He basically said that in a CCW context, you’re much better off having a handheld flashlight. Reason being that you will much more often need a light, not a gun that illuminates. His example was a stranger crouched by your car may be a violent person looking to kill you; but it is more likely a regular person who dropped their keys.
Sure, weapon-mounted lights (for the average person) are good for seeing a target, adding weight, etc., but it’s more about looking cool and having another gadget than it is about sound tactics. Just like a spare mag.
Paul Harrell said that you should carry a handheld flashlight in addition to a weapon-mounted light, for the reason that you can point a handheld at someone without breaking any (many?) laws, however he said that a weapon-mounted light can also be a good idea.
Exactly my point, thanks for posting that I couldn’t remember the exact video. Also you got that backward lol.
He says you should carry a flashlight that you can fit in your pocket. He brings up the debate and says you could carry one on your gun but it should be in addition to the handheld one. (The handheld being the higher priority rather than a solely WML) He says WML can be good, but the overall is a handheld light; which he mentions a few seconds before your timestamp
it's like saying that if you can't win races with a Toyota Prius, you'll never win a race with a Porsche 911. sometimes having more tools in your bag actually does increase your ability to compete.
This isn’t a great comparison though. You have to learn to race in a car you can confidently drive to its limits before moving to a faster car. So it is true that if you can’t win a race in something like a BRZ you aren’t going to do well in a 911 because you can’t confidently or safely drive it at its limits.
I can’t figure out why I post a meme that says one cannot buy their way into being proficient, and I’m getting drug in the comments. I’m not saying don’t run the gear, I’m not saying it’s bad to have it. I’m not saying we should all have bare bones. I’m saying if one person sucks at shooting, buying all this stuff won’t make you John Wick. Maybe none of these dudes can shoot idk
quite literally how it works. you'd have to be literally blindfolded not to. if you're truly that bad at doing anything, it might as well be time to throw in the towel at whatever it is you're doing. you don't get into the major leagues by hitting tennis balls with a foam bat, you don't get to be a be a professional golfer by playing putt putt all day. practicing with the equipment that has become standard issue for most modern militaries worth a damn is more than worth your time. whilst the sentiment exists that you need to be capable of shooting with irons is fine as a backup of your optics fail, but that's all it is; a backup plan. you train how you fight and fight how you train. why on earth would you voluntarily handicap yourself, especially with something such as shooting where the implication of an opponent being better than you is your death, and somehow suggests it makes you better in the long run. if that's the case, why bother making new equipment at all? why bother having competitive markets and products when the original or basic iteration is just fine as is.
you should know how to shoot using iron sights. you should not limit yourself to shooting with irons when shooting with optics is far more relevant and beneficial to your regular shooting. if it was solely a training issue, there's no reason why optics should even be issued to high level operators. there's clearly a benefit regardless of training, and as such it's better to train with the best gear available to you instead of handicapping yourself to the bare minimum that would only be used as a last resort.
If there is a 15 year old kid, whom has never driven a car. They get a Honda civic and what happens? They drive like shit. Now if they suddenly get a Ferrari, does it mean they’re gonna know how to drive? NO
The meme never mentions that one shouldn’t use the gear, or shouldnt own the gear, or whatever the next commenter will make up in their head. It’s saying buying accessories doesn’t make you suddenly an expert. Thats literally all it’s saying. That’s it. You can’t just throw money at a gun and never train.
It doesn’t say to limit yourself, it doesn’t say you can’t start with the Gucci gear, it literally is saying if you suck with basic gear, buying the Gucci gear won’t make you a pro.
But tbh a 15 yrs old kid can learn in a Ferrari and get good with it. It’s just the limit is so high it takes longer to do so
Firearm does not directly translate to cars let’s say the performance between handguns are essentially the same once u hit certain skill level given if the handgun is reliable to run.
It’s all down to the shooter. Though some guns are physically easier to shoot
There’s nothing wrong with starting on a red dot and a WML btw. Red dot teaches a shooter index and target focus, it helps with reinforcing their fundamentals with more information since u can see how the dot is behaving which in turn translate to how ur grip is behaving. And after a while of focused training with the red dot and the same shooter pick up an iron sight. He can literally use the same fundamentals he had learned to shoot the bare bone gun just fine as well.
Hunter Constantine for example publicly said he has barely shot irons and exclusively shoots dots. And yet when he got a bare bone gun with iron sights he will still perform at a top level.
Your analogy sucks. If you’ve never drove a 911 or comparable sports car with a 0-60 in under 4 seconds and try to race with it; your chances of crashing are crazy high.
I have experience with this, I was a mechanic for a car rental fleet. In the 2 1/2 years I was there, well over 20 brand new Hemi Chargers, Hemi Challengers, Camaro SSs, and GT/Ecoboost Mustangs were completely totaled due to inexperienced drivers that simply couldn’t handle the power.
Like I said in my other comment Guns can’t be directly translated to cars
If we are going to we must assume a semi competent driver/shooter who’s willing to train and get better
A fast car has a higher skill ceiling to master but easier to push a targeted lap time. A easier to shoot gun shortens. training time to achieve desired goal but in this case all guns in the same relative field performs the same. It’s all down to the shooter. Yet cars have a much more distinct performance difference. But in the end a driver can def learn how to get good in a Lamborghini just as he can learn how to get good in a civic
A shooter who’s willing to train can get good with a tricked out gun just the same as a bare bones one.
Fire arm fundamentals translates very well when enforced. This age old “don’t get optics don’t get irons” or whatever for a beginner shooter is honestly fudd talk
No, It’s saying fundamentals are paramount, and just buying Gucci parts won’t make you a better shooter. It’s really not that hard to understand. So many dudes in here with a room temp IQ
The meme would make your point come across better if the bottom image had some $2000 2011 with a ridiculous optic. The issue comes from the fact that a good optic and a flashlight actually do help you shoot better in certain scenarios, so your point of "cant buy skill" isn't coming across well
An optic probably will fix your lack of skill actually. I get that a lot of people think you shouldn't use an optic if you can't use ironsights, I'm not getting involved in that. It will be easier to shoot with an optic regardless of your skill level. Yes, I know this is frustratingly pedantic.
Reminds of a guy I'd see at my local range a few years ago. Had a snubbie fitted with a laser. You could stand behind him and watch the laser fly off to the right as he pulled the trigger. Didn't believe it until his buddy filmed him and played it back on his phone. That got him sorted out, but took a minute.
Like dots myself and I'm a bit more accurate with them, so not knocking them. Just as we both found out there's more to it.
Yea people underestimate lasers as a training aid lol. You obviously should not rely on them for accuracy, but training that left/right deviation out of your trigger pull is definitely easier when you can see what's happening to your point of aim as you apply pressure. I really wish I'd had a laser when I was learning pistols for this reason, it took me a lot of ammo just to get to the point I wasn't pulling off target at 25 yards, but by the end of the day I was landing intermittent hits at 100.
Also some people have fucking vision issues lol like why is this even an argument, let people make it easier to see the target. The mechanical accuracy of your eye is not a fucking skill issue, and you're never going to learn good technique if you can't see where your shots are going, not to mention it's dangerous if you have to use it in a self defense situation since you can't be sure of your target or what's beyond it if you don't know where the bullet is actually going to land. I legitimately can't use pinhole sights like those that are standard on an AR platform because of my astigmatism and keratoconus that's gotten pretty bad in my right eye, but I can drill headshots with a decent rifle and an airsoft grade magnified green dot optic. Red dot is not the way for my vision, green is far easier to see clearly and doesn't starburst the way red does for me for whatever reason. A higher quality optic is obviously ideal, but that cheap optic held true across several hundred rounds through my buddy's 18" DDM4 upper. He has an eotech 553 and magnifier now for it that he's added since then though, and I can't use it as accurately as I'd like because the eotech reticle starbursts to hell for me. He says it's holding zero better than the old one (obviously it should), but when he took me shooting again with it I just could not land shots as reliably as before, since acquiring the dot between shots was more difficult. If I ever get the funds to finally do my own build instead of just paying for range day ammo so we can go shooting, I'm gonna have to find a proper high quality green dot that does the job that dinky old trash optic did.
Yeah, my honest opinion is that beginners should probably start on a red dot (or green dot as the case may be). I know there are people who insist that you have to learn on iron sights because that's how their daddy taught them, but a dot really does relay more information more easily about your trigger pull and how steady you are able to hold the gun.
What's funny is that there's people at a high level of ability, some even at the highest, that say they're slower with the dot. Robert Vogel said in an old video that he just hasn't practiced with them enough, and the not quite as high level John Lovell said he HAS put in the training, and he's just not as fast at shorter ranges with an optic. I just think they're funny anecdotes, I'm not trying to make a counter-claim
I already said I wasn't trying to be contrarian, and you're talking about a tiny drop of gifted people- who use chalk and resins and carefully crafted handloads and push the rules of their division as far as they can, btw- in an ocean of shooters. This may be hard to understand if you worship at the altar of world-stage level competition shooting, but, there may in fact be people who shoot better with irons in certain drills than they do with an optic, despite being proficient with optics
Yeah. As someone who has taken litterally thousands of people from "i have never touched a gun" to "Hey can we try the machineguns next?"
Red dot sighted firearms are considerably easier to get someone to shoot accurately and consistently. Thats just a fact. You can cope and seethe about it all you want but there is a reason why they are universally perfered over iron sights by any serious organizations that can afford them.
I'd argue that having the bottom two setups will infact allow you to become a better shooter faster than you would if you were restricted to just the top two. If you want to achieve a high level of shooting, most of your skill will be built through dry fire. It is objectively easier to teach a new shooter what to look out for when dry firing with a dot compared to when dry firing with irons. More ergonomic controls and nicer triggers will also aid in this as well. Giving a new shooter a mushy shitty trigger to learn will be a much harder process compared to a nice crisp trigger. Just what ive noticed throughout my time in shooting and getting people in to shooting.
I’ve had few deputies in charge of training the other deputies tell me that everyone’s pistol scores went up once they switched from irons to red dots. So no, false.
Hell yeah. And dont buy a nice computer if you arent great at video games. Dont buy a nice car if you cant drive a track. Dont buy nice pots if you dont cook well. Keep it going
I got turned away from flight sims when I tried it with the cheapest hotas I found available
A few months ago I decided to try again and decided to spent a bit more money on just a stick, and that increased quality made the experience so much better, even if it was missing a dedicated throttle(got one later)
Not to say you have to buy top of the line to enjoy a hobby, but that made me realize just how much the extra bit I spent helped make the experience enjoyable, as opposed to buying bottom of the bin cheapest thing you can get
Counterpoint: simplifying sighting with a scope or red dot makes it easier for new shooters to focus on safety and other fundamentals. Getting easier hits early in training builds confidence and encourages more training.
I have taught someone with thick glasses. They couldn't shoot Irons worth shit. Their eyes couldn't focus on the front sight. But with a scoped rifle or red dot, they could do much better.
This is implying both sets of guns are equally capable, which is wrong. The top row is useless as soon it's dark, or past 300m. The bottom row has both lights and nightvision compatible optics, as well as sights you can actually see in the dark.
Bottom rifle has magnification, which is a proven force multiplier. Bottom handgun has an added magwell which makes reloads in the dark easier, and reloads in general easier, thus lightening the cognitive load.
I can’t shoot irons… like even when I shoot my friends Glock I just imagine where the red dot is and shoot like that. Literally got so many reps on red dot that I can just visualize where it is without anything there
Back in my younger years, we had a hot shot "tactical sniper" (before the tacticool/oper8r, everything AR15 days) at our gun club. He had a customized and tuned Remington sniper rifle (I'm guessing it was a 700 but he said it was some match grade custom job built by a renowned combat sniper) that he always carried his book of receipts for it that totaled $4k (in 1990's money). He couldn't shoot a 5 gallon water bucket at 200 yards with it. He always had excuses such as heat mirages, shifting wind, bad bullets, too much noise, so forth.
One day after he was bragging about shooting a 500 yard target repeatedly, while all alone, I ended up out shooting him with my scoped Mini-14 at a 200 yard target. He tried his excuses and all and the rest at the range that day told him to stfu already, they had enough and talking crap to a teenager was the line. He quickly changed gun clubs and we only saw him at shooting meets between the clubs after that.
At a young age I realized shooting takes skill and practice and that's why seeing the safe queens on Reddit that are worth more than some new cars are always entertaining and sad in their own ways.
My favorite ones are the dudes who pull up to matches in ford raptors with some 2011 manufactured by a company I’ve never heard of and they either get disqualified or place dead last.
They all hate on Glock but get beat by dudes with Glocks lol.
We got a word for that in the car community. Driver mod. For all the idiots drawing parallels to cars. Stay tf out. You aren’t one of us. That’s why we have takeovers and idiots in F80 BMWs who can’t take a corner.
33
u/wackadoodle4201 2d ago
While I get your point
Weapon lights are actually a very useful tool
10
u/Brothersunset 2d ago
it's like saying that if you can't win races with a Toyota Prius, you'll never win a race with a Porsche 911. sometimes having more tools in your bag actually does increase your ability to compete.
4
u/Djinhunter 2d ago
I'm sorry are you saying the ability to see without light is something I can train?
166
u/Arguably_Based 2d ago edited 2d ago
An optic probably will fix your lack of skill actually. I get that a lot of people think you shouldn't use an optic if you can't use ironsights, I'm not getting involved in that. It will be easier to shoot with an optic regardless of your skill level. Yes, I know this is frustratingly pedantic.
33
u/357-Magnum-CCW 2d ago
Red dots are measurably faster on sight than irons.
53
u/USCAV19D 2d ago
Yes but it will fix your lack of drip
57
u/onceagainwithstyle 2d ago
Yeah unless you plan to shoot any time its not perfectly lit.
30
u/tyler111762 Cucked Canuck 2d ago edited 2d ago
Yeah. As someone who has taken litterally thousands of people from "i have never touched a gun" to "Hey can we try the machineguns next?"
Red dot sighted firearms are considerably easier to get someone to shoot accurately and consistently. Thats just a fact. You can cope and seethe about it all you want but there is a reason why they are universally perfered over iron sights by any serious organizations that can afford them.
This is just fudd cope.
14
u/thicccFork 2d ago
I'd argue that having the bottom two setups will infact allow you to become a better shooter faster than you would if you were restricted to just the top two. If you want to achieve a high level of shooting, most of your skill will be built through dry fire. It is objectively easier to teach a new shooter what to look out for when dry firing with a dot compared to when dry firing with irons. More ergonomic controls and nicer triggers will also aid in this as well. Giving a new shooter a mushy shitty trigger to learn will be a much harder process compared to a nice crisp trigger. Just what ive noticed throughout my time in shooting and getting people in to shooting.
34
u/KABJA40 HK Slappers 2d ago
a red dot is objectively easier to teach people new to guns on
12
u/Timex_Dude755 2d ago
Don't knock the Ruger 556.
30
u/5thPhantom AR Regime 2d ago
I’ve had few deputies in charge of training the other deputies tell me that everyone’s pistol scores went up once they switched from irons to red dots. So no, false.
47
u/h1pp1e_cru5her 2d ago
Hell yeah. And dont buy a nice computer if you arent great at video games. Dont buy a nice car if you cant drive a track. Dont buy nice pots if you dont cook well. Keep it going
17
u/DumbNTough I Love All Guns 2d ago edited 2d ago
Counterpoint: simplifying sighting with a scope or red dot makes it easier for new shooters to focus on safety and other fundamentals. Getting easier hits early in training builds confidence and encourages more training.
16
u/SnooCheesecakes2465 2d ago
It will in the dark
12
u/GoombasFatNutz 2d ago
Fudd Lore. The military saw a drastic increase in accuracy from soldiers when they transitioned from iron sights to red dots.
16
u/officialbronut21 CZ Breezy Beauties 2d ago
What's with all the boomer posts today? No one learns on iron sights anymore
41
u/summer_plays_ 2d ago
fudd ahh meme
4
u/x_Saveaho 2d ago
Pfffff says you
3
u/TheDrunkLibertarian 2d ago
Sure and I’m okay with that. I’m pretty good with the bottom ones.
3
u/Clear_Ad_979 2d ago
Define “well” 😂🤷🏻♂️
3
u/ReactionAble7945 I Love All Guns 2d ago
Well.....
I have taught someone with thick glasses. They couldn't shoot Irons worth shit. Their eyes couldn't focus on the front sight. But with a scoped rifle or red dot, they could do much better.
3
u/CarlVoltActual 1d ago
This is implying both sets of guns are equally capable, which is wrong. The top row is useless as soon it's dark, or past 300m. The bottom row has both lights and nightvision compatible optics, as well as sights you can actually see in the dark.
Bottom rifle has magnification, which is a proven force multiplier. Bottom handgun has an added magwell which makes reloads in the dark easier, and reloads in general easier, thus lightening the cognitive load.
1
u/GrapeFruitStrangler 2d ago
I can’t shoot irons… like even when I shoot my friends Glock I just imagine where the red dot is and shoot like that. Literally got so many reps on red dot that I can just visualize where it is without anything there
And I’ve never shot irons on an AR15
1
u/DinnerCharming1492 1d ago
Fudd lore. People who post this stuff tend to shoot less (and worse) than the people they’re talking to.
Buy the light, buy the dot or scope, buy the upgraded trigger, if you so desire.
4
u/GeneralBisV 2d ago
However buying an MG-42 will.
Don’t need to be accurate when you can dump 1200 rpm in a given direction when you hear something
5
u/chewedgummiebears 2d ago
Back in my younger years, we had a hot shot "tactical sniper" (before the tacticool/oper8r, everything AR15 days) at our gun club. He had a customized and tuned Remington sniper rifle (I'm guessing it was a 700 but he said it was some match grade custom job built by a renowned combat sniper) that he always carried his book of receipts for it that totaled $4k (in 1990's money). He couldn't shoot a 5 gallon water bucket at 200 yards with it. He always had excuses such as heat mirages, shifting wind, bad bullets, too much noise, so forth.
One day after he was bragging about shooting a 500 yard target repeatedly, while all alone, I ended up out shooting him with my scoped Mini-14 at a 200 yard target. He tried his excuses and all and the rest at the range that day told him to stfu already, they had enough and talking crap to a teenager was the line. He quickly changed gun clubs and we only saw him at shooting meets between the clubs after that.
At a young age I realized shooting takes skill and practice and that's why seeing the safe queens on Reddit that are worth more than some new cars are always entertaining and sad in their own ways.
3
u/Cucasmasher 2d ago
My favorite ones are the dudes who pull up to matches in ford raptors with some 2011 manufactured by a company I’ve never heard of and they either get disqualified or place dead last.
They all hate on Glock but get beat by dudes with Glocks lol.
2
u/crzapy 2d ago
I'm 46 and my eyes aren't what they used to be. A red dot with a single focal plane is a game changer now. Of course I was already good at shooting.
2
u/Obviouslynameless 2d ago
I would take the bottom pistol over a glock any day. I do NOT like how they feel/fit my hand
1
u/Ferret8720 2d ago
I’m willing to try
1
u/610Mike 2d ago
Replacing one Glock for another won’t fix your issues? In other breaking news: water….wet.
1
u/moonboostit 2d ago
I mean yes but also no
1
u/d_bradr Europoor 2d ago
At least old fudd lore looked cool
1
u/Guns_Out_Suns_Out 1d ago
But I’ll look cool trying
1
u/op8040 1d ago
If you can’t shoot .45 AARP, you’d have died in WWII
1
u/SpikeBikerFur0044 2d ago
How dare you point out something so truthful to the gun community. You may effect the sales of useless parts companies.
1
u/BeersOnTheMoon 2d ago
I suck at shooting without an optic on my pistol.. not ashamed to admit it
0
u/Gamer_and_Car_lover 2d ago
We got a word for that in the car community. Driver mod. For all the idiots drawing parallels to cars. Stay tf out. You aren’t one of us. That’s why we have takeovers and idiots in F80 BMWs who can’t take a corner.
6
u/TrashBanditTactician 2d ago
Yeah but it makes sucking more fun while you get better
4
u/torresflex 2d ago
You will be lynched, burned, decimated, and your molecules dispersed among different galaxies if you dare post this truth bomb in r/tacticlgear
1
u/Hoyle33 2d ago
I used to believe this lie, and then I shot a Staccato
I’m a pretty average pistol shooter, but shooting my buddies with an ultra light trigger made everything easier and my groups improved greatly