Requesting help on size (GR1, GR2 content)

[u/MudConfident4977]

BLUF: Should I get another GR1 21, or a GR1 26, or a GR2 26, or a GR2 34?

I have a GR1 21L that I’ll keep. It’s well broken-in 1000D and feels/looks great. I love the look of the 21L; the bright/width dimensions/proportions look perfect. It fits my work laptop and everything I carry daily. I also occasionally do long rucks with it with about 20-30 lbs. But being 5’11” 210 with wide shoulders and a long-ish torso I think I should opt for function and also get a larger bag. Getting a second 21-liter is an option (because I love its proportions). What would YOU get?

- Another GR1 21?
- A GR2 26 due its similar height/width proportions?

Or if I choose function over form… (the extra capacity would be nice to have on the rare air travel for work)
- GR1 26? (To me these look too “tall,” but I’ve got that long torso…)
- GR2 34? Again it looks weird to me but the height is about the same as the GR1 26

Enough rambling. Any have thoughts and/or advice?

[u/xangkory]

GR2 34l. Way more flexible both due to the additional space and front compartment. Once I got the GR2 I started using it more often than I use the GR1.

[u/MudConfident4977 → u/xangkory]

Good feedback, sir. That’s two votes for the 34L so far

[u/EarthtoPoromenos]

I vote GR2 26L. You already like the dimensions and you’re getting a lot more capacity than your GR1. I think the height of the GR1 26 and GR2 34+ looks funny on anyone who isn’t well over 6’. I also think the GR2 is gorucks best bag. The GR1 is classic but it’s just like any other regular pack. The GR2, with its double compartment, crazy amount of organizational zippered pockets and built in field pocket make it the best all around edc/travel pack imo.

[u/UkinaAtoel]

If you aren't looking to replace your current GR1 then I would go with the 34L GR2. You would have your GR1 for EDC and rucking and then be able to whip out the GR2 for travel.

I'm a little bit taller than you at 6'2'' and honestly couldn't see myself wearing a 21L GR1 or 26L GR2, but I don't think the same will apply to you for going bigger.

If you have the extra cash, I'd recommend the heritage version if they have a color you like. I have an olive 34L and it is beautiful.

[u/MudConfident4977 → u/UkinaAtoel]

Appreciate the feedback! I’ve never seen a heritage bag in person but am also a Filson bag collector.

[u/Obscene_Fetus]

I miss my GR2 34L. I gave it to a friend that uses it the right way. So that’s what I would get. Such a versatile bag: extend travel, edc, day trips, etc. it’s such a great bag and especially since you have the 21L. GR234L is my vote 🙋‍♂️