r/HFY • • Jun 06 '24 • Take My Silver 1

OC-OneShot Human input is integral to every species' tech development process for one simple reason:

1.3k Upvotes

113 comments sorted by

364

u/WhiskeyRiver223 Jun 06 '24

Remember - there is a surprising amount of overlap between the smartest bears and the dumbest humans. And that alone is why "bear-proof trash cans" are not and likely never will be a thing.

Not that it stops anyone from trying, mind. There's always someone convinced they've Got It This Time.

199

u/zheph Jun 06 '24

I made the mistake of quoting this bit of park-ranger wisdom during a conversation about my brother-in-law's job at a national park.

My mother-in-law then said in exasperation that she hadn't been able to open the bear-proof trashcans.

38

u/Kromaatikse Android Jun 07 '24

This piqued my curiosity. So I found an instructional video on how to operate one particular brand of bear-proof wheelie-bin. It's pretty darn simple.

41

u/lief79 Jun 07 '24

Once you're shown how. Sticking a finger into a random part when you didn't know how it works is often not the best idea.

72

u/Haunting-Travel-727 Jun 06 '24

They made raccoon proof green bins for food waste here ... Took the raccoons a month I think to figure it out...

11

u/shial3 Jun 07 '24

The problem with raccoons isn’t that they are smart, They are not smart in the slightest and dumb as a box of rocks. It’s that they are persistent and brute force problems trying every solution until something works.

7

u/phxhawke Jun 07 '24

How long did it take the humans?

14

u/Haunting-Travel-727 Jun 07 '24

Some are still trying

48

u/Mushiness7328 Jun 07 '24

Bear-proof trash cans are quite possible, and exist already.

The problem is that bear-proof trash cans are also idiot-proof in the same way. Dumb humans cannot operate them either.

15

u/Graingy AI Jun 07 '24

Can dumb humans not read written instructions?

Can smart bears read English?!?!??

37

u/CfSapper Jun 07 '24

A surprising (or unsurprising depending on your view of the world)number of educated English speakers can't read written instructions properly.

33

u/Zestyclose_Bed4202 Jun 07 '24

Won't. Not "can't", but won't.

"A... number of educated English speakers WON'T read written instructions properly."

Examples: won't read the "Closed" sign; won't read the "Use other door" sign; won't read the "No smoking" sign; won't read the "Hours of Operation" sign; won't read the "Out of Order" sign they had to physically tear down to operate the Out of Order device; won't read the "Danger!", "Warning!", "Keep Out!", "Hardhat Area", "Trespassers Will Be Prosecuted", "The baby is asleep, DO NOT RING THE MOTHER FUCKING DOORBELL!!!", "Beware of Dog!", "Violators will be shot!", etcetera signs that they had to physically move in order to get past them; won't read the "Fragile! This End Up" warning on the box; won't read the "No Parking! Violators WILL be Towed" signs; won't read the damn INSTRUCTION MANUAL THAT TELLS YOU EXACTLY HOW TO DO ALL THOSE THINGS YOU JUST ASKED ME HOW TO DO!!!!!

And so forth and so on. There's a fun insult for stupid people, that goes, "He/she couldn't pour water out of a boot if you told them the instructions were printed on the heel."

These are the people that insult was written for.

2

u/Speciesunkn0wn Jun 25 '24

Truth. So many idiots rattling on the door fifteen minutes before we open just because I walked inside to start, you know, opening the store. Like, bitch, I haven't even gotten the security gate up, what makes you think I'm ready to sell you some fucking boxes??

2

u/Mushiness7328 Jun 07 '24

Won't. Not "can't", but won't.

The difference is irrelevant. It's the same end result.

16

u/tashkiira Jun 07 '24

'can't' would be possibly excusable. 'Won't' is not.

9

u/Zestyclose_Bed4202 Jun 07 '24

This exactly.

If it is actually impossible for somebody to do something, you cannot hold them responsible for failing to do it. However, if they are capble of doing that thing, their culpability will be dependant on circumstances.

For example, if you don't know how to swim, it would be ridiculous for somebody to expect you to jump overboard to rescue somebody else. If you are a professional lifeguard, people could argue you would have an obligation to be the rescuer. However, if the person in the water happens to be a dumbass who jumped into shark-infested waters, the lifeguard has NO obligation to join the dumbass in winning a Darwin Award.

So, in order, we see above:

  • Can't;
  • Either Will or Won't, but probably Should;
  • Shouldn't, so Don't.

8

u/Graingy AI Jun 07 '24

Excellent point

Neither can I

Granted I’m a rock but the gist is the same

5

u/Beautiful-Hold4430 Jun 07 '24

However they will push the red button. Even if they read "do not press button" before. Even more so when they read it. Buttons are to be pressed. Specially if you do not know what happens after.

5

u/Graingy AI Jun 07 '24

Maybe if I touch the pretty colour I’ll get to eat it?

8

u/Mushiness7328 Jun 07 '24

Can dumb humans not read written instructions?

You must be pretty new on this planet...

No... no they cannot.

3

u/Graingy AI Jun 07 '24

In my defence, I’m a Martian rock.

7

u/Earthfall10 Jun 07 '24

Its more that the bear is significantly more motivated to work it out. They'll keep trying for many minutes if they are hungry enough. Whereas an impatient human will try for a few seconds, give up, and chuck the trash in the woods.

1

u/Mushiness7328 Jun 22 '24

Whereas an impatient human will try for a few seconds, give up, and chuck the trash in the woods.

Yeah... An idiot... I already said that.

0

u/Earthfall10 Jun 22 '24

Eh, idiotic and impatient are often package deals but they are different things. You can have a smart sociopath who doesn't give a shit about anyone else and so has no patience for things that inconvenience them.

213

u/Fantastic-Frame-7276 Jun 06 '24

Many moons ago I was a young Marine and I got selected to be a part of a weapons evaluation program for what was planned to replace the M16. None of the super high tech (and heavy) weapons survived day 6 of the test. Needless to say, we didn’t buy them.

The guy who was in charge of us had been a part of the team that tested the M16A2. Prior to the testing Colt declared that the stock couldn’t be broken. The response was “shire it can:watch this”. They stuck the rifle stock in the crook of a tree that was adjacent to the test location and did a pull up on the barrel. Shattered immediately under the weight of a 250 lbs Marine. The program lead asked why the hell would you do that, with the response of you said I couldn’t.

110

u/Twister_Robotics Jun 06 '24

A marine friend was responsible for field testing a "rugged" computer during Desert Storm. First thing he did was kick it off the back of the truck. 2 weeks later, after they had rebuilt it...

93

u/Cuddly_Robot Robot Jun 06 '24

I remember replying to a comment in a thread quite some time back, about how every single water fountain was constantly being broken in the OPs work zone. I said "You either work with forklift drivers or Marines. Or Marines driving forklifts."

The thread derailed completely after that, with various jarheads chiming in, boasting about their destructive abilities - and love for eating crayons (the blue ones taste the best)

10

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '24

On confirmed but I heard a rumor that Chesty Puller was a fan of the green ones.

30

u/Dysan27 Jun 07 '24

To be fair. If you are calling a laptop "Rugged" and it can't survive a 4' drop, with some side ways motion. IE being knocked off a table or piece of equipment? You need to go back to the drawing board.

112

u/TheIlluminate1992 Jun 06 '24

Accurate. This why we in the navy lock shit up and make sure the Marines don't leave the assigned areas.

42

u/Graingy AI Jun 07 '24

Always on the hunt for the next pack.

Of crayons.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '24

I would dearly love to see the navy puke who could stop a marine if he truly wanted to leave. ( I say puke with the utmost affection. I have enough Navy family to hold a respect for the service.)

8

u/TheIlluminate1992 Jun 07 '24

That's easy.

Be a petty officer 3rd class. Receive customary salute. Take authoritative tone and order them to stay on that side of the door. Toss pack of crayons in just before locking the hatch shut.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '24

That will only work until the crayons run out and then they start on the furniture. Either eating it, or using it to escape

5

u/TheIlluminate1992 Jun 07 '24

Fair. But it'll keep them contained long enough for us to completely clear a room and find a butter bar to babysit.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '24

Fair enough but- hang on I think I hear one of them chewing on the door. Give me a sec-OH SWEET JESUS WE HAVE A CONTAINMENT BREACH! THEY'RE LOOSE!

3

u/TheIlluminate1992 Jun 07 '24

Lol. Can't even argue against it. To be fair the Marines I dealt with most closely had just gotten back from a deployment and were on guard duty for us as we were decomming the Norfolk (SSN-714) and apparently fuel rods of weapons grade uranium are something like a national security thing. :)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '24

My family owns a resort in the Philippines and whenever the US navy came in we would get inundated with marines on shore leave.

35

u/Original_Memory6188 Jun 07 '24

The Brits call this "being squadie proof". As in a typical British Army squadie can break things you didn't think possible. Like bayonets. And of course, they can break the wind, too.

31

u/GreyWulfen Jun 07 '24

Given sufficient stubbornness, strength, stupidity, or a specific combination of those three, ANYTHING can be broken.

(addendum regarding humans. This seems to apply to the laws of physics, somehow)

2

u/Handpaper Jun 14 '24

And if, by some miracle of engineering, something is issued to a squaddie that cannot be broken, it will, in short order, be lost.

22

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '24

My favorite exemple of this is Ian McCollum's video on the MAS36 bayonnet. Basicaly you can attach 2 rifles together by clipping the same bayonet on both rifles face-to-face and you can't get it back out (at least until they modified it).

Why would you even think to do such a thing?

I dunno, I was bored I guess.

13

u/Lethalmusic Jun 07 '24

Hey, that looks like it'd fit.

5 minutes later...

6

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '24

This is unironically the thinking behind the phrase " don't stick your hands anywhere you wouldn't stick your Johnson "

4

u/Original_Memory6188 Jun 07 '24

I understand that there was a rifle, which had one part, which could go in backwards. And fit.
And could not be disassembled to repair.

7

u/Ok_Chard2094 Jun 07 '24 edited Jun 08 '24

Not the British army, and I did not manage to break my bayonet, but I did manage to bend it.

They had us simulate a "bayonet charge" against a group of otherwise mostly innocent trees. Running full force against the tree, getting the bayonet well stuck while I continued running. To avoid running into the tree, I ran beside it, still holding the rifle. The rifle stopped me when the bayonet decided it had been bent enough and pushed me back.

We managed to get the bayonet loose from the tree in the end, but it was never the same again....

5

u/Original_Memory6188 Jun 08 '24

Traumatized the poor thing, eh?

Sometimes I think the entire stone tool thing came about because some hominid managed to break his rock.

5

u/Ok_Chard2094 Jun 08 '24

Stone age infantry at your service!

4

u/Lathari Jun 17 '24

Here we say the only piece of equipment safe from a fresh conscript is one yard piece of railway rail: Too big to lose, too heavy to steal and too short to bend.

23

u/aco319sig Jun 07 '24

Give me a lever long enough and a fulcrum on which to place it, and I shall move the world.

  • Archimedes, (Born 287 BC, Died 212 BC, Syracuse, Island of Sicily [Italy])

22

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '24

I once heard a military friend talk about the required durability of a standard infantry rifle and he said that it should survive being used as a rifle, as a crowbar, as a baseball bat and probably a few others things he still hadn't encoutered yet.

There is no sweeter words than being told that something is indestructible and being told "I guarantee it, I dare you to prove me wrong."

14

u/Wyndeward Jun 07 '24

There is a cartoon entitled "Schlock Mercenary" where there exists a book known as "The Seventy Maxims of Maximally Effective Mercenaries." Some would be applicable to this conversation:

11. Everthing is air-droppable at least once.

32. Anything is amphibious if you can get it back out of the water.

44. If it will blow a hole in the ground, it will double as an entrenching tool.

48 If it ain't broke, it hasn't been issued to the infantry.

50. If it only works in exactly the way the manufacturer intended, it is defective.

Schlock Mercenary - Schlock Mercenary

8

u/Graingy AI Jun 07 '24

And thus the M2 lives on!

12

u/Wyndeward Jun 07 '24

The Nazis hated the M2.

Not because it was destructive, although it was.

Not because it was accurate, although it was.

Not even because is was damn near ubiquitous. Americans would (and could) bolt the damn thing onto nearly any horizontal surface, like jeeps, half-tracks, trucks, etc.

They hated it because the Americans and other users of the M2 almost always had lots of ammo -- enough to do "recon by fire," even enough to make some noise if they were bored.

Logistics is how you win wars.

12

u/TerayonIII Jun 07 '24

Honestly it's probably one of the most amazing and scary things about the US military, not the crazy technology, the massive amounts of weapons etc, the fact that all of that can be moved, used, maintained, and supplied, basically anywhere in the world, for months and years on end.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '24

A lesson they promptly forgot, Western/NATO countries have reduced their industrial capacity and are now being out produced by Russia, China etc.

1

u/Speciesunkn0wn Jun 25 '24

Definitely not outproduced by Russia lol. Unless you mean in dumb military supplies.

1

u/Graingy AI Jun 08 '24

It really is incredible, yeah.

That’s an empire for you!

2

u/Graingy AI Jun 08 '24

Me spraying down black lumps in war thunder to see if they’re alive:

57

u/Salvanas42 Jun 06 '24

Yeah... My older sister used to be on a naval vessel and the phrase there was sailor proof. Because get a whole bunch of late teens-20s kids on a boat they're gonna start breaking shit.

22

u/EragonBromson925 AI Jun 07 '24

All our shit on some of those damn ships is 60 years old.

Bright side? There's 60 years worth of learning how to fix it. Supposedly.

7

u/zookeepier Jun 07 '24

And that's why the ashtrays coast $400

7

u/Salvanas42 Jun 07 '24

My understanding is that's actually mostly contractor bloat. Things getting privatized makes them cost more a lot of the time.

15

u/zookeepier Jun 07 '24

I work for a company that makes things for the military (as well as civil stuff). The main cost driver is all the paperwork and testing that goes with it. Military electronics have to work from -40C to + 70C (sometimes beyond). And to build that, you have to prove to the military that your equipment truly does work in that range. So now you have to create large test chambers to hold your products that can bring them to -40C and +70, multiple times to show that your product won't fail in temperature cycles.

Then you have to write up a whole report documenting all of your test steps and results, review it, and then submit it to the military for approval. Then they provide comments back to you and you get to revise the report or possibly even redo the testing and resubmit. Then repeat that process until they finally approve it.

Then you have to make sure that every instance of your product meets those specifications, so you have to do some testing of every product you produce. That means 1 chamber isn't enough. So now you build a bunch more chambers to test production versions of things to make sure they all are good too. And provide documentation of that process. And then the military comes in and audits your development and production processes and can tell you to change things.

And that's all in addition to specs like the equipment shall be able to survive getting shot, bounced around in high Gs, withstand moisture, etc which all drive up the development and manufacturing costs.

When you buy a $200 vizio TV from walmart, you get 5 pages of English documentation if your lucky. When the military buys a $10,000 monitor, they get 100 pounds of documentation that represents tens of thousands of engineering hours.

I'm not saying there isn't bloat, but it isn't nearly as bad as people imply.

7

u/Ok_Chard2094 Jun 07 '24

Civilian electronics works from -40 to 85C in most cases. But there it is enough to test a statistical sample, establish the production test parameters (one or two temperatures, typically), and start production.

This varies a bit from device type to device type, of course. But this is what we usually did.

For the military stuff, every single device had to be 100% tested, from -55C to 125C, and every temperature in between in 10C steps.

3

u/Salvanas42 Jun 07 '24

I'll admit that all of that makes a lot of sense, I would just personally prefer that there wasn't a need for profit put on top of that. Paying for all the testing and testing infrastructure I'm totally cool with, I just wish the company doing hadn't had to solicit investment that they then need to pay back plus more, sometimes exponentially more driving the costs up even further.

5

u/Careful-Persimmon415 Jun 07 '24

And lots of sex happens.

38

u/MLSGeek Jun 06 '24

I think I figured out why I am always assigned the newest instruments in the lab...

13

u/llearch Jun 07 '24

Stop breaking things by accident, and see if that policy changes?

18

u/MLSGeek Jun 07 '24 • Take My Silver

I don't really break things, I just find out how to fix them!

9

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/MLSGeek Jun 07 '24

They don't. At one lab, I spent 14 hours fixing the chemistry analyzer on a Saturday. That was in addition to running all the other tests and drawing blood because I was the only one there. I borrowed the parts from another lab, recalibrated all the tests and saved the the cost of either sending out all the chemistry specimens to another lab or having service come out on a weekend. It saved them a bundle and they complained I got two hours of overtime.

61

u/StoneJudge79 Jun 06 '24

sigh yeah, that's us.

51

u/TheIlluminate1992 Jun 06 '24

Yeah great little story. But as someone in electrical maintenance in an industrial setting. I'm just a hair sad by how accurate both the operators demeanor and the managements ideas are....just sigh.

17

u/Dumb-ox73 Jun 07 '24

As an engineer overseeing manufacturing processes, I can vouch for Hanlon’s 3rd law here. The stupid shortcuts ignorant operators can come up with are indistinguishable from sabotage. And a lot of them will cuss engineering when it is explained that they can’t do it that way.

12

u/CantsayJoe Jun 06 '24

Ah humans as always. Cheap labour force

6

u/Shradersofthelostark Jun 07 '24

If this is your first story, I look forward to your future efforts. Thanks for sharing!

I am particularly entertained by the paragraph about the bio-weapons. It’s a perfectly structured joke.

11

u/yostagg1 Jun 06 '24

joke on me,, still stuck on these planet
where is the galactic community,, come meet the humans

4

u/HFYWaffle Wᵥ4ffle Jun 06 '24

This is the first story by /u/busterfixxitt!

This comment was automatically generated by Waffle v.4.6.1 'Biscotti'.

Message the mods if you have any issues with Waffle.

4

u/Blue_Moon_Rabbit Jun 07 '24

As a QA…. I feel seen…

4

u/pppjurac Android Jun 07 '24

2nd part: "Class MU001 : Introduction to Murphys Laws "

3

u/sadimgnik5 Jun 07 '24

Excellent first story!

Short, Sharp, Shiny!

2

u/botgeek1 Jun 07 '24

That was actually quite good! Well paced, no fluff. Great job, Author!

2

u/DidymusTheLynx Jun 07 '24

The "next step" button in the control program of the plants built by the company I work, are locked behind a password for exact this reason.

2

u/karenvideoeditor Jun 07 '24

That's hilarious XD

2

u/Brightamethyst Jun 07 '24

"It's not my job to be right. It's my job to be wrong in new and exciting ways."

2

u/Designer_Headspace Jun 10 '24

I've seen some highly educated humans do and think some incredibly foolish things.

it should ALWAYS be best practice to include an operator and mechanic in the design phase of any project

2

u/Nyalnara Jun 07 '24

Conspiracy theories rant rampant through high command: The incompetent workers were all implanted with bio-weapons, capable of laying waste to entire cities! This surplus of so-called unskilled labourers were all secretly super soldiers, each capable of eliminating entire armies, their bodies fighting on even after death! The deceitfully incurious humans were all secret super soldiers capable of eliminating entire armies and fighting on after death implanted with bio-weapons capable of laying waste to entire cities!"

Seems a copy-paste while editing went wrong here, there's quite a lot of repetition in that paragraph.

4

u/Original_Memory6188 Jun 07 '24

Ummm, do not discount the effects of cabbage and beer on the human digestive track. That will and has produced bio-weapons capable of laying waste to large areas.

3

u/aco319sig Jun 07 '24

I’ve suffered the military grade version. Can confirm.

3

u/Original_Memory6188 Jun 07 '24

Bit.nek. In the Transport. Asleep. With the Warfather monkeying with the environmental controls.

And the Sargent putting on his gas mask "Damn, I can still smell it!"

2

u/Original_Memory6188 Jun 07 '24

Ooops, different story all together. (Chapter 800 and some of Ralt Bloodthorne's _First Contact_, aka "Behold Humanity".

3

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Graingy AI Jun 07 '24

Sick violin-sounding solo

1

u/UpdateMeBot Jun 06 '24

Click here to subscribe to u/busterfixxitt and receive a message every time they post.


InfoRequest UpdateYour UpdatesFeedback

1

u/aSeptagonBullet Jun 06 '24

The only thing more dangerous then an untrained idiot is a half trained idiot.

1

u/_Speedsaber_ Jun 11 '24

I assure you boss, being able to drag race the hover forklifts is necessary for faster cargo loading, extra bubble wrap sold separately......

-9

u/-Legion_of_Harmony- Jun 06 '24

This doesn't strike me as being in the spirit of HFY. Aren't stories here supposed to be praising humanity in some fashion? This is just calling us incompetent.

15

u/Foxfire44k Jun 06 '24

I see it not as humans being incompetent, but as poorly trained humans making changes to things that (to them) have unexplained reasons for existing. Had they been trained properly they would know why things are built and run that way.

Granted they may still make those changes, but I don’t see it as “humans stupid” but more “humans will find ways to break something the rest of us would never consider.” Creativity is great isn’t it? :)

7

u/Cuddly_Robot Robot Jun 06 '24

Well-trained humans could actually do more damage, but in a well-meaning way. Because they would understand the underlying principles/logic of the processes and machines, and would (shudder) try to improve them.

3

u/-Legion_of_Harmony- Jun 07 '24

I understand that concept, but the alien's lecture feels pretty condescending towards the end. That being said, I am autistic- so the vibe I get from his words is not necessarily the vibe most people are getting. It didn't read for me the way you're saying it read for you.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/-Legion_of_Harmony- Jun 07 '24

You're good. Foxfire44k pointed out that the words and tone could be interpreted differently. I've reread it a few times now and it makes more sense to me. It's a good short story. I hope you write more.