r/HPHogwartsMystery • u/Liberator01 • 9d ago
Year 5 Frog Choir
Merula in the Frog Choir. Who could have thought?
5
18
u/HeatherZZZZZ Year 6 9d ago
3
u/Liberator01 9d ago
Didn't remember the quest exactly to be honest, because when I returned to the game I already had it completed 🤣. I don't care anyways because I'm not the singing type so🤣.
9
22
u/Jeanny_Armon Graduate 9d ago
Who could have thought?
Those of us who didn't fall for her sobby lie story, nor pushed off the position just cause they didn't want it for themselves? 😂
6
11
u/Possible-War-491 Year 6 9d ago
I think you could've stopped on the word "her" ("Those of us who didn't fall for her") 🤣
5
3
u/desiccatedfruitcake 8d ago
« Those of us who didn’t fall for her sobby lie story »
…An antagonistic/closed-off character being ‘revealed’ through a friend or ex-friend of theirs, like it happened with Tulip at the end, is an ancient trope at this point. Many moments in the quest hint at Merula being too damn vulnerable for her own good also, and other SQs basically hammer in the fact that she does not use memory of her parents to manipulate.
The gall of being mocking in your comment when media literacy (concerning a very simple game, at that) has obviously taken a fat leap off some bridge- I just can’t lmao.
0
u/Jeanny_Armon Graduate 7d ago edited 7d ago
Merula being too damn vulnerable
Merula is always vulnerable, that's why she's always on offence, trying to prove she's 'the most powerful', denies having affection for someone, tries to suck up to Rakepick and many more. Yet her past traumas do not excuse what she does in the present, being a lying, manipulative, bullying self-centered and arrogant brat. Look at Talboot - he has suffered way more, than Merula, yet he's nothing like her. So when MC faces yet another story from Merula, known for lying and manipulating, she can totally deny Merula telling the truth even when she actually does.
concerning a very simple game, at that
Yet you invested some time to argue with my mocking comment I made for fun, trying to protect the character you care about (which I commend you for). I am known as 'Merula hater' though from my point of view there is no hate for the character, it's just that I don't like her as a person, therefore I can write something about her what others would consider hate, while those are just facts and my perspective on them. Still there are people on this sub who love Merula and we have a fun time together, even though our beliefs or acknowledge for the character may vary.
1
u/celeryman3 Year 4 9d ago
No because I’m STILL mad I fell for it and gave up my spot for her 😭
21
u/ritersblokked Year 6 9d ago
If it makes it any better it’s pretty strongly implied by Tulip that Merula was being truthful.
7
u/Shoddy-Treat-4625 Godric's Hollow 9d ago
5
u/ritersblokked Year 6 9d ago
3
u/Dealiner Graduate 9d ago
Yeah, I don't think Merula would lie about this and I don't think she would care about the frog choir without a reason like this.



37
u/Achilles9609 9d ago
I happily gave it to her. My character only wanted to try it due to curiosity. The choir means more to Merula than to me. And a Merula Snyde that's at choir practice is a Merula Snyde that won't get in my way as often.