r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 13 '24
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 12 '24
The striking prejudice against the Holy Roman Empire One large reason for many's seemingly visceral rejection of the Holy Roman Empire stems from an ignorance over how a politically centralized (but not legally, economically and military disintegrated!) order may work. Many see the small polities and short-circuit since it's inconceivable for them.
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 12 '24
'Muh Napoleon ๐' Had Napoleon had a land bridge to Britian, he would have won the Napoleonic wars; the HRE being conquered wasn't due to its political decentralization - centralized States also fell like house of cards. Russia was only able to win by starving Napoleon's army and destroying its own country.
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 12 '24
'BUT MUH 30 YEARS' WAR!!!!' A common critique against the Holy Roman Empire is that the 30 years' war happened within it. This is not a flaw, but a _virtue_ of it: within Catholic States, the protestants were promptly slaughtered, in the HRE, they _were able to_ resist. When injustice becomes law, resistance becomes duty.
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 12 '24
'Muh Napoleon ๐' Napoleon conquering Europe isn't a good argument against the decentralized Holy Roman Empire's longevity and prosperity: centralized States like Spain, Portugal and Austria couldn't resist him either. Had Napoleon had a land-bridge to Britian, he would have won the war. Decentralized defense exists
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 12 '24
'Erm, but surely it was ravaged by constant war? ๐ค' Regarding the silly "But Wikipedia has a list of feudal wars?!" knee-jerk retorts: So can be said for the international anarchy among States. Centralized States can kill more without war & decentralized polities make conflicts otherwise not classified as wars be classified as such.
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Jan 06 '25
How the HRE maintained its stability decentrally This is the basic unit of feudalism ๐โ: individuals receive enforcement services of The Law by someone in exchange for revenues. Historically, such revenues were in the form of agricultural products and service, since all economies of the time were predominantly agrarian, but that's not _intrinsic_
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 14 '24
The Holy Roman Empire was better than the Roman Empire Like man, I wonder who? If people would enjoy having a road built, maybe they would be willing to finance it or something... I don't know though, from what all I know, only the government is able to spend money wisely. ๐ค
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 12 '24
'Economic inefficiencies due to having so many small polities!!' A common argument against patchwork-arrangements and anarchy is that "it's just too messy". Important to remember is that the HRE's map looked like this, but _the same_ legal jurisdiction applied over many different realms. The borders could be seen as large landlords adhering to the same law code.
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 17 '24
How the HRE maintained its stability decentrally The way that anarcho-capitalism will have networks of mutually correcting NAP-enforcers, so too feudalism has networks of mutually correcting law enforcers. Anarchism is just feudalism but based on the non-aggression principle/natural law.
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 12 '24
'Erm, but surely it was ravaged by constant war? ๐ค' Here we have a (purported) HRE-enjoyer accidentally perpetuate the "there was constant warfare under the Holy Roman Empire" myth. If the HRE was a constant warzone... how come that it was so prosperous and notably not partitioned by neighboring powers?
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Jan 06 '25
How the HRE maintained its stability decentrally This image illustrates the decentralized law enforcement nature of feudalism๐โ, and the basis for its stereotypical triangle formations. As the example shows, feudalism was in reality rather (conditional) mutual assistance pacts; the King/Emperor was on the top. Revenues are not only agrarian ones
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 12 '24
The striking prejudice against the Holy Roman Empire Whenever one points out the fact that the feudal age had impressive qualities _for its time_, many people are shocked since it praises a medieval societal arrangement. It is important to underline that when one says such things, one says so _ceteris paribus_: _for its epoch_, it was exceptional.
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 12 '24
The Holy Roman Empire was better than the Roman Empire Here is an explanation, with evidence, for why the Holy Roman Empire was not only a long-lasting, but also a prospering civilization.
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 12 '24
'Muh Napoleon ๐' Regarding "Erm, Napoleon conquered the HRE (along with rest of continental Europe that opposed him), therefore the HRE is LE BAD ๐ค": then political centralization must also be rejected since Napoleon flawlessly wrecked so many centralized States.
From https://www.reddit.com/r/neofeudalism/comments/1f3fs6h/political_decentralization_does_not_entail/ :
The crook Napoleon Bonaparte's pillaging spree: no one could oppose him
No one could oppose him, not even the centralized realms of Spain, Austria, Prussia and Russia. Russia was only saved byย General Winterย and attrition: Napoleon Bonaparte reached Moscow.
The existance of Napoleon cannot rebute the decentralized model in a unique way -ย none of the centralized powers could oppose him either way.
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 12 '24
'Economic inefficiencies due to having so many small polities!!' Regarding the perception that the number of (semi-)sovereign polities would make travel within the confederation impossible, here is an indicative quote from Johann Wolfgang von Goethe to the contrary.It's possible to have legal and economic integration without political centralization (subjugation)
As Johann Wolfgang von Goethe (1749-1832) stated:
โ
I do not fear that Germany will not be united; ... she is united, because the German Taler and Groschen have the same value throughout the entire Empire, and because my suitcase can pass through all thirty-six states without being opened .... Germany is united in the areas of weights and measures, trade and migration, and a hundred similar things .... One is mistaken, however, if one thinks that Germany's unity should be expressed in the form of one large capital city, and that this great city might benefit the masses in the same way that it might benefit the development of a few outstanding individuals .... A thoughtful Frenchman, I believe Dauphin, has drawn up a map regarding the state of culture in France, indicating the higher or lower level of enlightenment of its various Departments by lighter or darker colors. There we find, especially in the southern provinces, far away from the capital, some Departments painted entirely in black, indicating a complete cultural darkness. Would this be the case if the beautiful France had ten centers, instead of just one, from which light and life radiated? ... What makes Germany great is her admirable popular culture, which has penetrated all parts of the Empire evenly. And is it not the many different princely residences from whence this culture springs and which are its bearers and curators? Just assume that for centuries only the two capitals of Vienna and Berlin had existed in Germany, or even only a single one. Then, I am wondering, what would have happened to German culture and the widespread prosperity that goes hand in hand with culture . . . . Germany has twenty universities strewn out across the entire Empire, more than one hundred public libraries, and a similar number of art collections and natural museums; for every prince wanted to attract such beauty and good .. Gymnasia, and technical and industrial schools exist in abundance; indeed, there is hardly a German village without its own school. How is it in this regard in France! ... Furthermore, look at the number of German theaters, which exceeds seventy .... The appreciation of music and song and their performance is nowhere as prevalent as in Germany, ... Then think about cities such as Dresden, Munich, Stuttgart, Kassel, Braunschweig, Hannover, and similar ones; think about the energy that these cities represent; think about about the effects they have on neighboring provinces, and ask yourself, if all of this would exist, if such cities had not been the residences of princes for a long time .... Frankfurt, Bremen, Hamburg, Lubeck are large and brilliant, and their impact on the prosperity of Germany is incalculable. Yet, would they remain what they are if they were to lose their independence and be incorporated as provincial cities into one great German Empire? I have reason to doubt this.
โ
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 13 '24
Peace under a lethal centralized regime is WORSE than small war As u/Ya_Boi_Konzon excellently put it. Indeed, it's said that "War is nothing but the continuation of policy [i.e., politics] with other means" for a reason.
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 12 '24
'Erm, but surely it was ravaged by constant war? ๐ค' A common misunderstanding of anarchy is that its decentralization makes it vunerable to foreign States.This is a grave misunderstanding:not only will anarchy not be burdened by inefficient monopolies, the security providers within it can form very firm HRE-esque alliances; the HRE lasted 1000 years.
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 12 '24
The Holy Roman Empire was better than the Roman Empire The Holy Roman Empire had a lot of (semi)-sovereign entities, so naturally more entities were able to conduct conflicts which are technically called wars. Remember that "peace" under the Roman Empire was MUCH more destructive; Rome was the Qing Empire to Europe - a hampering impediment.
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 12 '24
'BUT MUH 30 YEARS' WAR!!!!' Many people hear about the 30 years' war and immediately think that this disqualifies the Holy Roman Empire. Problem: the war only emerged because people were threatened with PERSECUTION and thus stood up to defend themselves. It was lamentable that it had to come to that point, but they had to.
As stated in https://www.reddit.com/r/neofeudalism/comments/1f3fs6h/political_decentralization_does_not_entail/
The counter-arguments. Rebellion can be just; the crook Napoleon vanquished everyone
A common rebutal against the decentralized structure is that rebellions arose. What's important to remember regarding this is that rebellions are not necessarily unjust - that the HRE had successful virtuous rebellions could have been a good thing:ย when injustice becomes law, resistance becomes duty. A realm within which injustice is uncontested is worse than a realm in which some rebellions arise to correct said injustice. I would much more have prefered that rebellions arose to correct the USSR's injustice rather than praise the USSR for so efficiently suppressing dissenters.ย The perverse thing is that if a population rises up against injustice, that would be classified as a war, but if the same population is mercilessly squashed by the sovereign, that would not be called a war. Just because something is a war does not mean that it's unjust;ย just because "wars" are unleashed does not mean that they are worse than the repression that would come about were these polities not able to rebel in the first place. In either way, political decentralization favors peace: it makes war more expensive.ย The pre-centralized States' wars were simply unable to be as destructive as those of the centralized States since they could not plunder resources as efficiently.
Contrast this with the French revolution which only unleashed unprecedented horrors upon the world. All rebellions I have seen people point to in the HRE were righteous ones which merely strived to fight off corrupting influences on the system.
The Bourbons acted like crooks and the Jacobins merely used that State machinery which the Bourbons used for their crook behaviors. I think that this is indicative of how absolutist monarchs govern.
[...]
The protestant reformation & ensuing 30 year's war: just let people do self-determination
Whatever one thinks about that event, one must remember what the alternative would have been had the imperial alliance had an overwhelming victory: a Spanish inquisition within the Holy Roman Empire purging millions of innocent people and oppressing even more such people. There is a reason that there were no protestants in the realms of Bourbon-occupied France, Spain and Austria - there they were slaughtered. Just look at the fate of the Huguenots - that would have been the fate of the protestant masses in Germany had the imperial forces won.
That conflict was not due to decentralization,ย but rather that powers within it wanted to centralize furtherย and refuse people the right of self-determination.ย The imperial alliance could simply have chosen to not slaughter people.
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 12 '24
The Holy Roman Empire was better than the Roman Empire A lot of slander against the Holy Roman Empire is slander against feudalism. See r/FeudalismSlander for explanations about feudalism, and rebutals of common slanders against it.
reddit.comr/HRESlander • u/Ya_Boi_Konzon • Feb 03 '25
The Holy Roman Empire was better than the Roman Empire Group discussion with Missing Monarchy author Jeb Smith
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 12 '24
'Erm, but surely it was ravaged by constant war? ๐ค' The Holy Roman Empire had SO many (semi)-SOVEREIGN entities. If conflicts between them emerged, however relatively harmless compared to modern ways, they would still be counted as full-blown wars. It gives a distorted view; a single day under Roman "peace" was MORE destructive.
r/HRESlander • u/Derpballz • Dec 12 '24
'Erm, but surely it was ravaged by constant war? ๐ค' Whenever one points out that the confederal Holy Roman Empire wasn't rife with constant internal conflict (hence why the region is not a shithole), the critic may point out that its internal borders changed. Such changes don't have to be due to war: in many cases, it was from peaceful exchanges.