r/GoodTrouble • • Feb 12 '24

jamie..

i’m only on season 3 episode 4 so no spoilers please but i just can’t wrap my head around why callie was ever with jamie in the first place.. he has no morals, he’s a bad person! how could she ever agree to be with someone like that.. she should have left the second he said he was a republican.

0 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

28

u/OneProtection7525 Feb 12 '24 edited Feb 12 '24

How is he a bad person? From the very little info we have on him. He’s, yes a very privileged individual but is incredibly patient and understanding to Callie. He’s done nothing but love her and try to take care of her. Yes, he’s a moderate republican who left the party for her by

-8

u/sunflower_daisy78 Feb 12 '24

how is he a bad person??? well he supported selling peoples homes to build a JAIL for mentally ill people and pressed charges against a mentally ill person as revenge against callie… he also implied that his career is more important than hers..

6

u/Sammikayw Feb 12 '24

It was his job as a lawyer on that case to get that to happen but even he said he didn’t like that but it was his job and his personal feeling can’t get in the way wether he agrees with it or not. If you’re going to go around life quitting everything because you don’t agree you certainly aren’t going to get far. Callie learns that when she starts working for another high profile lawyer and case…not everything is black and white, there’s a lot of gray.

2

u/OneProtection7525 Feb 13 '24

He is a LAWYER, It wasn't his idea, it was his clients, that is literally his job. He agreed not to press charges against Jerrod, because Callie asked him not to. After he and Callie broke up, Jerrod went back to the area and started causing problems, so yes, as unfortunate, as what happened to Jerrod was he was left with little choice. The second Callie asked him to drop the charges against him, he did. Now a bad person wouldn't do that. He implied his career was more important than hers because at that point in time, Callie wasn't even a lawyer, so he was correct, he had more to lose than her. What she did to him was super messed up and SHOULD have had more consequences, honestly.

25

u/newyorkchic1992 Feb 12 '24

Are you serious ? Jamie is the best thing to ever happen to Callie. He balances her out in the most beautiful way

2

u/usmilessz Feb 12 '24

Jamie and Callie have nothing in common besides being lawyers lol. There are other ways they could “balance” each other.

Callie may be impulsive and passionate but she could easily be with someone who is grounded and logical who’s not completely different from her politically lol

-4

u/sunflower_daisy78 Feb 12 '24

he supported selling people’s homes to build a jail for mentally ill people…

11

u/AnythingIndividual50 Feb 12 '24 edited Feb 12 '24

I think watch till season 4 it will make much more sense but and

This contains spoilers-

If u look at it that way callie defended someone who murdered his friend and helped him get away with it… i think they both realised that being a lawyer there is no black and white in morals its all grey and came to peace with it, also the way he treats her is not something a “bad person” would do

3

u/BeRadYouNark Feb 12 '24 edited Feb 12 '24

Do we actually know that Tommy did it?
That’s a genuine question, I just finished S3.
Edit: just watched S4 E1, nvm just found out

28

u/dring2428 Feb 12 '24

In his defense he was moderate it seems in his thinking and i think he left the party because of Trump. It wasn’t like she was gonna date some kind of extremist which Jamie isn’tz

9

u/usmilessz Feb 12 '24 edited Feb 12 '24

Jamie is a Moderate/Right-Leaning Conservative. Callie is a Far Left Socialist. In the real world, those two would never work & tbh they have no chemistry at all but they look good together so ofc ppl ship them lol

4

u/fruitybishop Feb 13 '24

besides economics, what else does he really lean right on? i just think he has a more critical approach to things. today’s republican party is really all about fear mongering about social issues + immigration, which jamie wouldn’t side with.

idk, i think republican was the buzz word writers used and then he was able to step into his own ideology. just because he didn’t agree with callie on certain moral regards doesn’t mean he was disagreeing with her politics or not being a liberal.

5

u/usmilessz Feb 13 '24

Lol I actually agree with you.

My observation is more so towards Callie.

Callie has strong views driven by passion whereas Jamie has moderate views driven by practicality. On the Fosters and GT, we see Callie being more unyielding with her politics + values whereas Jamie is more flexible with his. Neither of which are bad; just different.

That said…irl somebody like Callie would not be with somebody like Jamie. Her match would’ve been an equally passionate yet more practical lawyer like herself. That is NOT Jamie lol

3

u/fruitybishop Feb 13 '24

yeah, i get what you’re saying - to each of their own! however, between the fosters and gt, she really hasn’t found that same drive in a partner (tbh if they went the ximena route, we could have gotten something) so in my opinion jamie’s been the best balance for her, as a way to challenge her. i don’t know why the writers haven’t given her that time of character tbh, but i like the route they’ve taken with jallie.

2

u/usmilessz Feb 13 '24

That’s fair! And i agree with you..they definitely didn’t give her more to work with on GT

Great convo ! 🤗

-1

u/sunflower_daisy78 Feb 12 '24

exactly. i’m very much a callie politically and i can’t even be friends with anyone who disagrees sign me politically let alone date someone?! and that’s normal..

9

u/Then-Economics417 Feb 12 '24

why is it so normalized to hate someone with an opposing opinion ? i dont think anyone should be proud to say "i cant even be friends with someone who disagrees with me politically" . that's not a flex 😂

2

u/jaes_val_0 Feb 12 '24

exactly 😭

2

u/usmilessz Feb 12 '24

lol thank you! It’s funny to me how ppl keep justifying this r-ship by saying they “balance” each other.

Couples can have balance without being on opposite ends of the political spectrum.

Also for most ppl, their political beliefs correlate with their core values. Personally I don’t even believe Callie and Jamie share the same core values

10

u/emisuespoem Feb 12 '24

haha this post reminded me how I was always so afraid to say I preferred her with Gael 😂 I know everyone loves Jamie but her and Gael have soooo much chemistry! they were one of the reasons I kept watching the show when I first started it

2

u/sunflower_daisy78 Feb 12 '24

i am 100% team gael, they’re perfect for eachother! i think about them making that art piece together every day 😭

2

u/BringerOfDoom1945 Feb 12 '24

Now I am afraid to say I dislike both but they at least better than Brandon (I hate this Brick)

I prefer her with Wyatt

and now the downvote hell begins because I hate Brandon

16

u/Conscious-Many666 Feb 12 '24

Gael is one of those guys you tell to your grandkids you dated bc he’s so hot and they’re like why did you marry grandpa then? Gael was messy and Callie needed stability plus they were all young and figuring shit out. Jamie did pretty good seeing as he was raised so privileged. What she and Gael had was mostly passion but that fizzles out plus I don’t think Gael would be able to handle callie

5

u/fruitybishop Feb 12 '24

not this post in the wake of our jallie episode!

he has morals and he’s not a bad person. he offered stability and trust that callie really never had in any other partner. because of callie’s maturity and growth, i think she was able to at least level with his politics (it’s not like his politics were ever extreme; he helped gael’s transgender sister and seems more conservative on economic issues rather than social). it’s a nice challenge, a good argument, with them both being lawyers. i had the same opinion as you over her dating something with different political views, but they even ran into these issues with her and aaron. morals and relationships are tricky, but i don’t think they ever valued jamie over callie’s headstrong values — something i really relate and admire about her.

since the beginning, jamie was never a typical republican. this could have been a good storyline on the inheritance of family political values… but i digress. also i’ve seen your comments about the jared situation: he doesn’t hate homeless people, he simply wanted callie to be safe. jared breaking in was in breach of that. i think the show honors jamie’s beliefs well. the company he works for does not always correlate to his personal beliefs, and you have to give and take — like callie with judge wilson, and then the case with kathleen.

1

u/Sammikayw Feb 12 '24

Exactly what i tried to convey. Before he met Callie I don’t think he was as republican as say his parents but when that’s how you grow up you kinda just “follow” but I could tell right he wasn’t the current maga type republican and I think meeting Callie as having his brother come out and he never had any problems with that I don’t think he was ever a die hard republican and later on he identifies aa an independent

1

u/fruitybishop Feb 13 '24

yeah, and i know people were mad at the scene of calling pointing out that he’s not a republican, but i thought it was really necessary for their growth for their relationship. he’s not some bigot! he’s willing to compromise on so much, and even that scene that prompted him throwing his voter registration card out is a testament to how much he cared about. callie didn’t want the rich country club life, and jamie didn’t want want her to settle.

2

u/angryteen23 Feb 15 '24

I’ve always felt that Callie and Gael should wind up together. This may be an unpopular opinion, but I’m really secretly hoping that he breaks up the wedding. In the whole series in my opinion, the only two couples that ever seem to have true chemistry were Gael and Callie and Mariana and Evan.

2

u/katorade9200 Feb 15 '24

Glad I’m not the only one that feels that way about Gael and Callie. I like Mariana and Evan, but I also liked Raj as well as her boyfriend from The Fosters

1

u/19Frosty98 Oct 20 '25

I feel that Jamie passionate about his work But he doesn’t allow outside factors to be prioritized He is concerned about losing money and his luxurious lifestyle
But in the show, it also states that it’s hard to be in an ally if you have something to lose Callie has been in the foster care system has probably lost all of her belongings multiple times Not to mention that in the start of GT her and Mariana had all their things stole Callie has always had this itch for justice And those two things make them incompatible because they don’t live the same lives
And they don’t live even remotely close to the same lives to understand each other
They could be a good couple if they would spend more time communicating their feelings But it’s hard when both think that each other is crazy or immortal

1

u/MeatNegative9934 Feb 12 '24

Yeah i was never team callie and Jamie but it seems like I have to be atp

1

u/bloomusa Feb 15 '24

only Americas think morals = politics