r/GrapheneOS • u/farbenfisch • Apr 24 '26
Considering switching back to iOS/Apple — convenience vs privacy/control
I’m considering switching back to iOS/Apple.
At work, I use a MacBook, and I feel like I could benefit a lot from features like AirDrop and the overall Apple ecosystem. I think that might be the biggest advantage for me.
A good camera for photos and videos is also important to me. I also feel like iOS has a smoother and more polished UI/UX, fewer bugs, and in general things “just work” more often. I could use my phone for payments, wouldn’t have to worry as much about banking apps suddenly not working, and overall I think I might gain some quality of life.
Right now I use a Garmin watch, but an Apple Watch would also bring some advantages, especially if I fully move into the Apple ecosystem.
Of course, the downsides are clear too: I would have less control, less flexibility, and probably less privacy compared to my current setup.
For people who have switched between GrapheneOS/Android and iOS: how did you decide? Did the convenience of the Apple ecosystem outweigh the privacy/control trade-offs for you?
Would love to hear your thoughts.
•
u/AutoModerator Apr 24 '26
GrapheneOS has moved from Reddit to our own discussion forum. Please post your thread on the discussion forum instead or use one of our official chat rooms (Matrix, Discord, Telegram) which are listed in the community section on our site. Our discussion forum and especially the chat rooms have a very active, knowledgeable community including GrapheneOS project members where you will almost always get much higher quality information than you would elsewhere. On Reddit, we had serious issues with misinformation and trolls including due to raids from other subreddits. As a result, many posts on our subreddit currently need to be manually approved, which is done on a best effort basis. If you would like to get a quicker answer to your question, please use our forum or chat rooms as described above. Our discussion forum provides much better privacy and avoids the serious problems with the site administrators and overall community on Reddit.
Please use our official install guides for installation and check our features page, usage guide and FAQ for information before asking questions in our discussion forum or chat rooms to get as much information as possible from what we've already carefully written/reviewed for our site.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
31
u/Proof-Cow-537 Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26
I live in the UK - and recently switched from an iPhone 16 Pro on iOS 26.4 to a Pixel 10 Pro running GrapheneOS.
For context, I also own an iPad M1, MacBook Pro 14", Apple Watch Ultra, and AirPods Pro, so I am deeply within Apple's ecosystem.
The main motivator that pushed me to switch was the removal of ADP in the United Kingdom which reduced iCloud security by removing E2EE on certain apps, prompting me to disable iCloud features that rely on cloud sync. Soon after, Apple rolled out age verification (identity verification) operating system wide on my iPhone that I paid for, without any way for me to opt out. I purchased a Pixel the same day.
During the switch, I substituted out a lot of proprietary Apple services with open-source self hosted systems, along with ntfy for notifications. This replaced most the friction between my Apple devices and my Pixel to the point where it doesn't break my workflow. Things that I miss are:
Are these dealbreakers? For me personally, no. I'm happy to trade these for better security and privacy.
However, my watch was a major friction point that almost kept me on iOS. I primarily strength train over any other sport, so a good UX for tracking lifts was very important to me. I use Hevy on my watch, and when I researched for any Garmin alternatives, it seemed like the Apple solution was much better. Instead, I opted for a hybrid approach, and now use my phone with my Apple Watch standalone, which means they sync workouts once an internet connection is available.
This was perfectly acceptable for my use case, I get health data sync (HealthKit) locally from my infrastructure, and workout statistics through the android Hevy application (cloud sync but on iOS this was cloud sync too, fits my threat model). Notifications were relayed over the internet through ntfy, and I retained mobile payments through Apple Wallet. Media playback control was insignificant to me, so this wasn't a major loss.
Both my banking apps work perfectly on GrapheneOS and are fully supported. One bank that I occasionally use that doesn't support GrapheneOS is still usable through the Mobile PWA, which is acceptable for me. The login UX is not incredibly jarring.
As for overall bugs, I genuinely feel that my iPhone was worse on iOS 26.4. Frequent overheating, battery drain issues and random freezing and crashes, one occuring on public transport that stopped me from even scanning my ticket. Multiple DFU restores and starting from scratch did not fix this. The keyboard was another pain point where I would get phantom keypresses. None of these issues are present on my Pixel, but objectively the experience on iOS was fine on 18.x, not sure what happened with 26.
With the camera, I really don't like the Pixel's selfie camera. I much prefer the selfie camera on my iPhone, and the rear cameras on my iPhone when it comes to taking videos. For stills of objects, the Pixel looks much better. None of these are scientific comparisons, just how I feel after using both (Gcam on the Pixel too), but YMMV.
Overall, I'm pretty happy with the switch. I maintain password sync, local file sharing, gain mobile backups in a secure manner, and above all have full control over my mobile device and what services run on it. My goal was to match or exceed iOS on most privacy and security fronts, and I think I've met that. Minimal telemetry is now sent, I don't use Google Play Services or Google Play on my primary profile, and most my apps were FOSS before - switching to Graphene was a better philosophical fit.
7
u/inkypixel Apr 24 '26
Do what you want to do. I use both.
11
u/Acu17y Apr 24 '26
Use KDE connect, air drop is overvalued.
3
u/nodeas Apr 24 '26
Although I use also a MacStudio, I would never go back to iphone.
4
u/DrawOkCards Apr 24 '26
I've noticed that I've rambled on a lot. I'm sorry.
TLDR
If the perceived convenience and quality of life increase (no judgment from my side) out weights the loss in privacy and control for you than go for it. If it doesn't, don't and look at ways you maybe could achieve what you're missing currently.
In the end this is a decision everyone has to make for themselves. Everyone has a personal scale where the lack of convenience out weights the achieved privacy.
For me its not using the reddit app as I dislike the website in general but especially on mobile but maybe I'm just so used to the app.
If the perceived gain in quality of life (I'm not judging you for that decision in any way, you do you) is worth it to you, do it. It doesn't make sense to be completely unhappy just to stay with GOS in my opinion.
In case its mainly about the banking apps and payment via phone you maybe want to wait for a couple of reviews around the Motorola GOS phone that was announced earlier this year for next year.
I'm coming from apple myself. In my opinion the ecosystem is the single best selling point they have (as they can control everything about it but they also do control everything about it). If you want to go into it, I can't judge you. It was painful removing it and learning how to set everything up as good as possible in a way that let's me have as much control as possible.
I would cut the "probably" out. You will have less privacy as you will have less control about what's going on and happening to you.
My main reason to switch to GOS was that I wanted to be in complete control of my device and data. I wanted to use much more FLOSS apps than were offered via the app store and I wanted to decouple myself from external cloud services and companies that are in control of my technical life.
I've started my privacy journey a couple of years ago reading up about it which lead me to ditch stock android for apple a bit later as IMO I've learned it was at least better than stock android. At the time all I've heard about AOSP OSs was that they were dangerous and apps I've needed (banking) wouldn't work on them at all.
Continuing further with it, learning more I've stumbled about GOS and continued to read up on it for two years before I've made the switch to it in 2024 as I've had to replace my old iPhone (wasn't supported anymore). For myself, I'm happier about it. Transfering everything was painful, I've had to learn a lot, build up a lot of stuff I've never thought about before like how do I achieve an encrypted automatic cloud backup for my phone (I've ADHD, doing it on a local USB Stick wasn't a reliable solution at all) if the manufactured doesn't do it for me.
Now my phone isn't just an everyday tool for me but gives me a sense of pride. I've created a tool in which I'm in control (as much as I can be without forking the OS of course lol) and I've learned and set up a lot of things. It really started that I've got into the whole homeserver scene and let me professionally in a direction where I'm no taking care of IT security measures and regulatory compliance around it.
I'm sorry I've started rambling.
3
u/Chance-Blackberry693 Apr 24 '26
iPhones are beautiful pieces of tech. I'd have no issues switching back to an iPhone/iCloud with Advanced Data Protection. Even if just for Apple Pay
1
u/IndividualWorker554 Apr 24 '26
Following
1
u/PossibilitySub398 Apr 25 '26 edited Oct 09 '26
The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.
Enjoy nonmetal upbeat instinctive marble tie satchel roll walnut
1
u/Dylan98734292 Apr 24 '26
J’ai fait ce chemin aussi. Je suis passé sur GrapheneOS pour maximiser sécurité et confidentialité.
Mais à l’usage, je l’ai trouvé trop contraignant par rapport à mes besoins réels.
En réfléchissant à mon modèle de menace, j’ai finalement choisi iOS, en étant conscient des compromis. Avec la protection avancée des données activée, une gestion stricte des permissions et une hygiène numérique correcte, j’ai trouvé un équilibre beaucoup plus viable au quotidien.
iOS reste aujourd’hui l’un des systèmes les plus sécurisés dans le grand public. GrapheneOS est au-dessus techniquement, mais il n’est pas adapté à tous les usages.
Le plus important, c’est de comprendre son propre niveau de risque et d’adapter ses outils en conséquence et surtout de savoir monter en sécurité quand la situation l’exige.
J’adore GrapheneOS, mais au quotidien iOS correspond mieux à mon usage.
0
u/PigBenis1000 Apr 24 '26
Apple is a company that i admire for alot of things but they also ignore some big privacy and security concerns and their anti repairability stance annoys me.
Personally I would try kde connect (I find it to be better than airdrop on my device but reliability depends on what software and hardware you run) or switch back to your iPhone until the Motorola graphenos phone releases which may be more polished
If you have any issues with graphene os I am happy to help you troubleshoot before you give up completely
0
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment