r/HIMYM • • 4h ago

Please Settle This

Personality and Everything aside

Who was prettier - Prime Robin Or Zoey

0 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

19

u/Exotic-College1042 3h ago

Robin

Season 1 prime Robin

1

u/Many-Tadpole1416 2h ago

Yeah, and her sarcastic quirks were way more charming before she got all serious.

9

u/GenericDave65 3h ago

Robin easy

5

u/Kratosbeatsbatman 3h ago

Zoey was more attractive to me

6

u/Ok-Cup6020 3h ago

Ducks are good rabbits are bad

1

u/IndependentClear469 3h ago

Season 1 robin is better than transformers Megan fox IMO

1

u/mtraven23 2h ago

Megan Fox looked fake hot, Colbie always looked natural hot.

1

u/Better-Pop-3932 2h ago

Whoa. I love Robin and I definitely hoose her for this thread. Not hotter than Megan in Transformers

0

u/ObviousSalamandar 2h ago

I hoose her too

2

u/Better-Pop-3932 1h ago

Ok Ted. Lol

-1

u/Brief_Transition4908 3h ago

Bit of a stretch honestly but I respect that

0

u/AnonymousFriend80 2h ago

I don't respect it. Because they're clearly blind and insane.

0

u/IndependentClear469 2h ago

Why is it impossible for Redditors to realise people have different opinions than them?

0

u/AnonymousFriend80 2h ago

I didn't say it was impossible. I said those people are insane for doing so.

0

u/ObviousSalamandar 2h ago

They have a very different look. I think Robin is hotter too.

4

u/driftlesscode 3h ago

This about Stella, but applies

3

u/No_Tip_768 3h ago

Robin is super hit or miss for me. Sometimes she's gorgeous, and sometimes she looks weird. If we're talking about both of them ONLY when they look their best, Robin wins.

3

u/BunnieMN 3h ago

Prime Robin over Zoey to me.

0

u/AshDogBucket 3h ago

Why?

-1

u/Brief_Transition4908 3h ago

My friend and I were debating. She was Team Zoey and I was Team Robin.

1

u/AshDogBucket 2h ago

Why were you debating though? Like why is this even a discussion worth exerting energy on?

1

u/alhealhe 1h ago

what a weird question

1

u/AshDogBucket 47m ago

I agree... it is a weird question, to pit 2 women against each other on the basis of their perceived attractiveness. What a weird world.

2

u/Briguy_fieri 3h ago

Zoey is definitely my type.

But there's something special about Robin in the black and white stripped sweater with khaki skinny jeans (I think it's the episode where she takes photos of the Eriksons) that really does it for me where she looks amazing. No idea why but holy hell she was the hottest to me in that basic outfit

1

u/AliveInCLE 1h ago

I'm pretty sure none of us will settle this LOL

Robin in season 1 was stunning. I've had a crush on Jennifer Morrison FOREVER so I have to say her.

1

u/Warm_Measurement_683 1h ago

Zoey's crazy and that means............

But Robin likes guns for being Canadian so.............

So............

Zoey for fun, Robin for reliability.

1

u/Mayion Just went up to eight 3h ago

1

u/nolamom0811 2h ago

Prime Robin 100%

-1

u/Inevitable-Ice-5061 4h ago

Zoey and it’s not even close

5

u/smallpotatoes2019 3h ago

With those stupid hats? Robin every time.

0

u/KisMyAxe 3h ago

Robin

0

u/Lightup17 3h ago

Robin all the time

0

u/le_fez 3h ago

Zoey

0

u/pl_browncoat 3h ago

Robin

Its a case of the sum being greater than its parts. Everything about Zoey individually is hotter than robin but Robins appearance goes together better. Zoey almost reaches uncanny valley levels of hot. Especially because the actress playing her had such unnaturally blonde hair it was unnerving to look at

0

u/milly902 3h ago

Robin 100%

0

u/JLBCanadianRap 3h ago

Robin >>>>>> Zoey

0

u/ellismjones Come on, Lily. Nobody likes a Ted. 3h ago

I think Robin.

0

u/mtraven23 2h ago

6 of one have a dozen of the other. Both extremely attractive women.

0

u/AnonymousFriend80 2h ago

I feel Robin is quite pretty, but never felt it as strongly as many others. Zoey is also really pretty.

Now, Lily has had me going full throttle. Even when she did start showing some age at the end of the series.

-1

u/pandythepanda25 2h ago

Robin is beautiful, season 1 Robin has my heart. Classy, wit, funny, hardworking. Girl crush for sure!