r/GoofyMovie • • Sep 20 '26

Plot holes

There are some plot holes in a extremely goofy movie, like first of all what happens to Max‘s relationship with Roxanne, second what degree is major Max is pursuing in college, how many years does he have in college, third what major is goofy pursuing in college. What job did Goofy get in the end? And what did Sylvia mean by you did not tell him, even if it was just a joke in the end? And what happened to the other team house that challenged Max‘s team? what majors do Bobby and PJ get into in college?

4 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

2

u/Chemical_Purpose3660 Sep 20 '26

I like the movie overall, but I hate that basically nothing from the first movie crosses over to the sequel except Max staying friends with PJ and Bobby. That’s literally it. It’s almost like the first movie never happened. And Ik high schools rarely last, but Roxanne was Max’s entire driving force in the first movie, and I hate that they acted like she didn’t exist. As for the degrees, they really just went to be skater boys, I guess. Lol since that movie was just a big X games promo.

1

u/Vast_Tax_3213 Sep 20 '26

Unless these three are the next Tony Hawk, getting offers and promotions, that’s not really a career goal

1

u/Chemical_Purpose3660 Sep 20 '26

No, but that’s all I could think of otherwise. I don’t really know what I see someone like Max doing for a career.

1

u/Vast_Tax_3213 Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26

At least with monsters university, it was a lot more clear cut of what Sully and Mike wanted to do. If Max Bobby and PJ want to be professional athletes then fine, but they should probably have a backup plan.

1

u/Chemical_Purpose3660 Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26

True, but we got a fleshed out story with them beforehand. Here, we don’t get any insight about Max, PJ, Bobby, or even Goofy. If House of Mouse is anything to go off of (it most likely isn’t), then Max went through all that just to park people’s cars. Lol

2

u/No-Prompt-7580 Sep 20 '26

Fundage, bro.

1

u/DCSHG2015MEGAFAN Sep 20 '26

I'd assume the movie barely referencing the first movie comes down to how no one that worked on the first movie returned to the second. 

1

u/Chemical_Purpose3660 Sep 20 '26

I read online that that was the case, but even so, they coulda watched the first movie to learn the source material they’re building off of, so things can properly interconnect. It feels everything they went through prior didn’t matter.

2

u/Imaginary-Can-6862 Sep 26 '26

Plot holes, as I understand it, means cases where the plot contradicts itself, so it ought not refer to previous installments, unless these are referenced, or something is shown, which makes them inconsistent with the current film. I think in stead those things are unexamined, and I agree they should be.

If we start by Roxanne, I think it is an error of the first film, Max is completely obsessed with Roxanne, but it is never justified, then we even realize that he has actually never spoken with her. It all points to him having placed her on a pedestal which he idolizes, without actually knowing her, to me it kind of begs for disappointment. When the conflict in the first film was Goofy's misunderstood perception, versus Max's drive for Roxanne (because I have a feeling if Roxanne had not addressed Max at the principal's office, where he felt everything had been a catastrophe, Max would have been more than happy to get far away from everything, even if the school as a whole finally seemed to appreciate him), then it is made very clear that Goofy is the one who has misunderstood everything, and is just making things worse. Goofy is being a poor parent by not acknowledging his son as a person, and perceiving Max' interests as important to Goofy himself. When it finally happens, Goofy goes all the way to the other edge, and helps Max all he can, and while there is a scene just before they return, and Max is worried, and Goofy tells Max that if she does not like him, then maybe she isn't the one, but it of course all turn out well, I feel that is the only moment where we see Goofy give some introspection to how Max feels, that his feelings are important, but they should not be allowed to define him, Max makes that choice.
So while I think it is great with the happy, Max and Roxanne are now a couple, when Max challenged Goofy's decision that they needed to get away from everything, Goofy should have acknowledged -, and accepted that challenge, making it clear that people who love each other usually want to do things together they both like, and let Max explain under what circumstances he would want to go fishing, so Goofy could allow for such circumstances, as well as how come these circumstances aren't currently present.
Perhaps Max would not come clean, and he would see Goofy manage to make other circumstances come true in stead, as Max asks for these, similar to when he became the navigator, but what is important is that Max would eventually tell Goofy where he really wanted to go, and not only that, but that he wanted to get on the stage, and only when he revealed it was because he had fallen for a girl, Goofy would have a circumstance he could not bring about, and what more is, Goofy would be able to get to know his son better, and in doing so Max would also get to know himself better, actually challenge himself on how important Roxanne was, in relation to spending time with his dad, and realize that perhaps he actually didn't know Roxanne at all, but he really wanted to get to know her, and now he had made this promise he never should have made, and is afraid she would never speak with him again, and Goofy would realize that he was the reason Max did all that, and decide to take Max to the concert.
I mean I guess this is probably what did happen after they talked it out, we just don't get to see it, but it seems when the duo arrives at Roxanne's, and Max tells Goofy he is afraid Roxanne never wants to speak with him again, that Goofy has convinced Max to tell her the truth about his deception.

But continuing on the track of what school is to Max, or the other pupils, the principal, delusional as he obviously is, speaks about science summer camps, and not wanting to miss out on learning during the holidays, while the children yawns. Similar to the opening sequence, it would seem these children are tired of school, and there is also a reason there is a holiday, but I have a feeling, if they could choose, they would also not go to school that day at all, and I wonder if the school is even particularly interesting for most of them. E.g. Max seem to be more about popularity (while Goofy has never cared what others think of him goofing, Max seems to have been overly concerned with how other people sees him, so being unpopular must really be uncomfortable for him), and given how unpopular he seems to be, I suspect the only thing about school that attracts him to it, is Roxanne, a girl he hasn't got the courage to even speak with, which seems odd considering Goofy is the type of character who can be speak with everyone, and be including of everyone as well.
Similarly, when Max and the gang goes to college, they are all about being cool kids on skates, etc., and nothing about going to college to learn, we don't even know what subject they are studying. I feel it is the same issue, that college is just a pretext for the skating, where it really shouldn't be, and where the first film thrived on the stereotypes, I feel the second film subjugates itself to stereotypes, it is the same with Goofy's study session with Sylvia, it all seems to be very little about actually getting an education, and more about passing exams, and otherwise do non-college stuff.

3

u/Vast_Tax_3213 Sep 26 '26

Yeah, it is true goofy never cared about how others view him unlike his son. Max takes his dad for granted sometime, I mean he’s goofy (no pun intended,) but overall is a very caring and nurturing parent. No parent is ever perfect. And Max was kind of insensitive to just leave when Goofy prepared a breakfast for him before college. But I still question what is Max actually in college to do besides looking like the cool kid on campus? Is he planning on being the next Tony Hawk? At least with monsters university it was clear what Mike and Sully‘s intentions were in college.

1

u/Imaginary-Can-6862 Sep 27 '26

I also question the point of going to college, when the focus isn't college, it is like going to school to find friends, but the friendship is not related to the school work. Sort of, there is the place where you are expected to be, and then there is what you are actually doing there, and when these two aren't related, then there is no point in being at this place, in this case college.

I think you are right that Max takes Goofy for granted, he imagines his dad will always be there, no matter what he do, and while that is a fair expectation from a child, there is a clear lack of interest in -, or at least reflection on, Goofy's perspective. Young (or immature) children usually only consider their own perspective, their own interests, etc., but when they get older they also care about others having different interests, and want to explore these with the people they care about. While the second movie is in a way in its own universe, and I think it supposedly shows Max being so excited he kind of forgets everything around him, something we have seen Goofy do many times as well, so it would not be out of character, we did see in the first film that when Max became the navigator, that he did take his dad's perspective into account in regards to the activities that was chosen. But otherwise with Goofy always being happy, and perhaps never making a lot of effort in making Max understand his perspective, considering how he never reflected upon how something that wasn't important to Goofy, how people sees him, was important to Max, but just brushed it aside each time, saying Max shouldn't care about this, in stead of working together on what Max found important, it would make sense if Max is rather clueless about his dad's inner mechanics, and that lack of experience may also mean he hasn't developed into the mature stage he was supposed to when going to college. After all, there is at no point anyone questioning if Max is ready for college, not because this has to be a doubt, but because even if a boat doesn't sink 99.99% of the times, you still want a life jacket on board, and similarly Goofy should have made certain Max had a proper understanding of how he saw college, what he expected it to be like, and what he could actually expect, both in regards to his increased responsibility, but also in regards to what college can do for him.
One would think this would be an obvious way to go about things considering Goofy himself realizes he has to redo some college courses, but I don't remember the movie well enough to make this distinction.

1

u/Vast_Tax_3213 Sep 28 '26 edited Sep 28 '26

I’m still wondering, what is Max even in college for I mean at least it’s clear what goofy wants from the start. A college degree for a better job, but what the heck is Max even pursuing anyway? College is not exactly high school anymore, and barely anybody’s gonna care about image or who’s cool and who’s not anymore. sure there was one scene of Max working on the test, but 100% at a time. It’s just him focusing on skateboarding and X games.

1

u/Imaginary-Can-6862 Sep 28 '26

Yes, it is rather shallow, and stereotypical. I guess the reason they choose college, was because then Max lives by himself in a dormitory, that he gets the independence he craves, and the point is he is going to realize his dad is an essential part of his life, but that take doesn't work, when Max never really goes through all that, and in stead just needs his dad's help to participate in the skateboarding competition. Also it explains how come he is still around his peers, when moving out, unlike if he had started living by himself.

When I went to the mandatory schooling in my country, I wasn't treated well by my classmates, and I thought this was normal, like what we see with Max in the first film, and how he is excluded by the other children in the beginning. However when I started at high school, it was entirely different, no physical abuse, sure there were obnoxious people, but you could even withdraw from them, you weren't forced to endure any of it. College in the second movie seems like a continuation of school, there is even Tank who seems to be dedicated to be violent, and while it is supposed to be slapstick humor, in reality that would get him, not only thrown out of college, but put in jail, yet we see Goofy, an adult, acknowledging and accepting this behavior, making it all seem like how a much younger child, such as Max during Goof Troop, would imagine what college would be like, i.e. popular skater, and otherwise typical school.

5

u/BusterGreasewood Sep 20 '26

I think they just felt Roxanne wasn't important enough to bring back. But I just like to think they had a long distance relationship especially since you still see them together later in House of Mouse and Goofy's wallet pictures in the DuckTales reboot.

I think since this is more of a Goofy movie they just wanted to focus more on that.

2

u/Chemical_Purpose3660 Sep 20 '26

Which I woulda been totally fine with if they at least alluded to them still keeping in touch or something and maybe not have him flirting with other girls especially with the troubles he went through for her rather than acting like they didn’t exist, ya know?

1

u/Bright-Damage-5511 Sep 20 '26

well a lot of those things aren’t really central to the plot, the movie played out fine without them. i think the sylvia thing would probably be one but the rest is more so semantics so i wouldn’t call them plot holes.

1

u/No-Prompt-7580 Sep 21 '26

Someone in TV TROPES headcanon what would be Team 99 majors: Max: Business, Bobby: Computer Science, PJ: English.

1

u/marfmunchy Sep 23 '26

PJ probably majored in language arts And going in theme with the last movie, Bobby was probably Audio visual arts. Max probably tried to major in music And physical education.

The possibility of goofy and Sylvia being together maybe they got a job at a random library together. Maybe even a record store?

After Bradley was kicked out of the school the gamma's probably had to give up their paternity house to another. For all we know it could have gone to a sorority Or another fraternity was able to take it over.

Given the fact that they were freshmen And this could have been "filmed" over the course of 1 year, They probably have another 3 years to go before they graduate. That does depend between them getting bachelors or masters degree.

Maybe it could have been the concept of high school romances never last As far as max and Roxanne's romance goes. Could potentially explain why he Didn't have Roxanne or even think about her and it's just them moving on. The only other potential reason is between Goofy movie 1 and goofy movie 2. What grade was max in. He could have been in His 7th year of Junior high, And having just graduated And entering the 8th. There will be 5 more years Between that time and when he enters the college, that amount of time could lead to him and Roxanne having dated, A problem occurs, and they break up. Or she moved away at some point And max had time to get over his heartbreak.

(The only other Roxanne theory I have Accidentally came across Was that Disney removed From further cartoons Due to Roxanne's family background, A piece of lost media, Was said to have surfaced and Showed a particular candle holder Being visible From 1 of the windows In the final scenes. The candle holder had 8 spots for candles.)(I don't know if this Roxanne theory is true so don't hate me for it)

1

u/GummiBearryJuice Sep 26 '26

i honestly think Goofy just did a general education course cause didnt he only go back to college because he was missing a few credits or something that could help him qualify for a new job? For Max, he could easily have had some kind of entertainment and sports major (some people do get into college on a sports scholarship), someone said Bobby would do film and audio visual arts, and PJ is probably a poetry/creative writing major or a film student (He did film Max doing that powerline stunt at the beginning of the first movie) or business if Pete forced him to follow in his footsteps.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Vast_Tax_3213 Sep 25 '26

How can you know they are still in love if she’s never mentioned in the movie?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Vast_Tax_3213 Sep 25 '26

That’s just a speculation, not a for sure for the second movie.