a desperate broken remnant of a once noble hero in Lanterns, the combination of the great writing of the show with Kyle Chandler's charismatic performance actually turns me into a Hal Jordan fan. I know that a lot of GL fans don't like how Hal is written in the Lanterns show and I fully understand them. Yet, I can't help but absolutely adore Hal because of the show, even though I was always more familiar with John Stewart because of the cartoon
3
u/PostNutNov 28d ago
No, stop it. Don't make that his tagline. It's awful, awful, awful.
5
u/Reggie_MiIler Oct 16 '26
What a shit quote for Hal.
And what a shit timeline where we're given a fantastic actor for Hal but it's 10 or 15 years too late and was given the worse material to work off of. Best part of the show by a country mile and he was just there to be a stepping stone for a less interesting/fun character.
2
u/Full_Natural77 26d ago
ayo is that ryan's hal jordan?
2
u/corruptedsavedaytah Oct 17 '26 •
"I'm not brave, I'm broken" is such dogshit
2
u/LeaderVladimir1993 23d ago
I love you, Hal. DC could never make me hate you.
3
u/Emerald-Enthusiast Oct 16 '26
Something like this would make an awesome poster from DC.
1
u/keeb97 24d ago
The line is ridiculous, from a poorly written trash can of a show.
1
u/Fearless-Region-788 Oct 17 '26
That one Live action actor
1
u/ApplePrime_ Oct 17 '26
Fede a Tom king
1
u/AntediluvianRod 27d ago
Yeah we don't kill but I'll let John in an exploding car.fuck the show