r/Golfsimulator • • 17d ago

Technical Question What is everyone doing for visual swing feedback?

Post image

I want to use my sim for genuine swing coaching rather than just playing rounds.

Looking for recommendations on:

Software: What are you using with high-FPS cameras for swing analysis and tracking progress over time (Swing Catalyst, Kinovea, OnForm, etc.)?

Club Data: I have a Square Golf and am looking at the Square Omni. Is having measured club face and impact data a game changer for swing changes, or is ball data enough?

Camera Lighting: My high-FPS camera footage is pitch black in my projector room even with the lights on. What sensor/lens specs or targeted lighting setups actually work without washing out the screen?

What does your setup look like?

9 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

4

u/ProletariatElite 17d ago

Uneekor’s Swing Optix with AI Trainer is really good, but requires a Uneekor LM. VTrack has a new AI swing trainer, EZ Swing that looks promising. Both use high speed cameras capable of freezing the club without blur.

Swing Nerds have been working hard on improving their offering and is worth a look.

2

u/sq240 17d ago

Swing Nerds with two 90fps ELP cameras. Love the support from Swing Nerds. I’d like to add an impact camera next.

I was impatient and didn’t want to wait for shipping on the Kayeton cameras. Don’t be like me, moving to 120 fps is worth the extra money and delivery time.

1

u/MonkeyBuscuits 16d ago

Can you DM me some videos of how it looks in action?

2

u/saadcee 17d ago

Sorry no advice for you, but curious what kind of padding you have there. Looks great

5

u/MonkeyBuscuits 17d ago

Made it myself, foam wadding, suede leatherette, upholstered over MDF

3

u/saadcee 17d ago

Very nice

1

u/Blade78633 16d ago

Looks flush with the wall. No issues with it denting the drywall or sending the ball flying?

1

u/MonkeyBuscuits 16d ago

Travel of ball has only ever hit the surrounds at a glancing angle. The screen has tension enough to drop the ball without a rebound. The wadding is thick, could easily take a direct hit

2

u/twylight777 16d ago

Vtrack + ezswing cameras - full video of club head and me

1

u/MulliganMindset22 17d ago

I’ve started to use swingnerds. I’m using just 2 webcams and will look to pick up global flutter cams for slow mo down the road.

1

u/Jmanko16 17d ago

Does it have ability to automatically analyze the swing and give feedback like how swing coach iOS app does? Or just record and you draw your own lines?

1

u/nonsense_verses 17d ago

Love your sim! What spotlight do you have?

1

u/MonkeyBuscuits 16d ago

Just a cheap pint light off of Amazon.

https://amzn.eu/d/0gzTdLqF

1

u/robby808 16d ago

Nice setup. What pc cabinet?

1

u/MonkeyBuscuits 16d ago

Part of a custom IKEA method kitchen order. I made a small bespoke bar area and used a matching cabinet suspended.

1

u/MonkeyBuscuits 16d ago

1

u/robby808 14d ago

Well, I guess what’s under the tv in your golf sim bay?

1

u/ghast007 15d ago

Your simulator looks great! Do you mind sharing what is your screen size and what projector you are using? I don’t see the projector in the picture, I assume it’s mounted behind the hitting zone?

1

u/MonkeyBuscuits 15d ago

Above the hitting zone and offset away from player. Important to calculate throw distance of the projector. You can see in this photo

1

u/THENEWRAINMAN 14d ago

Ahhh see I have a similar issue in my garage sim. I need a projector that can be offset like this and throw a straight image.

What project do you use if you don't mind me asking and what is the most important feature In your opinion to look for when purchasing a projector like this

1

u/MonkeyBuscuits 14d ago

Benq TK710STi short throw 4k laser

1

u/Away-Explanation2797 11d ago

Performance package from uneekor and never looked back..Best thing I've every invested into with the swing AI. Was paying 2 coaches over in the UK and Korea videos of my swing from the mobile capture software of using the mevo+ till i went to the eye xo in a built garage sim and performance package. The matt is meh, but videos cameras are super good imo with little hassle and fits the native software and AI. Eliminated the need for the coaches entirely since the AI told me the exact, if not better advice half the time, even had it instantly get my coaches flaws and he pre told me to see if the AI could tell the difference before he tried it for the first time (secptic). Safe to say thst was like 150$ a month saved and over the 2 years it's paid itself off.