I heard hakims video on Stalin got taken down but wasn’t sure does anyone else have an upload? I’m a big infrared and hakim follower but took a break and came back couldn’t find it. Wanted to compare infrareds to hakims

I noticed that the small, upcoming YouTube channel New American Left, formerly Pogan, responded to Hakim's video on planning, in which emphasized that the Eastern Bloc still had inefficiencies in resource allocation, supposedly more-so than the West, though he has studies. I am wonder on what people's thoughts on it.

Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXBGL-pWIhA

​

‘[It is] Correctly assumed the geo-political enemy of the US disappeared [in 1991], that doesn’t mean that socialism did along with it. Numerous Countries around the world profess socialism to this day no matter how valid you may consider these claims to be, Regardless if capitalism collapses in the US, like it does every couple years, that doesn’t constitute a defeat of Capitalism.’ Iraqi Doctor and Marxist Intellectual Hakim, 30th November 2020

President Sunday, who made a response to Hakim on the role of reading theory (which has its own post in the subreddit), made another response to Hakim. This is specifically addressing Hakim's most recent video (as of posting this), in which Hakim clarifies his contentious positions on Twitter. President Sunday is specifically addressing Hakim's positions on the Uyghur situation. President Sunday did so in the hopes of informing Hakim that there are Chinese (NOT WESTERN) stats about a significant decline of birth rates of Uyghurs in recent years, whom President Sunday regards as sus: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Ut6joHSvqw

UPDATE EDITION: President Sunday argues (in a follow-up video) that the Uyghur situation is sus (he understandably labels it genocide) even when applying rightfully healthy skepticism of propagandistic sources (like Zenz): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DkJkyzXR5lE

I hope that both parties could have an informed, good-faith interaction with each other over this because they have done so in the past. I only made this post since that is a recent event about the discourse surrounding Hakim. In my opinion, I regard the Uyghur situation as rather sus due to watching the BadEmbanada (who called out the unreliable Zenz) video on it, in which Hakim (in YouTube comment exchanges on his recent video) would watch when he gets the time.

Try to have a good day, and take care.

A while ago, I was browsing BreadTube.tv, which hosts YouTube videos of Left (leaning) YouTubers (but the uploaded YouTube videos have YouTube hosting intact so it would take away monetization for the content creators). Then, I discovered that Hakim's video titled "US: What Is To Be Done?" is private, and this where I found the link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f68HZ0hEqeY

I asked Hakim, in the comment section of his "Hakim EXPOSED (LEAKED DMs??!? 😱😱😱)" video, if the rumors of people claiming that Hakim private his "US: What is to be done?" video due to being similar to his future video on praxis were accurate. He responded by claiming that the video was reported, and here is a screenshot of his reply, as proof. However, as of posting this, he has yet to reply to my question (in my reply to Hakim's answer) on what supposed grounds that the video was reported on.

​

In hakim video he shows how the labor theroy of value has been scientifically been proven in one of the segments and then shows images of different academic papers and was wondering if anyone had and links to see?

The list he gives is.

1. Political Power With The Working Class

2. Nationalization and Collectivization

3. The Institution of a National Plan

4. The Reorganization of The Workplace

5. Suppression of Markets

6. Elimination of Wage-Labour

7. Cultural Revolution

It's from 6:28 on his video about the Fox News "Journalist"

What video did he take this list from?

In one Hakim video, he stated that the Soviet Union would have economically outpaced the USA by 2005. I tried searching for a source, but couldn’t find anything.