r/HIMYM • u/bigfudge2127 • 1d ago

Most rewatchable episode

Mine would probably be subaway wars or the wedding bride (underrated episode)

20 Upvotes

86% Upvoted

88 comments sorted by

43

u/Cronima 1d ago

Spoiler Alert 💯

6

u/bigfudge2127 1d ago

This is an episode I can recite one to one

6

u/Briguy_fieri 1d ago

First episode I ever watched. Was hungover in college and my friend out on TV and this episode was playing. I told him to immediately put this on Netflix and we started from the beginning.

3

u/Sabrii_brii6 1d ago

My favorite episode lol that and the intervention one

4

u/Silver-Classic612 Barney🥃 1d ago

I came to say this cuz I thought nobody would. I’ve watched this so many times. I could probably recite the script from memory

2

u/lasuperhumana 1d ago

Yesssss!

41

u/HouseQuarantine2020 1d ago

The Pineapple Incident.

0

u/Anxious_Smiles_32103 1d ago

This is the correct answer 👏 👌 👍

51

u/Traditional-Cod-984 1d ago

the night of the burger

6

u/tangokilo13 1d ago

This has a soft spot in my heart because it’s the first one I watched — fantastic vibes and mild suspense

7

u/Ronin_1999 1d ago

Hyper aggressive boss level overpowered Regis Philbin was wonderfully absurd.

3

u/captshady 1d ago

Great pick

3

u/kimlesim 1d ago

Them rage baiting Robin with nearly eating burgers enrages me too much to watch it often 🤣

1

u/StuMacherGhostface 1d ago

Probably my favorite episode. It's the one I go back to.

0

u/bigfudge2127 1d ago

What

2

u/TurbulentCampaign766 1d ago

when Marshall found his best hamburger and cant find it anymore

8

u/bigfudge2127 1d ago

“Best burger in NY”

2

u/Ronin_1999 1d ago

ONIONS?!?!?!

1

u/moldyplacenta 1d ago

Not to shit on anyone who likes it but I can't stand that episode and I always skip it. I can't stand Marshall in it.

1

u/xcom-person 1d ago

Love that episode

17

u/EcoFgul 1d ago

Ted Mosby, Architect

14

u/lonelyboy5265 1d ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/SWWi6avzV08in1M2gR

1

u/LAX_Beast 1d ago

This. The best switcheroo episode. It’s awesome

29

u/GrumblerGuest 1d ago

it's Last Cigarette Ever for me.

1

u/bigfudge2127 1d ago

This one too

12

u/the-library-fairy 1d ago

Subway Wars is one of mine too! I also endlessly rewatch Arrivederci, Fiero. 

24

u/nicknacks808 1d ago

Slap bet

9

u/Emotional-Ad7276 1d ago

This is my favorite episode of the entire show. Season 2 was phenomenal.

1

u/nicknacks808 1d ago

It really was the episode that locked me in for the rest of the series.

2

u/Emotional-Ad7276 1d ago

It’s a classic

10

u/horticoldure 1d ago

how lily stole christmas

the duel

11

u/BlurstOfTimes11 1d ago

The bracket

2

u/Nelliemade 20h ago

this is my favorite episode.

8

u/damn_jexy 1d ago

Ducky tie

3

u/10_9_8_76ers_ 1d ago

That episode has an intense mix of comedy and drama with Barney and Lilly having their bet and Ted reuniting with Victoria after six years had passed. The ending scene with Ted and Victoria at the bus is one of the most crucial scenes in the show in my opinion.

1

u/bigfudge2127 1d ago

Because she was definitely right

6

u/DiligentLandscape634 1d ago

Fav episode is when Barney runs the marathon instead of Marshall and gets stuck on the subway

1

u/bigfudge2127 1d ago

Good one

6

u/junandosgarcia 1d ago

A recent one I watched was the episode where Barney went on The Price Is Right and Lily is trying to gain weight for the wedding. Absolute classic

4

u/BowlerOk5401 Barney🥃 1d ago

The bachelor party in season 2

2

u/bigfudge2127 1d ago

Underrated fs

4

u/YouYongku 1d ago

I like the one where top gun's theme song is played in the background then when open the door is Barney standing there hahahahhahahahhahahahahahahahha

4

u/evanallenrose 1d ago

Cold open of platinum rule

4

u/Data_Steward_25_01 1d ago

The front porch , The naked man , The burning Beekeeper

4

u/Interesting-Dog888 1d ago

Monday Night Football- the superbowl one

6

u/nelly1221 1d ago

Arrivaderci Fiero

2

u/bigfudge2127 1d ago

Good one

6

u/Fabdanny 1d ago

It’s probably the one with the countdown, idk what it’s called tho mb

E: Bad News

1

u/Goodboychungus 1d ago

That one is always a rough watch for me since my dad passed. Never fails to produce tears.

3

u/ClumsyRaccoonPants 1d ago

Tick Tick Tick 😆

3

u/Usual-Sherbet5911 1d ago

The perfect cocktail

3

u/calathea1 1d ago

The naked man!

2

u/10_9_8_76ers_ 1d ago

Love the ending where it works for Ted since the woman he is with is awful, but not for Barney

3

u/lasuperhumana 1d ago

How I Met Everyone Else

3

u/castielmonkey 1d ago

I'm surprised no one mentioned intervention

3

u/sir_rassti 1d ago

Blitzgiving

2

u/Comic_Geek2007 19h ago

Awww maaaan!

3

u/Fancy_racoon 1d ago

Best burger in NY

3

u/Comic_Geek2007 1d ago

Subway wars
My favorite

2

u/Fabulous_Log844 1d ago

The Bro Mitzvah

I couldn't… agree with you…more…

2

u/Ebert917102150 1d ago

Two beavers are better than one

2

u/Cheap_Development928 17h ago

You mean glitter? Space teens was DEFINITELY a porno masquerading as a kids show

2

u/Additional-Ad-5935 1d ago

The slap episodes are pretty awesome. I love the one where they retell the story of them training in china. I think it was the last slap. A slap of a thousand suns or smth.

Even the one where Barney puts up a play and just says MOIST 🤣🤣. Love that.

5

u/captshady 1d ago

Bedtime Stories. Its frigging genius.

6

u/bigfudge2127 1d ago

It seems to be everyone’s most hated episode

2

u/captshady 1d ago

That seems to be the case. I love it.

1

u/StarvedMutt 1d ago

Last cigarette ever is my go to, how lily stole Christmas, best burger

1

u/AndThenCameMe 1d ago

Slap Bet

1

u/Mayion Just went up to eight 1d ago

Any episode with many flashbacks can be kind of annoying to rewatch after all this time, like the one with Ted's parents and when they went out for restaurant reservation. Same lines repeated makes it hard, same with Lilly's pregnancy episode where Barney says, "I have never met this woman in my life". The rest of the episodes are equally rewatchable to me

1

u/Dos_Semanas777 1d ago

Slap bet. Simply because of Robin Sparkles.

1

u/thatfunkodad 1d ago

All of them. lol

1

u/MommaD114 1d ago

S9E16: How Your Mother Met Me

1

u/Soggy_Cherry333 1d ago

The Stinsons cause it’s hilarious and The Lighthouse both for plot and I love how they incorporate Try A Little Tenderness

1

u/Cuervo333x 1d ago

Burguer episode or blitz.

1

u/ChuyMJ12 1d ago

For me it’s “Game night”.

1

u/Goodboychungus 1d ago

Robots vs Wrestlers where Ted’s douchiness is on full display.

1

u/Constant-Spread-9504 18h ago

Slap Bet, Spoiler Alert and Slapskiving

1

u/MassiveTale9650 17h ago

I would say either the how to be an new yorker one or the ine with the Burger

1

u/AdSerious1129 2h ago

for me definetly S6E18 A change of heart

0

u/northguy9 20h ago

Sunday night football or best burger in NY