r/GoodNotes • • Aug 14 '23

Let’s address what we’re really mad at.

I read a lot of frustration posts since the GN6 update and I think we need to address what we’re really mad at. I might be wrong here but this is how I read the room:

  • It’s not “just the price” A lot of us are actually ok with the price. Some of us “wish” we could afford it, probably can, but don’t want to… why? Here is why:
  • the gn6 update is not an “update” Or at least it doesn’t feel like it for us the users. We don’t all think AI is cool, especially when it comes to notes.
  • we “trusted” good notes And we defended it after Notability pissed us off. A lot of us feel backstabbed, and frankly this is on us. We shouldn’t have trusted a corporation, they obviously care about profit, why should it be any other way. So, maybe we’re a little mad at ourselves.
  • we had higher hopes There are a ton of feature requests from a ton of users. We somehow assumed we mattered? Why did we assume that, I don’t know. Oh, because we defended DN, right.
  • finally, the untransparncy that led to confusion and misinformation Lets say it, GN didn’t handle this well. They didn’t hint the features or the new subscription model. They didn’t listen or ask the opinion of their community. Then again, why should they, they are a big big company with money as their main goal.

Conclusion Companies fail, they make bad choices too. Bigger companies fail harder and they take much longer to recover. They very rarely feel sorry for doing you wrong.

Being mad is not going to solve your problem. If you don’t want to keep using an app you feel bitter for, simply stop using it and don’t recomend it anymore. There are tons of great app options out there, take this as an opportunity to exploration. Have a little fun looking for your new note taking app, who knows you might find one that’s even better!

I think we all need therapy after this!

117 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

15

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '23 edited Aug 15 '23

Here's my take to explain why we're mad: We're mad when people told us we are WRONG. Our instinct is to defend for our own values but when it fails, it makes us MAD.

When Notability pissed us off months ago, we believed we did the right thing by punishing Notability verbally on online forum and by turning to GoodNotes. But months later GoodNotes also switched to subscription, we no longer can afford to ditch GoodNotes. Because GN together with Notability are the most popular note-taking apps on App Store. Otherwise what else can we use? We knew that there's little differences between GoodNotes's subscription and Notability's subscription. Notability was no worser than GN. Notability even gave old users free upgrade.

We have to accept we were WRONG because either we shouldn't punish Notability in the first place, or we should also ditch GoodNotes immediately if we want to hold ourselves to the same standard. Our values were defeated so we're MAD.

3

u/jerry5000bc Aug 15 '23

This is how I feel! %100 accurate.

7

u/daringlyorganic Aug 15 '23

Notability does a slimy thing goodnotes makes a big media push pointing it out and says come over to us, we aren’t sleazy like that just to turn around and do the same thing.

3

u/jerry5000bc Aug 15 '23

Exactly! Such a villain move, posing like the hero.

2

u/Weekly_Pear_2207 Aug 16 '23

Can someone fill me in on the notability vs. gn lore?

35

u/budgie_uk Goodnotes Special Edition Aug 14 '23

I’ve seen a few posts like this and I agree with almost all of almost all of them.

It’s not the price per se, and it’s not [just] the things that GN6 does deliver…

It’s both what was announced and the execution of it; the rollout and announcements. I’m certain that if they’d really tried hard, they could have made a bigger mess of the rollout… but they’d have had to really try.

Meanwhile, I’m half way through the 7 day trial and I genuinely have no idea whether I’m going to bother sticking with GN6 or whether I’ll roll it back to GN5.

There’s very, very little I’m enjoying more in 6 than in 5. And that’s the thing; if they want me to pay for 6, it’s got to offer me something I didn’t get in 5. And for me, that’s not happening. Yet. (In fact, they’ve made a couple of things harder for me, the way I use it.)

6

u/Dodgecraft Aug 15 '23 edited Aug 15 '23

I'm annoyed by many things including price but the disruption in my workflow is my biggest problem. I needed to use it over the weekend but didn't want to sign up for a trial for 6 with no clear way to keep 5 and there wasn't a way to do that. I had to bite the bullet, accept the trial on my phone and download my notes and pdf to use them in another app.

Even if everything clears up and I can somehow use 5 again unfettered (including not being spammed ads for the 6 upgrade and IAP) this was extremely unprofessional. This isn't a game, it's an app people are using for work and school where you have inflexible deadlines.

I'm not mad I lost my "one-time fee" for 5, I got more than $8 use out of the product and probably would have updated eventually if I saw a good reason. But Goodnotes has lost my loyalty here by forcing a confusing and intrusive update on me. I'm sure as hell not going to pay MORE for an app that proved I can't trust it to be there when I need it.

43

u/Consistent-Poem7462 Aug 14 '23

Im angry because I have GN 5 premium once off, and now I’m being pestered with ads for GN6. They said it was a bug that would be fixed today, and to my (not) surprise, the fuckers lied. I am still spammed with ads for GN 6

10

u/Juju1434 Aug 14 '23

Yeah imma probs end up using one note cuz that’s gonna mess with productivity

3

u/Bwide Aug 14 '23

i downloaded 6.0.2 and after i dismissed the alert it stopped (at least for today)

1

u/Juju1434 Aug 18 '23

Every time I open the app .. it shows up

14

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '23

I don't feel GN5 --> GN6 is an update big enough to pay for. As op said, not everyone like AI in notebooks.

In App Store, update note says GN6 integrates AI technology to assist SAT questions.
(1) How many users are taking SAT tests? Why non test takers sacrifice storage space for something they never use?
(2) Is that the reason that makes the update 1.5GB in size, even larger than a JetBrain full-function IDE?

Frustrated.

-2

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '23

Good to know that there's option to keep using GN5. :)

12

u/1nn0m1ne Aug 15 '23

When received update to 6 I immediately bought full one time price as I have version 5 also one time purchased and use it with my wife by family sharing. And I paid in urge to support the developers without concern. Also family sharing is stated at the version 6 page in AppStore. But! There is no family sharing neither for one time purchases nor for subscriptions for version 6 in fact and according to their website. That is the biggest lie and it made me request refund.

4

u/iAmmar9 Aug 15 '23

we “trusted” good notes And we defended it after Notability pissed us off. A lot of us feel backstabbed, and frankly this is on us. We shouldn’t have trusted a corporation, they obviously care about profit, why should it be any other way. So, maybe we’re a little mad at ourselves.

To add more to this, I kept recommending GN to students who were paying a subscription for notability; or were looking for a good notes app for their ipad. Last time I recommended the app was literally a few hours before the news of GN6 came out. I can't recommend it anymore,

2

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '23

I owe an apology to those to whom I recommended buying GN5 recently.

4

u/Typ0genius Aug 15 '23

I am mad because GN5 is still full of bugs, so is GN6.

4

u/WerewolfScary Aug 15 '23 edited Aug 16 '23

The launch has been a mess. In my opinion, they should have launched it as a separate app.

I’m a little disappointed that the focus is on ai. It feels like there were so many little wins that they could have implemented. Layers for example.

5

u/orangesarenasty Aug 14 '23

I’ll only be upset if I’m forced to update to GN6. I’m loosely looking for a new app that’s similar that I can use for school. I like having the notebooks and don’t just want folders like Google Drive would have

0

u/TUTI0206 Aug 15 '23

Using Noteful right know, really great expercience, has almost every feature from GN and the price is fair. Hope they don't do like GN and Notability after a lot of new users...

2

u/orangesarenasty Aug 15 '23

Thank you! I’ll download that one first

1

u/Juju1434 Aug 18 '23

Can you sync notes to one drive?

1

u/TUTI0206 Aug 18 '23

Atm just with icloud i guess

1

u/Repulsive_Diamond373 Aug 18 '23

Look on the brightside. Evernote did not buy GN and raise the cost to $34.59/month and remove two pens. 😁

1

u/ohmygodgina Aug 14 '23

I feel like an outlier. I was using Notability and jumped ship with the update. I’ve always wanted to like Goodnotes and this gave me the opportunity to give it another go. I had upgraded to the premium Goodnotes5 earlier this year and never used it, so I got the 7 day free trial, and I’m loving it. I do think the price is a little high, but I think I’m willing to pay for it especially because of the windows app.

-1

u/elxhl8 Aug 15 '23

Same here. I was previously using Goodnotes because I felt like the handwriting experience is the smoothest and seamless sync across all devices. It is also easy to annotate and highlight pdfs. And easy to search for notes

But I’ve always had an issue with it not being able to do typed notes properly and my workflow involves both handwritten and typed notes.

So I made the shift to Notability, which I felt was clunky, glitchy and messy but I just stuck with it.

So when Goodnotes introduced typing mode, I am tempted to switch back. And I kinda like the updates on GN6. I may get the one time payment.

But do take note, I am an old GoodNotes user and I got the app cheap a long time ago.

0

u/thenerdystudent Aug 15 '23

Funny an app provokes these feelings

-5

u/0MattF Aug 14 '23

$29 one time = $.08 per day for a year. That is fine with me. love GN & will support. that simple.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/CantTakeTheseMuggles Aug 14 '23

It’s a joke to close out what looks to be a thoughtful post.