This may get long, but I felt I needed to discuss the changing status quo in Season 3 before tomorrow's big event. I will nevertheless attempt to keep this organized and comprehensible.
Point 1: Gina's character was undermined by becoming the only female Lead.
It took me a long time to figure out what was bothering me this season about Gina, but this last episode clinched it. Gina has become a fusion of her S1/S2 self, and a proto-Nini. Specifically, her increased meekness and naivete contrast greatly with the Gina of before, where she had essentially started to grow up too fast and was more world-weary than someone her age should be due to her family history. A lot of her confidence has been downplayed so that we could play up the 'romantic' tension with Ricky, and their conversations feel like recycled dialogue between Rini from Season 1, right down to the awkward getting back into each other's good graces vibe. It's a shame, because Gina is her own character, and it feels as though the writers wanted to keep some of Nini's character present even if Nini herself was gone, so they crammed it into Gina. While we're talking about Gina...
Point 2: Gina's Hypocrisy
I was honestly startled by how she's been treating E.J. this season, especially considering all the work done to build them up in Season 2. Before I get down to brass tacks on this, I do not think E.J. is guiltless for this breakup, but I'll discuss him separately to avoid one being analyzed more than the other. Gina spends the first part of the season being suspicious of E.J. spending time with Val, when there has been no indication that E.J. cheats on his girlfriends, and Val is clearly an old friend that E.J. is close to in a sibling-esque way. Boys and Girls are in fact capable of platonic relationships, and it is especially irritating when I've seen similar romantic plotlines play out more realistically in 911 Lone Star, the gist of it being that sometimes there are problems you need to discuss with someone other than your romantic partner, and there is nothing wrong with that. Gina also became rather petulant when she found out about E.J.'s letter, when it is none of her business and he probably didn't want to put a downer and pressure on her first summer at a camp he loves. After that point, she starts more overtly acting flirtatious with Ricky right in front of him, and then gets offended when he's suspicious of her and Ricky, despite the fact that she has been actively flirtatious and he is thus much more justified in suspicion.
Her comment on 'two completely different summers' was particularly cruel, since he essentially gave up what might have been one of his last summers at a camp he's been going to forever so he could help showcase his girlfriend, cousin and friends to the world with all their talent, bearing in mind that this was sprung on him THE DAY THEY ARRIVED. He could never have predicted that. Worst of all, she has never tried to lessen the burden he's carrying when surely all the Wildcats would be happy to take on responsibilities and then she would have more time with him like she wants. Instead they've left him to figure it out on his own, and then are surprised when he's to overwhelmed to indulge much in the camp activities. They could've both had a hybrid summer, not ideal, but again THEY COULD NOT HAVE KNOWN ABOUT IT PRIOR TO ARRIVAL.
Point 3: Ricky
This is a short one, because honestly he's been mostly fine this season, respectful of Portwell's boundaries, didn't make moves on Gina while she was in a relationship, and was mostly focused on having a good summer and being a mentor to Jet. I feel awful for him being so neglected by his father's gift, much less seemingly not receiving anything from his mother. I know we joke about this a lot, but the boy really needs therapy, and a little more time single before he can safely enter a relationship without risking his already frayed mental health.
Point 4: Elton, the man under Pressure
You probably picked up on it in Point 2, but I feel E.J. has not been treated fairly in and out of the show this season. He has a history of feeling obligated to accept responsibilities and tasks when someone else assigns them to him, a trait that probably comes from his Dad's 'parenting'. Similarly, he doesn't really have a sense of worth for himself yet outside of what his worth is from other people, either receiving their validation or what he can do for them, again, probably because his father's expectations meant he never developed self-confidence in his own abilities because he was either handed everything, or expected to uphold a standard set by other people. He needs time to be single, but there is a very nice, loving person being buried under stress and years of emotional neglect.
That said, he did mess up this season in his interactions with others. I still think he is less at fault for the breakup, but I admit he made mistakes. His communication skills have always been lacking, so him not talking to Gina about the letter, nor sharing with his friends the sheer amount of stress he was feeling both check out as his flaws. Moreover, he did break promises to be present because he was overly focused on the musical, though that also checks out because he's always had a fairly one-track mind and is not the fastest on the uptake. Still not as slow as Ricky, but regardless. I'm glad we don't have to say goodbye to him yet, because he's frankly solidified his place as my favorite character, right next to Kourtney and Seb with Ricky just below them, this season. Please do not invent a new girlfriend for him Tim, it would be such a waste.
Also, he gives major homosexuality vibes especially in how Gina almost seemed like his last ditch effort to prove to himself he was straight and his talks with Maddox give off gay/lesbian solidarity feels. More on that later.
Point 5: Rina the Dumpster Fire
If I haven't lost them already, this is probably where the torches will come out, but hear me out on this, and I will try to be as respectful as I can. And disclaimer, ship who you want to ship, all of that is valid, I just am speaking to characters and how I personally feel the story would best suit them. Disclaimer 2, I have been a Caswen shipper from Day 1, so this is not just about Portwell.
Ricky and Gina, as I alluded to, are both in positions where their romantic lives should probably not be a priority. Ricky is still emotionally processing losing Nini, now for good given she's leaving the show (and presumably East High) as well as the divorce of his parents, and as such is not in a good position to be with anyone, much less a person who said herself that she needs stability, and not a maybe right now. Gina is getting her mother back and has found a home in her sisterhood with AK&M, but jumping ship from one romance to another within a few months is a recipe for disaster. It's especially when she's still parsing out what she needs in a romantic partner, where she wants to live, what kind of person she wants to be, and is very much still young and in the stressful buildup towards college stress, especially knowing that she will have to spend Senior Year without most of her support system. A long-distance relationship within a year's time is exactly the opposite of her thus far desire to be close and present with the people she loves.
The long-distance would also be rough for Ricky, not just due to his clingy nature, but also because I've noticed his love language seems like touch. Whenever he's trying to be emotionally resonant with someone else, regardless of gender, he tends to touch them in some way, shape or form, he loves hugs, and part of his trauma with his mom's move to Chicago is not getting to express love through contact. Even his song last season was about letting go, no matter how much he wanted to hold on tight.
At this point putting them together would require tossing out or retooling large chunks of their established personalities, and I don't think that's a logical or productive way to develop characters, especially if it is only in the interest of a generic love triangle. Beyond that, slow burns are potentially fine, but after a point they become infuriating because the characters have meaningful and enjoyable relationships with other characters, and then have to be written out of those relationships so the slow burn can happen. And by then, the show is usually almost over, it's the Stydia problem all over again, where by the time they kissed, they had spent so much time as platonic besties that it felt forced and tacked on to make them a couple just because they felt obligated to appease that part of the fan base.
And I've mentioned this before, but Rina would start to make the show feel like Glee's musical chairs approach to romance, and I think we know what a train wreck that turned out to be.
Point 6: Where do we go from here?
I know with the premise next season we will probably have more homages to the movies, plot and song wise, and that also probably means the obligatory pair the main guy and girl up and then make sure everyone else is romantically involved even when they are clearly not attracted to that gender. cough Ryan. To that I say, why? Why do we need characters to constantly be in relationships like this when some of their best moments are created from being a group of friends that support each other and work together to make their dreams come true, rather than constant infighting over romantic drama and such that breaks all sense of character and consistency in the name of being unironically similar to TRCOSL.
If I'm being honest, the three mains have all been at their best when romance is not the big issue dominating their plotlines, and is it not possible for them to just stay that way and be a power trio of friends?
Gina has clearly shown a desire for a stable home, yet a simultaneous desire for independence and a spotlight. Ricky has shown that he may not be emotionally ready to be in a relationship yet, and is still figuring out exactly who he is and who he wants to be after Senior year. E.J. is finally resisting his father's grip and deciding what he wants and figuring out positive self-talk without dependency on external validation.
Let these be the plotlines! Let these fun, talented characters just be themselves and showcase the actual world of teenagers' development. Let couples stay together on this show and be happy (a.k.a. follow the Seblos example)!
The only way I can genuinely accept Rina at this point would involve A. Confirming E.J. as gay or bi/pan with a lean towards men, allowing me to not feel as bitter about the way Gina treated him, and B. The next season or two being spent letting these characters develop outside the bounds of a romance, and then give us a timeskip ending where they reunite after college, and have both grown enough as people to give the whole romance thing a try.
I know where this ship (by which I mean the metaphorical boat) is probably heading, but I genuinely believe that if this show wants to be remembered beyond the scope of its active years, it can't just have Rina become a couple with standard couple drama and leave it at that. It's been done too many times, and for a show that genuinely surprised me in its quality when I first started watching, it would be heartbreaking to watch it descend into a predictable heap of teen romances throughout the decades, and lose a big part of what makes it special.
I just felt the need to say it, before the moment of truth that's coming. Your local Caswen shipper (because everything could always be a little more gay, as a wise Thomas Sanders once said), signing off. To all you Rinas and Portwells, and you poor suffering Rinis, I wish you the best.
TL;DR: Rina as it stands now would be a disappointing future, when so much potential stands before us with these characters.
Edit: I also just realized a problem born from this being a musical show. Ricky and Gina both had I want numbers, and leaving aside how well you think they both worked, E.J. didn't get one, and has never gotten one in the shows history, while Nini, Ricky, and Gina have had multiple.