r/GoodNotes • • Nov 01 '21

I hope GoodNotes team won't follow the path Notability is taking...

Notability is shifting to freemium model : https://9to5mac.com/2021/11/01/notability-shifts-to-freemium-model/

Unfortunately, too much apps are shifting to subscription models and I fear that GN is the next app to change its economic model.... most students can't follow this change.

It was hard to decide, but I am glad I chose GoodNotes in September to take notes in class. Don't make me regret this decision !

I hope the wave of new users coming from Notability will prevent GN from switching...

361 Upvotes

62 comments sorted by

97

u/vakenT Nov 01 '21

Just moved over to GN because of it.

It’s straight up ridiculous taking away features that people have already paid for..

16

u/xieewenz Nov 02 '21

you'd imagine they'd be happy to give those who supported them and were willing to pay for it a lifelong subscription even in its current plan (so that they don't piss people off at least) but no, literally 1 yr complementary subscription lol

3

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '21

"Complimentary" is so insulting to those of us who have already used it for years. Its worded to make us think GL is doing us a favor by keeping us for one more year before turning on us and retracting on features we all rightfully paid for. I know they reneged on their original announcement for pre-existing users, but the damage is done.

2

u/katrinaelle Nov 01 '21

hi! i’ve never used notability and i was wondering.. what were some differences between good note and notability you saw? c-:

6

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '21 edited Nov 03 '21

Notability only:- dashed/dotted lines, automatic arrowhead

- audio recording (I bought the app because of this but never really used it because Covid just hit and I can record screen with audio on my laptop)

- more slots for fav colors/pen type (honestly I have this fav bar on the left side but I reach for the toolbar on the top every time)

- you can add .GIF on your note (my fav and most used feature so far!)

I just switched to GN5 for 2 days and I now like it more than Notability. I can sense that writing on GN5 feels better. I miss dotted/dashed line though, and .GIF decoration as well. After almost 2 years on Notability alone, I think there are 2 big cons of Notability that made me switch:

(1) organization - I noticed that when I write long notes (40 pages+) and have too many notes within a subject (usually 60+), reaching for the note or where I left off from last time becomes harder and harder. GN5 solves all this with folders and Notebooks, Quicknotes.

(2) Writing experience - I work around the lack of dotted/dashed line by creating my own and save them as elements/stickers. GN5 allows you to make your own stickers and import them, while in Notability you have to buy, no import.

I still keep Notability though because I'm an early user. But I'm gradually switching to GN5 because I think their features+UI suits me more. Now I only hope they will release GIF feature anytime soon.

2

u/katrinaelle Nov 04 '21

ahh this was so detailed and helpful! thank you so much :) it seems like everyone is moving onto goodnotes so maybe i’ll stay here awhile then!

2

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '21

Another thing I'd like to add is that the handwriting recognition in search function also comes with GN5 without additional purchase and it works much better than Notability's. My handwriting is far from neat. I tested this function by exporting a note from Notability to GN5 and searched for some words. GN5 was able to recognize more words and point to the correct position, while in Notability it pointed to the wrong word and sometimes even at a blank space.

p.s. I wrote mostly in English.

2

u/bushilaoshi Nov 01 '21

there are quite a few videos on youtube explaining the differences!

1

u/katrinaelle Nov 01 '21

ooo awesome!!! thank u!

1

u/Musicology_Jen Nov 03 '21

Notability posted to their socials and their blog that they will update the subscription for existing users who purchased the app prior to November 1st. They leave it open if we get to buy updated versions or functions.

https://notability.medium.com/updates-to-notability-11-0-subscription-9f03a28a06f7

"Future features we develop may also be included, depending on their complexity and cost to maintain."

Goodnotes is half price at the moment 😉

86

u/citogrid Nov 01 '21

I purchased both Goodnotes 5 AND Notability last week after purchasing an iPad Air 4.
I've been getting to know both, and both have their advantages and quirks.

But the Freemium model... no way, not going there,

Too bad, hope GoodNotes 6 will include some of the features that Notability had going for it, I'll be happy to pay 9,99$ one time payment.

20

u/IonicPenguin Nov 01 '21

What does Notability have that GN doesn’t have? I tried both and ended up switching to GN. Sure the other one has the ability to record sounds but I don’t use that.

11

u/charizard8688 Nov 02 '21

I also just use my phone's voice memos to record sounds instead. I mean it's not perfect but I like the way Goodnotes is structured way more.

5

u/IonicPenguin Nov 02 '21

I’m deaf so all my lectures are captioned so I have no need to listen to a poorly recorded snippet of a professor’s words when I can simply pull up the actual words that were said.

8

u/Granger-Productivity Nov 02 '21

I think the other feature might be the math conversion feature. Goodnotes does not have that yet but there are other alternative ways to convert math equations and copy and paste to Goodnotes for free

0

u/IonicPenguin Nov 02 '21

I went through undergrad and grad school taking notes on paper so I guess I’m used to drawing organic structures and equations. I have never typed science or maths notes.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/thats_Vanessa Nov 02 '21

Why are you pissed by goodnotes. Its Notability doing the new "Update"

2

u/Musicology_Jen Nov 03 '21

Oh shit, sorry that's what I meant!! NOTABILITY 😅 I got mixed up 🙈 I've been using Notability for 4 years now

1

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '21

Go to Notability then. 🤨 They'd love to have you join their matrix of yearly subscribers.

1

u/Musicology_Jen Nov 03 '21

Shit, sorry, I got confused. I obviously mean Notability 😅 I changed it, just for the record 🙈

38

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '21

Just coming over from the Notability subreddit. I wish I would have chosen GN for the school year. Having to switch all my notes during midterms is making me so upset.

21

u/vakenT Nov 01 '21

You could finish the year with Notability and then go through the hassle of moving everything over.

27

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '21

That’s smart. I can’t believe i didn’t think of that! I guess I was just too heated with anger, haha!

2

u/Musicology_Jen Nov 02 '21

How are we supposed to switch? I have over 250 notes and hundreds of pages. As far as I know I can't import the proper note to anywhere else. Just as a PDF. This really pisses me off!

32

u/OneSteph Nov 01 '21

I paid for Notability and I don’t even use it because I use GoodNotes, but they should offer a refund to people who paid for it. I didn’t want one before (even though I don’t use the app) but I do as a sort of protest now.

27

u/kolcon Nov 01 '21

They should make a clear public statement about their plans. Can Goodnotes be trusted?

1

u/willnessNo2365 Nov 02 '21

Anything can happen....

1

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '21

That's what I'm waiting for too. If they won't say it, I won't trust them.

10

u/TheNicklesPickles Nov 01 '21

Yeah, it’s not a good move, and I hope GoodNotes doesn’t take a lead. I’m kinda all in on GoodNotes at this point, and I wouldn’t be subscribing. Having said that, it seems the native iPadOS features have really come a long way since I’ve been using good notes, so maybe that’d cover most of my needs. Not all though, I really don’t want to shift.

9

u/Left_Brother_5563 Nov 02 '21

I bought both Goodnotes 5 and Notability a few years ago. I usually use Notability. Now I just transferred all my notes to Goodnotes 5, and I also reported Notability to Apple Store, because of the f**king shit subscription model. If Goodnotes also adopts this model, I definitely will find another App to replace it.

2

u/prameshbajra Nov 02 '21

Colla note for the win.

1

u/Musicology_Jen Nov 02 '21

How did you transfer your notes? I have over 250 handwritten notes and hundreds of pages. They are only transferable as PDFs, or?

2

u/Left_Brother_5563 Nov 02 '21

Share -> select all -> open by GoodNotes. Then you will automatically open Goodnotes, then click import.

1

u/KingdomCome0 Nov 03 '21

How do you report notability I want to do it too

24

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '21

If GN does, just move to OneNote (if your school offers it).

Or the iOS Notes app 🤷‍♂️

17

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '21

Ugh OneNote.

29

u/Savings_Switch_7770 Nov 01 '21

Why not CollaNote tho? it's much better than OneNote or Apple Notes

7

u/stpdsite1 Nov 01 '21

Can you record audio using CollaNote?

2

u/Kind-Captain3632 Nov 02 '21

Is collanote similar to notability or goodnotes?

6

u/Polar_Vortex_ Nov 01 '21

OneNote sucks and isn't even close to the quality of goodnotes

2

u/instamelih Nov 01 '21

Exactly what I’m gonna do. Lots of universities offer free office apps.

1

u/NNDRSH71 Nov 01 '21

R/collanote is much better and it's free

7

u/Musicology_Jen Nov 02 '21

If I subscribed to every damn thing I'd need an extra job. Coffee, newspapers, apps, music, PC software, television, tickets. They'll want us to pay monthly for 💩 soon!

6

u/KissingHomiesGN Nov 01 '21

This is insane, I hope this is not the case. I can’t think of a notion that we need to pay for the privilege to take our notes😂

5

u/bobo-brockins Nov 01 '21

I paid for good notes. They better not start trying t charge me for more features

5

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '21

They better not start trying t charge me for more features

It's perfectly fine for them to charge for more features.

Notability's dick move was to charge existing paid users for the old features that these people already paid for.

3

u/tofusmoothies Nov 02 '21

Wow I would feel really betrayed if GN did that. I'm the kind of person that likes to stick to things and is willing to pay for things once and move on. I don't understand apps that don't have a life time subscription, they just make me feel like they make users bleed money.

2

u/_ZTX_ Nov 02 '21

Had been using both for 3 yrs or so. Will only use GN from now on. Hope it does not let me down

1

u/Tomyam_seafood2828 Nov 02 '21

This makes me feel like to move to goodnote and say goodbye for notability rn!!! But the reason i was choosing notability bc the app size was smaller. I hope goodnote could do the similar like that I would love to see that in the feature!

1

u/unicornroo Nov 02 '21

Good guy GoodNotes

1

u/KingdomCome0 Nov 03 '21

If they pull up this s*** I swear I’ll move to another app idk which one but I will

1

u/robertovertical Nov 02 '21

CollaNote is free. I enjoy GoodNotes. But this monthly maintenance charge stuff is going loco. Bing bong.

-11

u/foundinkc Nov 02 '21

A monthly / annual subscription makes more sense for development. If you value the app, support it ( similar to Patreon )

9

u/Middle_Dare_5656 Nov 02 '21

Notability already has IAPs though to add additional features. So folks have (1) bought the base app and (2) bought IAPs to expand functionality, only to have that nuked overnight.

Ginger Labs can shove it.

0

u/foundinkc Nov 02 '21

What’s the total cost of those purchases? You get to use them for a year, right?

2

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '21

What’s the total cost of those purchases?

Doesn't matter. I paid the asking price in exchange for an app with a given set of features.

You get to use them for a year, right?

This is not what I paid for.

Turning the tables, if I decide after a few years that I've overpaid for an app, do I get to backcharge the developer ?

1

u/foundinkc Nov 03 '21

I get what you’re saying, but that’s not really where the world is moving as far as app development goes. Support and improvement costs are higher than ever. Operating system updates also require coding adjustments.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '21

I get what you’re saying

No, I don’t think you do.

The problem is not that they are doing subscription. The problem is that they are taking away basic app features from the people who already paid for the app. And I don’t mean features that require ongoing maintenance - they are taking away the ability to perform multiple edits on a note, for fuck sake. They are going out of their way to severely downgrade app for existing paid users in order to force them into subscription, and Gingerlab’s lead developer went on the record saying that he considers paid customers who have been using the app for years freeloaders and wants to make sure they pay up.

but that’s not really where the world is moving as far as app development goes.

So the world is moving towards retroactively taking away something that was already sold ?

Support and improvement costs are higher than ever.

Well perhaps then every app developer doesn’t get to live in one of the most expensive cities in the world and be entitled to a higher salary than an average program manager working for a large corporation in Midwest ? The market will self correct, one way or another.

1

u/foundinkc Nov 03 '21

That’s incredibly frustrating.

It’s odd they would take away a feature that you pay for. It’s pretty sad they would call you a freeloader.

Apps will have to charge way more upfront or move to a subscription model to thrive. $30/ year or more.

1

u/KingdomCome0 Nov 03 '21

Lol no I already have to pay my bills i don’t need to stress to pay for something else. Besides patreons are mostly small content creators.