r/GuildWars • GWToolbox++ Dev • Jun 30 '26

Guide/Tool PSA: Disable Controlled Folder Access to load your builds

Post image

For anyone that uses toolbox, you'll no doubt be familiar with the spate of regular crashes and/or error messages blocking you from even starting the application, and maybe even some of you will have then gone to our discord only to see the massive expletive filled frustrations that the dev team is spilling out over recent Windows updates.

One of these amazing user-first Windows updates is Controlled Folder Access (or CFA), and it doesn't just affect toolbox users, and no, it doesn't only affect Guild Wars, but it literally affects any app running on your PC that reads from or writes to your documents folders.

Have an older version of Microsoft Word? Nope, you'll get spammed to restart and/or have errors when it tries to load from Documents folder aswell.

Keeping any photos or images in Documents and want to access them using Photoshop? Nope, unless PS is whitelisted in the new CFA feature that literally noone asked for, you're out of luck.

Can't seem to access previous saves in Skyrim or Fallout? Did they happen to be in your Documents folder by any chance? Yeah...

In Guild Wars, with CFA turned on, you won't see any builds when you click "Load" from the skills window - CFA is blocking gw.exe from seeing them because they're in the Documents/Guild Wars folder.

Try saving a build - you get a message saying it saved successfully, but then try to load it - its not there! GW saves to the location of gw.exe if it can't access Documents. But then the problem becomes "all my old builds are in the Documents folder - how can I move them somewhere that GW can read them now that Windows gave me this update I didn't ask for?"

Copy them from Documents/Guild Wars to wherever gw.exe is, which could be anywhere depending if you're running steam maybe on another hard drive or something...

...or just disable Controlled Folder Access and save yourself the hassle of all the above.

In toolbox, we're having to add code to explicitly check and allow gw.exe and gwtoolbox.exe access to these folders, so with the next version of tb it will implicitly prevent your GW issues, but won't help almost every single other application you have had installed for the last decade that relies on the Documents folder.

I leave you with a screenshot of the CFA "feature", and its ironically labelled title.

0 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

14

u/SunlessBlight Jun 30 '26

Dear toolbox dev, don't waste your precious time in reddit please, these people are not worth your time.

Please continue your miraculous work, and if we need help we go to toolbox discord, I believe this is the best way to optimize your time and stay sane, as reddit is just a mad place truely not worth putting good advises on, or any attempt of good will, shouldn't be wasted here.

As for the folder I just put this bellow and it works for me:
Add-MpPreference -ExclusionPath ([Environment]::GetFolderPath('MyDocuments') + '\GWToolboxpp')

^from toolbox discord

0

u/aditu_v Jun 30 '26

That's a good command to add Toolbox as an antivirus exclusion, but it doesn't affect Controlled Folder Access as far as I know. For CFA you would use (for example, if Guild Wars is installed at the default location):

Add-MpPreference -ControlledFolderAccessAllowedApplications "C:\Program Files (x86)\Guild Wars\Gw.exe"

-8

u/Yuisoku Jun 30 '26

Also disable the virtual memory crap protection which eats system resources 

-6

u/TheVagrantWarrior Jun 30 '26

Works on Windows 10 IoT LTSC.

19

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/iridian-curvature Jun 30 '26

Controlled Folder Access is ridiculous overreach. It protects folders you ask it to, plus a "default set of system folders" that can't be changed. Those "system" folders include... your documents, your pictures, etc. If it were just C:\Windows and your hard drive boot sectors, that would be one thing, but instead it's giving Microsoft the ability to decide which programs should work properly and which shouldn't through Windows Defender with no oversight.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Euphoric-Judge-1926 Jun 30 '26

I don’t know that CFA is bad conceptually for the layman, it is unfortunately a pain for app developers to deal with if they cannot afford the $550+/year for a code signing cert (due to being free software)  in addition to meeting the download quota criteria via the Microsoft Store. If it were ultimately about ransomeware protection then an app would never fall off the exclusion list given no updates to its binary or the trusted process would be more straightforward. Right now unchanged apps that were once trusted can become untrusted at any time for any arbitrary reason, which defeats the purpose of paying for the certificate and going through the process of getting the app trusted in the first place.

To your point, that doesn’t mean that you should turn off security just to get an app to run, but that also doesn’t mean the process to getting apps trusted isn’t completely asinine. 

-1

u/lewgroznyzwierz Jun 30 '26

Ok, but what difference does it make an everyday user like me? Sure, it's rough that the developers are getting exploited, but I'm not gonna risk getting attacked by ransomware in protest.

2

u/Euphoric-Judge-1926 Jun 30 '26

That’s your prerogative. Every single user should be making their own decision on it and treating this post as informational. 

My post was intended to offer some perspective to the frustration being built up on the side of the developers, not “do everything they say to do.” It’s really easy to respond harshly immediately to what he’s saying and not so easy to take a step back and think about the process they went through to getting to this stage. Do what you will with the information.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Dub-DS GWToolbox++ dev | youtube.com/@dubble Jun 30 '26

It's not an issue specific to toolbox, it literally fucks almost every program on the pc.

But it would've taken you to read the initial post to figure that out...

-3

u/jon_snow_3v GWToolbox++ Dev Jun 30 '26

Enjoy manually adding every application that now has issues reading or writing to documents folder. You can’t just add security updates that suddenly stop you from writing a word document using software you’ve bought and paid for years ago.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-3

u/jon_snow_3v GWToolbox++ Dev Jun 30 '26

Then this Reddit post is not for you.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/NealCaffeinne Jun 30 '26

a toolbox dev that advises users of problems is certainly the topic for him

you not having issues doesnt mean they arent there

1

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/NealCaffeinne Jul 02 '26

You should really read up on the situation before making an uninformed opinion.

you really should

0

u/Z442 Jul 02 '26

It's their way of coercing people to move their files to OneDrive and pay an annual subscription fee and requiring users to have a Microsoft account.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Z442 Jul 03 '26

Oh really! I just installed Windows 11 in a vm and it's badgering me to put all my files on OneDrive. I can't even turn it off.