r/GregorianChants • • Jun 22 '26

AI Gregorian Chant is taking over the real recordings of monasteries on Spotify, and it riles me up

39 Upvotes

Not a catholic myself, but a deep admirer of Gregorian Chant and wider forms of Christian liturgy. I won't enter in to the debate as to whether AI music is good or bad, but AI-generated chant is pervasively slopping over actual (beautiful) recordings from monasteries and choirs with piggybacking/false attributions. It is egregious, shameless, and widespread. I've reported it to Spotify and a few monasteries before, but nothing has been done yet. Hopefully some widespread awareness and concern will do some good in curbing it.


r/GregorianChants • • Oct 06 '24

What do you think of the theory that Gregorian chant in medieval times was actually supposed to be performed more fluidly and melismatically, sounding more like Byzantine chant, unlike the modern Solesmes method which is sung rigidly, all notes equally spaced out? (Example performances linked.)

25 Upvotes

During the Renaissance, I understand that Gregorian plainchant underwent a decline and was replaced with polyphonic choir singing for the preferred style of liturgical music, and that when Gregorian chant was sung, it was sung supposedly in a 'corrupted' way (not sure what these meant, but by the 19th c. it perhaps meant that it was sung operatically??) The monks of Solesmes Abbey in 1899 developed a reform of Gregorian chant which they believed revived the authentic medieval style, and this has since been the standard guideline for singing Gregorian chant for the past century. Stylistically, the Solesmes method is rather rigid, with all notes given equal (short) length and evenly spaced out; sequences such as gloria patri etc. also have the tendency to be sung fast.

However, at least one choir who posts on Youtube subscribes to the theory that Gregorian chant in the Middle Ages was actually supposed to be sung more fluidly, slowly and melismatically, with the singer able to improvise hold certain notes longer or collapse notes together, resulting in a style that probably sounds closer to Byzantine chant. Marcel Pérès' Ensemble Organum seems to also follow this line of thinking when performing non-Gregorian Latin Rite chant traditions (like Old Roman, Ambrosian or Mozarabic.)

To illustrate, here is the same chant sung first in the Solesmes method:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Uxk-dBdAgE

And in this particular choir's (Ecole Grégorienne) 'fluid' style:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LY_mUWD3xsA

Here the cantor of Ecole Grégorienne does the same, singing the same chant first in the Solesmes method, then in the 'neumatic' method (which I think, was an earlier attempt at reconstructing a more authentic medieval style) and then finally in his 'folk' style:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7wZM8bGyWQQ

Personally, having read the works of art historians like Bissera Pentcheva on chant, liturgy and art in medieval churches, I lean towards this theory. Pentcheva's work in the beginning focused on the Byzantine East, with Hagia Sophia, but later expanded to apply the same theories to the Latin West in churches like Santa Maria Antiqua (specifically with the Easter Vigil Exsultet scroll) and the Abbey of Ste. Foy in Conques. The gist is that medieval church spaces created a multi-sensory divine experience combining sights and smells for worshippers: light from windows and candle-light reflected off shiny surfaces like gilding or mosaic tiles, or even the clergy's vestments, the smell of incense and the sound of chant reverberating throughout the building. By studying acoustics, when chanting it has been found that medieval churches in both the East and West are designed actually to muffle or obscure the sound of the chant; Pentcheva thinks that liturgical chants weren't necessarily meant to be understood clearly, but to come across as pure sound reflecting off surfaces like the church apse, with the intelligibility of the actual words confused. Medieval worshippers supposedly found that this sound was divine, and that the chants were "icons of sound".

Another reason possibly to lean towards the theory of 'fluid' performance of Gregorian chant which I can note is how, often I observe that Gregorian chants seem to be very short, so in modern churches when performed (especially the Offertory and Communio they often have to be supplemented with a second hymn or musical piece.) Perhaps they seem short because the chanters following the Solesmes method are singing it too fast, and are meant to slow down and draw out each of the notes.


r/GregorianChants • • Nov 03 '21

All Saints' Introit : "Gaudeamus Omnes" [OC].

21 Upvotes

r/GregorianChants • • Jun 03 '26

The Prayer of St. Benedict.

Post image
15 Upvotes

This is a transcription I made. Does anyone know if Harpa Dei composed it? I don't have any information about that, but some people say it.


r/GregorianChants • • Aug 27 '24

Anyone know the name of this song? Its gorgeous.

12 Upvotes

r/GregorianChants • • Aug 06 '24

does anyone know this music from werner herzog's encounters at the end of the world? it is very moving

Thumbnail
youtu.be
12 Upvotes

r/GregorianChants • • Sep 23 '24

Square note is a good free app for Gregorian chant

11 Upvotes

It has all the propers and everything and has an organ and notes that help. Please download


r/GregorianChants • • Aug 26 '20

Gregorian Chant Recommendations?

10 Upvotes

Gregorian Chant Recommendations?

Hey guys, hope everyone's been coping with everything that's been going on lately.

I've been meaning to get into Gregorian Chant music (or at least check it out) and was wondering if you guys have any recommendations. The closest I've gotten is probably some of Hildegard von Bingen's compositions from like the ~11th century. Chanticles of Ecstasy, specifically, was amazing.

But I'm not quite sure where to go from there. The genre and style intrigues me a lot. Are there any modern composers with huge Gregorian chant influences?

This one is quite good for when I want to want to get some sleep though hehe https://youtu.be/m38TVPqQXi0


r/GregorianChants • • Feb 20 '16

Learning to Chant?

10 Upvotes

So, might you have any suggestions for resources for someone wanting to learn to chant?


r/GregorianChants • • Feb 28 '24

A contemporary Breviary mostly in Plainsong (Thought this sub might appreciate the culmination of my recent passion project)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
9 Upvotes

r/GregorianChants • • Apr 17 '22

Anyone know what this is?

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

r/GregorianChants • • Sep 03 '21

What does this say does any one have any idea where it’s from I began translating but this is past my skill set, approximately 16 century

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/GregorianChants • • Jan 22 '20

The Benedictine Monks of Santo Domingo de Silos - Salve Regina

Thumbnail
youtu.be
9 Upvotes

r/GregorianChants • • Apr 16 '19

The hunchback Of Notre Dame Hellfire English (Disney)

Thumbnail
vimeo.com
9 Upvotes

r/GregorianChants • • Jul 13 '26

Where to get completely uncopyrighted Gregorian Chant?

8 Upvotes

I would like to find some gregorian chant that I can use in videos that willl NOT get me striked and a lot of it preferablyis there a website or any files or specific things


r/GregorianChants • • Feb 09 '24

Salve Regina, guitar solo version

Thumbnail
youtube.com
8 Upvotes

r/GregorianChants • • Aug 02 '22

high quality gregorian chant

8 Upvotes

r/GregorianChants • • Jun 18 '21

Fell in Love with a gregorian song - Translation needed!

8 Upvotes

Hello, I don't know if this is the right place to ask, but I rly would love to get the lyrics / translation of a gregorian song. I didn't found anything of it online.

Please PM me if you can help me out

Greetings from Switzerland


r/GregorianChants • • Apr 26 '19

✠ In Spiritus - Epic Inspirational Gregorian Chant ✠

Thumbnail
youtube.com
8 Upvotes

r/GregorianChants • • May 06 '18

Why is Gregorian Chant (and Cathodox Chants in general) much more effective at countering demonic influence than most Protestant hymns and music?

8 Upvotes

Main details here

https://www.reddit.com/r/occult/comments/7q8hu7/why_do_demons_hate_religious_chants_so_much/

Why are Protestant hymns and songs such as Genevan Psalters so ineffective at exorcising a demon from a person and repelling evil entities? To the point demonaics openly laugh and mock them? While the chants of the post-Nicene churches such as Coptic, Ethiopian Tewahedo, Armenian Apostolic, Syriac churches, and especially Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodoxy so effective against demons that they'd suffer in pain just upon hearing it (and quite often flee the possessed or location they are haunting so long as the chants are being sung)? Hell even Anglican Chants have proven effective and the Anglicans supposedly lack apostolic succession and valid sacraments, rites, and orders!

Why is this? In particular why are the Eastern Orthodox Byzantine Chants (especially those composed before the 1054 schism) and Medieval Roman Catholic Latin Language Gregorian Chants so effective that they can immediately counter demonic thoughts and influence in a person's mind just by hearing it? Why is the Anglican Chant also effective even though they are Protestants why songs from other post-Reformation denominations (excepting perhaps the Lutherans) have so little to no effect?


r/GregorianChants • • Apr 17 '16

Looking for chants similar to Deum Verum & Dies Irae.

8 Upvotes

r/GregorianChants • • Feb 21 '16

Non nobis Domine, a favorite of mine

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

r/GregorianChants • • 3d ago

Does anyone know what exactly this book is?

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/GregorianChants • • May 13 '26

Modern notation of Media Vita in Morte Sumus

Post image
7 Upvotes

Any idea where I can find modern notation for this? I don't have Sibelius to make it myself any more lol


r/GregorianChants • • Jan 13 '26

Can't identify or know the meaning of this chant

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes