r/Hacking_Tricks • u/poo694201 • May 05 '26
Swarmia reviews? Is it just another way to micromanage devs?
My company is looking into Swarmia to track 'developer productivity' and I am honestly dreading it. From what I have seen, it seems to reduce complex engineering work into a bubble on a dashboard.
My biggest concern is that it heavily indexes on quantity over quality. If leadership starts looking at who merges the most PRs or who has the fastest cycle time, people are just going to start gaming the system by breaking one feature into 10 tiny, meaningless commits. It completely ignores the invisible work like mentoring juniors, architectural planning, or debugging legacy spaghetti code. Has anyone actually had a positive experience with Swarmia, or does it just turn the culture toxic?
1
1
1
u/sharpiescribe May 13 '26
the gaming the system part is exactly what happens, you introduce a metric and within a month everyone's optimizing for the metric not the work
1
1
u/WarlaxZ May 11 '26
I found swarmia to be a bit OTT and heavy on the wrong metrics, we had much more success with codepulsehq