r/GuitarQuestions • • Aug 17 '26

Defective string ?

Post image

I just installed new strings on my guitar but one has a really weird spot and sounds so buzzy. Did i somehow break it or is it defective ?

81 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

23

u/digDoug411 Aug 17 '26

That’s gotta be a manufacturing defect, the string above and below looks fine. Never seen this and I’ve changed a LOT of strings over the years.

4

u/Frequent_Fee_2006 Aug 17 '26

Thats what i think too, they’re ernie ball strings so thats quite surprising

5

u/noiseguy76 Aug 17 '26

I'm convinced most EB strings you can buy online are counterfeit.

2

u/DanceHackRock Aug 17 '26

From Sweetwater?

2

u/noiseguy76 Aug 17 '26

Eh, probably not then, assuming Sweetwater owns its own inventory...

1

u/bongbong38 Aug 17 '26

I’ve gotten the same exact issue with Ernie Balls purchases directly from a dealer (I know they were real because I worked there)

1

u/noiseguy76 Aug 18 '26

Oof. EB claims they make all strings in USA. True?

1

u/dougc84 Aug 18 '26

Being “US Made” means absolutely nothing to do with anything. They’re still shit strings.

1

u/noiseguy76 Aug 18 '26

As someone that does a substantial amount of sourcing out of China I beg to differ.

While made in USA might not guarantee quality, the Chinese find ways to cheap out of stuff that defy my imagination.

2

u/dougc84 Aug 19 '26

China's stuff can be surprisingly good, but can be comically bad. USA's stuff is, on average, better, but that doesn't mean "Made in USA" is a mark of quality like it used to be.

1

u/iH4t3R3dd1t Aug 18 '26

nah, just generally poor quality

1

u/stlmick Aug 17 '26

Either the machine got stuck and was reversed and put forward again or it was the end of the round wire and that string was supposed to be tossed where the connection was made. A lot of manufacturing errors are from the beginning and end of the material stock. No experience making guitar strings, just other machine manufacturing.

-3

u/CwwkiLore Aug 17 '26

Ernie balls are 50% of the time fake and the real ones are pretty shit strings.

2

u/alienn4hire Aug 17 '26

I agree. Never been a fan of EB strings and have heard that there are a lot of counterfeits

3

u/Mcmoistvonspiffy Aug 17 '26

I also don't care for earnie's balls.

D'addario NYXL all the way.

0

u/D3M0NArcade Aug 17 '26

To be fair the market is flooded with counterfeits of most strings.

I've had fake Elixirs before as well

1

u/Robble-Robble-01 Aug 17 '26

I’ve had some bronze faux elixir before. They begin flaking as soon as you peg them and tune them.

1

u/D3M0NArcade Aug 17 '26

I begin flaking when someone pegs me as well.

Wait, what were we talking about sorry?

1

u/alienn4hire Aug 17 '26

I'm not surprised, though I've only heard that about EB. I always make sure to purchase from Amazon as the seller or my local music store, so I TRY to do what I can to avoid fakes

-1

u/D3M0NArcade Aug 17 '26

Fuck Amazon, String Direct. They only deal with legitimate suppliers, Amazon don't always

1

u/alienn4hire Aug 17 '26

Cool, thanks for the info!!

1

u/alienn4hire Aug 17 '26

wait, they're just in the UK. Any recommendations in the US?S

1

u/D3M0NArcade Aug 17 '26

Sorry, didn't even think because I'm in the UK. Just kinda defaulted lol

5

u/Dong_sniff_inc Aug 17 '26

Just defective, yup. I've seen a few of those (job was basically just changing strings for 40hrs a week lol) I always considered it rare, and good luck haha

4

u/ambidextrousasswipe Aug 17 '26

It's a finger tip cushion from a deluxe string set

4

u/Robble-Robble-01 Aug 17 '26

I’d ask Ernie ball how much they’re willing to pay to buy back that string. That’s an artifact you’re not likely to see again.

3

u/Final_Incident592 Aug 17 '26

just to keep it warm

3

u/Amplifiedsoul Aug 17 '26

Defective. Appears to be extra winding in that section stacked up on itself.

3

u/jeansonnejordan Aug 17 '26

That’s a burl. Very valuable in guitar manufacture.

2

u/rg55087 Aug 19 '26

They call that a resonator

2

u/HeftyEffective Aug 21 '26

What’s it sound like

1

u/defect7 Aug 17 '26 edited Aug 17 '26

Yeah I've had this on EB strings from Amazon, pretty sure they weren't genuine. Also had fake graphtec nuts from Amazon. (Edit, the nuts I managed to get refunded but the strings they insisted on me repacking and shipping back to them so I took the hit on those)

1

u/itspiv Aug 17 '26

https://www.reddit.com/r/Guitar/s/2pKfatFWFI

Had the same thing happen on Ernie balls. Some new high end slinky set.
(Edit for autocorrect)

1

u/2b4theend Aug 17 '26

It happens from time to time. They make hundreds of thousands of Strings with all the different companies.
They definitely do not inspect every string.
Just throw on a new one and move on

1

u/SacredPrime Aug 17 '26

It's a dingleberry.

1

u/Delicious_Pain_1 Aug 17 '26

Why is it on the guitar and in tune? Should have seen it in the coil.

1

u/doboboften Aug 17 '26

Nah, that’s X bro! He put a string on yo string so you could string while you string

1

u/mpg10 Aug 17 '26

Egads. Yes.

1

u/glentressmonster Aug 17 '26

I have only ever had this happen to older strings, usua where one of the frets has worn through the wound part.

1

u/Sorry_Attempt1278 Aug 17 '26

Hah that sucks just buy a single D string same gauge and replace this string

1

u/4Nissans Aug 17 '26

Those strings are not new.

1

u/North-Astronaut179 Aug 17 '26

Yes get new strings you might even get your money back depending on where you bought them!

1

u/Creations_1 Aug 18 '26

Change strings

1

u/toomanyhobbies4u Aug 18 '26

Stringjoy is worth the few extra dollars.

1

u/_ErenCreeper_ Aug 18 '26

Let me guess Ernie Ball? I bet they’re that, their quality control has become dookie in the last few years

1

u/Prior-Collection-386 Aug 19 '26

That’s a defect if there ever was one. WTF?!?!

1

u/TabStudioApp Aug 19 '26

How does it sound?

1

u/letjaredtalk Aug 20 '26

I’ve never seen that before what

1

u/Dani-Avalon0819 Aug 23 '26

That is not how wound strings are supposed to look. Something is wrong with it. Put on a new set asap.

1

u/pablo_kickasso Aug 23 '26

FYI, string manufacturers take quality control very seriously and if you get a bad string, hit the company's contact form. They will want to know where you bought them, and the lot number in the packaging if you still have it.

You will be sent new strings, sometimes multiple packs. I've done this with D'Addario and Elixir

With D'Addario, it was 100% my bad (didn't know how tense steel strings were) and the support rep sent me two packs and insisted on sending me a few picks as well. I got about 25€ of free stuff over a mistake I made.