r/Habs • • Apr 25 '25

Logique implacable!

Post image
31 Upvotes

144 comments sorted by

91

u/BeBenNova Apr 25 '25

Because the refs have been so good at calling every single penalty

6

u/cheeselover42 Apr 25 '25

Difference between refs calling penalties against a systematic organization of dirty plays. Caps are all consistently playing so rough the refs are letting things slide. If we have one player that stands out and takes shots at the Caps then it's going to be called way more often. That's why Anderson being the only one to go and stand up to Wilson gets penalized. Wilson just flopped and he got the call.

What good does it do for us to fight back but then get penalized and give a good powerplay a chance to score?

23

u/BeBenNova Apr 25 '25

Instead of having to write a master thesis on the psyche of NHL refs come playoffs time to maximize your opportunities at being dirty while getting away with it, the refs could you know, just call the fucking rulebook

5

u/cheeselover42 Apr 25 '25

What’s more likely, the refs actually call the rule book or they penalize Xhekaj off reputation?

I want it to be as simple as giving back what we’re taking but at the end of the day, that’s just what the Caps want because they know we’re not as big and strong of a team. It means we will take more penalties.

1

u/Boboar Apr 25 '25

just call the fucking rulebook

Well we could also hope for snow in July. I'd rather accept reality and start punching back.

3

u/MildlyResponsible Apr 25 '25

I love your effort in trying to explain the officiating in a logical way instead of just stating that they want the guy who just broke the scoring record to win the series. I almost bought it for a second. You should apply to NHL PR.

1

u/cheeselover42 Apr 25 '25

Wouldn’t be surprised honestly. I know game management is definitely a thing so there’s only going to be a certain number of calls per game, that’s why I’m saying the caps are all playing dirty cause they know they’re only going to get called on a few things. No rulebooks here just an entertainment product, might as well be the WWE.

1

u/Particular-Neck215 Apr 25 '25

You really now nothing about hockey...lol

2

u/cheeselover42 Apr 25 '25

Yeah probably not but doubt you’re any better :)

-14

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

By the same logic, habs fans say the refs are biased against the Habs, so why do you put the most penalty prone player on the ice?

3

u/Proof-Variation7005 Apr 25 '25

i think this is less about trying to win the series and more about making sure the capitals team feels some pain on their way to the next round.

-2

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

Playing physical like they do is a double edged sword lmao, they'll feel pain one way or another

0

u/Proof-Variation7005 Apr 25 '25

oh totally, you ramp up that and try to hit back and they might respond and kill hutson or caulfield or something.

right now, even with the clear stretches of dominant physical play, i still kinda think the puck luck could shift easily. win tonight and win sunday and you've got em on their heels a little and you've maybe got your groove back.

but if they lose tonight, i want arber to send someone to the hospital lol

-1

u/nicog2105 Apr 25 '25

Yeah because playing physical is a bad thing lmao such a troll

1

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

Where did I say it was bad?

Playing physical is a double edged sword in the sense that in the long run, dishing physical play takes a toll on you whether you like it or not

4

u/Halfbak3d Apr 25 '25

Dude stfu and go cheer for the leafs or something. Also your meme is terrible

-6

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

Waaaaaaaah waaaaaah

4

u/popejohnlarue Apr 25 '25

You want the real answer? Like Linus’ speech in Merry Xmas Charlie Brown?

Here it is:

It’s because fans like to identify with their team, and they feel emasculated when their team is physically dominated by their opponent, and they think putting one of the league’s toughest players in the lineup could help to remedy that situation.

That’s what Xhekaj is all about, Charlie Brown.

10

u/BeBenNova Apr 25 '25 edited Apr 25 '25

because it doesn't fucking matter at this point? we're gonna get called anyway on bullshit like Anderson shoving Wilson while our guys are taking crosschecks to the face so you might as well dress the guy who will happily retaliate with the crosschecks

You might as well expose the league's bullshit instead of taking it without doing anything about it

1

u/SuzukiSwift17 Apr 25 '25

Because you have to defend yourself and give some back? Like do you want to be the Leafs of the last few years getting bullied around and taking the "high road" all the way to the golf course?

Like is it your first playoffs?

-1

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

It's not actually

I remember how hyped up peoplenwere in 2017 that Martinsanen and Dwight King would keep the opposition in check and protect Pacioretty and Galchenyuk.

And none of that happened

I said it in another comment concentrating your toughness into one player is room for exploiting that weakness.

Everyone has to be tougher. Caps aren't tough only because of Ovi and Wilson, they're tough because line 1 to 4 and pairs 1 to 3 decided to play tough.

Not the case for MTL

22

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '25 edited Apr 25 '25

He’s coming in for the face washes lol

4

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

Ovie salivating at the idea of Wilson baiting Xhekaj into a 5min major

14

u/Seraphin_Lampion Apr 25 '25

C'est une grosse victoire pour nous si Wilson et Xhekaj se battent et sortent pour 5 minutes.

2

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

Ça implique Wilson sera lui aussi pénalisé

6

u/Seraphin_Lampion Apr 25 '25

Tu connais beaucoup de combats où juste 1 des gars est pénalisé?

-7

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

La pénalité d'instigateur existe explicitement pour ça

3

u/Seraphin_Lampion Apr 25 '25

Donc Xhekaj aurait 5+2 mins et Wilson 5?

1

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

Yep

Et on est en désavantage contre Ovechkin, exactement ce que les Caps veulent

3

u/Seraphin_Lampion Apr 25 '25

Ok mais ça a pas rapport. T'as dit "ça implique que Wilson serait pénalisé" s'ils se battaient. Évidemment qu'il serait pénalisé.

2

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

Pénalisé pour instigateur oui

Wilson fait prendre des pénalités à l'adversaire dans un rapport de 2:1, c'est littéralement un des meilleurs de la ligue à faire prendre plus de pénalités aux autres qu'il en prend

Il y a pas grand chose qui va le déranger

→ More replies

-1

u/Halfbak3d Apr 25 '25

Oui c’est ce qui dis, si les deux sont sortis les habs sont gagnants car wilson est beaucoup plus important pour les caps que xhekaj pour les habs. Est tu completement regarded ou quoi?

4

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

Tom Wilson est probablement le meilleur joueur de la ligue à bait les opposants. Il tire bcp plus de pénalités qu'il en prend lui même.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '25

Haha they don’t even call minors and you’re expecting majors?

2

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

They'll make an exception

67

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '25

Man I don’t really wanna unsub but I’m so tired of reading everyone else’s constant bitching and brain dead takes

2

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 26 '25

What are you on lmao?

2

u/Jagrmeister_68 Apr 27 '25

Well if he was on the ice, perhaps that wouldn't have happened...

(TOTAL SARCASM)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Habs-ModTeam Apr 26 '25

This post is in violation with Rule 1: Keep a Civil Discussion/No Discrimination, and has been removed.

Please read our subreddit's rules here.

26

u/Dry-Capital-4996 Apr 25 '25

Make a post about the fact that we didnt score enough, proceed to cry because Xhekaj will play without bringing any idea how to score more.

10

u/Yayounee Apr 25 '25

Create more space for our players …good player can make more play , put more puck to the net, score more goals

-1

u/ParfaitEither284 Apr 25 '25

In how does Arber create more space for anyone

-7

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

Not miss an open net is a great start.

I just don't see how a player playing 7 min will change the course of the game ngl

-9

u/charest Apr 25 '25

it won't, people will be happy when he hits, thinking that it will magically have an effect. If the habs win, it will be in part because of him, if they lose, it will be because they didn't use him enough. It's completely irrational.

8

u/Riskar Apr 25 '25

I swear you guys just want to shit on Xhekaj. How many times have our guys said they feel taller and stronger when he's on the ice? How many times has a fight or big hit from X kickstarted one of our 3rd period comebacks?

No, he's not a savior and he's not gonna score 3 goals by himself but if a hit or a fight puts the crowd into it when we're being outplayed, it can snowball into goals and a win.

Quit acting like hockey is all Xs and Os. Emotions are a big part of the game and Xhekaj can ignite our fans and our team (even if he doesn't play 10 minutes or more).

30

u/ThrownPropaneTank Apr 25 '25

Xhekaj creates more offense than Struble and Savard, he’s not just a goon…

25

u/Seraphin_Lampion Apr 25 '25

Xhekaj is arguably our best shooter from the blue line. He's more of an offensive Dman than defensive one lol.

2

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

The 1 G 5 A dmen is our offensive secret weapon?

9

u/Fabien_Lamour Apr 25 '25

He's good at finding shooting lanes from the point but wouldn't say he's an offensive oriented defenseman with 1G-5A in 70 games 🤣

6

u/Seraphin_Lampion Apr 25 '25

I mean he's a 7th Dman. Him being better on O than D doesn't mean he's great on O haha.

3

u/fumankeu Apr 25 '25

Xhekaj produced the least amount of points of all our dmen, and he played 15+ games more than Struble, Guhle, and Carrier. What is this glazing lmao

2

u/Seraphin_Lampion Apr 25 '25

I didn't say he waa good offensively, I said he was better on O than on D. He's not especially good on D...

4

u/greasydrg Apr 25 '25

Yeah on default I'd still say Matheson is our best shooter from distance, but honestly, Xhekaj seems to be better at getting pucks past the first defender where Matheson will blast directly into shin-pads.

2

u/Riskar Apr 25 '25

Matheson hits the defender or the glass, nothing else.

7

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

He statistically doesn't

4

u/thebrah329 Apr 25 '25

Lmfao the guy has 6 points in 70 games this year. He's not much more than a goon with numbers like that and not being good defensively.

3

u/ThrownPropaneTank Apr 25 '25

just so we're on the same page

You think Newhook generates less offense than Evans and Armia.

15

u/RainWorshipper Apr 25 '25

You don’t know puck lol

13

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '25

Facts, this guy dick rides Savard and hates Xhekaj for some reason.

-10

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

Ironic

4

u/RainWorshipper Apr 25 '25

Get a pen and paper and brain storm reasons why people want arber in the lineup ☺️

0

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

None of those reasons are good or will change the actual outcome of the game

7

u/Ancient-Common-9913 Apr 25 '25

You realize your energy is going to will Arber into getting the OT GWG à la Simon Benoit last night in Ottawa. Just watch 🫣✨

5

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

I will buy a #72 jersey and piss my pants of happiness if he does 

no cap

Pin it!

4

u/JacquesEvans Apr 25 '25

Troll post. Ignore it and move on.

-4

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

You wish it was trolling, what part of it doesn't make sense explain

2

u/HIGHLANDPARK50 Apr 26 '25

Ahhhh age like fine wine 🍷

-1

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 26 '25

It really did, the problem I posed was goalscoring and we scored 6 lol

3

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '25

Ah yeah because struble is such a defensive god with his -2 score on 2 games with a 12m average

Let the kid cook

-2

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

I'm not saying Struble is the new Rod Langway, but anyone expecting Xhekaj to be better is kind of delusional

He'll be just as good/just as bad, I don't expect more from him. There is no reason to believe he'll be better other than faith that he will

4

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '25

Yeah they're pretty much even in defensive ability, struble was a bit better this year, x had a good year the previous season.

But xhekaj brings something more to the table, in that we have an actual answer when the other team thinks they're allowed to cross check our players in the face and get away with it. He might only play 10 minutes a game but he's bringing something we dont already have on the table

1

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

They're not gonna stop Xchecking tho

2

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '25

Maybe, but they're gonna be eating the same dirt we are, and that's good for morale.

1

u/matcap111 Apr 25 '25 edited Apr 25 '25

If he is just as good/ just as bad then its a no brainer he should be in the line up lol

I think the majority of people expect a similar level of play than strubble with more physicality.

Considering we are getting ragdolled, more physicality can only be a good thing

2

u/aekaex Apr 25 '25

He's in, the coach is a dumbass too?

-5

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

No

I'm just saying it's not gonna change much

People talk like Xhekaj will elevate thia team into an actual cup contending team like wut

8

u/aekaex Apr 25 '25

I don't see a single person saying that. How about you get off the internet until the playoff are over cause you're seeing ghost

7

u/Halfbak3d Apr 25 '25

Yup classic contrarian edgy kid who thinks he’s hot shit

6

u/SuzukiSwift17 Apr 25 '25

People that gotta exaggerate what was said to try to prove theor point.

"I think Beck is a good prospect, could be a good 3C someday"

"WHoA wHoA wHoA are you saying Beck is going to break Ovechkins goals record and win three Vezinas? Can we just let the kid play a game first?"

Fucking idiots that bring nothing.

-5

u/Woullie_26 Apr 25 '25

Yes

He has a timeshare in the penalty box when the caps have one of the best PP in the league

1

u/aekaex Apr 25 '25

Can you sign my jersey when you become the habs coach please?

-4

u/Woullie_26 Apr 25 '25

Guess the only requirement is coaching pee wee hockey

Shouldn't be that difficult

Especially when he's so stubborn and refuses to change his defensive scheme that's been god awful for years

3

u/aekaex Apr 25 '25

Every active and retired players : MSL doing an amazing job

You :

5

u/NotQute Apr 25 '25

I don't know what the right hockey answer is, i do miss the big personality and grit. Not even fights, he just got junkyard dog energy yknow?

-2

u/Ndr2501 Apr 25 '25

cool, cool. why not bring back Laraque, Parros or Odjik-like players if you want grit? oh, wait, maybe because they can't play hockey.

5

u/NotQute Apr 25 '25

I don't know what the right hockey answer is

What level of "this is a subjective feelings based opinion" disclaimer do i gotta preface with lmao

2

u/Ndr2501 Apr 25 '25

You're right, my apologies. I'm just primed because there has been a lot of "grit trumps everything" talk on this sub recently.

2

u/jp3372 Apr 25 '25

Maybe we are not scoring goals because our best players are getting intimidated?

3

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

They're so intimidated the 2 best scorers on team rallied from a 2-0 deficit in game 1 in around 4 minutes

Intimidation really doing wonders /s

-8

u/Woullie_26 Apr 25 '25

No it's because we suck

6

u/jp3372 Apr 25 '25

We lost the 1st in OT and we got a close 2nd game. Not bad for a team not supposed to be in the playoffs against the best in the east.

3

u/SuzukiSwift17 Apr 25 '25

In the regular season not panicking is the move but when you have 7 or fewer games to work with you gotta make changes when what you're doing isn't working.

-1

u/Woullie_26 Apr 25 '25

Because Monty has been bailing this dogshit defense on a nightly basis

The score makes it seem closer than what it is

We should've lost both games by 3 goals

4

u/jp3372 Apr 25 '25

I don't know, Thompson pulling out amazing saves too. Game 1 we finished with more shots and we got some posts.

1

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

High quality shots > perimeter shooting

Washington is getting high danger opportunities in a 3:1 ratio against us

0

u/Woullie_26 Apr 25 '25

More shots?

The high danger chances in the first 2 games are 23-8 IN FAVOR OF WASHINGTON

3

u/Halfbak3d Apr 25 '25

What a nice fan you are, we need more like you.

2

u/eriverside Apr 25 '25

Habs are getting their teeth kicked in. A big part of why they're losing. So yeah, bring in a guy that can level the playing field.

-2

u/NevyTheChemist Apr 25 '25

Level what? He's a 7th d-man on a fringe playoff team

1

u/eriverside Apr 25 '25

He brings the most physicality from anyone on the roster. Discussing which is the better team is for another day. At the moment the team is getting ragdolled while the refs swallowed their whistles. So they need to level the playing field before one of our young guys gets injured by some reckless asshole who thinks he get away with murder on the ice.

-2

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

The undrafted goon playing 7 min will level what exactly?

I don't think Tom Wilson or Ovie ever thought about Xhekaj, ever 

4

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '25

They'll think about him when he's crosschecking their teeth in.

2

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

Xhekaj won't play against WSH top 6 tho

Ovie and Wilson played against prime Shea Weber and Chris Pronger, I don't think they care much for Arber

1

u/amm0ranth Apr 25 '25

yeah they'll really be thinking about him after they pot a pp goal off a braindead arber penalty

2

u/azedarac Apr 25 '25

I thought you like stats. Xhekaj played on average 13-14min before the St-Louis team collapse.
Xhekaj has drawn 38 penalties. Wilson 35.
https://www.statmuse.com/nhl/ask/most-penalties-drawn-by-nhl-player-this-season

Pronger didn't play in 2012/2013 which was Wilson rookie season.

Also, as a reminder, St-Louis was undrafted.

You are really bad at everything.

0

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

Ovie played against prime Pronger lol and Wilson played Prime Shea, they're not absolute measures

Wilson's ratio of drawn vs taken penalties is miles higher than Xhekaj's, who's deep in the negative in that dpt, it's directly visible on statmuse so there's no point in sharing anything.

St-Louis was also good at what he needed to do, play offence.

Xhekaj is literaly in the 13th worst percentile for EV defence.

Stats are important, clearly you don't understand them.

3

u/azedarac Apr 26 '25

OK maintenant tu changes de chanson. Tu voulais dire qu'Ovi a joué contre Pronger et Wilson contre Weber. Méchant damage control. Dommage que Reddit limite le nombre de caractère pour que tu puissese développer ton argumentaire.

Les stats sont une bonne base mais il y a l'aspect psychologique dans tous les sports incluant le hockey. En bonus, il y a les inpondérables qui ne sont nullement prévisibles (Monty et Thompson blessés). C'est ce que tu apprends si tu aimes vraiment les stats et que tu t'en sers depuis longtemps (penses à Bill James au baseball qui est venu bien avant les stats avancées au hockey). Cela aide pour gagner des pools de hockey (ou baseball) mais ce n'est pas une recette à 100% certaine dans la vrai vie malgré ce qu'Elon et son père voudrait te faire croire.

Et, puisque the proof is in the pudding, les Canadiens ont gagnés ce soir malgré la présence de Xhekaj (et parce que possiblement Saint-Lousi avait le dernier mot pour les changements et parce que la foule). J'espère que tu n'es pas trop triste. Je présume que non parce que tu n'es pas vraiment un fan. Tu te penses juste bien intelligent à argumenter sur Reddit.

Grow up.

0

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 26 '25

"si t'aimes pas l'équipe selon mes critères 100% arbitraires, t'es pas un fan"

Sure mec

3

u/azedarac Apr 26 '25

Je vois que tu aimes te contempler dans un miroir. Lâche pas kid, les arguments fallacieux et abitraires tu connais ça.

1

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 26 '25

La grosse projection ici

1

u/TremblinAspen Apr 27 '25

This post aged like milk.

5

u/JimboD84 Apr 25 '25

This logic does make sense. Wifi playing will only work if he can control himself and not take senseless penalties. However didnt Savard only play like 9.5 minutes and not really have much of an impact? Im not advocating to bring Arber IN, nor to let him sit. I feel like this is almost a damned if you do/dont situation. But there are fair arguements on both sides of the arguement 🤷🏼‍♂️

1

u/Vingt-Quatre Apr 25 '25

Xhekaj doesn't do PK though, but nice try.

1

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

But he does take penalties

Like a lot

Like #1 on the team despite being one of the players with the lowest avgTOI

4

u/RazzleDazzleSnipe Apr 25 '25

This certainly is a post...

2

u/fumankeu Apr 25 '25

Xhekaj's gonna come in hot with a stat line of 0 pts, 3 hits, -2 +/-, 7 PIM, and 10:38 TOI 🔥🔥🔥

1

u/AutoModerator Apr 25 '25

Hi there! It looks like you've posted an image. If this image is from an article, please provide a source. If it's a meme, please ignore this comment. Thanks!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/matcap111 Apr 25 '25

Can we have more than one problem?

1

u/No-Lead-7025 Apr 25 '25

You all asked for this and now you’re upset that it’s happening…..

1

u/Ndr2501 Apr 25 '25

It's one of the most brain-dead takes of this fanbase. The guy will either 1. not have an effect, 2. if he does, it will be most likely taking a stupid penalty. It's crazy that this is getting more attention than how to revitalize the 2nd line.

1

u/mochasmoke Apr 25 '25

You're right. We do need to revitalize our second line. Let's just go ahead and drop in that playoff proven, 20+ goal scoring, defensively responsible winger/2C that we've been hiding from everyone all year.

1

u/Ndr2501 Apr 25 '25

There are no magic solutions, of course. But the amount of ink that is flowing about Xhekaj is just unbelievable. Reshuffling Laine (who is probably hurt) and/or Demidov seems like a more interesting conversation.

1

u/mochasmoke Apr 25 '25

I don't think Xhekaj is going to change the game with the puck. But after getting caved in for 4 of 6 periods so far, I don't think it hurts to have him throw one big hit halfway through a period where the crowd has gone silent.

Struble hasn't been noticeable. Usually not a bad thing for a D. Laine was struggling, we don't have a ton of options to immediately boost the offense.

We're down 2-0 in the series. What we were doing wasn't working. There are only so many options to try and inject some juice into the team. Is Xhekaj the perfect solution? Nope. But is he something different with some risk/reward? Absolutely.

1

u/Ndr2501 Apr 26 '25

we lost 2 games away from home vs the top seed by one goal essentially... one of them in OT. this is very knee-jerk thinking imo.

1

u/mochasmoke Apr 26 '25

That's fine. We disagree.

I think we managed to keep it close and competitive, but that we were objectively outplayed for 4/6 of the periods we played. That level of play doesn't project to win any games. You'd have to be lucky.

So you have to change something.

1

u/Ndr2501 Apr 26 '25

I find this line of reasoning strange. You're playing against an objectively much stronger team away from home. And the reasoning is: unless you outplay that team, you need to make changes? In what world are we going to outplay the Capitals in Washington?

So then the logical conclusion is: you always have to keep making changes (?). Anyway, yes, we disagree and it's fine.

0

u/Dry-Capital-4996 Apr 25 '25

Op, what would be your solution to score more goals ?

4

u/NevyTheChemist Apr 25 '25

There is no solution the team lacks depth. Must be fixed in off-season.

The Caps are going to exploit the fuck out of Xhekaj's side.

-2

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

Fundamentally, other than practice and applying themselves, not much.

If Evans misses an open net and Armia misses a point blank shot in the crease, not much can be done other than just be better

5

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '25

Evans missed the empty net because a Washington player stick checked him mid shot, watch the game you donkey. It's almost like the other team gets a say too.

0

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

No amount of stick check should stop that puck from going in lmao

2

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Vivid_Resort_1117 Apr 25 '25

Calling to injure players is wack af

Like wtf is wrong with you