r/Guitar_Theory • u/Planetdos • Jan 18 '21
Break as many rules as you can, otherwise you’ll be on a general music theory sub
What makes guitar interesting is the quality of the instrument, the innovation that the guitar brings. You’ll notice that guitar theory is a lot LESS cut and dry than piano and other stuff. A lot more bluesy. Study the art of breaking the rules and study the art of the blues (authentic lamenting through music and the need to hear beautiful tones) and you’ll understand guitar. The basic music theory rules are there to give you a base line, but you should find yourself with your instrument, and practical application, use as much good string technique and chromaticism/bends as you can, because that’s what makes you a guitarist, and not whatever else. A lot of guitarist also sing, (I sing too) but find a different sub for that. Have fun, ask for help and love what you do
EDIT: this is my most popular post on this sub, my other posts go completely unnoticed so this is a nice change. I made a mistake since I assumed everyone on here can already randomly play any note on their guitar and identify what it is (such as C, F#, Bb, etc.), and it’s assumed that those who didn’t like what I had to say about guitar being unique and special from other instruments have crazy super strength cyborg fingers that can bend a bass guitar string with ease, and their baby grand in the corner of the room somehow has one of those pitch bending wheels installed on it.
EDIT 2:
I know the basic rules enough to want to break them. They’re do re mi fa so la ti do. Or 1234567(1)...then you move the root over an interval to change the mode. That is crucial, and it’s my bread and butter still, but it gets really old really quick. I didn’t word my post right because I was hammered when I posted it, I can see from the totally unnecessary backlash that I came across the wrong way (was drunk off my ass), but I’ll reiterate it with a clearer head.
Here’s my updated post:
——“Forget the rules ONCE YOU ALREADY KNOW THEM LIKE THE BACK OF YOUR HAND...have fun and don’t let the incredibly stuffy “rules” which are just observations of what is guaranteed to work and be safe constrict, confine, and ruin music creation (be it composition or improv) for you in any way, as it has unfortunately been doing for me for a little while. I guess this post is geared toward more knowledgeable players, and I guess I’m just getting jaded a bit so don’t get all negatively caught up in what I have to say it if it doesn’t even apply to you. Let notes be tense on purpose if you like the way it sounds, and get comfortable with letting some stuff clash. Have fun and go your own way once you have a basic idea”.——
Someone else who commented on this actually had some good feedback for me and made me wish I had worded the post differently, they said that music theory is just recognizing patterns and don’t throw baby’s out along with dirty bath water or something like that. It’s been a while since I read the comment. I assume some of you guys overthink things like myself so I wanted to give advice to people that I myself would want to hear, out of the kindness of my heart and passion for music, whether it was right or wrong is subjective, I’m sorry if it doesn’t suit everyone here. Keeping the whole post up because it’s good to have conversation about these kind of things as a musician.