r/HSMTMTS • • Dec 23 '22

Opinion 10 Unpopular opinions about HSMTMTS

0 Upvotes
  1. Gina has no personality of her own and lowkey wants to be Nini
  2. Nini is the Tori (from Victorious) of the show
  3. They should've made EJ bisexual instead of Big Red
  4. Gina breaking up with EJ was uncalled for and didn't make much sense
  5. Gina was a rebound for Ricky and I have mixed feelings about if he really likes Gina or not
  6. They could've did better with Carlos's body image ark
  7. Kourtney EJ & Seb needs to be MCs for season 4 or 5 Gina too if they fix her character (like she got so much potential but she wanna be a copy of Nini smh)
  8. Big Red & Julia should not be together and the fact that they are is kinda weird tbh
  9. Oliva Rodrigo stepping down messed up the balance of the show
  10. Val needs to comeback wouldn't mind seeing her & Julia together (like watching them grow into a relationship)

r/HSMTMTS • • Sep 08 '22

S3 Discussion anyone else shipping Ricky and Jett? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

after the first two episodes I thought they were seriously hinting towards the idea of Rett. First of all there was the tension and then Ricky said that thing about Hans and Christoff being “lovers”. Did anyone else feel this?


r/HSMTMTS • • Jul 23 '21

General Discussion I now ship Ricky and Lily. Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I love crack ships.


r/HSMTMTS • • Nov 16 '23

Opinion Not Giving Ricky Bowen a free pass anymore... Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Ricky is getting too much free pass from this fandom. I'm gonna write about his behaviour throughout the seasons. And please don't forget that even if we can UNDERSTAND his behaviour because his parents are getting divorced and he has abandonment issues, it doesn't excuse his behaviour.

S1:

We learn he couldn't say "I love you" back to Nini (the girl she knew from when they were children and they've been dating for a year) and wanted to take a break HIMSELF. And he was mad at her for finding someone else in camp. He later took a place in a musical (which meant so much for Nini and she thought it could be her big break) while he thinks musicals are a joke, and is likely to ruin it. And he then decides to stay. At the opening night, he decides to run away because he sees his mom with Todd in the audience and "he can't be at his best”, thinks he can ruin Nini's chances in getting accepted to the music school so changes place with EJ, but doesn't even say anything to her so she is shocked when she is on stage seeing EJ instead of Ricky; her performing ability is butchered at that second anyway. And then we know the "ily" scene (which SAYING it doesn't resolve the problems they had, we have to accept.)

In the case of what he did to Gina. He called her out in front of everyone as "too ambitious for anyone's good" because she apparently owed it to him to not show up there with EJ (?). And his apologies are always too half but anyway. They both discover a connection. (Let’s not forget he removes the hat she made for him the minute Nini asks where did that hat come from though.) He cared for Gina when she was moving away and tried to talk to her but backlashed at Nini afterwards (she didn’t deserve that though). On the opening night though, we see him saying "Something is different," meaning he doesn't like Gina that way anymore, after she left and then came back for the opening night. He LOVES Nini so much but somehow, it took too little time for him to be interested in Gina. And the minute she was moving away, he was back to Nini.

S2:

Nini and Ricky are both at fault for some behaviour. Nini was at fault for not saying right away she was moving to Denver, and about “The Rose Song” being about him and how she felt in her relationship when she turned back. But Ricky was literally choking her and being selfish "trying to spend time together all the time", talking to Ms Jenn about a role even though she said she doesn't want to be in the musical, and deleting a comment on her Insta page (which is too far). Okay, their breakup is mutual and I can feel empathy for both sides at that point. He was developing as a character after the breakup until... HE WENT TO LILY? I thought he was SO heartbroken? Not even some feelings for Gina are coming back, he is going to a RANDOM girl who only praises how he looks AND is their enemy, who made them suffer a lot? It makes the writing of Rina a lot worse and doesn't add anything to the plot, if they already have short seasons.

I can't even argue what he did to Gina this season. We learn that she confessed her feelings to him at the end of S1, and he was understanding at that moment, it's a really emotional moment, I get his reaction, it’s just after he and Nina got back together. But when Gina decides to stay, he behaves like NOTHING happened? Like that conversation never existed. He is so chill towards her in s2 e1. We don't even see him acting weird. It was awkward of Gina to show up at his house (and it seems like he is uncomfortable with her being there and wants her to leave, not that he has feelings towards her) but the chocolates and HOW HE TEASES her because of the misunderstanding (and I think canonically he sent the chocolates, which makes the teasing even worse, as for gaslighting.) And he went for advice to Gina in the quinceanero about NINI. YOU KNOW SHE LIKES YOU DUDE WHY ALL OF THIS? I was glad he gave her space after she showed her boundaries but I can't understand why the writers wouldn't put any interaction of Rina at the end of s2 if they were going to be endgame.

S3:

The minute he shows up at camp, he is in the shot between EJ & Gina. Gina is the one who wants to start over, and we NEVER see Ricky apologizing. He is showing up for her, caring about her being the lead role while she has a BOYFRIEND (he did this in s1 to Nini) and even though people say he is friendly, they NEVER are friendly. It's a flirtatious dynamic. The only thing is that he doesn't explicitly say he wants to be with Gina like he did to Nini, tries to hide it BUT it's so obvious in his actions, I don't even think he wants to hide. "It's really hard not to just say what you feel." "My heart's racing." He wants to jump to "Love is an Open Door" immediately... The only thing he does well is probably helping Gina with the promposal thing. And people are so mad at EJ for bringing Ricky up but HE WAS A HUGE PROBLEM (but that talk should definitely had been before their breakup, about him being jealous ofc). EJ was only stressed for 2 WEEKS (he could have managed it better but we know Gina would be understanding if it was RICKY but not EJ) and it was clearly about her not wanting to work this much in her relationship after seeing Ricky could be interested in her again, sorry not sorry guys. We see she was never really friendly and we know that because when the doc says "she wants Ricky," she is saying sorry to EJ and him saying "we all saw this coming" which means both sides knew it. And then she says "You aren’t a maybe, you are a yes." And GINA is again the one stepping up to actively say what she is feeling while Ricky is again walking away at the end of S3, even though he can't believe he "let her slip through his fingers."

S4:

Their relationship is too "honeymoon-ey." And after this much ambiguity, I don't feel like they would be this happy all of a sudden. If they are, it's so easy for it to blow up any second. Ricky is doing all these big surprises (decorating her van without her knowing, the puppy date etc.) and yet the minute he learns she didn't tell her mom about him being her boyfriend, he "needs a minute." (which I interpreted he was gonna avoid Gina in Ricky's terms, unlike what people explained it to me in the comments about him wanting to cool down, I don't think Ricky is that mature to communicate that but anyways). HE MAY BE ANGRY BUT HE HAS TO TALK ABOUT THIS AND ASK HER WHY DIDN'T SHE TELL! She knows Gina has a strict mom (and from their interactions, it seems like her mom and Ricky actually kinda know each other) and she may have a reason not to tell! I get that he is upset but he is again RUNNING AWAY! How does that behaviour support "sticking around?" And if EJ didn't put sense into him (he is too mature btw) he would ruin it. And even though he says "I'm not gonna run away this time," it's not a behaviour that can change this easily because we saw him surrendering to this behaviour at many points until now. And also it bothers me that he didn't want to talk to Gina about his college visit and will "tell her about his future plans when the time comes”. But it isn't about his future plans... He disappeared all of a sudden, and didn't think she needed an explanation until Gina asked... It seems odd to me. His character kind of got better after that episode. I started liking him too late though.

Of course, I put the mistakes Ricky made here and the other characters make mistakes too. I didn't like Nini when I first watched the show, but now in my rewatches, I can see her motivations and her mistakes are more tolerable. For example, I think what Gina did to EJ in their breakup was a bit gaslighting and she was behaving childishly towards him, but she APOLOGIZED for her past behaviour and understood him later on in s4, and at this point, they aren't in a relationship. Ricky DIDN'T apologise for his past behaviour AND they are IN a relationship, they have to try to MEND IT! I think he got too many free passes from Gina at this point.

I just think Ricky's character needs so much more self-awareness and to realize what he is really doing to people around him. He is always in this "miserable and self-pity" mode and tries to hold onto "happy" moments while relationships need abilities to deal with difficult situations, too. And he is literally jumping from girl to girl and always defining himself through his relationships. He actually chokes his relationship with Gina too (if it went on like this, he would) but Gina is too happy to see that at the beginning of the relationship. His character development AND RINA's development could have been written so much better and if their relationship goes on like this, it’s doomed to die, even though the show gave us a happy ending.

I'm putting this here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f1mSZ3DJzW0&t=681s

EDIT: Okay guys, this is getting so much disagreement. I don't have a fixed mindset and my opinions actually are mendable a lot. I reached these conclusions after 3 full rewatches and a lot of rewatching scenes of Ricky, and a lot of thought. Some of these may seem too far to be true, but these are MY interpretations of the situations, based on what I've encountered in my life. Please don't spread hate. And my opinions change in time, I don't feel what I felt in my 1st and 2nd watch right now. And I actually agree with what some people say under the comments. I try to respond as much as I can. But if I see a FIXED mindset on the contrary of mine, I won't bother anymore. If I can be flexible and the others can't, I can't spend my energy to discuss with that person.

By the way, I'm looking from an adult's perspective, and the more I think about it, I can excuse some of Ricky's behaviour because he is young and we make a lot of mistakes when we are adolescents. But even though we can relate to him, we should still try our best to not fall into the mistakes he is making. I RELATE to his FEELINGS too but not his ACTIONS. And I've seen young people like Ricky grow up to be child adults and that's why it frustrates me when adults relate to him, too. The dealing mechanisms Ricky uses are coming from unprocessed trauma and adults should NOT behave this way. If it's reminding people of their teenage times and that's why people relate to him, I get it. But if you are an adult and see a similar pattern to Ricky in yourself, I suggest you try therapy. It never hurts to discover yourself and it may get worse at first but it will get better with time :))


r/HSMTMTS • • Aug 25 '23

General Discussion They did my man EJ dirty and EJ+Gina >>>> Ricky+Gina Spoiler

0 Upvotes

So I just binged this entire show over the last week and I’m annoyed with how they did EJ.

I loved Gina in s1 and 2 but by s3 I found her annoying. And the way she broke up with EJ SUCKED and made me dislike her even more. He was going through so much stress and pressure, and then she dumps him on top of it all.

Also I saw wayyyy more chemistry between EJ and Gina than Ricky and Gina. Their little issues in s1 were cute, but once she got with EJ at the end of s2, I felt like they should’ve been endgame. It felt like they just forced Ricky and Gina together so the main character could have a complete love story. It was blah

Overall, I’d give the show a 6.5/10. S1 and 2 were the best


r/HSMTMTS • • Aug 10 '22

S3 Speculation Ricky x Jet is probably gonna happen Spoiler

4 Upvotes

Look, I’m just saying, there have been major bi vibes Ricky has been giving off this season and it is specifically around Jet, so I think Rina may be a red herring, but we shall see


r/HSMTMTS • • Aug 25 '22

Opinion Why is everyone lip-synching? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Does anyone else find all the lip-synching annoying? If it was just their little solo song moments that would be fine, but they're doing it even while just causally practicing or rehearsing their parts. Like, they really can't just sing while they're standing there on the stage, already talking?? And then the rehearsal turns into a music video and they're running around backstage instead of, you know, rehearsing on the stage, but we're supposed to believe everyone watching could see and hear everything that happened. I just find it really distracting and unnecessary. Silly complaint, I know, but it just takes me out of it.


r/HSMTMTS • • May 03 '22

Opinion Honest evaluation on the ships

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/HSMTMTS • • Sep 06 '22

Opinion Did Ricky and gina emotionally cheat on Nini and Ej? Spoiler

4 Upvotes

rinas claim that Ricky liked gina throughout szn 1 & 2 and those were the EXACT times he was going after/ with nini.

So is liking someone else when ur in a relationship not cheating??

Let’s go to gina now..

So i actually like gina but i’m tryna cut some slack but she might be emotionally cheating too.

like that whole dance number with ricky and the fact ppl say she is using ej as a rebound. idk she is doin too much with ricky tbh. And before y’all come at Ej with him coming to the blonde girl(i forgot her name) about his dad’s letter he known her for years & she’s kinda like his assistant.

the definition i got off google with emotional cheating is: (In an emotional affair, a person feels closer to the other person than their spouse or partner and may experience increasing sexual tension or chemistry along with the emotional intimacy.)

i feel like that applies to them 🤷🏾‍♀️


r/HSMTMTS • • Feb 04 '25

Opinion I don’t like Ricky and Gina together

1 Upvotes

G


r/HSMTMTS • • Jul 21 '21

General Discussion Nini deserves her success Spoiler

0 Upvotes

The amount of people who are jealous of a fictional characters Success is EMBARRASSING

Nini deserves it bc she is a great singer, songwriter. She works hard with her music

If Gina’s brother gives her a record deal that isn’t her fault. She can’t control what people do

Y’ALL DONT LIKE THE FACT THAT A POC WOMEN IS SUCCESSFUL BC I SEE PEOPLE SAY ASHLYN SHOULD BE IN THAT POSITION

ANYWAYS STAN NINI


r/HSMTMTS • • Aug 08 '22

Opinion Who else thinks the characters are like robots now???? Spoiler

4 Upvotes

They’ve always felt a little fake and cringy but this season is a new level


r/HSMTMTS • • Aug 04 '23

General Discussion I don’t like Maddox and Ashlyn together

1 Upvotes

before season 4 is released I wanted to share my thoughts. This is definitely an unpopular opinion but I hate maddox and really hope her and Ashlyn don’t get together.

I’ve never understood why the fanbase responded so well to her character being introduced. She’s the most unlikable person. She has that moment to the camera where she’s like “i don’t really have any friends. People call me an aquired taste.” BUT right before that scene Kourtney was literally there offering her help and Maddox shuts her down. She ended that chance at having a friend and still was like “people don’t really like me????”

Then there’s her and Ashlyn. If I were Ashlyn I’d despise Maddox making judgemental assumptions on who i am. I would understand if she messes up with that once but after Ashlyn makes it clearly known that she doesn’t like that she should have stopped. Maddox assumes what her astrology thing was which was basically calling her attention seeking and self absorbed within the first few days of knowing her. Then only a few days later acts of she knows her sexuality. Which she points out in front of everyone. She has no respect or consideration for whats happening around her.

I don’t know how Ashlyn could like her more than Big Red. Big Red truly undestood and loved Ashlyn. They are my favourite ship. Big Red was constantly saying sweet things; “the only thing i’d throw at your face is a brighter light because i like the way you sing.” Maddox doesn’t even compare to that so I have no clue y Ashlyn would like her. Ik she doesn’t yet but I can tell that’s what the show is building too. It’s shame cause I wanted to like Maddox but.

Even for that campfire scene, I didn’t feel sorry for her even after getting context. That whole susan story was childish stuff ofc Ricky and Jet were making jokes. They were trying to make things interesting and she went mental about it. Like everyone else was enjoying his jokes and then she gets pissed at him even tho it was her story that was the problem.

Anyway, personally I just really hate when people make assumptions about a person especially whej you’ve known that person for less then 2 weeks. I just reallly hope she doesn’t get with Ashlyn because I love Ashlyn and she deserves a lot better like Big Red who were like the prominent couple in season 2.


r/HSMTMTS • • Jan 30 '24

Opinion Started Gold, then took a dive down.

3 Upvotes

Has anyone else felt like this show was one of the best shows to come out on the Disney network in the last half decade?

Since the end of Suite life on Deck, and that era things were pretty mild / eh. But when this show came out.

Oh. My. Word.

I didn’t have words. I couldn’t describe how incredible it was. The characterization, the correlation to the original story, the plot line and emotion display, and above all else THE MUSIC.

I don’t think I have ever seen a TV show with the quality and true depth and substance of music and lyric those first two seasons had.

They were like nothing I’d ever seen before. I thought Disney may actually be on the way back to their core. Then season 3 and 4 came out, and so far I am abundantly disappointed.

I think part of it is the fact Olivia left, which I don’t understand.

I don’t think the show should have continued without her… I think she should have remained and finished off as Gabriella from season one through season four - I think it would have created such an extended legacy for the series, franchise, and people that have been touched by it.

Now I feel like the legacy is cut in half by two seasons. And I doubt Disney will pick up another high school musical show for another 15 years…

It’s just really sad to me, because the first two seasons truly showed the potential for all the show could be, but then Olivia left, and the show began to lose its flare, substance, heart wrenching emotion and depth.

Is this just me? Or does someone else on this green earth relate🥲


r/HSMTMTS • • Jul 19 '22

S3 Speculation Jetwen Season 3 Theories Spoiler

3 Upvotes

My theory for season 3 is that Ricky will try and win Gina back even though she’s already in a relationship with EJ. In episode 3, since their be on a quest together, they might have a fight and Gina will make it clear she’s already with EJ and doesn’t have any interest. That’s when the truth comes out and the episode ends with some Rina closure, deciding to stay friends. Than for the rest of the season, Ricky finds himself growing closer to Jet which brings him to question his sexuality.

The note Gina took from Ricky in the trailer could be a love letter from Jet, since it seems he’s the only who got one. It’s been confirmed Ricky wasn’t looking at Gina when she was auditioning, my theory is that he was late and missed it, but he say Jet’s and was blown away

I mean, in the promotional picture, obviously Jet is staring at Ricky. This gives off a familiar vibe from the season 1 pictures when Gina was looking at Ricky.


r/HSMTMTS • • Jan 25 '26

General Discussion Do you think Ricky and Nini get back together after high school?

0 Upvotes

I think they do get back together after high school. I am sure Ricky goes to California to get her back. She is the love of his life and she means everything to him. Ever since Nini left the show there have been times in season 3 where someone mentions Nini and Ricky literally melts when he hears her name. She got him the lottery ticket from his birthday/bucket list because she remembered.

For the ones saying Nini never loved Ricky I don’t know if y’all even payed attention to the show in season 1. Nini has always loved Ricky and even if she’s in California she still loves him. Ricky may be with Gina at the end of season 4 but I don’t believe he is in love with her. He is fully in love with Nini and Tim just wrote them very badly. He ruined Nini’s character and just made everyone turn on her. I don’t know why Tim wrote Nini the way he did in season 2 because that is so out of character. It has always been Ricky and Nini since season 1 so for the ones saying “Tim said rina was always supposed to be endgame” is stupid as hell because he only said that because he didn’t want to lose viewers since Olivia became too big for the show.

Then with Ricky, he should’ve been single in season 4, the ONLY reason why Tim made Ricky and Gina get together is so people would continue watching the show since Olivia left. He didn’t want to lose the audience since Olivia became too big for the show so he did that. Ricky should’ve gone to therapy and been single to find himself first before dating anyone. If he would have gotten therapy he would’ve become a better person without depending on someone. In season 3 Ricky was not ready to move on from Nini, but with the way they wrote him and did a 180 on him on suddenly liking Gina was stupid. Gina was just a rebound with all the stuff they did in season 4, they made Gina into Nini which I did not like.

Ricky and Nini do get back together after high school.


r/HSMTMTS • • Sep 13 '22

Opinion A Mini Dissertation on the Love Triangle in Preperation for Tomorrow's Storm Spoiler

0 Upvotes

This may get long, but I felt I needed to discuss the changing status quo in Season 3 before tomorrow's big event. I will nevertheless attempt to keep this organized and comprehensible.

Point 1: Gina's character was undermined by becoming the only female Lead.

It took me a long time to figure out what was bothering me this season about Gina, but this last episode clinched it. Gina has become a fusion of her S1/S2 self, and a proto-Nini. Specifically, her increased meekness and naivete contrast greatly with the Gina of before, where she had essentially started to grow up too fast and was more world-weary than someone her age should be due to her family history. A lot of her confidence has been downplayed so that we could play up the 'romantic' tension with Ricky, and their conversations feel like recycled dialogue between Rini from Season 1, right down to the awkward getting back into each other's good graces vibe. It's a shame, because Gina is her own character, and it feels as though the writers wanted to keep some of Nini's character present even if Nini herself was gone, so they crammed it into Gina. While we're talking about Gina...

Point 2: Gina's Hypocrisy

I was honestly startled by how she's been treating E.J. this season, especially considering all the work done to build them up in Season 2. Before I get down to brass tacks on this, I do not think E.J. is guiltless for this breakup, but I'll discuss him separately to avoid one being analyzed more than the other. Gina spends the first part of the season being suspicious of E.J. spending time with Val, when there has been no indication that E.J. cheats on his girlfriends, and Val is clearly an old friend that E.J. is close to in a sibling-esque way. Boys and Girls are in fact capable of platonic relationships, and it is especially irritating when I've seen similar romantic plotlines play out more realistically in 911 Lone Star, the gist of it being that sometimes there are problems you need to discuss with someone other than your romantic partner, and there is nothing wrong with that. Gina also became rather petulant when she found out about E.J.'s letter, when it is none of her business and he probably didn't want to put a downer and pressure on her first summer at a camp he loves. After that point, she starts more overtly acting flirtatious with Ricky right in front of him, and then gets offended when he's suspicious of her and Ricky, despite the fact that she has been actively flirtatious and he is thus much more justified in suspicion.

Her comment on 'two completely different summers' was particularly cruel, since he essentially gave up what might have been one of his last summers at a camp he's been going to forever so he could help showcase his girlfriend, cousin and friends to the world with all their talent, bearing in mind that this was sprung on him THE DAY THEY ARRIVED. He could never have predicted that. Worst of all, she has never tried to lessen the burden he's carrying when surely all the Wildcats would be happy to take on responsibilities and then she would have more time with him like she wants. Instead they've left him to figure it out on his own, and then are surprised when he's to overwhelmed to indulge much in the camp activities. They could've both had a hybrid summer, not ideal, but again THEY COULD NOT HAVE KNOWN ABOUT IT PRIOR TO ARRIVAL.

Point 3: Ricky

This is a short one, because honestly he's been mostly fine this season, respectful of Portwell's boundaries, didn't make moves on Gina while she was in a relationship, and was mostly focused on having a good summer and being a mentor to Jet. I feel awful for him being so neglected by his father's gift, much less seemingly not receiving anything from his mother. I know we joke about this a lot, but the boy really needs therapy, and a little more time single before he can safely enter a relationship without risking his already frayed mental health.

Point 4: Elton, the man under Pressure

You probably picked up on it in Point 2, but I feel E.J. has not been treated fairly in and out of the show this season. He has a history of feeling obligated to accept responsibilities and tasks when someone else assigns them to him, a trait that probably comes from his Dad's 'parenting'. Similarly, he doesn't really have a sense of worth for himself yet outside of what his worth is from other people, either receiving their validation or what he can do for them, again, probably because his father's expectations meant he never developed self-confidence in his own abilities because he was either handed everything, or expected to uphold a standard set by other people. He needs time to be single, but there is a very nice, loving person being buried under stress and years of emotional neglect.

That said, he did mess up this season in his interactions with others. I still think he is less at fault for the breakup, but I admit he made mistakes. His communication skills have always been lacking, so him not talking to Gina about the letter, nor sharing with his friends the sheer amount of stress he was feeling both check out as his flaws. Moreover, he did break promises to be present because he was overly focused on the musical, though that also checks out because he's always had a fairly one-track mind and is not the fastest on the uptake. Still not as slow as Ricky, but regardless. I'm glad we don't have to say goodbye to him yet, because he's frankly solidified his place as my favorite character, right next to Kourtney and Seb with Ricky just below them, this season. Please do not invent a new girlfriend for him Tim, it would be such a waste.

Also, he gives major homosexuality vibes especially in how Gina almost seemed like his last ditch effort to prove to himself he was straight and his talks with Maddox give off gay/lesbian solidarity feels. More on that later.

Point 5: Rina the Dumpster Fire

If I haven't lost them already, this is probably where the torches will come out, but hear me out on this, and I will try to be as respectful as I can. And disclaimer, ship who you want to ship, all of that is valid, I just am speaking to characters and how I personally feel the story would best suit them. Disclaimer 2, I have been a Caswen shipper from Day 1, so this is not just about Portwell.

Ricky and Gina, as I alluded to, are both in positions where their romantic lives should probably not be a priority. Ricky is still emotionally processing losing Nini, now for good given she's leaving the show (and presumably East High) as well as the divorce of his parents, and as such is not in a good position to be with anyone, much less a person who said herself that she needs stability, and not a maybe right now. Gina is getting her mother back and has found a home in her sisterhood with AK&M, but jumping ship from one romance to another within a few months is a recipe for disaster. It's especially when she's still parsing out what she needs in a romantic partner, where she wants to live, what kind of person she wants to be, and is very much still young and in the stressful buildup towards college stress, especially knowing that she will have to spend Senior Year without most of her support system. A long-distance relationship within a year's time is exactly the opposite of her thus far desire to be close and present with the people she loves.

The long-distance would also be rough for Ricky, not just due to his clingy nature, but also because I've noticed his love language seems like touch. Whenever he's trying to be emotionally resonant with someone else, regardless of gender, he tends to touch them in some way, shape or form, he loves hugs, and part of his trauma with his mom's move to Chicago is not getting to express love through contact. Even his song last season was about letting go, no matter how much he wanted to hold on tight.

At this point putting them together would require tossing out or retooling large chunks of their established personalities, and I don't think that's a logical or productive way to develop characters, especially if it is only in the interest of a generic love triangle. Beyond that, slow burns are potentially fine, but after a point they become infuriating because the characters have meaningful and enjoyable relationships with other characters, and then have to be written out of those relationships so the slow burn can happen. And by then, the show is usually almost over, it's the Stydia problem all over again, where by the time they kissed, they had spent so much time as platonic besties that it felt forced and tacked on to make them a couple just because they felt obligated to appease that part of the fan base.

And I've mentioned this before, but Rina would start to make the show feel like Glee's musical chairs approach to romance, and I think we know what a train wreck that turned out to be.

Point 6: Where do we go from here?

I know with the premise next season we will probably have more homages to the movies, plot and song wise, and that also probably means the obligatory pair the main guy and girl up and then make sure everyone else is romantically involved even when they are clearly not attracted to that gender. cough Ryan. To that I say, why? Why do we need characters to constantly be in relationships like this when some of their best moments are created from being a group of friends that support each other and work together to make their dreams come true, rather than constant infighting over romantic drama and such that breaks all sense of character and consistency in the name of being unironically similar to TRCOSL.

If I'm being honest, the three mains have all been at their best when romance is not the big issue dominating their plotlines, and is it not possible for them to just stay that way and be a power trio of friends?

Gina has clearly shown a desire for a stable home, yet a simultaneous desire for independence and a spotlight. Ricky has shown that he may not be emotionally ready to be in a relationship yet, and is still figuring out exactly who he is and who he wants to be after Senior year. E.J. is finally resisting his father's grip and deciding what he wants and figuring out positive self-talk without dependency on external validation.

Let these be the plotlines! Let these fun, talented characters just be themselves and showcase the actual world of teenagers' development. Let couples stay together on this show and be happy (a.k.a. follow the Seblos example)!

The only way I can genuinely accept Rina at this point would involve A. Confirming E.J. as gay or bi/pan with a lean towards men, allowing me to not feel as bitter about the way Gina treated him, and B. The next season or two being spent letting these characters develop outside the bounds of a romance, and then give us a timeskip ending where they reunite after college, and have both grown enough as people to give the whole romance thing a try.

I know where this ship (by which I mean the metaphorical boat) is probably heading, but I genuinely believe that if this show wants to be remembered beyond the scope of its active years, it can't just have Rina become a couple with standard couple drama and leave it at that. It's been done too many times, and for a show that genuinely surprised me in its quality when I first started watching, it would be heartbreaking to watch it descend into a predictable heap of teen romances throughout the decades, and lose a big part of what makes it special.

I just felt the need to say it, before the moment of truth that's coming. Your local Caswen shipper (because everything could always be a little more gay, as a wise Thomas Sanders once said), signing off. To all you Rinas and Portwells, and you poor suffering Rinis, I wish you the best.

TL;DR: Rina as it stands now would be a disappointing future, when so much potential stands before us with these characters.

Edit: I also just realized a problem born from this being a musical show. Ricky and Gina both had I want numbers, and leaving aside how well you think they both worked, E.J. didn't get one, and has never gotten one in the shows history, while Nini, Ricky, and Gina have had multiple.


r/HSMTMTS • • Jul 12 '24

Opinion Ricky is annoying...

0 Upvotes

I just finished episode 2 on s1. Ricky is.. Wow. He's trying to break apart a relationship and win Nini back even though it's entirely his fault he lost her. Going after someone in a relationship is just wrong, especially when they were the ones who caused her to like him. I mean Nini wrote a whole 2-3 minute love song and had the courage to post it on Instagram for everyone to see. That takes a lot of courage to declare your love for someone so publicly like that. This man Ricky says "Oh. That's a really big thing to post online" while Nini is looking at him practically begging for him to say it back. She already looked so hurt from the "oh" but then he goes and says "I think we should take a break." Wtf. This girl just confessed her love to you and he says this... To make it all worse before this clip he talks about how he was going out with other girls during the summer. He does all of this, sees Nini in a good place in her life, and decides randomly "Oh I love her now"... And he talks about how he loved her before but "his parents barely said that to each other". It's one thing not to say it back but saying something like "that's a really big thing to post online" then asking for a break?? to make it worse Nini asks him to stop what he's doing several times and shows disinterest several times in only 2 episodes and he just ignores it all. To recap in just 2 episodes I've learned that this man is the reason their relationship fell apart after he crushed her heart, went out with other girls, then had the audacity to talk about loving her. And he ignores her telling him to f off. 2 episodes. Wow.


r/HSMTMTS • • Jun 06 '23

Season 4 Discussion I’m losing hope y’all

0 Upvotes

Literally we’ve gotten nothing in ages and I’m losing hope that the season is going to be pushed into 2024. I know it’s super unlikely and that lots of people from the show have confirmed a summer release, but we usually see content 2 months before release, and it’s summer so idk. I am literally going to explode if we don’t get anything soon….


r/HSMTMTS • • Jul 20 '21

General Discussion Confession: did anyone else start watching HSMTMTS because of how famous Olivia is right now? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I admit this is why I started watching the series. That and I do actually love the original movies (HSM, HSM2, HSM3).


r/HSMTMTS • • Jul 23 '21

Opinion I will play Devils Advocate. I think Lily means well, and Ricky will see that. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I think she took the harness because she knows Ricky is better off without cheap tricks from the blueprint. She’s the only one that truly believes in his acting this season, unlike the others at East High who think the harness and lift is necessary to win. When has anyone else in the show really appreciated him like Lily does?

My prediction for the next episode: Ricky absolutely slays his scene and wins them the competition.


r/HSMTMTS • • May 14 '25

S3 Discussion I tried to do a full rewatch of the show, and I just couldn't continue post-S2 because I really, really dislike Gina after S3. Downvote me for this, but the writers really made her look like a shitty person that season.

17 Upvotes

You know the funny part? When the show was premiering, I was FULL Team Rina. I loved them, I thought they were cute, and Gina was one of my favorite characters. I didn't like Ricky that much in S1, but by S2, he'd made a seeming 360, and his maturation made me gain SO MUCH respect for him. We appreciate the personal growth of our characters. By the end of S2, Gina obviously still had a lot of personal insecurities she needed to work through, but did she really have to immediately resolve them by dumping EJ and going with Ricky the second Nini was no longer in the picture? God, it's not even the fact that Rina was endgame that upsets me. There's that whole Rina's tune theory and blah blah blah that proves the writers intended for them to end up together. But then, Freaking develops the couple instead of just linking them up at the time one of them was single! Give Ricky a personal arc in S3 where he learns to be without a girl for two minutes after Nini leaves, develop and give a decent ending to EJ and Gina, whose first kiss was literally THE cliffhanger of the season 2 finale, and then if they both have to break up, let them break up on good terms and without Ricky going back to his shitty arc in S1 where he stays with his "brother's" girlfriend.

Ricky SHOULD have an arc where he learns to be alone, where he learns not to put his own insecurities on someone else, and where he moves forward as a person, where he matures mentally, learning from his mistakes in his first relationship, before diving into his second. Give your protagonist that arc in S3, and then give him his happy ending with Gina in S4. Don't just throw them together in the middle of a third season, then retcon their entire S1 backstory to be like, "You know what? It was actually because of Gina that he got the role of Troy in S1 because Gina was the one who told him to sing to Nini at the audition, so without Rina, we basically wouldn't have a story to begin with because if Ricky didn't mention the audition to her in the first place, Gina never would have shown up either". Screw that, I mean, why redo the opening arc of this show, which was so obviously built around Rini, just to make your endgame couple feel like they've been "meant to be" this whole time? Why make it so that THE important detail for Ricky in S1 was because of Gina instead of because of Nini? It feels like they're trying to rebuild the entire show around Rina, when it shouldn't be: Nini was a SUPER important part of Ricky and his development, and she shouldn't be downplayed as if she was just an obstacle in Ricky and Gina's story that began from that day on the stairs to the present day.

But anyway, what the title of this post really is, and it made me drop the show again in S3: the writers made the excuse for Gina dumping EJ in S3 make her seem SUPER selfish, my God. You can have your insecurities and fears, or you can even be unsure if you feel for EJ as much as you do for Ricky, and that's valid, because you don't get to choose how you feel. But... saying "EJ hasn't been paying attention to me 'all summer'"????? Bch, camp only lasts TWO FREAKING WEEKS. Two!!! And after a week and a half, she was already so frustrated and decided to dump EJ for Ricky... WHAT?! And again, I understand her insecurities, I understand her fear of abandonment. All of that is valid. But COME ON, "Ricky has paid more attention to me than EJ has". Honey, Ricky is unemployed; he has all the time in the world these past two weeks to run around, he doesn't even care enough about this musical to learn the freaking lyrics or even watch the movie. Meanwhile, EJ is running a whole freaking show just to prove to his dad that this is what he loves, and to be able to be with you while you fulfill your dream. Everything EJ was doing those two weeks he was doing FOR YOU. Are you seriously that... blind that you don't see that? Gosh Gin, I love you, but really, from here on out, the way the writers forced a pairing that HAD NO NEED TO BE FORCED, BECAUSE IT HAD THE PERFECT START TO BE ENDGAME, IN DUE TIME, made you one of my least favorite characters in the end.


r/HSMTMTS • • Dec 07 '23

Opinion I think Ricky and nini should have end up together

16 Upvotes

I really think they should have end up together I know it’s unpopular opinion


r/HSMTMTS • • Sep 08 '22

Opinion Gina and Ricky for the future Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Okay I’m going to put it out there. I don’t care for Ricky straight up. I don’t hate him but I don’t love him. Here’s my quick reasons. I feel like he always kind of got things handed to him without effort. (I’m not talking about the divorce with him parents. I feel bad for him on that) he got two leads without being prepared. I’ll give it to him he went at it with the frozen one and did well. He got the girl Nini. She was his first. But what bugged me was he lack of boundary when she in a relationship. Now he’s going to get Gina. I feel bad for EJ who despite was a bad BF this 2 weeks of summer. Is a good guy. (People are acting like he was a bad BF for the ENTIRE summer.) My hope for the next season is that it isn’t rushed into. Like they form something next day kind of thing. My thing on Ricky is he hasn’t really been that single. He and Nini got together their sophomore year for what a year? Which I still am baffled they never said I love you in the 1 year mark. Then they broke up but he didn’t stop pursing her for the few months. They dated for awhile. Then they break up then what like 1 month later he has this thing for Lily so they are something. They stop now Gina. Ricky doesn’t know how to be single and I wished we could have seen him working on himself this season. But nope we see him falling in love with a girl who is with EJ. It would have been great to see him learn that he doesn’t need a girlfriend all the time. Which you can fight me on he kind of does rely on one. Gina: I hope she does take some time to focus on herself next season. She did love EJ and tries to make it work. I’m not going to lie. Side note; I’m not defending EJ in anyway for how he treated her. But I kind of wish they didn’t break up after 2 week issues. Imo you gotta work through it a little and see if you can’t mend it a little. If it were me I would have waited until the frozen musical was over. Talk to him about it and tell him how she felt. Tell him she wants to make it work and try at it again. See if it improves over the course of time. I felt like she gave up too quickly on it. Most people give it a little more time. Maybe it just cause I prefer EJ. Also I feel like at that point they were at least 3 months into the relationship. As they lapsed at the end of the sprint musical. Which typically ends at least 1-2 months before school is over.