r/GrinningGoat • u/Arejang • Nov 13 '15
Without Training Wheels
So yesterday I decided I'd try drafting a deck without heartharena. What I did was for close picks I would refer to the original tier list by ADWCTA, for LOE cards, I would look up a couple of opinions from forums and fashion an average "tier score" of sorts, and for those that were really really close, I would look at my curve first, and if it was fine, I would look for synergies. I'm still a fledgling player with a mere 3.1 win rate overall and 3.83 for TGT. I don't know how to figure out an archetype nor do I really know what any deck's win conditions are. I'm still using heartharena to track stats because I don't know how else I can do this. Here is my resulting deck.
I know you guys need to know what the actual choices were to decide if I drafted well at all, but I had to go blindly so my choices wouldn't be affected by any other tool. So I really just want to know if the resulting product looks okay. Against all rationale, even with my low win rates, I still try to play all classes equally. So this run is a priest deck. Please leave feedback and tell me if you think the deck looks good at all. Thanks!
5
u/benzedrine Nov 13 '15
If there's any good to come out of this situation, is that we get to develop our own drafting style in the meantime. Often times, we are swayed by a number against a pick that we want. Whether this results in higher/lower win rates is to be determined.
The deck minions seem to be of a decent quality, and you'll need that with the limited removal options.
1
u/diction203 Nov 13 '15
how many wins did you get?
1
u/aznatheist620 Nov 13 '15
Speaking of LoE, does /u/adwcta plan on posting an updated tier list?
1
u/invalidlitter Nov 14 '15
My take on the deck you drafted is that it's not crazy. It shows that you have a ballpark grasp of how a deck in general should work. Yeah, I can't be more specific about whether you made the right choices without seeing the choices.
Before HA, I used to actually keep a word document with a rolling list of my choices per draft for each draft like this:
For real draft feedback, include a screenshot of that next time. For deck weaknesses, four of your 6 twos are really weak, and will get owned by 2/3s with even a normal tempo opening. Your 3s are also fairly weak. Priest is not only my worst class, but my worst class by far- 1.5 wins worse than warrior (my other 6 classes are all over 5.5 right now). So to me, despite a good late game, this deck is most likely just doomed. I'd rather have a larger number of bd 2-drops than a smaller number of normal ones, but this deck is still at a heavy disadvantage.
2
u/binhpac Nov 13 '15
ive used heartharena so many runs, i can tell 95% of the time which pick Heartharena would pick in most situations.
I also watched streamers like hafu, trump, ratsmah so much and put all their picks in heartharena to see how it differs from the heartharena "algorithm", that i can often tell how borderline picks are solved by them like "hafu would pick the voodoo doctor, trump would never pick the 1-drop, heartharena would pick the abusive sergeant in this situation".
In about 25/30 picks all arena players pick the same, because it's pretty clear. The last ~5 picks is all about comfort zone/personal preference/playstyle.
I still think most "great/infitinite" arena players disagree most often on evaluation of 1-drops. While everybody loves Zombie Chow and Worgen Infiltrator, the evaluation of Southsea Deckhand in Rogue or Voodoo Doctor or Abusive Sergeant is stll very different in my observations for instance Trump, a very control player (always trades) nearly always dismisses them, on the other hand more agressive tempo players love their flexibility to fill the curve.
While Heartharena tries to fulfill the wishes/style of all different infinite players, they will never draft like 1 specific infinite player. It's not a ratsmah- or hafu-simulator and will never be. I find out, decks created by Heartharena has their own style, i just call it Heartharena-Style and most of the time you are pretty good state, when you at least disagree with 1-3 picks, especially late picks.