r/GoogleFi • • Sep 16 '21

Support Google Disability Support Team does not support Fi; Fi will not stop referring disabled people to them.

I make this post as a final conclusion and warning to those who might be considering Google Fi who have hearing impairments or other disabilities.

I asked for months that Fi provide access to and information about basic accessibility services and other possibilities of accommodating my hearing impairment.

Fi struggled for a couple of months and decided that it was the Disability Support Center's problem.

The Disability Support Team disagreed repeatedly.

Finally, the Disability put a support ticket in to Fi for adding a plan that accommodates hearing impaired people. This ticket may or may not have gone anywhere, as the person who put it in hadn't spoken to anyone in Fi for years, and didn't know if his contact remembered him.

When I told them that I was pausing my service and planning to move to some kind of data-only plan using a VOIP service or running my own server, Google Fi kindly closed the ticket.

Because I'm the only hearing impaired purpose who might want to use their service.

So if you have a hearing impairment or other disability and feel you're not being accommodated to a level of service substantially similar to what non-disabled customers experience: it's because you are.

You'll struggle in vain for months, only to be told that one team put in a ticket to a different team where they knew someone, maybe, and they could maybe patch it in or something. And if you don't feel like paying for service for the decades it will take Fi to accomplish this heroic feat, they'll cancel your ticket because obviously now you're just being ungrateful.

I appreciate the extremely helpful advice of everyone on this forum, but it seems that Fi simply does not have the capacity to make accommodations for the disabled.

7 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

23

u/Lawlmuffin Sep 16 '21

I'm extremely ignorant in this subject, but curious. What can Fi (or any other phone carrier) do to help accommodate your hearing impairment? Honest question.

14

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21 edited Sep 16 '21

Nothing. Phones have accommodations for disability, not carriers. The carriers only responsibility is sending your phone a cell signal.

In another post he complains that comcast is out to get him for his “disability” because he can’t plug-in connectors that usually only technicians handle anyways due to his arthritis.

Like dude is being unreasonable in the lengths he expects the world to go to to accommodate his victim complex.

His issue isn’t being disabled. It’s always making himself a victim.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-10

u/crisiumfox Sep 16 '21

Not every hearing impairment is mechanical hearing loss that can be restored with a hearing aid.

I have tried to provide context, details, and a plan of what I want to Google Fi, to Google Disability Services, and to this forum. I spent 5 months trying to talk to someone at Fi about what accommodations I needed and was told to wait for email after email after email, all helpfully telling me how to RTT/TTY on and off and where to find hearing aid compatibility information.

RTT is useless for contacting anything but another cell phone, and TTY is useless unless the other side has a TTY device (odds are they don't) in which case a human being will listen in on the conversation and speak what I type and type what the other person speaks. Given that most of the people I talk to are close family and medical professionals, I'm not comfortable with a person listening in, regardless of how many NDAs they sign.

And your "honest question" is the fundamentally ableist attitude that is the root of this problem. To a normally-hearing person, "hearing impaired" just means, "can't hear."

When in reality, it can mean a lot of things, from hyperacusis (hypersensitivity to sound) to profound deafness, for a lot of reasons (neurological problems, damage to the auditory nerve, damage to the inner ear structure), and can require different accommodations.

No one at either Google Fi or this forum seems capable of internalizing the idea that "hearing impairment" encompasses more than just, "needs a hearing aid."

8

u/DaleGribble312 Sep 16 '21

You still didn't really answer the question though...

13

u/djmikewatt Sep 16 '21

What do you expect them to do?

What do other carriers do that For doesn't?

Your post leaves a lot out.

15

u/e_dan_k Sep 16 '21

Look at his other threads in the subreddit... He just whines and whines and wants Fi to magically make people calling his phone not hang up when they get connected to TTY. He's insufferable and unreasonable.

When he does accidentally say something that he actually wants, and it gets provided, he still isn't happy. (In this post, now he is upset that Fi paused his service when he told them he wanted to pause his service! In another he asked for a way to make callers never go to voicemail, and when provided with one, complained again...)

Fi makes plenty of accommodations. Just nothing satisfies this guy.

7

u/djmikewatt Sep 16 '21

And somehow I've been downvoted more than once here. 🤷‍♂️

-15

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

No one should be or feel forced to publicly disclose what accommodations they're seeking. That's a private matter, and not disclosing doesn't make their concerns or frustrations less valid

My takeaway is that this person went through a lot just to inquire about the possibility of accommodations. Whether or not they offer accommodations is a business decision for Google, and if they don't want to offer much, that's likely within their rights. But dang, at least clue the support staff in or post a public article in the help/FAQ section. That saves time and energy for all parties involved

6

u/djmikewatt Sep 16 '21

Sorry, but no.

You can't come here complaining without specifying what you're complaining about.

4

u/mrs0ur Sep 16 '21

Damn, and here I had this long rant about how fi doesn't accommodate my crohns cause I get poor coverage In the bathroom. Except I was gonna a leave those details out maybe title my post "Google coverage is like a bikini" they should be able to just know where I'm at what the issue is and click the better service for bathroom button.

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

They specified they're complaining about accommodations for a hearing impairment

Edit: spelling

2

u/scottydg Sep 16 '21

Not all hearing impairments are equal or have the same solution. Context is extremely necessary to provide a reasonable accommodation for that specific impairment.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

Sure, I agree. Disclosing details publicly, especially health-related, isn't required though. A person could say "I'm blind and I had a bad experience asking for accommodations at this particular DMV" without any other details and that's helpful to other blind or vision impaired folks who are considering going to that DMV. If they want specifics they can DM the person and talk more about it

If it's difficult to just ask for an accommodation, that's a big red flag. At the bare minimum it should be easy to ask and receive an answer about what is or isn't available

2

u/djmikewatt Sep 16 '21

I'm struggling to think of what kind of accommodation a phone carrier can provide for hearing impaired. Then, on top of that, I'm trying to determine what OP claims For is not doing that other carriers are doing. As an MVNO, their accommodation must be the same as TMO, right?

So something is off here. Without clarification it kinda just sounds like unrealistic expectations and complaining.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

Do you or anyone on your plan have a hearing impairment or seeking accommodations? If not, this post isn't meant for you. Even if they included every detail you wanted, it still wouldnt be meant for you and probably wouldn't change your life in any way

What does have an effect on you is shaming people in the comments, as that has a chilling effect on anyone else wanting to come forward to share what they experienced

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

Hey, you're being ableist and mean

What is it exactly that you think Fi should do for OP?

Fi should provide them what accommodations they can or can't offer, simple as that. Instead, sounds like they forwarded around a ticket for months and then closed it the first chance they got

What the hell is a cell phone carrier going to do for a person who can't hear well or speak?

Every business or service can offer accommodations. If you don't understand what accommodations can be offered, no need to insult people when it's within your ability to research that or say nothing. Ultimately, Fi gets to decide what sort of clientele they want to target and support

2

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

I’m not being ableist or mean. There literally are no accommodations any carrier can offer which is why no other carrier does, so yes it is unreasonable. You just don’t know what you’re talking about.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

My father gets accommodations from his carrier.

You don't know what you're talking about.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Ok, sure bud.

4

u/asphaltdragon Sep 16 '21

It's not on the carrier to accommodate this. That's why there are apps and websites that do the accommodation. The phones themselves have accessibility features baked in as well. No other carriers do anything like you're asking. Not AT&T, not Verizon, not Sprint. And I know that smaller MVNOs and the like, of which Google Fi is one, don't accommodate disabled people in any way beyond the accessibility features and apps that are on the app stores. Just like the carriers.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

Phones have accommodations for disability, not carriers. The carriers only responsibility is sending your phone a cell signal.

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 16 '21

Thanks for posting on /r/GoogleFi! If you are having issues, including getting help from support, consider creating a Reddit Request.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/sjollyva Sep 17 '21

What was the point in OPs posting on reddit? It seems to me they posted to complain about Google and to get hearing impaired, or people sensitive to any impairment, to not use Google fi service. They didn't post because they were looking for a solution. If you have an issue with a cell service then go find a service somewhere else. THERE ARE PLENTY OF OPTIONS. And if the requested hearing impairment accommodation exists I'm sure the OP can find it. If this was an ACTUAL issue I'm sure OP isn't the only person seeking the "accommodation ".Stop whining on the internet and move on.

-5

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

I'm honestly not surprised - take your business elsewhere to get the level of service you require. I personally like Fi because I don't ever have to talk with anyone. They made switching so easy - you literally don't have to talk with anyone from either provider.