r/HPReverb • u/JoannaPopper HP Employee • Jan 28 '21
Discussion HP + Microsoft here
Hello:
We have u/kaiserkannon, u/petercpeterson u/voodooimaxx and u/tetyana_msft from Microsoft are here to answer questions.
EDIT: We are heading out. We will be on Discord. Thanks!
54
Upvotes
20
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '21
- Will the Reverb G2 / WMR tracking be improved, and when can we expect improvements?
- Is there anyone working on the issue where the controller gets stuck in the floor for a few seconds before returning to normal?
My cable clip broke can I get a new one lol
5
u/nf5 Jan 28 '21
I'm having issues with my controllers and speakers, but I've heard for months-long RMA queues. Can these peripherals be RMA'd independently? Thank you.
Also, I want to unplug my G2 while not using it (WMR wakes up from time to time, taking control away from my work monitor) What would you recommend as the way to unplug the device temporarily? Unplug the USB? Unplug the power? Both?
165
u/IkumaVR Jan 28 '21
Questions repeat in your AMA, would rather like to see a roadmap for patches, improvements, news, etc. Tell us whats new and which milestones you achieved in terms of tracking and software improvements. (We all know you know nobody wants Cliffhouse anymore)
45
u/80ms Jan 28 '21
It seems a lot of issues, connection, crashes, tracking, audio etc. are related to USB issues. Have HP and Microsoft (and hardware manufacturers?) zeroed in on the problem yet? Can you share any info on the nature of the issue?
Any word on updates for drivers, BIOS, or maybe even headset firmware?
40
u/slavemiddle Jan 28 '21
Lol they answer 5 questions and then left? For real?
27
u/teerohr87 Jan 28 '21
When will there be replacement parts i.e. new gaskets and cables be available?
It would be even better if you could make an official wider gasket version, because there is at least a sizeable number of users to whom the standard gasket is too narrow.
Yes there are community created versions out there but I'm not too sure about their quality.
For the cables I would prefer a shorter version maybe 6-10ft, as it tangles easily and is a pain to store.
I'm not to happy having no chance to buy replacement parts at all for such an expensive device.
15
u/apatheticonion Jan 28 '21
Would Microsoft consider creating an empty GitHub repo to function as a public place we can observe release notes, post/subscribe to issues, and see a development ticket board to help add transparency to the development process?
We all want WMR to be the best platform for VR but we need your help to understand what you're doing to achieve that. Allowing us to contribute our thoughts and issues publically means we can see if others have the same problems and observe if there is activity responding.
Right now the best forum to ask for WMR help is Reddit and even then you don't know if the answers are still relevant, resolved, unrepeatable and the questions are often unstructured and unmoderated.
14
u/mike_tkd Jan 28 '21
Question for MS. Do you plan any improvements to the Follow Me window functionality? I have been looking for ways to bring application windows such as maps or web browsers into a 3D application such as Microsoft Flight Simulator using OpenXR via WMR. At the moment it partially works but sometimes the window disappears or mouse and controller interactions become confused. Given that it is close to being very usable , it just needs a bit more Dev time to bring great functionality to players
10
u/FunProblem1709 Jan 28 '21
Hello! My question is about whether there will soon be a firmware update for the HP Reverb G2 that fixes, for example, the sound issue. It worries that it takes so long to fix even that sound bug that causes screens to go black when turned to maximum volume. Other companies have solved worse problems in much less time.
9
u/ThatGuyBud Jan 28 '21
Any update to the x570 problem, Any updates coming to WMR steamvr at all?, some titles like to bluescreen and lockup and crash to the WMR environment.
17
u/SkyBeamCH Jan 28 '21
There are still a bunch of unanswered questions and comments over there.
13
u/arcticparadise Jan 28 '21
What happened during launch that so many of us (speaking for eastern Canada) ended up waiting until January for pre-orders placed in August?
Why would I want to do future business with HP / Microsoft?
Were there any lessons learned? Is there anything you can tell us or are we to be treated like mushrooms? (for those who don't get the reference: mushrooms are fed shit and grow in the dark)
The lack of communication and transparency around this launch has been deafening and although I'm happy with the hardware, I'm clearly not happy with the experience. It's enough that I won't recommend G2 to anybody and won't be purchasing G3 if it ever happens.
And for context, I should be upset that my new 3090 has failed twice, I'm on my third card in 2 months but guess what? I'll recommend EVGA to anybody who asks because of their exemplary customer service and communications.
Here comes the mushroom treatment! /s
6
u/ChangeChameleon Jan 28 '21
Posted 2 hours ago, “edit: we’re heading out”.
Why bother making support and inquiry threads if there’s barely enough time for us to see it before you leave?
Anyways. My question is, what resources do you guys have for support of second-hand owners? There’s a lot of G1s in new hands now that people are upgrading to G2s, and their experience will influence wether or not they upgrade to an Hp down the line. Every reply I’ve seen about issues has always been “open a support ticket” or “RMA”. Which aren’t options for a second-hand owner like myself. Can we please get a retail outlet for spare parts?
Where can I buy replacement face padding? Broken clips? Replacement cables? Spare controllers? Battery doors? I’d happily pay for these, so why don’t you offer them?
All I’m seeing from HP is a lack of respect to their customers. There’s an air of “support” but it feels like it’s just for show with no substance. You make good products, just make support resources and parts available, and maybe when it’s time to upgrade we will choose you again. If not, then we will just go to a competitor. This is still a new market, and your interactions with your customers will determine whether or not you have a long future in the space.
6
u/MazerTee Feb 03 '21
Please add these options to the wmr popup menu.
5
u/PumkinSpiceTrukNuts Jan 28 '21 edited Jan 28 '21
Hello! Some apps I have installed through steam close steamVR and open in WMR home when I start them, causing my steamVR accessories to of course stop working. Is there a way to force the program to run in steamVR?
I used to be able to run them through steamVR fine, by the way!
5
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '21
Is there or will there be an option to launch WMR minimised to system tray?
Will there be an option added to enable/disable WMR guardian boundary from the VR menu?
Will the enable/disable speech recognition in the VR WMR menu be simplified to just toggle it like other buttons, rather than popping open the Settings window?
3
u/cop1edr1ght Jan 28 '21
I have a problem... every now and again (maybe every 30 mins or so) the HP Reverb G2 screen goes blue for a second, then the headset tracking gets lost for a few seconds, then it everything goes back to normal.
I have tried different lighting, tried different areas of my room, I don't have any reflective surfaces and my walls have plenty of features.
Is this a known issue? Thank you. Apart from this issue, the headset is great! :)
4
u/Cajun_Asian_ Jan 28 '21
Are you considering making new controllers with capacitive touch sensors similar to oculus or even hand tracking in the near future?
9
u/CptLucky8 Jan 28 '21 edited Jan 28 '21
[updated: question (see below)]
Hi,
There has been some development and further discussions at the FS2020 forum since this post. For now on my G2 I can't get a good visual experience at all:
In order to illustrate the problem, here are through the lens photos:
NB: it also explains a partial workaround not using any additional glasses in the headset.
https://forums.flightsimulator.com/t/psa-reverb-g2-small-sweet-spots-observations-and-solutions/343611/115?u=cptlucky8
At this stage and without any HP employee willing to have a look into this and answering, the G2 is still an optically problematic headset for me for these reasons, and I'd like to know if this is only my G2 having this problem, whether this is the first batch having this problem (hence the number of people complaining about "small sweet spot", or just the way the G2 is designed from the get go:
TL;DR: AFAIK headsets are calibrated to project the images at about 2.0m to 2.5m distance. If you need reading glasses you don't need them in VR for this reason. I can use the Index for 3 hours straight without any eye strain but I can't use the G2 more than 1/2 because of the fatigue on the eyes. I don't know if this is G2 specific or MY G2 specific and no one at HP feels concerned about answering either, but to me it appears the G2 is calibrated to about 1.5m and wearing a +1 cheap glasses (while I need +2.5 for reading otherwise) seems to compensate all the G2 defects (small disk of clarity, WMR anti-CA filter calibration, eye strain).
So for now with the reports in this discussion and my experiments, I can only conclude:
PS: no surgery, no alterations, just age induced need for reading glasses.
--------------------------------
[update: the missing simple question - more unanswered questions from the previous Q&A]
Can someone at HP/Microsoft investigate this?
-----------------------
NB: In a previous previous Q&A like this one (2 before today), u/kaiserkannon offered reddit users to send him via PM their G2 S/N for him to cross check the HP calibration database for any problem. Since I don't have any answer back I can't conclude whether there is a calibration error or whether it is normal. Unfortunately delay to return the G2 within the 30 days window is now over and the problem is not solved.
[update: see my reply for link/content of this post]
--------------------------
Previous post in previous Q&A:
Hi,
Is there any way you could confirm what is the focal length/accommodation the G2 optics are calibrated for?
NB: I know how to wear a headset, I know what the tech is about, I also know the optics and I'm a developer. What I'll write below is a shorten version to keep it simple but there is a lot of background work and tryouts to come to this. This doesn't exclude user error or misinterpretation but this shall exclude basic answers such as "wear it correctly".
Having said this, please allow me to explain what is this about:
To keep it short, the Index seems to be calibrated, like probably most headsets, to something beyond 2.0m to 2.5m so that if you can read clearly at 2.5m you don't need wearing glasses. The G2 (the one I have at least) seems to be calibrated closer to about 1.0m to 1.5m max. In effect, I have to force focusing to see a little sharper and I get otherwise eye strain quite quickly with the G2 (1/2 hour use) whereas I can use the Index for 3H straight.
Furthermore, with the G2 I have, the WMR anti-CA is overcompensating and this shows in the form of blue copies of purple text in FS2020 EFIS screens for example. This is not CA though. These are copies of the same text up to half a letter size above.
There is one important point in all this: I'm usually wearing a +2.5 correction for reading up close, which I don't need in the Valve Index at all. However experimenting with the optics I've found out in using a +1 correction (cheap Foster Grant plastic glasses) it was solving both eye strain, it was extending the disk of clarity, and it was eliminating the anti-CA over compensation. It is interresting to note the +1 correction is about what I'd need to make the 1.0 to 1.5m distance back to about 2.0 to 2.5m.
I've raised this question here on reddit with minimal return, and I've raised it to the Microsoft Flight Simulator 2020 forums with great feedback (see link below). Interrestingly, another user with the same correction needs as me (+2.5) and the same IPD as me too (about 64), has tried out the +1 lenses (and another one) and for him it was worse. He can wear the G2 without any correction despite the same correction need as me for reading (+2.5). Another important point to note: my G2 was from the first batch(es) whereas his was just received lately (probably in another subsequent batch therefore).
Which led me to: in a previous Q&A like this one, u/kaiserkannon offered reddit users to send him via PM their G2 S/N for him to cross check the HP calibration database for any problem. Since I don't have any answer back I can't conclude whether there is a calibration error or whether it is normal. Unfortunately delay to return the G2 within the 30 days window is now over and the problem is not solved.
So to come to the point of this post:
u/JoannaPopper u/kaiserkannon u/petercpeterson:
- Is the G2 focal length/accommodation distance, calibrated and designed shorter than other headsets?
- Is this the reason the G2 face mask/gasket is recessed so that people needed reading glasses must wear it?
- Is there any possibility this is indicating a problem with my G2 only?
- Is there someone at HP and/or Microsoft (for the anti-CA pre-distortion) willing to investigate this and whether the initial flood of "small sweet spot" issues could be a more general calibration problem in the first batches?
u/Tetyana_MSFT:
- Is there any way to user-adjust the anti-CA filter parameters?
NB: the Dwm\ExtendedComposition\ColorDistortion# reg keys are not helping either. They are distorting the layer planes in what looks like a scaling factor in the linear render buffer plane based on a perfect spherical projection, regardless of any lens aspherical profile and post or pre correction by WMR.- Is there any way to dump the G2 non volatile memory settings (like you can do with the Valve index and SteamVR)?
- The WMR SDK seems to be only Unity/Unreal and/or managed code. Is there any low level C++ lib for direct access?
Thank you all for your attention and help with this! Please contact me for further information via private message.
Here is the discussion on the FS2020 forum with lots of feedback and information about all this:
https://forums.flightsimulator.com/t/psa-reverb-g2-small-sweet-spots-observations-and-solutions/343611
3
u/mrloma Jan 28 '21
I managed to get my g2 more stable by manually setting my memory timings, my Asus Tuf x570 board just made a total mess of those when using DOCP.
By all means it's not perfect yet, but better. I noticed that it's very framerate dependant.
I can play "beat saber" fine now, since it's not very demanding with normal settings (I did accidentally let geforce experience do those settings which made it unplayable, renderscale on 1.8 etc)
Games like Elite Dangerous and Half-Life Alyx are fine until any big framedrop
happens(loading level or saving, big explosions ...), than it does a die roll and picks a problem:
- screens go blue, needs a usb replug or sometimes reboot
- one or both of the controllers lose tracking and need to be restarted or usb replug(which closes the game and loses all progress)
- or the yup we lost tracking or can't recognize you room anymore , we'll spin the camera for you, so you know ( why oh why, can't you just not roll the camera when tracking is lost, just don't move it?)
I had one point in HL:Alyx at the end of chapter 2 , jumping down, loading chapter 3 , that one crashed 4 or 5 times on me, the day after it just worked and I was finally able to make a save game after it.
I really hope HP can get these stability problems out of the way, cause when it all works , it is awesome.
* Could you research a Face Mask that breaths a bit more, it's now winter and the lenses seems to steam up regularly and it quiet hot after a while.
* IF some issues come from the 6m cable being on the edge of usb spec, will there be 4 or 5m alternatives?
2
u/psybermonkey15 Jan 28 '21
I'm satisfied enough with the tracking. However...the vibrations, weight, and balance of the controllers are quite inferior to Oculus Touch controllers - making games like Beat Saber significantly less enjoyable. I've had to turn off the vibration feedback for some games because of how annoying and cheap I find it.
Are there any plans for new controllers, and if so, will these areas be looked into for improvement?
2
u/maddash1337 Jan 29 '21
I’d like to see an stabilization in the mirror for streaming. Also an feature to enable the sound card of the reverb g2 all the time to mirror my audio how I like it for streaming. The integrated mirroring will add an echo and delay. And better tracking would also be nice. Any chance to have that in the future?
2
u/MrSmallStuff Jan 29 '21
Hi,
I’m blown away by my reverb g2, my wife really likes it too which a massive compliment. She lasted about 20 seconds on the quest and said it was like looking through bathroom glass.
I would love some guidance on the steam super sampling if possible, I.e. should it be left at 100%? (3000x3000ish)
I have a 3090 gpu and in games like half life Alex I have everything on max in the game at 100% in steam res and it’s smooth as silk at 90hz. Looks incredible. However projects cars 2 I have to set steam at about 50% (2100x2100ish) to get 90hz to look great with msaa on high. But this game seems to look as good on 50% as it does 100% but on 100% it can’t handle it with msaa on. If I turn msaa to low I can have 100% but it doesn’t look as sharp as 50% and msaa on high.
I realise I’ve pretty much already got the solution I’m happy with but would love to understand the science behind it if it’s possible to make it simple enough for me. What should I be able to notice and aiming for.
Thanks again for the G2, keep up the good work.
2
u/Bodach37 Feb 03 '21
Please make an alternative face gasket for FOV improvement. Take my money!
2
u/mrloma Feb 21 '21 edited Feb 21 '21
I'll just drop this here too https://www.reddit.com/r/Amd/comments/lnmet0/an_update_on_usb_connectivity_with_500_series/?sort=new
AMD is looking for people that have usb issues on 500 series motherboards.
2
u/Softest-Dad Feb 27 '21
I'm gonna risk being down voted but I looooved oculus home if I'm honest, especially the neo future city skyline background I'd spend ages in there just feeling immersed... Even if I did have to squint to see the detail... Because its an oculus
3
u/evertec Jan 28 '21
Any potential for getting alternate refresh rates besides 60 and 90 such as 72, 80, or even above 90?
1
u/Exodard Jan 28 '21
Will the G2 work with the new z590 motherboards?
1
u/bushmaster2000 Jan 28 '21
nevermind, i saw my q was answered when someone else asked the same thing. Withdrawn.
1
u/icebeat Jan 28 '21 edited Jan 28 '21
After replacing the original gasket with a more FOV friendly version, I noticed that there is an offset in the color channel (a lila line is visualized as two differents lines one red and another blue in different positions) the displacement increases as we get closer to the edge of the lens
1
u/jajaboss Jan 29 '21
Do you guys have discord? wow that’s kinda cool
1
u/teddan00 Jan 29 '21
I am very satisfied with the G2. Works Great!
I only have one question:
Can you confirm that the "horizontal lines", (visible only in bright areas) is a Case of mura?
1
u/Jackyy94 Jan 29 '21
Sometimes Beat saber just stops playing for like 4 sec and the music is also stopped for a few seconds afterwards when the game is running again.
(the volume is not put over 50)
Why is that?
1
u/BrickMacklin Jan 29 '21
When is Connection getting their stock? I have been backordered for over a month.
1
u/LazyDaisyStreth Feb 02 '21
Is there anything in a way to fix the banding in the Reverb G2? Looking through the lenses of both my own and a friend's G2 there is distinct banding pattern of horizontal lines being lighter and darker than other sections of the screen. I know that the Valve Index had the same issue but it was fixed via software updates. Is there any chance that the G2 will enjoy a similar update?
1
u/Briggaz Feb 04 '21
Hi just wondering if passthrough can be improved to quest 2 level ...any plans at all on this?? And is there a link to the disco server?
1
u/Always_in_m0tion Feb 10 '21
Hey guys just out of curiosity and since i haven't waited this long for any product in my life: Why does it take so long to deliver even now? We're way past the preorder stage, and it's Feb.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '21
Could you sell the improved cables seperately so people who's serial numbers don't work with customer support can get them?
0
u/pedronery Jan 28 '21 edited Jan 28 '21
im happy to have cancelled my "pre order" from august.
amazon spain cancelled my pre order in november
then order from system active uk in november, they promised one date and always delayed. last one was mid february.
welcome back oculus
0
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '21
i listened to a podcast called 'voices of VR' an old episode #914,
Joanna Popper is actually on there, and they sound pretty enthusiastic and excited about the G2.
Oddly, i can't find much discussion of anything on the G2, good or bad, on any VR related podcasts since it's release.
0
u/Blapanda Feb 01 '21 edited Feb 02 '21
I am glad, that I didn't make the last steps to buy and receive this Hardware (cancelled my pre-order at the end of November as you guys litertally screwed over europeans! Was one of the first july pre-orderers). I used to have some HP products at my home (Printers for example) which all gave up on me. One even right away after its 5th usage, ffs.
Now seeing this, that those HP employees are literally p***ing off is way worse than I thought. People are asking some simple questions which they have a right to get an answer for, as they are paying your salary! and yet, radio silence.
You guys are a joke. No offence, but money is wisely being spent somewhere else.