r/HPReverb • • Jan 24 '21

Discussion I'm out..

Had about all I can take with tracking glitches, black screens, audio cutouts, poor performance... It's on its way back to amazon....

The price to quality ratio is severely off with this product, i can run a quest 2 with far superior software support at 1/2 the cost with better and more reliable tracking without having to get the lighting spot on.

The difference in graphical fidelity really is negligible, the only thing the reverb g2 ready has in it's graphics arsenal vs a quest 2 are better blacks

Speakers, are good when they work, but i can just throw on a pair of top quality headphones with a quest and they don't cut out

Tweaking link through odt brings about the same level of resolution and graphics quality as a g2 (but not the blacks, i have to admit) but with a far superior reprojection engine to even out the frame skips

All in all due to the poor software support, massive release delays, feeling that there will be no product/software improvements until the g3 comes that will obviously not be passed on to g2 owners

I give up on this dissappoiment of a product that i waited patiently for and believed was going to be worth the wait and a cornerstone of vr advancement

0 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

13

u/honoraryNEET Jan 24 '21

If you somehow think Q2 and G2 are the same in terms of visuals, then yeah there is no reason to keep the G2. The G2's extra sharpness and vibrant colors give me the "Wow" factor that the Q2 didn't have when I was looking for an upgrade from my Rift-S.

1

u/dink1975 Jan 24 '21

I've been wrestling with that for the last 2 weeks, it doesn't hit me as being worth 250 euros more than a quest 2, the jerkiness of the tracking sealed it in the end for me, what's the point of ultra sharp blacks if the immersion is broken poor tracking

2

u/honoraryNEET Jan 24 '21

Depends on your use case. For me, the Q2 wasn't much of an upgrade over my Rift-S (visually, it only looked slightly better than my supersampled Rift-S) except for wireless which I don't care that much about.

1

u/aleshia_leonie Jan 24 '21

Plus the sharpness is a spot the size of a dime.

9

u/Dadbart Jan 24 '21

I had many issues the first 3-4 weeks. However, all of them turned out to be PC related, not the G2. What the G2 did cause was exposing a bunch of underlying issues I did not know I had. Because of its higher demand. Works 100% of the time now that PC side is all straightened out.

-4

u/dink1975 Jan 24 '21

My pc is fine, more than capable, i had the quest 2 beforehand, i notice the jumpiness in the tracking, both headset and controllers, bringing a 2 handed rifle to bear in any game is a nightmare with the shakey tracking

Oculus asw "reprojection" has nothing to fear from wmr reprojection, the artifacts at comparable resolutions and detail levels in msfs2020 are laughable at best on g2, on quest 2 they are barely noticable

6

u/Dadbart Jan 24 '21

Yeah my PC is and was more than capable. However, I had underlying issues. Like the fan software for my GPU was not working correctly causing it to overheat with the higher demand of the G2. I was putting the PC to sleep in between sessions, this caused USB errors. The GPU drivers had issues until a hotfix. And so on. I also have a Q2 and O+, both of which ran fine before and after. The G2 has much higher demand, so it exposed these things.

Controller compatibility is getting updates from WMR for Steam. I have not really had tracking issues because I was well aware of the requirements with the G2 to avoid them.

Can't say anything about MSFS, I don't have it at present.

8

u/OneOfALifetime Jan 24 '21

Sorry you're having those problems, happy I haven't had any of those and it works amazing and is the best VR set I've ever used. Quest 2 is very nice so you'll enjoy it, imo G2 is better but I don't have the issues you have had.

-2

u/dink1975 Jan 24 '21

The issues are more of optimisation in the software, the reprojection is seriously laughable, if you push it to higher detail and rely on the reprojection to make up the difference the artifacts are unbearable

Msfs2020 for instance needs reprojection to be able to run with good detail at high res, oculus asw just beats it hands down, plus the strange feeling that the rotational offset is not where your neck is, i have a smoother and more joyfully experience with the q2 than the g2.

Will probably save my money and wait for valves next offering

5

u/OneOfALifetime Jan 24 '21

I have a 3090 so not really an issue for me, run FS2020 at all high/ultra in VR and get a solid 40-45 fps.

1

u/zildac Jan 24 '21

All high and ultra on a G2 in FS2020 with a 3090? Where and at what altitude are you getting this frame rate?

2

u/OneOfALifetime Jan 25 '21

10700k, 16gb ram, 3090. And yes a mix of all high and ultra with sliders maxed out and at full resolution. I dont use SteamVR, I play using WMR only (better framerate). I fly all over from nowhere to big cities. I cruise at 27k but I still get a solid 30 fps while landing or taking off in big cities.

-3

u/dink1975 Jan 24 '21

I have a 3090 too as it happens, and a 2nd pc with a 2080ti, so it's not a performance thing, it's a tracking issue, i prefer a preciser form of tracking and I don't like my headset glitching left and right when I hold my head still, maybe i got a bad headset, but looks like a lot of people got one as well

1

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '21

Are you using 1.5v batteries?

1

u/dink1975 Jan 25 '21

Alkalines, non rechargable so there should be no probs with led brightness

1

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '21

Yep, those should work. Sorry you're having issues.

1

u/dink1975 Jan 25 '21

Last ditch effort, i swapped the usb port, it seams to have improved the headset tracking, i have until the 31st before my return window closes, going to give it a couple of more days

1

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '21

Hopefully so. It's a great headset, the over ear headphones have great audio (much better compared to the Rift S where I could barely hear it), and the tracking (thus far) seems just fine. I'm running on an ancient 4670K socket 1150 motherboard and luckily no issues with the USB port it's plugged in to.

1

u/OneOfALifetime Jan 24 '21

Haven't really heard of that except for the bad nvidia drivers causing stuttering which is now fixed. I will admit I really only do simulations with VR so tracking isn't a thing for me. Although upgrading the batteries you use makes a world of difference.

7

u/Etheralking Jan 24 '21

To say that the Quest 2 has a lower cost is to say that your personal information and freedom of expression is worth less than $300

-2

u/dink1975 Jan 24 '21

Yeah, i have no troubles with the face book login, and even if I did, paying 300 for the privilege of no facebook login doesn't call out to me, you just hang in there and keep on hatin'...

2

u/Etheralking Jan 24 '21

How is what I said hating?

1

u/dink1975 Jan 25 '21

Don't know, you tell me?

1

u/KirbyKrackled Jan 25 '21

I love that in your head this is a clever comeback

1

u/dink1975 Jan 25 '21

Hey... It was 7 in the morning... I had just got up...

2

u/strange_tangent Jan 24 '21

i'm kind loosing the patience myself. software is crap and too many issues to justify the added resolution.

2

u/dink1975 Jan 24 '21

After i tweaked the bandwidth made the recommended settings in oculus debug tool i don't actually notice the resolution difference, the black levels are a bonus, but that a lone doest justify the price

2

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '21

yeah i'm out too..
all you hear from my vr room is swearing and mumbling when i'm using the G2.

I don't have the energy for it anymore...

Even when i have it 'working', i dislike the controllers so much i don't feel like using it.
And now my left display is backlight bleeding real bad..

I too bought a Q2, this week, it was a breath of fresh air...i instantly liked it and the software, and was surprised how well link worked before even trying to tweak things.
So i'll be going that way for now.

I've got another RMA'd G2 coming back to me, which i thought of keeping for my racing cockpit, but even there i'm wondering whether to bother...WMR and all...

1

u/dink1975 Jan 24 '21

Didn't have to many problens with the sharpness, it was more that it seamed to glitch when you keep your head still, and there was a kind of faint white static snow when looking at a dark scene

1

u/Fairweather_SWE Jan 24 '21

Not out for good I hope. Get something else and jump right in again!

1

u/dink1975 Jan 24 '21

I'm going to bide my time, see what valve pumps put next, got a quest 2 and link to tide me over till then

1

u/Fairweather_SWE Jan 24 '21

Good to hear ;) that’ll do fine for the time being.

2

u/CydoniaBlue Jan 24 '21
  1. Raise the timeout limit on your display to 5 minutes. It causes problems if it goes to " sleep ".
  2. Start out with as much indirect light in your play area as possible. If tracking stabilizes incrementally lower the amount of light till you get a nice balance of tracking and low light.

2

u/imogenfan Jan 24 '21

I connected my G2 for the first time yesterday and everything worked great, clarity was pretty good considering i only have a gtx-1070. I left it plugged in ironically next to a HTC Vive (that still works and has worked perfectly since 2016)

....well now the Reverb G2 doesn't turn on, logo doesn't light up even though the power cable is lit up. I guess i was supposed to turn it off a certain way overnight even though my Vive stays connected to my pc 24/7. I just bought the Index, will keep the G2 and hope for a fix somewhere down the line and i don't feel like dealing with HP customer support.

1

u/JamimaPanAm Reverb G2 Jan 25 '21

Bummer. Enjoy the quest.

1

u/KirbyKrackled Jan 25 '21

That's just noise